Order size and break-even
How much you must sell for the collection to pay back, and how much to order under uncertain demand.
About the topic
This topic answers the question a brand asks before sending an order to the factory: how many pieces to order. Before the order is placed the volume can still change; afterwards the money is already in fabric and sewing and a mistake has to be sold at a discount. So there are two views at once: how much must be sold for the collection simply to pay back (break-even), and how much to order when demand is unknown in advance.
Break-even is simple. Say you order 1,000 pieces at a cost of RUB 1,200: RUB 1,200,000 invested. The real average price you will get is not the list price: part will go at a discount and buyers will get terms, so we take net revenue per unit after all concessions, say RUB 2,100 before VAT. Then break-even is 1,200,000 / 2,100 ≈ 571 pieces, or 57% of the run. If you are sure to sell at least 60%, risk is small; if you hope for 55%, you are close to the edge. This figure shows how thin your safety margin is.
When demand is uncertain, something else matters more: what costs more, a shortage or an excess. A shortage costs lost margin (2,100 − 1,200 = RUB 900 per unit). An excess costs the gap between cost and the price at which leftovers will go, say RUB 800: a loss of RUB 400 per unit. The ratio 900 / (900 + 400) ≈ 0.69 shows up to which quantile of demand to order: the level covered with probability about 69%. This is the reasoning behind the critical-ratio formula: order more when a shortage costs more than an excess.
The decisions of this topic: whether to accept the factory’s discount for a larger run; whether to make the first order smaller and keep a reserve for reordering; whether to go to a trade show and take pre-orders; whether a micro-batch is worth it. The main trap is comparing runs by unit price rather than by profit. Example: 500 pieces at RUB 1,300 against 1,000 pieces at RUB 1,200 at real demand of 600. In the first case profit is 500 × 2,100 − 650,000 = RUB 400,000. In the second 600 × 2,100 + 400 × 800 − 1,200,000 = RUB 380,000. The cheaper unit lost because the leftover is costlier. Start with one collection: break-even, then two or three demand scenarios.
Key ideas
Break-even on the net price
Break-even is more sensitive to discounts than it seems. With RUB 900,000 invested and a net price of RUB 1,800, the threshold is 500 pcs. Give the buyer another 10% off and the price becomes RUB 1,620, while the threshold rises to 556 pcs (900,000 / 1,620). The discount is 10%, but the required volume is 11% higher: the deeper the concession, the faster it grows.
Cost of shortage and cost of excess
The cost of excess depends on where the leftover goes. Margin is RUB 900 per unit. If leftovers can be sold for RUB 1,000 against a cost of RUB 1,200 (a loss of RUB 200), the shortage share is 900 / 1,100 ≈ 0.82, and the order safely goes above average demand. If the loss equals the margin, RUB 900, the share is 0.5 and you order exactly the median. So before calculating volume, find out where and for how much the leftovers can be sold.
Critical ratio
The share of shortage cost in the sum of both losses shows the demand level to order up to: 900 / 1,300 ≈ 0.69. For roughly normal demand with mean 600 and spread 100 this is about 600 + 0.5 × 100 = 650 pieces. The larger the spread, the further the order moves from the mean.
Volume discount and tiers
Compare tiers by the demand at which they are equal. The net price is RUB 2,100 and leftovers go at RUB 800. A batch of 400 pcs at RUB 1,350 earns RUB 300,000. A batch of 800 pcs at RUB 1,200 earns 1,300 × D − RUB 320,000, where D is demand in pieces. They are equal at D ≈ 477: the larger batch is justified if demand exceeds 477 pcs, almost 60% of the batch.
First order and reorder reserve
If the factory can add a batch quickly, the first order is made conservative and the reorder is decided from early sales. You pay a small premium for speed but avoid leftovers. The reserve works while the reorder lead time is shorter than the season window.
The order of the first batch waits for the critical tasks of the stage, not for “about half” of the route
There are 31 tasks left on the route out of 63, 10 of them critical. On the production stage 2 critical tasks are not closed, and while they are open it is too early to place the order. A conditional batch of 1,200 units at a cost of RUB 2,400 is RUB 2.88 million, put at risk by a premature order: the sample, the acceptance terms and the supplier documents are closed first, the volume is confirmed later. While the blocker stage is not ready the next stages, channels and calendar, remain provisional. The transition condition is described in the term “Launch stage gate”.
Formula: The sum at risk = units in the batch × cost per unit; the order is placed when all critical tasks of the stage are done
What to do: Before placing the order check the production stage: critical tasks closed, the threshold of the rest met; otherwise order a smaller trial batch.
Think first: The route is 51% done. Why is it not enough to order the batch?
