ESG and sustainability: what a brand and a retailer should measure, how to report and how to avoid greenwashing
A working breakdown of sustainability for apparel, footwear and accessories: the environmental load of a collection, the supply chain and labor conditions, leftovers and returns, recycling and extended producer responsibility, reporting and checking claims. It decides which indicators to keep, which claims can be published and where to budget costs.
Why this document
A sustainability claim on a label or in advertising has to be proven: without data it turns into greenwashing and a risk of complaints. The product and production director, buying and the lawyer read this document. It shows which indicators to keep: the item footprint, the share of certified materials, leftovers and returns, recycling and the costs of extended producer responsibility. It also helps decide what can be published and what cannot. Without it the report is assembled in a hurry at a partner’s request, and there is nothing to back the claims.
At a glance
- What is this document and why is it needed?
- A working breakdown of sustainability for apparel, footwear and accessories: the environmental load of a collection, the supply chain and labor conditions, leftovers and returns, recycling and extended producer responsibility, reporting and checking claims. It decides which indicators to keep, which claims can be published and where to budget costs.
- Who owns the document and how often is it rebuilt?
- Brand: product and production director with the finance director; retailer: commercial director, buying and logistics; a yearly calculation with a quarterly reconciliation of leftovers and returns; the result goes to the owner, the lawyer (claims check) and, where needed, into reporting and partner requests.
- What mistakes are the most common?
- Taking emission factors “from the internet” without a source and publishing them as fact → the claim cannot be supported → use supplier data or a method marked “estimate”. Claiming an “eco-friendly collection” on one material in one style → misleading → claim only what is supported by object, base and period. Counting sustainability only for materials → leftovers and returns go to disposal → keep leftovers, returns and their fate as separate indicators.
For whom
- Brand
- The brand controls what is in the product: material, sewing, factory, packaging. It computes the footprint of an item, the share of certified and recycled materials, supply chain traceability and labor conditions in factories, responsibility for goods and packaging placed on the market (EPR), and the truthfulness of claims on labels and in advertising.
- Retail
- The retailer controls what happens after buying: choice of suppliers and range, logistics, leftovers, returns, packaging, store energy, claims in advertising and on the shelf. It computes the leftover share and its fate, the share of returns back into sale, waste and packaging, the footprint of logistics and stores, requirements for suppliers.
What it consists of
What sustainability consists of in fashion
- Environment (E): materials and their origin, emissions by stage, water and chemistry at dyeing and finishing plants, leftovers and waste, packaging, recycling, energy of warehouses and stores.
- People (S): working conditions in factories (pay, hours, safety, a ban on forced and child labor), conditions in stores and warehouses, customer rights (product safety, returns, personal data).
- Governance (G): policy and the responsible person, data and verification, supplier contracts, a code of conduct, complaints and corrective actions, truthfulness of claims.
- What this document does not do: it does not replace a sustainability report under adopted standards and does not claim that any indicator is mandatory; the mandatory Russian and EU norms are in the “Russia” section and marked by verification status.
Environmental load of a collection: what to compute
- A simplified carbon footprint of an item: materials (mass × (1 + cutting loss) × material emission factor), sewing (energy per kg of item), logistics (per kg), packaging (per item). In the exercise the cutting loss is 12%, sewing 1.2, logistics 0.8 kg CO2e per kg, packaging 0.1 kg per item (illustrative coefficients).
- Example result: an item of 0.45 kg in the women line gives 5.1 kg CO2e, in the men line (0.6 kg) 7, in kids (0.3 kg) 3.1, footwear (0.9 kg) 12.9, accessory (0.35 kg) 5.5. The maximum per item is in “Footwear”; per RUB 1,000 of revenue the highest is “Footwear” (2.7 kg), the lowest “Women” (1.6 kg).
- The water footprint of an item: material mass × liters of water per kg of material. Coefficients depend on the region and the growing method, so in the exercise they are conditional and in a calculation for publication they are taken from the material supplier.
- Brand: compute the footprint and water for every style from the specification (gross use, composition, sewing), not for a category on average; then the choice of fabric and cut is visible in roubles and kilograms.
- Retailer: for other brands take supplier data; if there is none, compute from the composition and mass in the card marked as an “estimate”, do not publish it as a fact.
- Retailer: compute the footprint of logistics and stores (energy, cooling, light, last-mile delivery) separately from the product footprint; do not mix them into one per-item indicator.
Materials and certificates
- The share of certified materials by mass: Σ (item mass × units × certified share) / Σ (mass × units). In the example it is 23.3% against a target of 30% for each category; below target: women, men, footwear, accessories.
- A certificate confirms a batch and a supplier on a date, not an item in general: keep the certificate number, term, scope (which materials and plants) and a copy in the material card; without this the claim “made of certified cotton” cannot be supported. The criteria of particular certificates are not given in Lab (not checked): see the text of the standard.
- The share of recycled materials is computed separately: mass of secondary material in the item / item mass; ask the supplier what exactly is recycled (production waste or used products), the wording of the claim depends on it.
- Brand: in the specification and the factory contract fix permitted materials, the obligation to pass certificates and the right of inspection; replacing a material without agreement removes the ground for a claim.
- Retailer: require from suppliers a certificate copy and composition for every item you promote as “sustainable”; without a document do not put a shelf or catalog marker on it.
