Far and near factory: break-even premium
Calculates how much more the nearer factory may cost than the far one for the switch to still pay: savings on money in transit, on markdowns from a later decision, on freight and delay risk. The result is sensitive to the unsold share, so a range is shown.
At a glance
- What question does it answer?
- How much more a nearer factory may cost for the move to still pay.
- What data is needed?
- Price, lead time from payment to warehouse and freight for both factories.
- How to read the result?
- Compare the break-even price of the nearer factory with its real price. The result rests on the difference in unsold share: read the neighboring table rows, not one number. Example on the default values: Far: full item cost with capital and markdown — RUB 3,086.52; Near: the same — RUB 3,007.47; Near is dearer (+) or cheaper (−) than far — −RUB 79.05; Break-even price of the near factory — RUB 2,827.71.
Why and how to reason
The near factory costs more per item but wins on three things: money is tied up for fewer days, less goes unsold (the decision is taken closer to the season), and freight and delay risk are lower. So compare full item cost, not the price list. Far: price 2,400 + freight 120 + capital (2,400 × 18% × 90 ÷ 365 = 106.5) + markdown loss (25% × 1,600 = 400) + risk 60 = RUB 3,086.5. Near: 2,750 + 40 + 47.5 + 160 + 10 = RUB 3,007.5. So near is RUB 79 cheaper though RUB 350 dearer on the price list. The break-even near price comes from equating full costs: RUB 2,827.7, headroom RUB 77.7, i.e. you may pay 17.8% more than the far price. The result is sensitive to the unsold share, so a ±10 point range is shown.
When to use it
It is useful when choosing between a cheap far and a dearer near production, especially for fashion with a leftover risk. Assumption: quality is equal, and the unsold share for each site is honestly estimated (the near one is smaller because you can reorder). It does not fit basics with stable demand and almost no leftovers: there price wins. If unsold-share estimates are debatable, trust the range, not a single point.
How to read the result
The key numbers are headroom to the break-even price and the break-even premium. If the 17.8% premium exceeds what the near factory asks (14.6%), the switch pays. Check the range: at a far unsold share of 15% the difference may vanish. Decide when the whole range is favorable, not just the center. Do not forget non-numeric arguments: batch flexibility, speed of fixing mistakes, the option to reorder in season and a lower risk of missed dates. If the premium fits within break-even, run a trial order at the near factory and check real lead time and quality before moving the main volume.
Common mistakes
The usual mistakes: counting only the price list; using the same unsold share for both sites; ignoring the cost of money over the lead time; overstating markdown loss. If the money rate ignores the real credit or capital cost, the conclusion is distorted. Do not set the unsold share of the near factory to zero: even it leaves some leftovers.
What data is needed?
- Price, lead time from payment to warehouse and freight for both factories.
- The cost of money and the markdown loss per piece.
- Your estimates of the unsold share for each factory and the delay risk.
Inputs
| Field | Unit | Value in the example | Meaning |
|---|---|---|---|
| Item price | ₽ | 2,400 | The price of the item at the far factory excl. VAT. |
| Time from payment to warehouse | days | 90 | The time from payment to receipt in the warehouse for the far factory, in days. |
| Freight per piece | ₽ | 120 | Freight per piece from the far factory, excl. VAT. |
| Unsold share | % | 25 | Your estimate from past seasons, not a norm. |
| Expected loss from delays (optional) | ₽ | 60 | Per piece. Optional. Empty: the field is ignored (counted as zero in sums). |
| Item price | ₽ | 2,750 | The price of the item at the near factory excl. VAT. |
| Time from payment to warehouse | days | 35 | The time from payment to receipt in the warehouse for the near factory, in days. |
| Freight per piece | ₽ | 40 | Freight per piece from the near factory, excl. VAT. |
| Unsold share | % | 10 | What share of items stays unsold, in percent: it is usually higher for the far factory because of the long lead time. Your estimate. |
| Expected loss from delays (optional) | ₽ | 10 | The expected loss from missed deadlines in money per piece. Empty: 0. |
| Cost of money | % a year | 18 | The rate of your own loan or overdraft from the bank contract; for reference: the Bank of Russia key rate was 14.00% on 23.10.2026 (check the current one, next decision 18.12.2026). 18 here is an example, replace with yours. |
| Markdown loss per unsold piece | ₽ | 1,600 | Purchase price minus clearance revenue. |
How it is calculated
| Step | Formula |
|---|---|
| Money in transit | price × rate × time ÷ 365 |
| Markdown | unsold share × markdown loss |
| Full cost | price + freight + money in transit + markdown + delay risk |
| Break-even near price | (far full cost − freight − markdown − near delay risk) ÷ (1 + rate × time ÷ 365) |
Worked numbers
Default values from the app; in the interactive version you enter your own.
- Far: full item cost with capital and markdown
- 3,086.52 ₽
- Near: the same
- 3,007.47 ₽
- Near is dearer (+) or cheaper (−) than far
- −79.05 ₽
- Break-even price of the near factory
- 2,827.71 ₽Above this price the switch does not pay.
- Headroom to the break-even price
- 77.71 ₽
- Break-even premium over the far price
- 17.8 % · yours 14.6 %
Sensitivity to the far factory’s unsold share
| Far unsold share | Far full cost | Near minus far | Better |
|---|---|---|---|
| 15 % | 2,926.52 ₽ | 80.95 ₽ | far |
| 20 % | 3,006.52 ₽ | 0.95 ₽ | far |
| 25 % | 3,086.52 ₽ | −79.05 ₽ | near |
| 30 % | 3,166.52 ₽ | −159.05 ₽ | near |
| 35 % | 3,246.52 ₽ | −239.05 ₽ | near |
The near factory’s gain rests on the difference in unsold share: check it against your history and read the neighbouring table rows. The gain in lead time and margin does not always repay a higher price.
Nuances and limits
- Comparing only the item price without capital, markdowns and risk.
- Taking unsold shares from thin air rather than history.
- Not showing a range.