Syntha Lab RU

Cost of quality: prevention, appraisal, internal and external failure

Adds the four categories of quality cost, shows the cost of poor quality (COPQ: internal and external failure), the share of quality cost in revenue and the shares of the categories. Estimates whether extra prevention pays off at the expected reduction of defects: the annual effect, ROI and payback.

Choosing a factory and quality For whom: Quality and production directors.

Calculate on your data →

At a glance

What question does it answer?
What quality costs, how much of it is failure and whether prevention pays off.
What data is needed?
Four cost categories.
How to read the result?
The failure share of the cost of quality and the ROI of prevention. Example on the default values: Cost of poor quality (COPQ): RUB 5.5 million; Cost of quality: RUB 7.8 million; Cost of quality to revenue: 6.5%; Failure share of the cost of quality: 70.5%. The figures are illustrative: enter your own to see your result.

Why and how to reason

The cost of quality is not only workshop defects. In the example it is 7.8 m RUB (6.5% of revenue), the failure share 71%; an extra 0.5 m on prevention with a 15% reduction of defects gives an effect of 0.825 m RUB and ROI of 65%.

When to use it

Apply when budgeting quality, choosing between appraisal and prevention and talking to a factory about the defect allowance.

How to read the result

Look at the failure share and ROI: if failures are over 70%, money goes on correcting.

Common mistakes

They count only workshop defects without customer returns and believe the reduction estimate without a pilot.

What data is needed?

  • Four cost categories.
  • Revenue.
  • Extra prevention and the expected reduction of failures.

Inputs

FieldUnitValue in the exampleMeaning
Prevention₽800,000Training, product passports, factory audits, pilot samples, technologists. The example value is illustrative.
Appraisal₽1,500,000Incoming inspection, laboratory, sampling control, inspectors at factories. The example value is illustrative.
Internal failure₽2,400,000Defects before shipment to the customer: rework, write-off, second-grade goods by the loss. The example value is illustrative.
External failure₽3,100,000After sale: returns, exchanges, claims, refunds. Do not leave it empty: it is usually the largest part. The example value is illustrative.
Revenue for the period₽120,000,000Optional: without it the share of revenue is not counted. The example value is illustrative.
Additional prevention₽500,000How much you are ready to invest in prevention on top of the present. The example value is illustrative.
Expected reduction of failures%15By how many percent the cost of internal and external failure falls: your estimate from a pilot. The example value is illustrative.

How it is calculated

StepFormula
COPQinternal failure + external failure
Cost of qualityprevention + appraisal + COPQ; share of revenue = cost of quality ÷ revenue
Effect of preventionreduction of failures × (internal + external failure)
ROI(effect − extra prevention) ÷ extra prevention

Worked numbers

Default values from the app; in the interactive version you enter your own.

Cost of poor quality (COPQ)
5.5 m ₽Internal + external failure.
Cost of quality
7.8 m ₽Prevention + appraisal + COPQ.
Cost of quality to revenue
6.5 %
Failure share of the cost of quality
70.5 %
Failure per rouble of prevention and appraisal
2.39×
Annual effect of prevention
825,000 ₽Reduction of failures × COPQ.
ROI of prevention
65 %(Effect − extra spending) ÷ extra spending.
Payback of prevention
7.3 months
Cost of quality to revenue after
6.2 %
Cost of quality by category, m RUB
Bar chart: Prevention 0.8, Appraisal 1.5, Internal failure 2.4, External failure 3.101234PreventionPreventionCosts: 0.80.8AppraisalAppraisalCosts: 1.51.5Internal failureInternal failureCosts: 2.42.4External failureExternal failureCosts: 3.13.1m RUB
Data as a table
MeasureCosts
Prevention0.8
Appraisal1.5
Internal failure2.4
External failure3.1

Quality cost categories

CategoryAmountShareTo revenue
Prevention800,000 ₽10.3 %0.67 %
Appraisal1.5 m ₽19.2 %1.25 %
Internal failure2.4 m ₽30.8 %2 %
External failure3.1 m ₽39.7 %2.58 %

More than 70% of the cost of quality is failure: money goes on correcting, not on preventing.

What to do with the result: find the most expensive cause of defects (from the “Defects” calculation and the returns report) and invest in preventing it; compare not with zero but with the alternative: tighter inspection. A typical mistake: counting only the workshop’s defects, without customer returns.

Nuances and limits

  • Counting only workshop defects.
  • Ignoring returns.
  • Believing the reduction estimate without a pilot.

Terms used

Calculate on your data →