Supply chain due diligence: the map of links, risk by link, factory admission and a corrective plan
How to check a brand’s or retailer’s supply chain before an order and at its renewal: draw a map of links from the finished garment down to the fiber, assess the risk of each link on labor, safety, chemicals and raw material origin, admit a factory by a checklist and keep a corrective plan. The head of buying or production uses the document to decide which suppliers to admit, where an on-site audit is needed and which sustainability claims can be made honestly.
Why this document
Most supply chain problems are found late: a lot is delayed because of a subcontractor the brand did not know about, a buyer asks where the fabric was made and there is no answer, a violation is found at a factory that was visible at the first visit. Supplier checks turn these risks into an order of action: what to learn before an order, what to request in documents, what to see with your own eyes and what to do when a violation is found. The document is read by the heads of buying, production and sustainability, a lawyer and the finance director who assesses the price of the check.
At a glance
- What is this document and why is it needed?
- How to check a brand’s or retailer’s supply chain before an order and at its renewal: draw a map of links from the finished garment down to the fiber, assess the risk of each link on labor, safety, chemicals and raw material origin, admit a factory by a checklist and keep a corrective plan. The head of buying or production uses the document to decide which suppliers to admit, where an on-site audit is needed and which sustainability claims can be made honestly.
- Who owns the document and how often is it rebuilt?
- Led by the head of buying or production with a lawyer and the head of sustainability; the map is updated on a change of supplier and once a year; admission is done before the first order and at renewal; the result is kept in the supplier’s file and handed to the manager quarterly.
- What mistakes are the most common?
- Brand: the map ends at the sewing factory → only half of the purchases are covered, the dyehouse and the fabric remain unknown → fix in the contract the duty to disclose the lower links. Retailer: they believe a supplier’s claim and repeat it on the shelf → on checking, the claim is not supported → require a supporting document and word only what it covers. Brand: they check the factory once before the first order → in a year conditions change and the brand does not know → repeat the check and keep the right to an unannounced visit.
For whom
- Brand
- A brand is responsible for the chain as a whole: the sewing factory, fabric, yarn, dyeing, trims, subcontracting. For a brand the check starts with the map of links and the admission of the sewing factory and then goes deeper to the fabric and the dyehouse. The main thing for a brand: the contractual right to audit and a ban on subcontracting without consent, otherwise there is nothing to check.
- Retail
- A retailer is responsible for the suppliers of brands and of the own label: from other brands it requires documents and statements, for its own label it checks the chain itself. The main thing for a retailer: choose which suppliers need full admission (own label, import, children’s) and for which documents and a sample check are enough.
What it consists of
Why check and what the check does not guarantee
- Commercial reasons: a failed delivery because of a hidden subcontractor, defects from unsuitable finishing, the requirements of buyers and platforms, sustainability claims that must be supported.
- Legal reasons: mandatory conformity confirmation under technical regulations, the duty to advertise truthfully and for deliveries to the EU new rules on forced labor and traceability (check applicability and terms).
- A limit: a paper check sees only what is shown; a visit sees more but for one day. Any audit is a snapshot and not a guarantee, so monitoring and the right to an unannounced visit are needed.
- Brand: a claim “made responsibly” without a map of links and a check is a reputational risk; word only what is supported by a document and an audit.
- Retailer: a claim on the shelf or in the product card is also the retailer’s responsibility; without confirmation from the supplier do not repeat it.
The map of links (template)
- Columns: the link (sewing, fabric, yarn and fiber, dyeing and printing, trims, packaging), the legal entity and address, the country, the share of purchases, subcontractors, capacities, documents (registration, certificates), map coverage, on-site audit coverage, the date of the last check.
- Map coverage equals the share of purchases by the link known by name and address; the overall coverage is the sum of purchase shares multiplied by the link coverage. A map that ends at the sewing factory covers only half of the purchases.
- Brand: for the key fabric ask the supplier for the names of the mill and the dyehouse; fix the right to ask for them in the contract.
- Retailer: for the own label ask the manufacturer for the map, for other brands ask at least for the sewing factory.
Risk assessment of a link
- Four factors scored from 1 (low risk) to 5 (high): labor (working time, pay, forced and child labor), safety and buildings, chemicals and effluent, raw material origin and traceability.
- The risk of a link is the average of the factors; the priority of the check equals the share of purchases × (1 − the share audited on site) × risk ÷ 5. It shows where an audit gives the most: a large, unchecked and risky link.
- The scores are your judgment from data; for countries, processes and past violations use open data and feedback but do not call a country dangerous without facts. The score is revised when new information appears.
- Brand: the dyehouse and printing on chemicals and effluent, sewing on labor, yarn on origin.
- Retailer: suppliers of the own label and imported goods get a higher priority than brands with their own check.
Factory admission: the checklist
- Legal: registration, who the owner is, not in liquidation or bankruptcy; a contract with the right to audit, a ban on subcontracting without consent and a duty to report changes.
