Syntha Lab RU

Air or sea: does speeding up pay

Compares the air-freight surcharge with the margin it protects and the cash it frees earlier. Finds the number of delay days at which air pays.

Choosing a factory and quality For whom: Production and logistics managers offered air freight to speed up a shipment.

Calculate on your data →

At a glance

What question does it answer?
How long a sea delay justifies air freight.
What data is needed?
Pieces in the shipment and the air surcharge per piece.
How to read the result?
The break-even delay is the number of days beyond which air is better. If sea shipping delays longer, speeding up pays. The break-even surcharge shows what you can pay per piece. Example on the default values: Air surcharge for the whole shipment — RUB 125,000; Margin protected — RUB 164,640; Gain on money in transit — RUB 6,904; Result: air minus surcharge — RUB 46,544.

Why and how to reason

Air freight pays when waiting by sea costs more than the surcharge. What waiting costs: while the shipment is on its way, goods do not sell and part of demand is lost for good (the buyer went elsewhere). So we compare two sums. Air surcharge for the shipment: RUB 250 × 500 = RUB 125,000. Protected margin: days saved (14) × daily sales (12) × margin (RUB 1,400) × share of demand lost permanently (70%) = RUB 164,640. Plus a gain on money: a shipment costing RUB 1 million at 18% a year frees about RUB 6,904 over 14 days. Result: 164,640 + 6,904 − 125,000 = RUB 46,544 in favor of air. Break-even delay: surcharge ÷ (margin lost per day + money per day) = 125,000 ÷ 12,253 ≈ 10.2 days. If the sea route is late by less than 10 days, air does not pay.

When to use it

Reach for it for seasonal and fast-selling goods with a known sales rate, when the shipment may miss a demand window (season start, promotion, holiday). Assumptions: daily sales are constant and the share of permanently lost demand is honestly estimated. It does not fit goods without scarcity (if you hold ample stock, delay costs nothing) or shipments where air is physically impractical. For several options, compare full delivery cost first.

How to read the result

Read net result and break-even delay together. A positive result with a large margin in days (14 against 10.2) means the decision is robust. If the margin is small, air pays only if the sea route slips, and a split shipment (part by air) is worth considering. The break-even surcharge (RUB 343) shows up to what rate air still pays: compare it with the carrier quote. A warning that lost sales exceed the shipment means daily sales or days are entered wrongly. Consider a middle option: part of the shipment by air, the rest by sea. It often gives most of the margin protection for a fraction of the surcharge.

Common mistakes

Overstating the permanently lost share (70% fits a season hit but is small for a basic); using margin instead of contribution after returns and markdowns; guessing the days saved as a couple of weeks without checking; comparing air and sea without insurance and packaging. Do not enter daily sales as a season average if the sales peak falls in the waiting window.

What data is needed?

  • Pieces in the shipment and the air surcharge per piece.
  • Daily sales, margin per piece, the share of sales lost for good.
  • Optional: cost and the cost of money.

Inputs

FieldUnitValue in the exampleMeaning
Pieces in the shipmentpcs500How many items are in the batch you ship: the cost of speeding up is divided by them to get the surcharge per item.
Air surcharge per piece₽250The air-freight surcharge per item, excl. VAT.
How many days air is fasterdays14By how many days air arrives faster than sea.
Daily sales of these piecespcs/day12How many units of these items sell per day when in stock.
Margin per piece₽1,400Price minus variable costs.
Share of sales during the wait lost for good%70Your estimate: some customers will wait or buy later.
Cost of a piece₽2,000The item’s cost excl. VAT: for the margin the faster sales preserve.
Cost of money% a year18The rate of your own loan or overdraft from the bank contract; for reference: the Bank of Russia key rate was 14.00% on 23.10.2026 (check the current one, next decision 18.12.2026). 18 here is an example, replace with yours.
Sea: probability of a delay%00: no risk, as before. The share of voyages where sea arrives later than the term; from your past shipments.
Sea: how many days of delaydays0The average length of a delay when it happens. The expected delay = probability × days.
Air: probability of a delay%00: no risk, as before. The share of air shipments that came later than the term; from your past shipments.
Air: how many days of delaydays0The average length of an air delay when it happens. The expected delay = probability × days.
Days in transit by sea (for capital in transit)days—Optional. Needed to show the cost of the money frozen in transit for each mode (see the “Goods in transit” calculation). Empty: not counted.

How it is calculated

StepFormula
Margin protecteddays (adjusted for the delay risk) × daily sales × margin × lost share
Money in transitcost × shipment × rate × days ÷ 365
Break-even delaysurcharge × shipment ÷ (sales × margin × share + cost × shipment × rate ÷ 365)

Worked numbers

Default values from the app; in the interactive version you enter your own.

Air surcharge for the whole shipment
125,000 ₽
Margin protected
164,640 ₽
Gain on money in transit
6,904 ₽
Result: air minus surcharge
46,544 ₽
Break-even delay
10.2 daysAir pays if sea shipping delays longer than this.
Break-even surcharge per piece
343.09 ₽

Air pays: 46,544 ₽ more than the surcharge costs. Margin in days: 3.8.

Nuances and limits

  • Assuming all sales during the wait are lost for good.
  • Using daily sales for the whole collection rather than these pieces.
  • Not checking that the loss does not exceed the shipment.

Terms used

Calculate on your data →