Answer: The order depends on the critical tasks of the production stage: two of six are not closed. A batch of 1,200 units at RUB 2,400 is RUB 2.88 million at risk.
The buying plan goes backwards from revenue
The order is derived by a chain: plan revenue 110.0 m RUB, minus the non-seasonal revenue leaves the seasonal 98.0 m RUB; it is divided by the markup coefficient and by one minus the discount to get the cost of goods sold 49.9 m RUB; Sell-through before the sale gives the delivery 58.4 m RUB, cancellation gives the order 63.5 m RUB. Each assumption is visible on its own and open to challenge.
Formula: Order = cost before the sale ÷ sell-through before the sale ÷ (1 − cancellation)
What to do: If the order does not fit the budget, change the plan growth or discounts and record the reason; Sell-through is not fitted to the wanted order.
Think first: Season sell-through came out at 85.3%. What does a value above 100% mean?
Answer: The plan requires selling more than is delivered: revenue is overstated, the markup understated or the discounts too deep.
The markup coefficient is not the markup percent
The coefficient is the price excl. VAT divided by cost: 2.4 is a markup of 140%. If the percent is put into the formula, cost comes out several times lower than the real one. The effective discount of the plan 18.1% is counted from the same coefficient.
Formula: Coefficient = price ÷ cost; markup % = (coefficient − 1) × 100
What to do: Record in the reference which markup you store: the coefficient or the percent.
How many to launch to get the required good pieces
A contract order is in good pieces, while the workshop gets a launch. Stage yields multiply: cutting 98%, sewing 96%, QC 94%, packing 99.5% give 87.99%, so for 5,000 good pieces 5,683 must be launched. If half of the QC rejects can be reworked, the yield is 90.80%, the launch 5,507. An average yield hides the stage where money is lost: count losses in money at the accumulated cost.
Formula: Launch = required good pieces ÷ rolled yield
What to do: Put the launch and the defect allowance into the contract.
Think first: Stage yields are 98, 96, 94 and 99.5%. What is the rolled yield?
Answer: About 88%: yields multiply, they are not averaged.
How to work through it
- Assemble the investment: unit cost at the warehouse and the run size.
- Determine the average net price after discounts, buyer terms and returns.
- Compute break-even volume and its share of the run.
- Describe demand with three scenarios (low, expected, high) with probabilities.
- Find the loss on leftovers: at what price the tail will go and what it costs.
- Compare runs and factory price tiers by expected profit.
- Decide on a reorder reserve and the deadline by which it can be made.
- Check the order path: confirmation, fill rate (share fulfilled) and lost sales on short delivery.
Where to start
First collection break-even: how much must be sold to recover the run. Then the order under uncertain demand, the item price by run tier and a first-order scheme with a reserve for top-ups. Calculations of the topic in order: “Collection break-even and order size”, “How much to order under uncertain demand”, “Unit price by run tiers and the minimum run”, “First order and reserve for reorders”, “Trade fair and pre-order: payback and batch risk”, “Starter brand model: first batch and cash to start”, “Order path: confirmation, fill rate and lost sales”, “Micro-batch versus large: fixed costs, experience curve, break point”, “Label launch readiness: stages, critical tasks, the blocking stage and how many tasks are missing”, “Yield cascade across stages”. See also (their primary topic is another one): “Reorder from early sales”, “Order entry: a check of MOQ, multiples, the delivery window and payment”, “Seasonal buying: critical ratio and the optimal quantity under normal demand”, “Buying plan from revenue backwards: revenue → cost → order”.
Calculations in this topic
Collection break-even and order size
Calculates how many units you must sell to recover development and launch, and shows profit at different sell-through of the run.
How many units you must sell to recover development and launch.
How much to order under uncertain demand
Compares order sizes by expected profit: ordering less than demand loses sales, ordering more leaves stock that clears at a lower price.
Which order size gives the highest expected profit if demand may vary.
Unit price by run tiers and the minimum run
Compares run options with different factory prices: cost, unsold stock and profit. Shows at which run it pays to order and when a cheap price for a big run turns into frozen stock.
Which run is better to order if the unit price falls as the run grows and demand is uncertain.
First order and reserve for reorders
Calculates what share of the plan to order at once and how much capacity to keep for a reorder after the first sales. Compares the expected profit, leftover and lost sales of a two-stage order with a single large order. The logic is our own: demand is given by scenarios, early sales remove part of the uncertainty, a reorder costs more and is limited by capacity.
What share of the plan to order at once and how much capacity to keep for a reorder after the first sales.
