The customer-supplied materials scheme: the contract, accounting, tax, customs, rights to the fabric, responsibility for losses and a calculation against FOB
A review of the scheme in which you buy the fabric and trims yourself and hand them to the factory, which sews and charges only for the work. The document shows how the tolling scheme differs from FOB and turnkey sewing, which contract clauses hold it, how to account for materials and losses, how tax and customs work when the border is crossed and when it is cheaper. It decides whether to take the fabric on yourself and on what terms.
Why this document
Most small brands sew at someone else’s factory, and the questions “whose fabric, who pays for defects, how to write off leftovers” are settled by the contract and not by good relations. The tolling scheme gives control over the fabric and the purchase price but moves the risk of overuse, storage and raw material logistics onto you. The owner, the head of production, a lawyer and an accountant read the document before the first order under this scheme. It helps to compare the schemes in money and not to forget the contract clauses without which losses and disputes are inevitable. Tax and customs rules are given as a scheme and marked unverified: they are confirmed by an accountant or a customs broker.
At a glance
- What is this document and why is it needed?
- A review of the scheme in which you buy the fabric and trims yourself and hand them to the factory, which sews and charges only for the work. The document shows how the tolling scheme differs from FOB and turnkey sewing, which contract clauses hold it, how to account for materials and losses, how tax and customs work when the border is crossed and when it is cheaper. It decides whether to take the fabric on yourself and on what terms.
- Who owns the document and how often is it rebuilt?
- The head of production and a lawyer with the chief accountant; the contract and consumption norms are agreed before buying the fabric; the document is reviewed when the factory or the fabric changes.
- What mistakes are the most common?
- Not fixing consumption and loss norms → overuse falls on you and the dispute is endless → fix the norm from the marker and the penalty threshold in the contract. Not keeping a materials card per factory → leftovers “dissolve” → a transfer act, a usage report and an inventory count every quarter. Compare the schemes only by the fabric price → logistics and money in stock drop out → calculate the full cost per garment and the break-even fabric price.
For whom
- Brand
- A brand decides whether to take the fabric purchase on itself for price and quality and how to fix loss norms, rights to patterns and the reference, acceptance and deadlines. The main questions: overuse, leftovers, responsibility for defects, tax and the accounting of materials at the contractor.
- Retail
- A retailer with a private label uses the scheme when it buys fabric centrally and hands it to several factories. The main questions: one fabric and standard for all factories, accounting of leftovers at each, raw material logistics and the usage report.
What it consists of
How the schemes differ
- CM or CMT (cut, make, trim): the factory sews from your fabric and your trims, you pay for the work; this is the tolling scheme.
- FOB: the factory buys fabric and trims itself and sells you the finished garment at a price in which materials carry its markup; you get less control and less hassle.
- Full package: the factory also develops the style, picks the fabric and patterns; more convenient for a small brand but dearer and more dependent.
- The choice criterion: if you have a better fabric price and quality than the factory and are ready to manage materials, the tolling scheme wins; if the fabric is needed in a small quantity or you have no buying experience, FOB more often wins.
What must be in the contract
- The title to materials and goods stays with the customer; the factory stores materials separately, does not swap or use them for other orders; inventory counts and customer access are provided.
- Consumption and allowable loss norms per garment with the marker, width and shrinkage; the procedure of calculating overuse and a penalty or deduction for exceeding the norm.
- Transfer and acceptance of materials by an act with quantity and quality; a usage report with leftovers and waste after each lot; the fate of leftovers and scraps.
- Rights to patterns, the reference and the design belong to the customer; a ban on passing to third parties and on making overruns; responsibility for leakage.
- Quality and acceptance: AQL, the reference sample, claim periods, the procedure of rework and fabric replacement for defects caused by the factory and by the material.
- Deadlines and penalties: the sewing time from receipt of materials, penalties for delay and downtime, force majeure; insurance of materials and finished goods at the factory warehouse.
Tax, accounting and the border (a scheme, check with an accountant and a broker)
- Handing over customer-supplied materials without a transfer of title is usually not treated as a sale and VAT is not charged on the transfer itself, but at the factory the materials are accounted for separately and the customer keeps them as its own materials (unverified: check the procedure and accounts).
- The sewing fee is taxed at the factory under its regime (simplified or general); at the customer it enters the cost after acceptance; VAT on the service is deducted when the rate and documents follow the regime rules (unverified).
