The factory under a magnifier: price by article, single-supplier risk, cost of quality, yield and money in the workshop
The document gathers six checks a brand makes before an order and after the first batch: a justified sewing price from its own norms, supplier concentration, the cost of quality, yield by stage, money in work in progress and the choice between a customer-supplied scheme and the factory buying the material. The decision it supports: at what price, launch volume and supply scheme to agree with a factory.
Why this document
A factory knows its costs better than the brand, and haggling over the total is lost by the one without its own breakdown. If the price is split into materials, labor, overheads and profit, it is visible in which article the quote diverges from the norms, and the argument is about the time study, not about mood. The same principles work for quality and launch: the cost of defects and the yield by stage turn the words “all is fine with us” into roubles. The document is read by the buyer, the production manager, the technologist and the finance director.
At a glance
- What is this document and why is it needed?
- The document gathers six checks a brand makes before an order and after the first batch: a justified sewing price from its own norms, supplier concentration, the cost of quality, yield by stage, money in work in progress and the choice between a customer-supplied scheme and the factory buying the material. The decision it supports: at what price, launch volume and supply scheme to agree with a factory.
- Who owns the document and how often is it rebuilt?
- Brand: the production manager collects the norms and the time study, the buyer negotiates, the finance director approves the assumptions; recalculate before each order and after each batch.
- What mistakes are the most common?
- Taking SAM from the factory’s word → the should-cost repeats its norms → measure with a time study. Comparing a quote with logistics against one without → the gap is distorted → bring them to the same terms. Counting supplier risk only by share → the replacement time is ignored → enter the weeks without supply.
For whom
- Brand
- A brand on contract compares factory quotes, counts the launch for an order and the defect reserve and decides whether to supply fabric itself. The consumption norms and the time study belong to the brand, not to the factory.
- Retail
- A retailer with a private label does the same on a smaller scale: the should-cost helps check an agent’s quote, and the cost of quality shows what returns of the private label cost.
What it consists of
The should-cost of a piece
- Materials = fabric consumption × price × (1 + waste) + trims + packing. Labor = SAM in minutes × the factory rate per minute. Overheads = a percent of labor. Factory profit = a percent of the subtotal.
- If the factory disclosed the price breakdown, the gap is split into materials, labor with overheads and profit; the largest positive gap is the article to negotiate. If it did not, the calculation shows the profit the quote builds in at your norms.
- The price is compared on the same terms: with fabric or without, with logistics or without. Otherwise the gap measures the difference of terms, not the factory’s greed.
Supplier concentration and a second source
- HHI is the sum of squared supplier shares; the inverse shows the effective number of equal suppliers. The expected loss equals the probability of failure times the share of the largest, the margin and the share of the season without supply.
- A second source pays off when the loss it removes is above the price surcharge on the moved volume. The switching time enters the calculation as a separate number: there is no instant replacement.
The cost of quality and the yield
- The cost of quality is prevention, appraisal, internal and external failure. External failure includes customers’ returns, exchanges and claims; if it is zero, it was most likely not counted.
- The yield multiplies by stage: cutting, sewing, QC, packing. For the required good pieces the launch equals the target divided by the rolled yield; the losses of each stage are counted at the accumulated cost.
- Reworking part of the QC rejects raises the QC yield but costs money: the net effect equals the saved losses minus the cost of rework.
Money in the workshop and the customer-supplied scheme
- By Little’s law there are as many pieces in progress as the daily output times the cycle time. Money in them is counted by the degree of completion, not by the full cost.
- The customer-supplied scheme wins if logistics, the cost of early payment, insurance and losses above the norm are less than the factory’s markup on material. Accounting, taxes and liability for handing over the material are defined by the contract and a specialist.
What to do with the result
- Show the factory the should-cost by article and ask it to disclose the article with the largest gap; check SAM with your own time study.
- Put the launch, not the number of good pieces, into the order and write the defect allowance into the contract; revise the norms after each batch.
- If one supplier holds most of the buy, qualify a second one on a small volume in advance: it is cheaper than looking for a replacement at the moment of failure.
