Syntha Lab RU

Sourcing from factories: CMT, FOB, OEM/ODM, full cost and lead times

A comparison of production terms (CMT, FOB, LDP, OEM, ODM) and factories by one full cost, minimum order and lead time. It is used to choose the factory, country and working model, to decide what share of orders to diversify, and to see which price is really cheaper after logistics and duties.

Production, logistics, channels Brand and retail Verified: 2026-11-14

Open interactively →

Why this document

The unit price at the factory and the price in the brand’s warehouse differ by fabric, trims, logistics, duty and payment terms, so offers cannot be compared on the price list. Purchasing, the finance director and the head of product read it: it reduces everything to one full cost and shows what the minimum order delivers and how much cash it freezes. Without it a cheap-looking factory turns out dearer because of lead time and defects. The country and model are therefore chosen on full cost with risk, not on the sewing price.

At a glance

What is this document and why is it needed?
A comparison of production terms (CMT, FOB, LDP, OEM, ODM) and factories by one full cost, minimum order and lead time. It is used to choose the factory, country and working model, to decide what share of orders to diversify, and to see which price is really cheaper after logistics and duties.
Who owns the document and how often is it rebuilt?
Run by the brand’s sourcing and production manager (or product) together with finance; reviewed before every season and when exchange rate, duties or freight change; the result goes to the head of buying and the CFO.
What mistakes are the most common?
Comparing item price rather than full cost → the “cheap” factory turns out dearer → cost everything to the warehouse. Ignoring MOQ and lead time → cash locked up and a missed season → compute MOQ in money and put the lead time in the calendar. One factory for everything → a supply failure stops sales → a backup factory and a concentration limit.

For whom

Brand
The brand chooses a model: CMT (the factory sews from brand materials, you pay for the work), FOB package or full package (the factory buys materials and ships the finished item; a cooperation model, not a delivery term), OEM (sews to your design), ODM (offers its own models, you choose and add a label). Separately the delivery basis under Incoterms 2020 (FOB, FCA, CIF etc.) is chosen: it decides who pays freight and when risk passes. LDP (delivery with duty paid) is a trade expression, not an Incoterms term. The more the factory does, the higher the price and the lower the control over materials.
Retail
A retailer buys finished goods from brands and distributors; direct factory sourcing is used for private label and own-brand imports. Then the same calculation applies, plus range planning: factory minimums (MOQ) are often larger than one style needs, so size runs and colors are combined into a single order.

What it consists of

1. Working models

  • Brand: CMT (cut-make-trim): you pay for cutting and sewing, the brand buys the materials; maximum control, but you must manage fabric and trim supply.
  • FOB as a cooperation model (FOB package, full package): the factory buys fabric and trims itself, sews and ships the finished item; the price includes sewing and materials. Do not confuse it with FOB as Incoterms 2020 (a delivery term: risk passes on loading on board the vessel at the port of departure, sea and inland waterway transport only): state both the model and the basis in the contract, for example “FOB package, Incoterms 2020 FOB Shanghai”.
  • Brand: OEM: the factory sews from your tech pack; ODM: the factory offers its own designs and fabrics, you select and add your label; ODM is faster and cheaper, but differentiation is weaker.
  • LDP (landed duty paid): a trade expression for a price delivered to the warehouse with duty paid, not an Incoterms term; in meaning it is closest to DDP (Incoterms 2020). Convenient for comparison, but the supplier markup and risk premium are baked in: clarify who is declarant and who pays import VAT.

2. Comparing quotes

  • Columns: unit price, freight, duty (on customs value), fees and broker, defect allowance, FX buffer, cost of money over the lead time, MOQ, lead time, payment terms.
  • Comparison is made on one basis: “delivered to the warehouse, excl. VAT, with allowances”.

3. Lead time by stage

  • Sample approval and material order, fabric production, cutting and sewing, inspection, delivery to the port, transit, customs, delivery to the warehouse; a buffer for delays.

4. Risk assessment and diversification

  • Share of one factory or country in the order (concentration), a backup factory (dual sourcing), nearshoring (production closer to the market) with shorter lead times and lower MOQ at a higher price.

5. Factory scorecard

  • Quality (share of rejected lots), delivery reliability (OTIF), flexibility, price, compliance (audits, certificates), communication; scored by season.

