Unit price by run tiers and the minimum run
Compares run options with different factory prices: cost, unsold stock and profit. Shows at which run it pays to order and when a cheap price for a big run turns into frozen stock.
At a glance
- What question does it answer?
- Which run is better to order if the unit price falls as the run grows and demand is uncertain.
- What data is needed?
- Expected demand for the season and the average selling price.
- How to read the result?
- The lowest factory price often does not give the best profit: if demand is below the run, leftovers eat the benefit. Check the result at demand 20–30% lower (a conventional stress, set your own) and choose the run that withstands the cautious scenario. Example on the default values: Demand of 1,200 units, selling price RUB 4,900 and four tiers from 500 to 3,000 units. The best profit comes from a run of 1,000 units (profit RUB 1.95m, cost per sold unit RUB 2,950 including one-off and other costs, no leftovers), although the lowest factory price, RUB 2,050, belongs to the largest run. If the result changes when demand is 20–30% lower, choose the smaller run. Next: “How much to order under uncertain demand” and “End-to-end cash gap”.
Why and how to reason
A factory gives a lower price for a larger run, and there is a temptation to order more. But a cheap unit that does not sell costs more. The calculation compares runs by profit. Sold = the smaller of the run and demand. Revenue = sold x price + leftover x cost x share recovered at clearance. Costs: run x factory price + one-off + other variable costs on sold units.
The best unit price is not necessarily the best run: when the run exceeds demand, surplus units cost money, and clearance will recover them only partly.
Example. Demand 1,200, price 4,900, clearance of leftover returns 40%. A run of 1,000 at 2,350: sold 1,000, revenue RUB 4.9 m, costs 2.35 + 0.35 + 0.25, profit RUB 1.95 m. A run of 2,000 at 2,150: sold 1,200, leftover 800 gives RUB 0.69 m, profit RUB 1.62 m. A run of 3,000 at 2,050 gives only RUB 0.56 m.
When to use it
It is useful when a factory offers price tiers and a minimum run, and you must choose a run. Suitable for new styles with uncertain demand. Assumption: demand is known or estimated. If demand rises, the best run shifts up. For uncertain demand use “How much to order” with scenarios. A factory’s minimum run is often negotiable, so clarify it before calculating. Also consider the production lead time.
How to read the result
Find the run with maximum profit: 1,000 in the example, and its cost per sold unit of RUB 2,950 is above the factory’s lowest price of RUB 2,050, because one-off and variable costs are included. Leftover at the best run is zero. Check that the run is not too small if demand turns out higher: you will lose sales. Decision: choose a run near expected demand, not the lowest price, and discuss with the factory the possibility of a repeat order. Ask the factory whether a large run can be split into parts at one price: then you get the cheap price without frozen stock.
Common mistakes
Typical trap: taking demand as “whatever luck brings”; counting leftover revenue at selling price; ignoring one-off costs of the style; ignoring frozen cash. Also: assuming leftover can be returned to the factory. Also: not counting storage of leftover and the cash frozen in it until clearance.
What data is needed?
- Expected demand for the season and the average selling price.
- Run tiers and the factory unit price from the quotation.
- Optionally: one-off costs of the style, clearance revenue on leftovers, other variable costs.
- Where to take it: season demand from a cautious sales plan based on history and buyers’ orders; run tiers and factory price from the commercial offer; one-off costs (samples, patterns, grading) from the factory’s invoices; revenue from leftovers from past clearances (as a share of cost); other variable costs from costing. One tier is one row.
Inputs
| Field | Unit | Value in the example | Meaning |
|---|---|---|---|
| Expected demand for the season | units | 1,200 | How many you will really sell at the average price below; estimate cautiously. |
| Average selling price (excl. VAT) | ₽ | 4,900 | Average selling price per unit excl. VAT after discounts. |
| Revenue on leftovers at clearance (optional) | % of cost | 40 | How much comes back from unsold goods as a share of their cost. Optional. Empty: the field is ignored (counted as zero in sums). |
| One-off cost of the style (optional) | ₽ | 350,000 | Samples, patterns, grading: spread over the run. Optional. Empty: the field is ignored (counted as zero in sums). |
| Other variable costs per sold unit | ₽ | 250 | Other variable costs per unit sold: logistics, commissions, packing. |
How it is calculated
| Step | Formula |
|---|---|
| Sold | The lesser of the run and demand |
| Revenue | Sold × price + leftovers × cost × clearance share |
| Profit | Revenue − run × factory price − one-off costs − sold × other variable costs |
Worked numbers
Default values from the app; in the interactive version you enter your own.
- Best by profit
- 1.95 m ₽ · Medium (1,000 units)
- Cost per sold unit at the best run
- 2,950 ₽Run cost, one-off and other variable costs minus the revenue from leftovers, per sold unit: the price minus this figure is the profit per unit.
- Unsold left at the best run
- 0 units
- Lowest factory price
- 2,050 ₽ · Maximum discountProfit at it 556,000 ₽: a low price is not always worth it if demand is below the run.
Comparison of runs
| Tier | Run | Factory price | Cost | Unsold | Profit |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Minimum run | 500 | 2,600 ₽ | 1.65 m ₽ | 0 | 675,000 ₽ |
| Medium | 1,000 | 2,350 ₽ | 2.7 m ₽ | 0 | 1.95 m ₽ |
| Large | 2,000 | 2,150 ₽ | 4.65 m ₽ | 800 | 1.62 m ₽ |
| Maximum discount | 3,000 | 2,050 ₽ | 6.5 m ₽ | 1,800 | 556,000 ₽ |
Demand is the most uncertain figure: check the result at demand 20–30% lower and compare with “How much to order under uncertain demand”. Cash frozen in a larger run, count in “Cash flow” and “End-to-end gap”.
Nuances and limits
- Estimate demand on a cautious scenario: overestimating demand is the main reason for an excessive run.
- Cash frozen in a bigger run costs interest: compare the factory discount’s benefit with it.
- A low unit price at a large run is eaten by unsold leftovers: look at profit, not price.
- Money frozen in a larger run costs interest: check it in the cash flow.