- Write-off of materials at the customer follows the usage report and within the norm; above-norm consumption is either recovered from the factory or taken to losses, and this decision must be fixed in the accounts and the contract.
- When the border is crossed the materials and goods go under customs procedures of processing inside or outside the customs territory; inside the union there are no procedures but indirect taxes and marking are counted; a broker gives specifics (unverified).
Brand: what to fix and calculate
- Calculate the schemes on one style: FOB and tolling, with raw material logistics, the cost of money in the fabric stock and the overuse risk; compare the full cost per garment.
- Fix in the contract the consumption norms from the marker and the penalty threshold; check the factory norm by the fabric consumption calculation (the “Cutting and fabric consumption” document).
- Keep a materials card for each factory: handed over, used, waste, leftover; reconcile it with the fact by an inventory count once a quarter.
- Keep the patterns and the reference with you and hand the factory copies limited to a number of orders.
- After the first lot compare the economics with FOB by actual consumption and the leftovers record and not by plan; the difference will show whether the scheme is justified.
Retail: what to consider with centralized fabric buying
- Buy fabric in a large lot at one price and hand it to several factories on a schedule; this lowers the price but grows the stock and the risk of uneven write-off.
- Introduce one template of the transfer act and the usage report for all factories and reconcile leftovers at each once a month.
- Plan the raw materials logistics to factories and finished goods to the distribution center as two branches of one flow; recalculate the cost when the route changes.
- For a private label fix a common standard of fabric quality and acceptance and penalties for all factories with one formula.
- Keep a register of material leftovers at each factory as working assets: it enters the stock value and the chain’s inventory count.
Where the data comes from
| Data source | Fields |
|---|---|
| The factory contract and appendices: norms, acts, reports | consumption and loss norms, the penalty procedure, rights to patterns |
| Buying fabric and trims and logistics to the factory | price, width, shrinkage, time, delivery cost |
| Materials accounting and inventory | handed over, written off, leftover, waste for each lot |
| Factory quotes for CM and FOB for the same style | sewing price, garment price, markup on materials |
How to build it step by step
- Step 1: Choose one typical style and describe the specification: fabric, marker, consumption norm, trims.
- Step 2: Ask the factory for two prices: FOB and CM, and clarify the markup on materials.
- Step 3: Calculate the tolling scheme: fabric at your price, materials logistics, the cost of money for the storage period, sewing, the overuse risk.
- Step 4: Find the break-even fabric price: at what purchase price of yours the schemes are equal (see the formula and the example).
- Step 5: Agree with the factory the consumption and loss norms, the penalty procedure for overuse and the schedule of materials handover.
- Step 6: Fix the rights to patterns, the reference and materials, the storage, inventory and insurance procedure and the fate of leftovers.
- Brand: Step 7: Agree with an accountant the accounting of the materials handover, write-off by the report and tax on the service; with a broker when the border is crossed.
- Retailer: Step 7: Set up one report of leftovers across all factories and reconcile it with a monthly inventory count.
- Brand: Step 8: After the first lot compare actual consumption with the norm and decide: keep the scheme, correct the norm or move to FOB.
- Retailer: Step 9: Revise the distribution of materials between factories once a season by the actual times and losses.
Formulas
| Measure | Formulas | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Garment cost under FOB | C_FOB = (M × P_f + Tr) × (1 + n) + CM | M is fabric consumption, P_f the fabric price at the factory, Tr trims, n the factory markup on materials, CM the sewing price. |
| Garment cost under tolling | C_toll = M × (1 + y) × P_o + Tr + CM + M × L + M × P_o × r × d / 365 | y is overuse above the norm, P_o your fabric price, L raw material logistics per meter, r the annual money rate, d days of fabric storage. |
| Break-even fabric price | P_o* = [ (M × P_f + Tr) × (1 + n) − Tr − M × L ] / [ M × (1 + r × d / 365) ] | If your fabric price is below P_o*, the tolling scheme is cheaper than FOB at zero overuse. |
Formulas in notation
- Tolling scheme
C = M(1 + y)P + Tr + CM + M·L + M·P·r·d/365
Fabric use with overuse times the price, plus trims, sewing, materials logistics and the cost of money in stock.
