Syntha Lab RU

Micro-batch versus large: fixed costs, experience curve, break point

Compares the unit cost and margin of a micro-batch and a large batch of one style: fixed costs for patterns and setup are spread over the batch, labor falls along the experience curve, material is dearer in a small batch. Finds the smallest batch from which margin reaches your target.

Order size and break-even For whom: Heads of production and purchasing, product directors and owners of small brands when choosing the batch size.

Calculate on your data →

At a glance

What question does it answer?
How much a micro-batch costs against a large one and from which batch a style reaches the target margin.
What data is needed?
The selling price, the target margin, material per unit at a standard lot, the surcharge for a small batch and its threshold.
How to read the result?
On the default data (price 4,500, patterns 45,000, setup 12,000, experience 90%) a unit of a micro-batch of 100 pcs costs 2,707.12 against 1,642.54 for a batch of 3,000 pcs: 1,064.58 or 64.8% dearer. Fixed costs give 21.1% of the micro-batch cost. Margin 39.8% against 63.5%. The 45% target is reached from a batch of 148 pcs. To get the large batch’s margin the micro-batch must be sold at 7,416.58. Example on the default values: Unit cost, micro-batch: RUB 2,707.12; Unit cost, large batch: RUB 1,642.54; Gap per unit, the micro-batch is dearer by: RUB 1,064.58; Micro-batch is dearer than the large, %: 64.8%. The figures are illustrative: enter your own to see your result.

Why and how to reason

Unit cost depends on batch size for three reasons. First: fixed costs (patterns, grading, cutting set-up) do not depend on the run, and the smaller the batch, the more per unit. For a micro-batch of 100 units it is (45,000 + 12,000) ÷ 100 = 570, for 3,000 units 19. Second: the experience curve, labor per unit falls with accumulated output. At 90% per doubling the hundredth unit costs 58% of the first and the three-thousandth 35%. Third: material is dearer for a small batch: a 15% surcharge below the threshold of 500 units. As a result the micro-batch is 2,707 against 1,643 for the large one, 65% more, and a margin of 40% against 63% at a price of 4,500. The breakpoint from which margin is not below the 45% target is 148 units.

When to use it

It fits when deciding on a micro-batch, a capsule, a test collection or moving an order to another factory. Do not use it for models where fixed costs are already paid (a repeat). Assumptions: one experience curve for the whole batch, a stepped surcharge on material, one price, pattern costs charged to the model and not the batch, other costs independent of batch size.

How to read the result

The key numbers are the gap per unit (1,065) and the breakpoint (148 units). If your micro-batch is below the breakpoint, you are selling at a loss relative to the target, and the question is price or volume. “Price of the micro-batch at which margin equals the large one” (7,417) shows how much to raise price to make a small run worthwhile: that is the path for an exclusive. If the price cannot be raised, increase the run or cut fixed costs, for example by using ready patterns. It is worth comparing the share of fixed costs (21%) with your ability to lower them.

Common mistakes

Charging patterns per batch rather than per model, taking an 80% experience curve without confirmation, not entering a material surcharge, mixing a factory’s minimum order with an economically sensible one. Check the experience curve against two past batches: it varies a great deal between factories and products.

What data is needed?

  • The selling price, the target margin, material per unit at a standard lot, the surcharge for a small batch and its threshold.
  • Patterns and grading per style, setup per batch.
  • The labor cost of the first unit, the cost share after doubling output, the sizes of the micro-batch and the large batch.

Inputs

FieldUnitValue in the exampleMeaning
Selling price excl. VAT₽4,500The price at which the brand sells a unit (wholesale or yours). The example value is illustrative.
Target margin%45The share of the price that must remain after cost: the break point is searched against it. Your target, not a norm. The example value is illustrative.
Material per unit at a standard lot₽1,100Fabric, trims, packaging per unit at the price for a usual purchase lot, excl. VAT. The example value is illustrative.
Surcharge on material in a small batch%15By how many percent material is dearer when the batch is below the threshold below: remaining stock, small rolls, trims in small lots. The example value is illustrative.
Batch threshold for the standard material pricepcs500From which batch the material is bought at the standard price. For footwear the threshold depends on the last and the size, for accessories on the minimum of material, for children’s on height: take your own. The example value is illustrative.
Patterns and grading per style₽45,000One-off costs per style: construction, patterns, grading. For footwear add lasts and molds by size. The example value is illustrative.
Setup and cutting per batch₽12,000Costs that do not depend on the batch size: line setup, marker, preparation. The example value is illustrative.
Labor cost of the first unit₽1,500The labor cost of the first item including shop overheads, before experience builds up. From your shop data; the example value is illustrative.
Cost share after doubling output%90The experience curve: 90 means that with each doubling of cumulative output the labor cost per unit falls to 90%. 100: no experience. Take it from the shop’s history on similar styles. The example value is illustrative.
Micro-batchpcs100Units in the small batch you want to compare.
Large batchpcs3,000Units in the large batch for comparison; larger than the micro-batch.

How it is calculated

StepFormula
Fixed per unit(patterns and grading + batch setup) ÷ batch
Labour along the experience curvecost of the first unit × sum of n^b over n = 1…Q, b = log2(share after doubling)
Materialstandard price × (1 + surcharge) if the batch is below the threshold
Break pointthe smallest batch at which (price − cost) ÷ price is not below the target

Worked numbers

Default values from the app; in the interactive version you enter your own.

Unit cost, micro-batch
2,707.12 ₽
Unit cost, large batch
1,642.54 ₽
Gap per unit, the micro-batch is dearer by
1,064.58 ₽
Micro-batch is dearer than the large, %
64.8 %
Margin of the micro-batch
39.8 %
Margin of the large batch
63.5 %
Share of fixed costs in the micro-batch unit cost
21.1 %
Labour per unit to the first unit, micro-batch
58.1 %The experience curve effect: the average share of the first unit’s cost.
Labour per unit to the first unit, large batch
34.9 %
Micro-batch price at which margin equals the large batch
7,416.58 ₽Micro-batch cost ÷ (1 − margin of the large batch).
Break point: the smallest batch with margin not below the target
148

Unit cost by batch

BatchUnitsFixed per unitMaterialLabourUnit costMargin
Micro-batch100570 ₽1,265 ₽872.12 ₽2,707.12 ₽39.8 %
Large batch3,00019 ₽1,100 ₽523.54 ₽1,642.54 ₽63.5 %
Break point148385.14 ₽1,265 ₽823.19 ₽2,473.33 ₽45 %

A micro-batch of 100 pcs costs 2,707.12 ₽ per unit against 1,642.54 ₽ for a batch of 3,000 pcs: 21.1 % of the micro-batch cost is patterns and setup. Margin 39.8 % against 63.5 %; the target of 45 % is reached from a batch of 148 pcs.

The experience curve is taken from your history on similar styles; without it enter 100. The calculation does not count the risk of unsold stock: a micro-batch usually sells better by share, a large one leaves a bigger leftover (see the leftover calculations). Amounts excl. VAT.

Nuances and limits

  • Take the experience curve from the shop’s history on similar styles; without data enter 100.
  • The calculation does not count leftover risk: a large batch is cheaper per unit but leaves more unsold.
  • For footwear add lasts and molds by size to the style costs, for children’s the height-based size run.
  • Take the batch threshold for material from the fabric supplier’s terms, not from what you wish.

Terms used

Calculate on your data →