Factory scorecard
Compares 2–4 factories on the same criteria: a weighted score, red flags and the gap between first and second place. A red flag outranks the sum: a factory with a great price and failing quality must not win.
At a glance
- What question does it answer?
- Which factory is best on the same criteria and whether the leader has a red flag.
- What data is needed?
- 3–6 criteria: quality, lead time, price, readiness for small runs and credit, stability, compliance.
- How to read the result?
- Look at flags first, then the sum. The gap between first and second in scale percent shows how clear the choice is: with a small gap decide by a sample or a trial run. For Russian brands “small runs and credit” often weighs more than price. Example on the default values: Leader without red flags, % of maximum — 72.7% · Factory B; Gap between first and second, scale points — 5.5%; Factories with red flags — 1.
Why and how to reason
Choosing a factory is not choosing the cheapest: price is one of six to eight traits. So each criterion gets a weight (how much it matters) and each factory a score from 1 to 5. Weighted score = sum(weight × score) ÷ sum of weights. In the default example weights are 3, 2, 2, 2, 1, 1, total 11. Factory B: 3×4 + 2×4 + 2×2 + 2×4 + 1×4 + 1×4 = 40, a score of 3.64 out of 5, which is 72.7% of the maximum. Factory C scores higher on the sum (43 ÷ 11 = 3.91) but has quality 1, below the red-flag threshold of 2. An average hides such a failure: five fives cover one one. So a red flag outranks the sum: a flagged factory drops to the end of the list, and B becomes the leader, ahead of A by 5.45 scale points. The calculation protects you from a choice where one weak spot cancels everything else.
When to use it
It is useful when comparing 2–4 factories after samples and negotiations, with something to back each score (sample results, audits, delivery history). It does not replace a full cost calculation: price here is only one scored criterion, for real roubles use the quote comparison. It does not fit a single factory or a choice based on impressions: eyeballed scores give a pretty illusion of precision. Set weights before scoring, otherwise you tune them to the expected winner.
How to read the result
Read in this order: red flags first, then the leader without flags, then the gap. A gap of 5 scale points is small: a mild change of weights can flip the order, and then a trial order or negotiation decides, not the score. A gap of 15–20 points is robust. A flagged factory is not necessarily out: the flag says to cover the weakness (inspection, smaller prepayment, own acceptance) or decline. Test sensitivity: raise the price weight by one and see whether the leader changes. After choosing a factory, keep the scores and their grounds: a season later check who actually proved best and adjust weights and criteria for the next choice.
Common mistakes
Giving high scores for promises; equal weights although quality matters more than lead time to your brand; setting the flag threshold too low (then no flags appear and the tool becomes a plain average); scoring factories on different criteria (the tool rejects partial scores). Do not read percent of maximum as probability of success. Do not let different people score factories without a common scale: one person’s five equals another’s three.
What data is needed?
- 3–6 criteria: quality, lead time, price, readiness for small runs and credit, stability, compliance.
- Scores 1–5 per factory from facts: samples, delivery history, audit.
- Optional: criterion weights and the red-flag threshold.
Inputs
| Field | Unit | Value in the example | Meaning |
|---|---|---|---|
| Red flag if any criterion scores below | score | 2 | A rule of thumb, replace with your own: such a factory is dropped from the ranking whatever the sum. |
How it is calculated
| Step | Formula |
|---|---|
| Weighted score | S = Σ(weight × score) ÷ Σ weight |
| Red flag | any criterion scoring below the threshold |
| Gap | (S of first − S of second) ÷ 5 × 100 |
Worked numbers
Default values from the app; in the interactive version you enter your own.
- Leader without red flags, % of maximum
- 72.7 % · Factory B5 points = 100%.
- Gap between first and second, scale points
- 5.5 %
- Factories with red flags
- 1
Factory ranking
| Place | Factory | Score (1–5) | % of maximum | Red flags |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Factory B | 3.64 | 72.7 % | — |
| 2 | Factory A | 3.36 | 67.3 % | — |
| — | Factory C | 3.91 | 78.2 % | Quality and consistency |
Factory C scores highest on the sum but carries a red flag (Quality and consistency). The ranking leaves it out.
The sum compares factories with each other, it is not an absolute grade. Score yourself as a customer too: late changes and uncertain volumes come back as defects and delays.
Nuances and limits
- Scoring from one sample does not show consistency.
- Putting price above quality without costing defects.
- Weights fitted to a factory already chosen.