First order and reserve for reorders
Calculates what share of the plan to order at once and how much capacity to keep for a reorder after the first sales. Compares the expected profit, leftover and lost sales of a two-stage order with a single large order. The logic is our own: demand is given by scenarios, early sales remove part of the uncertainty, a reorder costs more and is limited by capacity.
At a glance
- What question does it answer?
- What share of the plan to order at once and how much capacity to keep for a reorder after the first sales.
- What data is needed?
- Price, unit cost, the rush surcharge and the recovery on leftover.
- How to read the result?
- An example with the default figures: a 70% first order (7,000 pcs) gives an expected profit of 27.15m against 26.325m for a single order of 10,000 pcs: a gain of 825,000. Leftover of 175 pcs costs 210,000 and lost sales of 625 pcs cost 1,875,000 in margin. A single order loses 3,675,000 (875 pcs leftover and 875 pcs lost). The share table shows the best share (90% in the example); if the best share is close to 100%, reorder capacity or the signal is too weak for a two-stage order. Example on the default values: Expected profit: your share — 27.2 m RUB; Expected profit: a single order — 26.3 m RUB; Gain of the two-stage order — RUB 825,000; Best first-order share (5% step) — 90% · profit 28.3 m RUB.
Why and how to reason
Ordering everything at once is risky: if demand turns out low, unsold goods remain, if high, you lose sales. A two-stage order reduces risk: first part of the plan, then after seeing early sales a re-buy (dearer and limited by capacity). Demand is given by scenarios: low 6,500 (25%), base 10,000 (50%), high 13,500 (25%). A single order of 10,000: in the low scenario 3,500 remain at a price of 800 against cost of 2,000, loss 4.2 million; in the high scenario 3,500 pieces are missed at a margin of 3,000, loss 10.5 million. Expected loss 0.25 × 4.2 + 0.25 × 10.5 = 3.675 million, expected profit 26.3 million. Two-stage, 70% at once (7,000) and a re-buy up to 40% of the plan at a 15% markup: expected profit 27.15 million, gain 825 thousand ₽, leftover 175 units, missed 625. The best first-order share is 90%.
When to use it
It is useful for goods that can be re-bought in season (basics, fast factories) under uncertain demand. Assumptions: scenarios and probabilities are honestly estimated, the early signal (80%) shows demand in the first weeks, re-buy capacity exists. It does not fit collections with a long production cycle nor goods that cannot be re-bought. If the rush markup exceeds the loss from leftovers, a two-stage order does not pay.
How to read the result
Look at the gain of a two-stage order against a single one and at the best first-order share: you have 70%, the optimum is 90%, so you are too cautious and the unused re-buy capacity is not needed. Leftover and missed demand in units show what you fear more. Check the accuracy of the early signal: at low accuracy the re-buy is made blind and the gain falls. Decision: order a larger first part and keep the re-buy for high demand. Agree on a capacity reserve for the re-buy with the factory in advance and in writing: without a reserve the calculation describes an option that may not exist.
Common mistakes
The usual mistakes: setting scenarios for show without probabilities; not entering the leftover price; overstating re-buy capacity; ignoring that the re-buy arrives later and loses part of the season. The 25/50/25 probabilities are illustrative: enter your own, based on history. Do not treat the re-buy as guaranteed: delivery dates slip.
What data is needed?
- Price, unit cost, the rush surcharge and the recovery on leftover.
- The single order, your first-order share, reorder capacity and early-signal accuracy.
- Demand scenarios with probabilities (in the example 6,500, 10,000 and 13,500 pcs with probabilities 25, 50 and 25%).