Where the data comes from
| Data source | Fields |
|---|---|
| Specification and time study | fabric consumption, waste, trims, packing, SAM, factory rate |
| Purchases and deliveries | supplier shares, margin, replacement terms, factory quotes |
| Quality and production | defects by stage, returns, daily output, cycle time, accumulated cost |
How to build it step by step
- Step 1: Collect the norms from the specification and measure SAM with a time study.
- Step 2: Count the should-cost by article and compare it with the quote on the same terms.
- Step 3: Ask the factory for the price breakdown and find the article with the largest gap.
- Step 4: Count the supplier shares, HHI and the expected loss of a failure of the largest.
- Step 5: Compare the loss with the cost of a second source and decide whether to qualify it.
- Step 6: Collect the four categories of the cost of quality, including returns, and find the failure share.
- Step 7: Count the launch from the stage yields and the losses in money at the accumulated cost.
- Step 8: Estimate the money in the workshop and compare the customer-supplied scheme with buying by the factory.
Formulas
| Measure | Formulas | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Should-cost | (materials + labor + overheads) × (1 + profit); gap = quote − should-cost | Prices excl. VAT, on the same delivery terms. |
| Launch | required good pieces ÷ (cutting yield × sewing yield × QC yield × packing yield) | Round up. |
| Money in the workshop | daily output × cycle time × cost × degree of completion | For a steady flow. |
Worked example
An illustrative example: a quote of RUB 1,720 against the should-cost and the launch for 5,000 good pieces
| Metric | Value |
|---|---|
| Materials, RUB | 806.0 |
| Labor, RUB | 437.0 |
| Should-cost, RUB | 1,480.2 |
| Gap, RUB | 239.8 |
| Rolled yield, % | 88.0 |
| Launch, pcs | 5,683 |
HHI of suppliers is 300.0 thousandths, the cost of quality RUB 7.8 million, money in the workshop RUB 6.0 million, saving under the customer-supplied scheme RUB 41.4 per piece. All numbers are illustrative.
Figures
- positive
- negative
- total
Data as a table
| Step | Change | Level |
|---|---|---|
| Materials | +806 | 806 |
| Labor | +437 | 1,243 |
| Overheads | +79 | 1,322 |
| Profit | +159 | 1,481 |
| Gap | +240 | 1,721 |
| Quote | — | 1,720 |
From norms to the factory price. The gap between the should-cost and the quote is a separate step.
Data as a table
| Measure | Costs |
|---|---|
| Prevention | 0.8 |
| Appraisal | 1.5 |
| Internal failure | 2.4 |
| External failure | 3.1 |
Cost of quality by category. Failures are more than twice as heavy as prevention and appraisal together.
Specifics by category
- Apparel
- Apparel: SAM and waste depend on the fabric pattern and the number of sizes in the marker.
- Footwear
- Footwear: defects and yield by stage are counted separately by last and upper material.
- Accessories
- Accessories: trims and packing give a noticeable share of the price, count them line by line.
- Kids
- Kids: higher inspection requirements and external failure by claims, set aside more for appraisal.
- Men
- Men: long runs, stable yield, a time study pays off faster.
- Women
- Women: more styles and short runs, a longer cycle, work in progress costs more.
Common mistakes
- Taking SAM from the factory’s word → the should-cost repeats its norms → measure with a time study.
- Comparing a quote with logistics against one without → the gap is distorted → bring them to the same terms.
- Counting supplier risk only by share → the replacement time is ignored → enter the weeks without supply.
- Counting only workshop defects → customer returns are not counted → include external failure.
- Taking an average yield instead of the yield by stage → the launch is understated → count each stage.
- Counting work in progress at the full cost → money in the workshop is overstated → take the degree of completion.
- Giving material without loss norms and insurance → losses fall on the brand → fix norms in the contract.
Russian specifics
- The method is managerial and not regulated; accounting and taxes on handing material over to a factory (the customer-supplied scheme) are defined by the contract and the accountant. The defect allowance is written into the contract through AQL.