Incoterms 2020: 11 terms (who pays freight, insurance, duty; when risk passes)

  • Group 1, any mode of transport, the seller carries almost nothing. EXW: goods are handed over at the seller’s premises; freight, export and import clearance and duties are on the buyer, insurance not required, risk passes when the goods are placed at the buyer’s disposal. FCA: the seller clears export and hands the goods to the buyer’s carrier at the agreed place; freight is on the buyer, insurance not required, risk passes on handover to the carrier.
  • Group 2, any mode of transport, freight paid by the seller but risk passes earlier. CPT: the seller clears export and pays freight to the named destination, insurance not required, import and duties are on the buyer, risk passes on handover to the first carrier. CIP: the same but the seller must insure the cargo on broad terms (Institute Cargo Clauses A) for the buyer.
  • Group 3, any mode of transport, delivery to the destination. DAP: the seller delivers the goods on a means of transport ready for unloading; unloading, import clearance and duties are on the buyer, risk passes at the destination before unloading. DPU (replaced DAT in 2020): as DAP but the seller unloads, risk passes after unloading. DDP: the seller does everything, including import clearance, duties and import VAT, insurance not required, risk passes at the destination; for a buyer in Russia it must be clear who will be the declarant.
  • Group 4, sea and inland waterway transport only. FAS: the seller clears export and delivers the goods alongside the vessel at the quay, risk passes alongside. FOB: the seller clears export and loads the goods on board the vessel at the port of shipment, risk passes on loading on board and freight is paid by the buyer; for containers handed over at a terminal FCA is usually more accurate. CFR: the seller pays sea freight to the destination port but the buyer bears risk and later costs: risk passes on loading on board at the port of shipment (that is, before the goods arrive). CIF: as CFR plus insurance on minimum terms (Institute Cargo Clauses C) for the buyer. In all four insurance (except CIF) is not required and import and duties are on the buyer.
  • How to choose: Incoterms are not law but ICC trade usage, they apply if the contract refers to “Incoterms 2020”, the term and the place; when computing full cost (the formula in this document) restate offers to one basis.
  • Brand: with EXW and FCA organizes transport, insurance and export clearance in the factory country itself; with FOB pays freight and bears risk from loading on board; with CFR and CIF the seller pays freight while the brand bears risk from loading on board just the same (so the cargo must be insured; with CIF the seller buys only minimum cover).
  • Retailer: when buying from a foreign factory into a Russian warehouse prefers bases with a clear declarant: with DAP the buyer is declarant and pays duty, with DDP the seller, and import VAT and its deduction depend on this.

Brand and retailer: what differs in practice

  • Retailer: when buying finished goods from factories or importers compares offers by full cost, not by the price list.
  • Retailer: assesses the minimum order by locked capital and sell-through time: a large minimum at a distant supplier may not pay back.
  • Retailer: chooses delivery terms (Incoterms) so as to know who pays freight and duty and bears risk in transit, and checks this against the contract.
  • Retailer: takes the supplier defect share from its own receiving history, not from promises, and raises it for a new supplier.
  • Retailer: splits buying across suppliers: local for fast repeats, distant for basics with a long lead time.
  • Retailer: covers exchange-rate risk with a price clause or a prepayment at a fixed rate when buying in foreign currency.

How to read the result and what decisions follow

  • The supplier with the lowest price is rarely the cheapest by full cost: see which item flips the order and negotiate on it.
  • The position of a point on the lead-time and cost chart shows the trade-off: a faster and slightly costlier supply reduces leftover risk and locked capital.
  • Decision: the order share by supplier, the minimum order, the delivery basis and a reserve for rate and time.

Control checks

  • For each offer the sum of components equals the full cost and all offers are computed on one base (one unit, one basis, one rate).
  • The lead time in the calculation equals the production schedule plus transport plus customs and agrees with the season start on the shelf.

Checklist before signing a factory contract (unverified: a reference, not legal advice)

  • The delivery basis (Incoterms 2020), the moment of transfer of risk and cargo insurance are stated (the basis table follows common practice, the rules text was not opened, unverified).
  • The tech pack, tolerances and acceptance plan, the claim term and the procedure for return or discount on defects are described.
  • Currency, payment procedure and currency control, liability for production delay and the right to cancel are defined.
  • Rights to prints, patterns and labels stay with the brand and transfer to third parties and sale of leftovers by the factory are prohibited.