Trade fair and pre-order: payback and batch risk
Two questions of wholesale. Whether taking part in a trade fair or showroom pays back: orders from contacts against the cost of taking part and the break-even number of orders. Whether to launch a batch on pre-orders: how many units are confirmed, whether they cover the factory minimum, how much money depends on free sales and what the result is.
Whether a trade fair or showroom will pay back and whether pre-orders are enough to launch a batch safely.
Starter brand model: first batch and cash to start
Calculates the economics of a new brand from zero: net price and unit margin, break-even sales per month, the minimum first batch, the peak cash need and the result of the first batch by month. Samples, launch and fixed costs are entered separately so you can see what eats the start.
What first batch is needed, how much cash the start will take and when it returns.
Order path: confirmation, fill rate and lost sales
By units reconciles “ordered, confirmed, delivered, accepted”: the confirmation rate (CONF), fulfillment of what was confirmed, unit fill rate overall and on time, where most is lost and what the shortfall and lateness cost. OTIF by orders alongside.
How much of what was ordered is confirmed, delivered and accepted, where most is lost and what it costs.
Micro-batch versus large: fixed costs, experience curve, break point
Compares the unit cost and margin of a micro-batch and a large batch of one style: fixed costs for patterns and setup are spread over the batch, labor falls along the experience curve, material is dearer in a small batch. Finds the smallest batch from which margin reaches your target.
How much a micro-batch costs against a large one and from which batch a style reaches the target margin.
Label launch readiness: stages, critical tasks, the blocking stage and how many tasks are missing
From a table of stages (how many tasks, how many done, how many of them are critical and how many critical are done) and a readiness threshold it counts which stages are ready, which stage blocks moving on and how many tasks are missing before it is ready. A stage is ready only when all critical tasks are done and not less than the threshold of the others. The calculation shows the order of work, not the quality of execution: “done” is marked by you.
Which launch stages are ready, which one blocks moving on, how many tasks are missing before it is ready and how many critical tasks are left.
Yield cascade across stages
Multiplies the yields of four stages (cutting, sewing, quality control, packing) into a rolled yield, counts how many pieces to launch to get the required number of good ones and the cost of losses at each stage at the accumulated cost. Compares with a variant in which part of the QC rejects can be reworked.
How many to launch to get the required good pieces and where money is lost.
Reorder from early sales
Builds a season forecast from the first weeks of sales and the cumulative curve of past seasons, estimates the reorder needed (low, central and high) and calculates the profit of the reorder lot including the rush surcharge and the minimum lot.
How much to reorder after the first weeks of sales and whether it is worth it at the rush surcharge.
Order entry: a check of MOQ, multiples, the delivery window and payment
Checks an order to a supplier before entry: the minimum lots by SKU, the multiple of the size run or box, the minimum order amount, whether the delivery falls into the window before the sales start and the payment schedule (prepayment and the balance). Suggests corrected quantities.
Is the supplier order right before entry: lots, multiples, the minimum amount, timing and payment.
Seasonal buying: critical ratio and the optimal quantity under normal demand
Finds the buying quantity of a seasonal item that maximizes expected profit when demand is given by a mean and a spread: the critical ratio, the stock-out probability, expected leftovers and lost sales, the gain against your plan.
How much of a seasonal item to buy so that expected profit is highest when demand is uncertain, and what that gives against your plan.
Buying plan from revenue backwards: revenue → cost → order
Goes from the net revenue forecast of the current season to the order for the next one: adds the plan growth, subtracts the non-seasonal revenue (old seasons, future ones, consignment, made to order), turns the seasonal revenue into cost of goods sold through the markup coefficient and the period discount, then through Sell-through at cost and the cancellation rate into delivery and order. Shows the effective discount of the plan. The stock under this budget is counted in the “Open-to-buy” calculation; here we answer how large the order must be for the plan revenue to add up.
How large the order must be for the plan revenue to add up at your markup, discounts, sell-through and cancellation, and what effective discount the plan holds.
Self-check questions
- What volume must I sell to recover the investment and what share of the run is it?
- At what price do I count break-even: list or net average?
- What does a one-unit shortage cost and what does an excess cost?
- What is my demand range and where does it come from?
- At what price and by what time will leftovers go?
- Is the factory volume discount worthwhile once leftovers are counted?
- Can I reorder and will it arrive in time for the season?
- What share of the order will the factory really fulfill on time?
- What happens to profit if sales fall 25% below plan?
Knowledge check
Multiple-choice questions. The correct answer and the explanation follow each question.
How many critical tasks are left on the whole route if there are 26 and 16 are done?
