Syntha Lab RU

Should-cost vs the factory quote

Builds a “justified” sewing price from your own norms: materials with waste, trims and packing, time by time study (SAM) at the factory rate, overheads on labor and the factory profit. Compares it with the quote and shows the gap in money and percent, the profit the factory builds in at your norms and, if the factory disclosed the price breakdown, the article with the largest gap to negotiate.

Choosing a factory and quality For whom: Buyers, production and procurement managers negotiating the sewing price with a factory.

Calculate on your data →

At a glance

What question does it answer?
What the justified price of a piece is at your norms and in which article the factory quote is overstated.
What data is needed?
Fabric consumption, price, waste, trims, packing.
How to read the result?
First the gap in percent, then the profit the quote builds in at your norms, then the article to negotiate. Example on the default values: Materials: RUB 806; Labor: RUB 437; Overheads: RUB 79; Factory profit: RUB 159. The figures are illustrative: enter your own to see your result.

Why and how to reason

Haggling with a factory over the total makes no sense: it is unclear what is in it. Should-cost splits the price into articles by your norms. In the example materials are RUB 806.0, labor RUB 437, overheads RUB 78.7, the should-cost RUB 1,480.2 against a quote of RUB 1,720: a gap of RUB 239.8 (16.2%). At your norms the quote implies a factory profit of 30.1% instead of 12%.

When to use it

Apply before talks on the sewing price, when changing a factory and at each price rise. It does not replace the “Bill of materials and cost” and “Quote comparison” calculations: here the justified price and the gap.

How to read the result

Look at the gap in percent, then at the profit the quote builds in at your norms, and the article with the largest gap if the factory disclosed the breakdown. A negative gap is a reason to check what the quote includes.

Common mistakes

They take SAM from the factory’s word, leave out shrinkage and waste, compare a price with logistics against one without and haggle over the total rather than an article.

What data is needed?

  • Fabric consumption, price, waste, trims, packing.
  • SAM by time study and the factory rate, overheads and profit.
  • The factory quote and, if available, its breakdown.

Inputs

FieldUnitValue in the exampleMeaning
Fabric consumption per piecem1.6Net by your marker, before waste. Take it from your own marker, not from the factory’s word. The example value is illustrative.
Fabric priceRUB/m380Delivered to the workshop, excl. VAT, at the current rate and duties. The example value is illustrative.
Fabric waste and shrinkage%12The share added to fabric consumption for marker waste, shrinkage and cutting rejects. The example value is illustrative.
Trims₽95Zips, buttons, thread, lining, labels per piece. The example value is illustrative.
Packing₽30Bag, carton, tags per piece. The example value is illustrative.
Standard minutes per piece (SAM)min38By time study or time tables, not the factory’s word. Includes all sewing operations. The example value is illustrative.
Factory rate per minuteRUB/min11.5Cost of a minute with contributions for the factory region. The example value is illustrative.
Overheads on labor%18Rent, energy, factory administration: percent of the labor cost. The example value is illustrative.
Factory profit%12Percent of the subtotal (materials + labor + overheads). Your guide for negotiation. The example value is illustrative.
Factory quote₽1,720Price of one piece excl. VAT on the same delivery terms as the should-cost (with or without fabric). The example value is illustrative.
Materials in the quote₽860Optional: if the factory disclosed the price breakdown. Empty or 0: no breakdown of the gap. The example value is illustrative.
Labor and overheads in the quote₽560Optional: the part of the price for labor and overheads. The rest of the quote is counted as profit and other. The example value is illustrative.

How it is calculated

StepFormula
Materials1.6 m × 380 ₽ × (1 + 12%) + 95 ₽ + 30 ₽ = 805.96 ₽
Labour and overheadsSAM × rate per minute; overheads = percent × labour
Should-cost(materials + labour + overheads) × (1 + profit)
Gapquote − should-cost; share = gap ÷ should-cost
Article to negotiateby the quote breakdown: materials, labour with overheads, profit and other; the largest positive gap is taken

Worked numbers

Default values from the app; in the interactive version you enter your own.

Materials
806 ₽Fabric × price × (1 + waste) + trims + packing.
Labour
437 ₽SAM × factory rate per minute.
Overheads
79 ₽
Factory profit
159 ₽
Should-cost
1,480 ₽Subtotal × (1 + profit).
Factory quote
1,720 ₽
Gap, RUB
+240 ₽Quote − should-cost.
Gap to should-cost
+16.2 %
Factory profit implied by the quote
30.1 %Quote ÷ subtotal − 1 at your norms.
Article to negotiate
Profit and other: +141 ₽
From norms to the factory price, RUB per piece
Waterfall: Materials +806, Labour +437, Overheads +78.7, Profit +159, Gap +240, Quote 1,72005001,0001,5002,000MaterialsMaterialsMaterials: +806+806LabourLabourLabour: +437+437OverheadsOverheadsOverheads: +78.7+78.7ProfitProfitProfit: +159+159GapGapGap: +240+240QuoteQuoteQuote: 1,7201,720RUB
  • positive
  • negative
  • total
Data as a table
StepChangeLevel
Materials+806806
Labour+4371,243
Overheads+78.71,322
Profit+1591,480
Gap+2401,720
Quote—1,720

Should-cost and quote by article

ArticleShould-costQuoteGap
Materials806 ₽860 ₽54 ₽
Labour and overheads516 ₽560 ₽44 ₽
Profit and other159 ₽300 ₽141 ₽
Total1,480 ₽1,720 ₽240 ₽

What to do with the result: show the factory your should-cost by article and ask it to disclose the article with the largest gap; do not haggle over the total blindly. Check SAM with a time study: it is the most common point of divergence.

A typical mistake: taking SAM from the factory’s word, leaving out shrinkage and waste, comparing a price with logistics against one without.

Nuances and limits

  • Taking SAM from the factory’s word.
  • Leaving out shrinkage and waste.
  • Comparing a price with logistics against one without.

Terms used

Calculate on your data →