Worked example
Cost of one garment: FOB and the tolling scheme (illustrative inputs: consumption 1.41 m, the factory fabric RUB 640 per meter, yours RUB 600, trims RUB 60, sewing RUB 320, factory markup 8%)
| Item | FOB, ₽ per garment | Tolling without overuse, ₽ | Tolling with 6% overuse, ₽ |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fabric | 974.59 | 846.00 | 846.00 |
| Trims | 64.80 | 60.00 | 60.00 |
| Sewing | 320.00 | 320.00 | 320.00 |
| Materials logistics | 0.00 | 19.74 | 19.74 |
| Cost of money in the fabric stock | 0.00 | 20.86 | 20.86 |
| Fabric above the norm | 0.00 | 0.00 | 33.84 |
| Total per garment | 1,359.39 | 1,266.60 | 1,300.44 |
| Total for a lot of 1,000, thousand ₽ | 1,359.4 | 1,266.6 | 1,300.4 |
With zero overuse the tolling scheme is cheaper while your fabric price is below RUB 664 per meter; an overuse of 6% against an allowed norm of 2% eats part of the gain. In a real table plug in your own prices and the actual consumption from the factory report.
Figures
Flows of materials, goods and money under the tolling scheme. Title to the fabric and goods stays with the customer; the factory receives only the payment for the work and reports on usage.
- Fabric and trims supplier → Customer (brand or chain)
- Customer (brand or chain) → Factory: sewing to the norm
- Factory: sewing to the norm → Usage report and leftovers; Finished goods to the customer warehouse
- Usage report and leftovers
- Finished goods to the customer warehouse
Data as a table
| Measure | Total per garment |
|---|---|
| FOB | 1,359 |
| Tolling without overuse | 1,267 |
| Tolling with 6% overuse | 1,300 |
Garment cost by scheme, ₽. The tolling scheme wins on the fabric price and the markup but adds logistics, money in stock and the overuse risk.
- Tolling
- FOB
Data as a table
| Actual fabric overuse, % | Tolling | FOB |
|---|---|---|
| 0 | 1,267 | 1,359 |
| 2 | 1,267 | 1,359 |
| 4 | 1,284 | 1,359 |
| 6 | 1,300 | 1,359 |
| 8 | 1,317 | 1,359 |
| 10 | 1,334 | 1,359 |
| 12 | 1,351 | 1,359 |
Total tolling cost as overuse grows, ₽. While overuse is below the allowed norm it costs nothing; above the norm every unit falls on the customer unless the contract introduces a penalty.
Specifics by category
- Apparel
- Apparel: fabric is the main share of materials, so tolling gives most with a large purchase and an accurate marker; watch shrinkage and width.
- Footwear
- Footwear: materials are fragmented (leather, lining, soles, hardware) and tooling belongs to the factory; leather and soles can be customer-supplied, the rest the factory buys itself.
- Accessories
- Accessories: leather and hardware are customer-supplied, losses are counted by hide area and yield; the yield norm per hide decides who pays for leather defects.
- Kids
- Children’s: fabric and trims must have safety documents, so customer-supplied materials are checked at entry and the certificates are kept with the transfer acts.
- Men
- Men’s: suit fabrics are dearer and overuse costs more; consumption norms and leftover control are stricter here and a marker with directional pile gives more losses.
- Women
- Women’s: many colors and small lots, fabric leftovers pile up; plan the minimum fabric order per color and the fate of leftovers (reuse, sale).
Common mistakes
- Not fixing consumption and loss norms → overuse falls on you and the dispute is endless → fix the norm from the marker and the penalty threshold in the contract.
- Not keeping a materials card per factory → leftovers “dissolve” → a transfer act, a usage report and an inventory count every quarter.
- Compare the schemes only by the fabric price → logistics and money in stock drop out → calculate the full cost per garment and the break-even fabric price.
- Leave patterns and the reference with the factory → they go elsewhere → keep them with you and hand over copies with limits.
- Not agreeing accounting and tax before the first lot → additional charges and fines → agree the procedure with an accountant and a broker in advance.
Russian specifics
- Contract work and the tolling scheme in Russian accounting are formalized by a work contract and acts; the customer accounts for the materials handed over as its own and the contractor keeps them separately. Check the procedure and accounts with an accountant.
- Brand: if the factory is in another country the movement of materials and goods is formalized as a customs processing procedure; inside the EAEU it is not applied but the indirect taxes and marking are counted. A broker confirms.
- Retailer: with centralized fabric buying for several factories you need one set of acts and reports per factory and a monthly reconciliation of leftovers; these documents confirm the write-off.
- The tax at the factory depends on its regime: on the simplified system the sewing fee is taxed differently from the general one; this affects the price and the customer’s possibility to deduct VAT (unverified).