- A. 31
- B. 10
- C. 2
- D. 16
Correct answer: B. 10. 26 − 16 = 10; 31 is the remainder of all tasks. Of the critical ones 2 lie on the production stage. Covered in: The order of the first batch waits for the critical tasks of the stage, not for “about half” of the route.
A batch of 1,200 units, a cost of RUB 2,400. What sum does an order placed before the critical tasks are closed put at risk?
- A. 1.44 m ₽
- B. 2.88 m ₽
- C. 7.2 m ₽
- D. 2,400 ₽
Correct answer: B. 2.88 m ₽. 1,200 × RUB 2,400 = RUB 2.88 million. This is money at cost, not revenue: shelf revenue would be larger, but goods without ready documents cannot be sold. Covered in: The order of the first batch waits for the critical tasks of the stage, not for “about half” of the route.
3 tasks are missing before the production stage is ready. How should they be read?
- A. Three tasks, including 2 critical ones: close them first
- B. Any three tasks of the stage, the critical ones do not matter
- C. Three tasks of the next stage
- D. Three tasks of any stage of the route
Correct answer: A. Three tasks, including 2 critical ones: close them first. A stage is ready at all critical tasks and not less than 80% of the rest. 2 of the missing 3 are critical: without them the threshold does not count. Covered in: The order of the first batch waits for the critical tasks of the stage, not for “about half” of the route.
What does the order start from when counted backwards from revenue?
- A. The stock in the warehouse
- B. A competitor price
- C. The revenue forecast and the plan growth from which the non-seasonal part is subtracted
- D. The number of stores
Correct answer: C. The revenue forecast and the plan growth from which the non-seasonal part is subtracted. Stock and orders in transit are subtracted by the OTB calculation; the plan chain starts from revenue. Covered in: The buying plan goes backwards from revenue.
The markup coefficient is 2.4. What is the markup in percent?
- A. 140%
- B. 240%
- C. 2%
- D. Cannot be determined
Correct answer: A. 140%. Markup = (coefficient − 1) × 100. Covered in: The markup coefficient is not the markup percent.
What is the rolled yield of stages 98, 96, 94 and 99.5%?
- A. 96.88%
- B. 94.00%
- C. 87.99%
- D. 96.00%
Correct answer: C. 87.99%. The product: 0.98 × 0.96 × 0.94 × 0.995. Covered in: How many to launch to get the required good pieces.
How many to launch for 5,000 good pieces (rounded up)?
- A. 5,683
- B. 5,319
- C. 5,400
- D. 5,000
Correct answer: A. 5,683. 5,000 ÷ 0.8799 = 5,682.2, up 5,683. Covered in: How many to launch to get the required good pieces.
What does reworking half of the QC rejects give?
- A. A yield above 99%
- B. The launch does not change
- C. The launch grows
- D. A yield of 90.80%, a launch of 5,507
Correct answer: D. A yield of 90.80%, a launch of 5,507. The QC yield rises to 97%. Covered in: How many to launch to get the required good pieces.
Common mistakes
Mistake: Taking the list price instead of the average after discounts
What it costs: Break-even looks lower than real
How to avoid: Count on net revenue per unit.
Mistake: Planning only optimistic demand
What it costs: Leftovers exceed what margin pays for
How to avoid: Set three scenarios and weight them.
Mistake: Comparing runs by unit price
What it costs: Choosing the cheapest, not the most profitable
How to avoid: Compare expected profit including leftovers.
Mistake: Counting break-even at full price although part will go at a discount
What it costs: The investment will not return on time
How to avoid: Include the share sold at a discount.
Mistake: Ignoring the factory fill rate
What it costs: The actual batch is smaller than ordered and sales are lost
How to avoid: Include short delivery and lead time in the plan.
Mistake: The order is placed at “about half” of the route
What it costs: Critical production tasks are open, the batch goes blind A conditional order of 1,200 units at RUB 2,400 is RUB 2.88 million at risk of defects, missed deadlines and rework.
How to avoid: Check the critical tasks of the stage before the order Close the critical tasks of the stage and place a small trial batch first, then confirm the full volume after acceptance.
What it looks like (illustrative figures): 51% of tasks are done, but 2 of 6 critical tasks are open on the production stage.
Substituting the markup percent for the coefficient
What it looks like (illustrative figures): Cost comes out several times lower, the order is understated.
Not subtracting the non-seasonal revenue
What it looks like (illustrative figures): The order also covers what will sell from old seasons and consignment.
Mistake: Taking an average yield
What it costs: The launch is understated A short delivery of the order.
How to avoid: Count by stage Count yield by stage and fix the defect allowance in the contract.
What it looks like (illustrative figures): An average yield of 96.9% gives about 5,161 instead of 5,683.