Inputs
| Field | Unit | Value in the example | Meaning |
|---|---|---|---|
| Selling price per piece excl. VAT | ₽ | 5,000 | Average full price excl. VAT. |
| Unit cost excl. VAT | ₽ | 2,000 | The first-order price at the factory or workshop, delivered to the warehouse. |
| Surcharge for a rush reorder | % | 15 | On top of unit cost. From your contract or correspondence; there is no Russian benchmark, enter your own. |
| Recovery per leftover piece | ₽ | 800 | What you actually get per leftover piece after clearance, excl. VAT. |
| Single order (main plan) | pcs | 10,000 | What you would order if there were no reorder. The first order is a share of it. |
| Your first-order share | % | 70 | The share of the main plan ordered at once. Example: 70%. |
| Reorder capacity | % | 40 | As a percentage of the main plan; how much production can make in-season. From your contract. |
| Accuracy of the early signal | % | 80 | What share of the demand uncertainty the first sales remove: 0% means the signal is useless, 100% means demand is known. Estimate from past seasons. |
How it is calculated
| Step | Formula |
|---|---|
| Demand estimate after early sales | estimate = (1 − accuracy) × mean demand + accuracy × scenario demand |
| Reorder | = min(capacity; max(0; estimate − first order)) if the price is above the reorder cost |
| Sold | = min(demand; first order + reorder); leftover and lost by the difference |
| Scenario profit | = sold × price + leftover × recovery − first × cost − reorder × cost × (1 + surcharge) |
| Expected | the sum of scenario profits with their probabilities |
Worked numbers
Default values from the app; in the interactive version you enter your own.
- Expected profit: your share
- 27.2 m ₽
- Expected profit: a single order
- 26.3 m ₽
- Gain of the two-stage order
- 825,000 ₽
- Best first-order share (5% step)
- 90 % · profit 28.3 m ₽
- Expected leftover: your share
- 175 pcs
- Loss on leftover: your share
- 210,000 ₽Leftover × (unit cost − recovery per leftover piece).
- Expected lost sales: your share
- 625 pcs
- Margin lost on lost sales: your share
- 1.88 m ₽Lost pieces × (price − unit cost).
- Leftover and lost sales: single order, loss
- 3.68 m ₽For comparison with your share: the sum of the two losses under a single order.
- Expected reorder: your share
- 2,550 pcs
First-order share and the expected result
| First share | First order, pcs | Expected profit | Leftover, pcs | Lost, pcs | Vs single order |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 40 % | 4,000 | 21.5 m ₽ | 175 | 2,375 | −4.8 m ₽ |
| 45 % | 4,500 | 22.7 m ₽ | 175 | 2,000 | −3.64 m ₽ |
| 50 % | 5,000 | 23.9 m ₽ | 175 | 1,625 | −2.48 m ₽ |
| 55 % | 5,500 | 25 m ₽ | 175 | 1,250 | −1.31 m ₽ |
| 60 % | 6,000 | 26.2 m ₽ | 175 | 875 | −150,000 ₽ |
| 65 % | 6,500 | 26.7 m ₽ | 175 | 750 | 337,500 ₽ |
| 70 % | 7,000 | 27.2 m ₽ | 175 | 625 | 825,000 ₽ |
| 75 % | 7,500 | 27.5 m ₽ | 250 | 500 | 1.2 m ₽ |
| 80 % | 8,000 | 27.8 m ₽ | 375 | 375 | 1.5 m ₽ |
| 85 % | 8,500 | 28.1 m ₽ | 500 | 250 | 1.8 m ₽ |
| 90 % | 9,000 | 28.3 m ₽ | 625 | 175 | 1.97 m ₽ |
| 95 % | 9,500 | 28.3 m ₽ | 750 | 175 | 1.93 m ₽ |
| 100 % | 10,000 | 28.2 m ₽ | 875 | 175 | 1.89 m ₽ |
A share of 90% gives 1.14 m ₽ more than yours.
Scenarios, probabilities and signal accuracy are your estimate. Test the result on several sets: if the decision flips on small edits, take the more cautious share.
Nuances and limits
- Assuming high signal accuracy without testing it on past seasons.
- Forgetting that reorder capacity is limited and the lead time eats part of the season.
- Setting scenarios and probabilities at random: the result is sensitive to them.