- Production: capacities and load, the equipment list, the quality control process, the list of subcontractors, samples and a trial lot.
- Labor and safety: work hours and overtime, pay and personnel documents, fire safety and exits, the state of buildings and equipment, occupational safety; a visual check and talks with workers without management.
- Chemicals and environment: the list of substances used and their storage, effluent treatment, waste, compliance with product safety requirements; a separate check for dyeing and printing.
- Brand: admission of a key factory with a visit and a trial lot before the season order.
- Retailer: admission of an own-label supplier by the same list, the rest by documents and a sample check.
The on-site audit and the corrective plan
- The visit: pre-agreed and unannounced; look at the shop floor, the warehouse, sanitary rooms, documents, talk with workers separately; record the result with photos and notes.
- Findings are divided by severity: critical (danger to life, forced labor) stop the order at once; serious ones are corrected within up to 30 days; minor ones within up to 90 days; the terms are a benchmark, check for your case.
- The corrective plan (CAP): the finding, the cause, the action, the owner at the factory, the term, the confirmation, the date of the repeat check. The brand helps and does not only penalize: it is often simpler to fund the correction.
Where the data comes from
| Data source | Fields |
|---|---|
| Supplier file and contract | legal entity, address, subcontractors, capacities, the right to audit, payment terms |
| Purchasing and acceptance | share of purchases by link, defects, missed deadlines, claims, the check sample |
| Audits, documents and feedback | audit reports, certificates, test results, open data on violations, workers’ appeals |
How to build it step by step
- Step 1: Make a list of all suppliers by link and calculate the share of purchases by each link.
- Step 2: Brand: ask the sewing factory and the fabric mill for the names of subcontractors and second-tier suppliers; fix this right in the contract.
- Step 3: Retailer: ask the brands and the own-label suppliers for the list of factories and the conformity documents; mark where there is no answer.
- Step 4: Assess the risk of a link on four factors and calculate the priority: share of purchases × (1 − on-site coverage) × risk ÷ 5.
- Step 5: Brand: run the admission of the key factory with a visit and a trial lot before the season order; record the result in the file.
- Step 6: Retailer: run the admission of an own-label supplier by the full list, the rest by documents and a sample check.
- Step 7: Draw up the corrective plan for the findings: cause, action, owner, term, confirmation, the date of the repeat check.
- Step 8: Brand: decide what you are ready to claim about the chain; word only what is supported by a document and an audit. Retailer: check your claims against what the supplier confirmed.
- Step 9: Calculate the cost of the check program (visits, tests, team time) and compare it with the share of purchases covered; decide where to widen coverage.
Formulas
| Measure | Formulas | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Map and on-site coverage | Coverage = Σ share of purchases of the link × the link coverage | Counted by purchases in rubles and not by the number of suppliers: one large unchecked supplier matters more than ten small ones. |
| Risk of a link | Risk = the average of the scores on four factors from 1 to 5 | The score is a judgment from data; update when new information appears. |
| Priority of the check | Priority = share of purchases × (1 − on-site coverage) × risk ÷ 5 | Check links with a high priority first; a low priority means a paper check. |
Formulas in notation
- The check priority of a link
Pr_i = s_i·(1 − a_i)·ρ_i / 5
s_i: the link’s share of purchases; a_i: on-site coverage; ρ_i: the link’s risk from 1 to 5.- Overall coverage
K = Σ s_i·m_i
m_i: map or on-site coverage of a link; K: the overall coverage by purchases.
Worked example
The women’s apparel brand’s map of links: share of purchases, coverage, risk and the check priority (illustrative scores)
| Link | Share of purchases, % | Map coverage, % | On-site coverage, % | Risk, 1-5 | Priority, % |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Fabric (weaving and knitting mill) | 28 | 70 | 20 | 3.00 | 13.44 |
| Sewing (factory) | 50 | 100 | 60 | 2.75 | 11.00 |
| Dyeing and printing | 6 | 30 | 0 | 3.25 | 3.90 |
| Trims and finishing | 8 | 50 | 0 | 2.25 | 3.60 |
| Yarn and fiber | 5 | 15 | 0 | 3.00 | 3.00 |
| Packaging | 3 | 60 | 0 | 1.25 | 0.75 |
Map coverage by purchases is 78%, on-site audit coverage 36%: the map and the audit do not reach yarn and dyeing. The first to check are sewing and fabric: a large share of purchases and incomplete coverage. The scores are illustrative and calculated by code.
Figures
- Map coverage
- On-site coverage
Data as a table
| Measure | Map coverage | On-site coverage |
|---|---|---|
| Sewing (factory) | 100 | 60 |
| Fabric (weaving and knitting mill) | 70 | 20 |
| Trims and finishing | 50 | 0 |
| Dyeing and printing | 30 | 0 |
| Yarn and fiber | 15 | 0 |
| Packaging | 60 | 0 |
Chain coverage: the map and the on-site audit by link, % of the link. Map coverage falls deeper into the chain: from the sewing factory to yarn; there is a visit only at two links.