Russia and the EAEU
For a Russian brand the order-volume decision rests on money already frozen: a prepayment to the factory, then the buyer’s deferral. So besides break-even one looks at the cost of holding goods: loan interest, warehouse, discount risk. Choose the rate by your real cost of money, not by a benchmark.
Taxes change the net price. The buyer price is counted before 22% VAT if you are a payer; on the simplified regime the net price and the buyer’s credit differ, so ask how the buyer purchases. Chestny ZNAK marking also applies to leftovers: you need codes for the whole run before circulation, and unsold goods do not release you from these costs. The end of transition periods and stock rules is set by decree No. 2129 (the fourth marking wave): check which dates apply to your category.
The minimum batch, size multiples and delivery window are fixed in the contract and specification; electronic document exchange (UPD) confirms shipment. If you sell on marketplaces, remember that stock in the platform warehouse blocks money and paid storage grows with time: take tariffs from the current offer. For a trade show and pre-orders, count buyer prepayments as part of financing, not as a guarantee of sales.
The volume logic is the same in any country, but the currency, VAT rate and marking rules change. For reference: VAT rates by country are on the page “EAEU and CIS countries” (as of 14.11.2026). In Kazakhstan light-industry marking is introduced in stages from 1 December 2026 and stock must be marked by 1 January 2028: for the volume plan this means the cost of codes on unsold goods. For Belarus, Armenia and Kyrgyzstan (domestic market) the dates of national marking: indicative as of 14.11.2026, check the text of the act. If you order a batch for several EAEU countries, sizes, packaging languages and codes are counted separately for each market, and the factory minimum is split among the countries.
Categories and audiences
- Apparel
- For apparel: seasonal risk is the highest and leftovers lose value quickly, so the loss on leftovers grows toward the end of the season. Order the main volume on basic models and keep fashion items to a small first order with a reserve. Count break-even on the net price including the depth of the end-of-season discount.
- Footwear
- If it is footwear: the batch spreads over 8-12 sizes, so unsold extreme sizes remain as a tail even when the core has gone. The minimum batch for tooling is higher than in apparel. Count leftovers by size, not in total, and allow for reordering only the core of the size run.
- Accessories
- On accessories: unit cost is low and the minimum batch in pieces is large, so the run often exceeds demand, but the leftover per unit is cheap and goods can be kept for the next season. A shortage costs more than an excess and storage is longer: order more generously than apparel.
- Kids
- In children’s wear: demand is tied to the school and holiday calendar, and sizes change quickly, so leftovers of the previous growth sell worse. Certification and marking are fixed per item and a small run does not recoup them. Count break-even including these fixed costs.
- Men
- A men’s basic model (jeans, shirt) lives longer than one season: leftovers carry over to the next one, so the loss on excess is smaller, the critical ratio is higher, and the order goes above average demand. The factory’s larger-batch tier is more attractive here. Calculate the break-even point on annual demand for the model, not seasonal demand.
- Women
- A women’s model splits into colors and sizes, and leftovers in one color do not cover a shortage in another, so excess costs more. The order is calculated for the whole model and then split by color, with the reorder reserve kept for the colors that early sales confirm. Check that after splitting no part falls below the factory minimum batch.
Questions this topic answers
- How many units must we sell for the collection to pay back?
- How much to order if demand may turn out differently?
- What will be left unsold and what does it cost?
- Does the factory’s discount for a bigger run pay back once leftovers are counted?
Key measures and terms
Study first
What next
Next step: “Collection and range”, “Order data quality”, “Working with stock: transfers, top-up, defects, prices, order entry”. Related: “Investment in collections and projects”, “Cash and working capital”, “Season, price and discounts”.
Documents on this topic
- Sourcing from factories: CMT, FOB, OEM/ODM, full cost and lead times
- Wholesale documents: pre-order, ship window, chargebacks, EDI/ASN
- Footwear: lasts, size run, returns and buying economics
- Niches: sport and outdoor, underwear, outerwear, knitwear, bridal, school uniform, workwear
- Scale and barriers: economies of scale, experience curve, CAC, tipping point
- Ultra-fast and flexible chains: test-and-repeat, on-demand, near sourcing
- Target audience segmentation and segment size: TAM, SAM and SOM with honest assumptions
- Label launch: from an idea to the first sales — stages, documents, calculations in order and readiness criteria
- A buying plan from revenue backwards: revenue, cost, delivery, order and the recalculation rules
- The factory under a magnifier: price by article, single-supplier risk, cost of quality, yield and money in the workshop
- Sourcing from China: finding and checking a supplier, a trial batch, cargo, acceptance and the full cost
- A data cube for planning: measures, dimensions, grain and the season calendar