Syntha Lab RU

Unit price by run tiers and the minimum run

Compares run options with different factory prices: cost, unsold stock and profit. Shows at which run it pays to order and when a cheap price for a big run turns into frozen stock.

Order size and break-even For whom: Brands buying production, product and production managers.

Calculate on your data →

At a glance

What question does it answer?
Which run is better to order if the unit price falls as the run grows and demand is uncertain.
What data is needed?
Expected demand for the season and the average selling price.
How to read the result?
The lowest factory price often does not give the best profit: if demand is below the run, leftovers eat the benefit. Check the result at demand 20–30% lower (a conventional stress, set your own) and choose the run that withstands the cautious scenario. Example on the default values: Demand of 1,200 units, selling price RUB 4,900 and four tiers from 500 to 3,000 units. The best profit comes from a run of 1,000 units (profit RUB 1.95m, cost per sold unit RUB 2,950 including one-off and other costs, no leftovers), although the lowest factory price, RUB 2,050, belongs to the largest run. If the result changes when demand is 20–30% lower, choose the smaller run. Next: “How much to order under uncertain demand” and “End-to-end cash gap”.

Why and how to reason

A factory gives a lower price for a larger run, and there is a temptation to order more. But a cheap unit that does not sell costs more. The calculation compares runs by profit. Sold = the smaller of the run and demand. Revenue = sold x price + leftover x cost x share recovered at clearance. Costs: run x factory price + one-off + other variable costs on sold units.

The best unit price is not necessarily the best run: when the run exceeds demand, surplus units cost money, and clearance will recover them only partly.

Example. Demand 1,200, price 4,900, clearance of leftover returns 40%. A run of 1,000 at 2,350: sold 1,000, revenue RUB 4.9 m, costs 2.35 + 0.35 + 0.25, profit RUB 1.95 m. A run of 2,000 at 2,150: sold 1,200, leftover 800 gives RUB 0.69 m, profit RUB 1.62 m. A run of 3,000 at 2,050 gives only RUB 0.56 m.

When to use it

It is useful when a factory offers price tiers and a minimum run, and you must choose a run. Suitable for new styles with uncertain demand. Assumption: demand is known or estimated. If demand rises, the best run shifts up. For uncertain demand use “How much to order” with scenarios. A factory’s minimum run is often negotiable, so clarify it before calculating. Also consider the production lead time.

How to read the result

Find the run with maximum profit: 1,000 in the example, and its cost per sold unit of RUB 2,950 is above the factory’s lowest price of RUB 2,050, because one-off and variable costs are included. Leftover at the best run is zero. Check that the run is not too small if demand turns out higher: you will lose sales. Decision: choose a run near expected demand, not the lowest price, and discuss with the factory the possibility of a repeat order. Ask the factory whether a large run can be split into parts at one price: then you get the cheap price without frozen stock.

Common mistakes

Typical trap: taking demand as “whatever luck brings”; counting leftover revenue at selling price; ignoring one-off costs of the style; ignoring frozen cash. Also: assuming leftover can be returned to the factory. Also: not counting storage of leftover and the cash frozen in it until clearance.

What data is needed?

  • Expected demand for the season and the average selling price.
  • Run tiers and the factory unit price from the quotation.
  • Optionally: one-off costs of the style, clearance revenue on leftovers, other variable costs.
  • Where to take it: season demand from a cautious sales plan based on history and buyers’ orders; run tiers and factory price from the commercial offer; one-off costs (samples, patterns, grading) from the factory’s invoices; revenue from leftovers from past clearances (as a share of cost); other variable costs from costing. One tier is one row.

Inputs

FieldUnitValue in the exampleMeaning
Expected demand for the seasonunits1,200How many you will really sell at the average price below; estimate cautiously.
Average selling price (excl. VAT)₽4,900Average selling price per unit excl. VAT after discounts.
Revenue on leftovers at clearance (optional)% of cost40How much comes back from unsold goods as a share of their cost. Optional. Empty: the field is ignored (counted as zero in sums).
One-off cost of the style (optional)₽350,000Samples, patterns, grading: spread over the run. Optional. Empty: the field is ignored (counted as zero in sums).
Other variable costs per sold unit₽250Other variable costs per unit sold: logistics, commissions, packing.

How it is calculated

StepFormula
SoldThe lesser of the run and demand
RevenueSold × price + leftovers × cost × clearance share
ProfitRevenue − run × factory price − one-off costs − sold × other variable costs

Worked numbers

Default values from the app; in the interactive version you enter your own.

Best by profit
1.95 m ₽ · Medium (1,000 units)
Cost per sold unit at the best run
2,950 ₽Run cost, one-off and other variable costs minus the revenue from leftovers, per sold unit: the price minus this figure is the profit per unit.
Unsold left at the best run
0 units
Lowest factory price
2,050 ₽ · Maximum discountProfit at it 556,000 ₽: a low price is not always worth it if demand is below the run.

Comparison of runs

TierRunFactory priceCostUnsoldProfit
Minimum run5002,600 ₽1.65 m ₽0675,000 ₽
Medium1,0002,350 ₽2.7 m ₽01.95 m ₽
Large2,0002,150 ₽4.65 m ₽8001.62 m ₽
Maximum discount3,0002,050 ₽6.5 m ₽1,800556,000 ₽

Demand is the most uncertain figure: check the result at demand 20–30% lower and compare with “How much to order under uncertain demand”. Cash frozen in a larger run, count in “Cash flow” and “End-to-end gap”.

Nuances and limits

  • Estimate demand on a cautious scenario: overestimating demand is the main reason for an excessive run.
  • Cash frozen in a bigger run costs interest: compare the factory discount’s benefit with it.
  • A low unit price at a large run is eaten by unsold leftovers: look at profit, not price.
  • Money frozen in a larger run costs interest: check it in the cash flow.

Terms used

Calculate on your data →