Where the data comes from

Data sourceFields
Factory quotesprice, MOQ, lead time, payment terms, Incoterms, quote validity
Logistics and brokerfreight rate, insurance, fees, transit time, duty by HS code
Financeexchange rate, cost of money rate, payment terms, working capital limit
Quality and order historyrate of rejected lots, OTIF, sample durations, remarks

How to build it step by step

  1. Brand: Step 1: Obtain quotes on the same tech pack and volume (at least three) with one Incoterm; if terms differ, convert to a common basis.
  2. Brand: Step 2: Add freight, insurance and fees; compute duty on customs value at the EAEU tariff rate for the HS code, not by feel.
  3. Step 3: Add a defect allowance from the factory history and an FX buffer for currency contracts.
  4. Step 4: Compute the cost of money: the item ties up cash from prepayment until sale; multiply by the rate and the time.
  5. Brand: Step 5: Add up and compare; show MOQ and the cash locked (MOQ × full cost) alongside.
  6. Step 6: Estimate lead time by stage and match it to the collection calendar: late delivery of seasonal goods costs more than the price difference.
  7. Brand: Step 7: Assess risk: concentration, backup factory, sanctions and logistics restrictions, settlement currency.
  8. Brand: Step 8: Decide on full cost, lead time and risk together; record the choice in the scorecard and in the minutes.
  9. Brand: Step 9: Record in the order and contract separately the model (CMT, FOB package, OEM, ODM) and the Incoterms 2020 delivery basis with the place.
  10. Retailer: Step 10: When buying into a Russian warehouse from a foreign factory determine the declarant and the payer of duty and import VAT and restate all offers to one basis.

Formulas

MeasureFormulasNote
Customs value and dutyDuty = (price + freight + insurance) × duty rateTake the rate from the EAEU common customs tariff for the HS code; import VAT is not added to cost if it is recoverable.
Brand: Full unit costFull = price + freight + duty + fees + defect allowance + FX buffer + cost of moneyBring all offers to one basis: delivered to the warehouse, excl. VAT.
Cost of moneyCost of money = cost × rate ÷ 365 × (production and delivery days + selling days)A prepayment lengthens the period; if you pay in stages use the average time the money is tied up.
Brand: Cash locked by MOQCash locked = MOQ × full unit costA large MOQ makes a cheap quote expensive if you cannot sell it through.
Brand: Break-even volume between factoriesQ* = difference in fixed costs ÷ difference in variable cost per unitShows the volume at which the cheaper distant factory beats the near one.

Formulas in notation

Landed cost per unit
L = P + F + d × (P + F) + S
P price, F freight, d duty rate, S fees. For supplier B: RUB 2,321.0.
Cost of money over the term
K = L × i × (T + D) / 365
i annual rate, T lead time, D stock days. For supplier C: RUB 122.4 per unit.
Full cost
C = L + L × b + P × f + K
b defect share, f exchange-rate buffer. For A, B and C: 1,828.4 / 2,547.0 / RUB 2,062.0.
Capital locked in the minimum order
Z = MOQ × C
For A, B, C: RUB 549 k / RUB 2,547 k / RUB 6,186 k.

Worked example

Three quotes for one style on a common “warehouse, excl. VAT” basis

OfferPrice, RUBFreight, RUBDuty, RUBFees, RUBDefects, RUBFX, RUBMoney, RUBTotal, RUBLead, dMOQ cash, k RUB
A: Russian factory, CMT (brand-supplied fabric)1,720180.0026.10.064.31,828.445549
B: Turkish factory, FOB1,98070246.02546.459.4120.22,547.0752,547
C: Chinese factory, FOB1,52095193.83055.245.6122.42,062.01056,186

The cheapest by item price is C: Chinese factory, FOB: RUB 1,520. On full cost (duty 12%, money rate 18%, selling window 30 days, FX buffer 3%) the best offer is A: Russian factory, CMT (brand-supplied fabric), RUB 1,828.4. The gap between the highest and lowest full cost is RUB 718.7 per unit; the cash locked by MOQ is RUB 549 thousand. The duty rate in the example is notional: use your own from the EAEU tariff.

Figures

Full unit cost by supplier and what it consists of
Bar chart: A: Russian factory, CMT (brand-supplied fabric) 1,720, B: Turkish factory, FOB 1,980, C: Chinese factory, FOB 1,52005001,0001,5002,0002,5003,000A: Russian factory, CMT (brand-supplied fabric)A: Russian factory,CMT (brand-supplied…Price: 1,720Freight: 18Defects: 26Cost of money: 641,828B: Turkish factory, FOBB: Turkish factory,FOBPrice: 1,980Freight: 70Duty: 246Fees: 25Defects: 46FX buffer: 59Cost of money: 1202,546C: Chinese factory, FOBC: Chinese factory,FOBPrice: 1,520Freight: 95Duty: 194Fees: 30Defects: 55FX buffer: 46Cost of money: 1222,062RUB
  • Price
  • Freight
  • Duty
  • Fees
  • Defects
  • FX buffer
  • Cost of money
Data as a table
MeasurePriceFreightDutyFeesDefectsFX bufferCost of money
A: Russian factory, CMT (brand-supplied fabric)1,720180026064
B: Turkish factory, FOB1,98070246254659120
C: Chinese factory, FOB1,52095194305546122

Full unit cost by supplier and what it consists of. The unit price is not everything: freight, duty, fees, defects, an exchange-rate buffer and the cost of money over the lead time change the order of suppliers. Best by full cost: A: Russian factory, CMT (brand-supplied fabric); the lowest price is at “C: Chinese factory, FOB”. Illustrative figures.