- 1 … 5 score
Data as a table
| Labor | Safety and buildings | Chemicals and effluent | Raw material origin | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sewing (factory) | 4 | 3 | 2 | 2 |
| Fabric (weaving and knitting mill) | 3 | 2 | 4 | 3 |
| Trims and finishing | 2 | 2 | 3 | 2 |
| Dyeing and printing | 3 | 3 | 5 | 2 |
| Yarn and fiber | 3 | 1 | 3 | 5 |
| Packaging | 1 | 1 | 2 | 1 |
The risk of a link on four factors, a score from 1 to 5. Darker means higher risk: dyeing has the highest score on chemicals and effluent, yarn on raw material origin.
The supplier check cycle. The map and the risk determine where a visit is needed; findings go into the corrective plan and a repeat check closes the cycle.
- Map of links → Risk and priority
- Risk and priority → Admission and visit
- Admission and visit → Corrective plan; Order stop on a critical finding
- Corrective plan → Repeat check
- Repeat check → Risk and priority
- Order stop on a critical finding
Specifics by category
- Apparel
- Apparel: the chain is long (fiber, yarn, fabric, dyeing, sewing); the biggest risk is in the dyehouse and sewing subcontractors; mapping down to the fabric and the right to an unannounced visit are important. For seasonal orders do the check before placing the order and not after cutting starts, otherwise a violation will have to be corrected in the middle of the season.
- Footwear
- Footwear: glues, solvents and leather; the risk is in chemicals, tanning and effluent and in small craft upper workshops; the process must be checked and not only documents. Check separately the storage conditions and ventilation at the gluing and painting sections: that is where occupational safety requirements are more often violated.
- Accessories
- Accessories: metals, coatings, leather and plastic; the origin of materials and the safety of coatings (including skin contact) are the main questions; often many small subcontractors. For metals and coatings request documents on composition and test results for each material, especially if the product comes into contact with skin.
- Kids
- Children’s: the highest price of error: the safety of materials and dyes, mandatory conformity confirmation under the technical regulation; factory admission and lot tests are mandatory and not sample-based. Request documents under the regulation and the lot’s test results before shipment and check the numbers against the marking on the product and the packaging.
- Men
- Men’s: stable basic items give long relations with factories; risks are in subcontracting and overtime in the season; a repeat check once a year is usually enough. A repeat check once a year is usually enough but on a growth of volume or a change of dyehouse hold an unscheduled one before the volume grows beyond the factory’s capacity.
- Women
- Women’s: frequent model changes and small lots push factories to subcontract; it is here that the map of links is often lost, so control of subcontracting and admission of new factories matter more. Ask for the list of subcontractors with every new order and keep it in the file: it is changes in subcontracting that most often cause failures.
Common mistakes
- Brand: the map ends at the sewing factory → only half of the purchases are covered, the dyehouse and the fabric remain unknown → fix in the contract the duty to disclose the lower links.
- Retailer: they believe a supplier’s claim and repeat it on the shelf → on checking, the claim is not supported → require a supporting document and word only what it covers.
- Brand: they check the factory once before the first order → in a year conditions change and the brand does not know → repeat the check and keep the right to an unannounced visit.
- Retailer: they count coverage by the number of suppliers → one large unchecked supplier goes unnoticed → count coverage by purchases in rubles.
- They fine for every finding without a corrective plan → the supplier hides problems → help to correct, fix terms and re-check.
Russian specifics
- Brand: products of light industry are subject to mandatory conformity confirmation under the technical regulation TR CU 017/2011; a chain check does not replace a declaration or a certificate. Rule: CU Commission decision 876 of 09.12.2011: TR CU 017/2011 on safety of light-industry products (Customs Union Commission Decision of 09.12.2011 No. 876) (rule check not completed).
- Retailer: for children’s products TR CU 007/2011 applies with mandatory conformity confirmation; request documents for each lot and check them against the marking. Rule: CU Commission decision 797 of 23.09.2011: TR CU 007/2011 on safety of products for children and adolescents (Customs Union Commission Decision of 23.09.2011 No. 797) (rule check not completed).
- Brand: if you sell or plan to sell in the EU check the EU regulation on prohibiting products made with forced labor and the rules on ecodesign and the digital product passport: check applicability, terms and traceability requirements with a lawyer. Rule: EU Regulation 2024/3015 of 2024: Regulation (EU) 2024/3015 (ban on forced-labor products) (rule check not completed).
- Retailer: the right to check and the ban on subcontracting without consent are formalized by a supply contract and supplementary agreements under the Civil Code; the terms on the right of a visit must be in the text of the contract. Rule: Civil Code part 1: Civil Code, part one (including Arts. 330, 424) (rule check not completed).
- Brand: workers’ data and personal data during an on-site audit (photos, talks) are processed taking into account the personal data law and consent; clarify the rules with a lawyer before the audit. Rule: Law 152-FZ of 27.07.2006: Federal Law of 27.07.2006 No. 152-FZ on personal data (rule check not completed).