Syntha Lab RU

Comparing quotes: CMT, FOB, full package

Brings factory quotes in different “packages” (cut and make only, with materials, full package) to one basis: the item price in your warehouse with brand materials, losses, logistics, one-off costs and the cost of money. Shows the gap to the target cost.

Choosing a factory and quality For whom: Brand buyers and finance managers comparing factory quotes.

Calculate on your data →

At a glance

What question does it answer?
Which quote is cheaper once brought to one basis and whether it meets the target cost.
What data is needed?
For each quote: factory price, brand materials, logistics, one-off costs, materials prepayment days.
How to read the result?
Compare the total on the common basis, not the price in the email. The difference between full package and cut-and-make with materials often just moves materials and working capital to the factory: decide by your readiness to hold materials and risk. A positive gap to target is closed by value engineering and negotiation. Example on the default values: Cheapest on the common basis — RUB 2,601.6 · CMT, domestic factory; The runner-up costs more by — RUB 398.4 · 15.3%; Spread from cheapest to dearest — RUB 673.29; Target cost — RUB 2,560.

Why and how to reason

Factories quote in different packaging: CMT is sewing only, FOB is sewing with factory materials, turnkey includes everything. You cannot compare RUB 900 with RUB 3,000 directly. So everything is brought to one basis: item price at your warehouse with brand materials. To the sewing price add materials with waste (1,500 × 1.05), logistics, one-off sample and pattern costs divided by the lot (40,000 ÷ 2,000 = RUB 20), duty, and cost of money while materials and payment are tied up. Money: (1,575 × 60 days) × 18% ÷ 365 ≈ RUB 46.6. CMT in Russia: 900 + 1,575 + 60 + 20 + 46.6 = RUB 2,601.6. Target cost at a shelf price of RUB 8,000 excl. VAT and a 68% margin is 8,000 × 0.32 = RUB 2,560, so the best quote misses by RUB 41.6.

When to use it

It fits when you have 2–3 quotes of different structure and must see which is really cheaper. Assumption: quality and lead time are comparable, otherwise the cheap one may be worse (also see the factory scorecard). It does not fit a single factory or options with very different lot sizes: one-off costs are divided by the lot and unit price depends on it. For foreign options check duty and marking separately.

How to read the result

See who is cheapest on the common basis and by how much the second is dearer: that difference pays for moving materials risk and lead time to the factory. The gap to target cost shows whether to negotiate: RUB 41.6 per piece on a 2,000 lot is 83 thousand ₽. Warnings such as no logistics and import without duty mean the quote is incomplete and understated. Decision: ask the factory for missing items or add them as estimates. Before deciding, ask each factory for missing items in writing and recalculate: the best quote often rises 3–8% once logistics and samples are added.

Common mistakes

Typical trap: leaving logistics or duty empty and trusting the total; ignoring brand material waste; omitting one-off costs (patterns, samples); comparing quotes for different lot sizes. A turnkey row with blank fields looks cheaper not because it is cheaper but because the fields are empty. Do not compare quotes for different lot sizes without recalculating one-off costs.

What data is needed?

  • For each quote: factory price, brand materials, logistics, one-off costs, materials prepayment days.
  • The run, the cost of money and material losses.
  • Optional: shelf price and target margin.

Inputs

FieldUnitValue in the exampleMeaning
Runpcs2,000The batch size in pieces: the one-off costs are spread over it.
Cost of money% a year18The rate of your own loan or overdraft from the bank contract; for reference: the Bank of Russia key rate was 14.00% on 23.10.2026 (check the current one, next decision 18.12.2026). 18 here is an example, replace with yours.
Losses on brand materials%5The brand’s losses of fabric and trims in cutting and sewing, in percent. Empty: 0.
Shelf price excl. VAT₽8,000The shelf price excl. VAT: for comparison with the allowable cost. Empty: no comparison.
Target margin%68Allowable cost = price × (1 − margin). A rule of thumb, replace with your own.

How it is calculated

StepFormula
Common basisfactory + materials × (1 + losses) + logistics + duty + one-off ÷ run + cost of money
Cost of money(materials with losses × material prepayment days + factory price × factory prepayment days) × rate ÷ 365
Target costshelf price excl. VAT × (1 − margin)

Worked numbers

Default values from the app; in the interactive version you enter your own.

Cheapest on the common basis
2,601.6 ₽ · CMT, domestic factory
The runner-up costs more by
398.4 ₽ · 15.3 %This difference pays for moving the materials risk and the lead time.
Spread from cheapest to dearest
673.29 ₽
Target cost
2,560 ₽
Gap of the best quote to the target
41.6 ₽A positive gap is closed by value engineering: trims, construction, fabric width.

Item price on the common basis

QuoteFactoryMaterials with lossesLogisticsDutyOne-off per pieceMoneyTotalVs cheapest
CMT, domestic factory900 ₽1,575 ₽60 ₽0 ₽20 ₽46.6 ₽2,601.6 ₽0 ₽
Full package3,000 ₽0 ₽0 ₽0 ₽0 ₽0 ₽3,000 ₽398.4 ₽
FOB, overseas factory2,700 ₽0 ₽140 ₽340 ₽15 ₽79.89 ₽3,274.89 ₽673.29 ₽

Not included or not stated: Full package (logistics, samples and patterns). Ask the factory or enter your own estimates, otherwise prices are not comparable.

Nuances and limits

  • Comparing a cut-and-make price with a full-package price.
  • Forgetting samples, patterns and material defects.
  • Counting direct costs only.

Terms used

Calculate on your data →