Lead time and stock cover by supplier. For each supplier the time from order to warehouse and then the stock sell-through time: both freeze money.

StageStart, daysLength, days
Lead time: A045
Stock sell-through: A4530
Lead time: B075
Stock sell-through: B7530
Lead time: C0105
Stock sell-through: C10530
Lead time and full cost
Scatter plot: 3 points1,8002,0002,2002,4002,600406080100120A: Russian factory, CMT (brand-supplied fabric): 45; 1,828A: Russian factory, CMT (brand-supplied fabric)B: Turkish factory, FOB: 75; 2,547B: Turkish factory, FOBC: Chinese factory, FOB: 105; 2,062C: Chinese factory, FOBLead time, days↑ Full cost, RUB per unit
Data as a table
Lead time, daysFull cost, RUB per unit
451,828A: Russian factory, CMT (brand-supplied fabric)
752,547B: Turkish factory, FOB
1052,062C: Chinese factory, FOB

Lead time and full cost. The lower left is better: fast and cheap; a distant supplier with a low price ends up on the right because of lead time and minimum order.

Specifics by category

Apparel
Apparel: the most developed CMT and FOB market; key parameters are fabric and cutting; knit and woven are made in different factories; MOQ is often 300–1,000 units per color.
Footwear
Footwear: tooling (lasts, molds) is made for the brand and costs separately; MOQ is higher and lead time longer; FOB is more common; materials and soles are supplied by the factory.
Accessories
Accessories: factories are narrowly specialized (leather, textile, metal); MOQ applies to material and hardware; there is no grading but there is a variety of materials and tests.
Kids
Kids: safety requirements are added (certificates, no small parts); the factory must have kids’ production experience and test reports; a higher share of cost goes to testing and inspection.
Men
Menswear: stable silhouettes, longer series and fewer sizes per style; large orders are easier to plan and price falls with volume.
Women
Womenswear: more styles and colors in small series, higher risk of small MOQs and a variety of trims; a flexible factory with a low MOQ and quick re-orders is more often needed.

Common mistakes

  • Comparing item price rather than full cost → the “cheap” factory turns out dearer → cost everything to the warehouse.
  • Ignoring MOQ and lead time → cash locked up and a missed season → compute MOQ in money and put the lead time in the calendar.
  • One factory for everything → a supply failure stops sales → a backup factory and a concentration limit.
  • Not fixing exchange rate and Incoterms → the price drifts → fix currency, rate or formula and the delivery basis in the contract.
  • Computing duty on an approximate rate → customs error → HS code and rate from the broker before ordering.
  • FOB as full package and FOB under Incoterms are confused → freight costs and risk sit elsewhere than expected → record the model and the basis separately.

Russian specifics

  • Duty rates come from the EAEU Common Customs Tariff by HS code; EEC Council Decision No. 80 approved the EAEU HS and the tariff. Rule: EEC decision 80 of 14.09.2021: EEC Council Decision of 14.09.2021 No. 80 (EAEU commodity nomenclature and Common Customs Tariff).
  • Payments to a foreign factory and currency control: duty to report currency operations and confirm the import with documents; terms and procedure to be confirmed with the bank and the accountant. Rule: Law 173-FZ of 10.12.2003: Federal Law of 10.12.2003 No. 173-FZ on currency regulation and control.
  • The VAT base on import is determined under Art. 160 of the Tax Code; deduction under Art. 171. Rule: Tax Code Art. 160: Tax Code, Art. 160 (tax base on import).
  • Conformity confirmation of light-industry and children’s products is done before import and sale. Rule: CU Commission decision 876 of 09.12.2011: TR CU 017/2011 on safety of light-industry products (Customs Union Commission Decision of 09.12.2011 No. 876).
  • Incoterms 2020 is an ICC publication: the table follows widely known practice, the text of the rules was not opened; in the contract state the edition, the term and the place.

Open interactively →