Supply chain and labor conditions
- A chain map by tier: sewing (tier 1), fabric and finishing (tier 2), fibre and raw material (tier 3). The traceability indicator: the share of purchases (in money or units) for which the factory and country are known at each tier. Start with tier 1, then 2.
- Conditions check: a supplier code of conduct, self-assessment, an on-site check by an independent party, a report of breaches and the deadline to cure them. Indicators: the share of factories checked in the last 24 months, the number of critical findings, the share cured on time.
- Forced labor: when exporting to the EU the ban on placing on the market goods made with forced labor applies (Regulation 2024/3015, application from 14.12.2027 per unchecked data); for a Russian brand with exports it requires documents on the origin of raw material (unverified).
- Brand: build the cost of checks and cure of findings into the factory price and do not change the factory on the first finding: the indicator “share cured on time” matters more than the number of breaches found.
- Retailer: if you have private labels you are responsible for the chain like a brand; for other brands request confirmation of checks and do not claim “fair production” without it.
Leftovers, returns, recycling and extended producer responsibility
- Season leftovers and returns in the example: leftovers 34,600 pcs and returns 26,150 pcs, together 60,750 pcs. Fate: 16,213 pcs returned to sale after checking, 25,990 sold in the outlet and sale, 11,265 passed to recycling and donors, 7,282 disposed of. The share kept (everything except disposal) is 88%.
- The best sustainability indicator of leftovers is their absence: a more precise forecast, less buying depth, reorders instead of one large lot. Disposal of an item with material and water already invested is the most expensive in money and in footprint; consider it last.
- Extended producer responsibility (EPR) in Russia: producers and importers of goods and packaging from Government lists must ensure recycling or pay an environmental fee; the lists, targets and rates changed and are not checked against the act texts in Lab (unverified): check whether your goods are in the list and who pays.
- Brand: keep records of the mass of goods and packaging placed on the market by list group: without it you can neither declare recycling nor compute the fee.
- Retailer: a reseller of finished goods from Russian suppliers does not pay the fee per unchecked data, but a retailer with private label and an importer keep records like a producer; clarify the status of each line with a lawyer.
- Retailer: returns back into sale depend on acceptance: a condition checklist and photos raise the share of resaleable items; without an acceptance standard the share returned to sale falls and disposal grows.
Claims and anti-greenwashing
- Publication rule: every claim has an object (which item or lot), an indicator, a comparison base, a period and a document. “30% fewer emissions” without a base and a period is not a claim but a slogan; do not use “eco”, “green”, “natural” without a criterion.
- A five-question test before publication: what exactly is asserted, what supports it, which part of the item or chain it refers to, whether an omission misleads (for example, packaging is claimed and the material is silent), whether the document is valid on the publication date. If any question has no answer, the claim is not published.
- No specific anti-greenwashing norm in Russia was identified in Lab (the search was not complete): the general requirements of the advertising law (accuracy) and the consumer protection law apply; in the EU Directive 2024/825 bans generic environmental claims without support and labels without a certification scheme (application from 27.09.2026 per unchecked data), which matters for exports to the EU (unverified).
- Brand: agree claims on the label and the site with the lawyer and keep a dossier of evidence (certificate, calculation, date); on a change of material or supplier re-check the claim.
- Retailer: do not repeat a brand claim in your advertising and on the shelf without its dossier: whoever distributes the advertising is responsible for it; do not put a general “green” label on a whole section.
Indicators and reporting
- The minimum set for a year: the footprint of an item and the collection (t CO2e and kg per RUB 1,000), the share of certified materials, the share of recycled materials, the water footprint, traceability of tiers 1 and 2, the share of factories checked in 24 months, the leftover share and its fate, the share of returns back into sale, the mass of goods and packaging placed on the market (for EPR).
- Frequency: footprint and water once a year after the season, leftovers and returns quarterly, factory checks by schedule (every two years for tier 1 and by risk for tier 2); the boundary and calculation method are fixed and not changed without a note.
- The report is published only for the part supported by data and verification: indicator, value, boundary, method, period, a note “estimate” or “verified”. Mandatory sustainability reporting forms for your company, if any, should be determined with the lawyer: they are not checked in Lab (unverified).
- Brand: the report is built from specifications and factory contracts; Retailer: from supplier, warehouse and store data; common indicators (leftovers, returns) are consolidated by one rule so that brand and retailer figures can be compared.
How to read the result and which decisions follow
- In the example an output of 175,000 pcs gives 1034.1 t CO2e (illustrative coefficients); the category “Footwear” has the largest footprint per item, “Footwear” the largest per RUB 1,000 of revenue. Decision: first the levers on the most loaded styles (composition, cutting loss, mass), not evenly across the collection.
- Brand: the share of certified materials is 23.3% against a target of 30%. Decision: set the target by category where suppliers have certified materials, not equally for all; a material without a document in the card is not counted.
- Retailer: 88% of leftovers and returns is kept, 12% is disposed of. Decision: acceptance of returns by checklist and the route “outlet, recycling” before disposal; every point of the share returned to sale reduces both losses and footprint.
- Brand: compare styles by footprint per RUB 1,000 of revenue: a more expensive style with the same footprint gives fewer emissions per rouble, but this is no reason to hide the footprint per item.
- Retailer: do not add the product footprint and the footprint of stores and logistics into one indicator: different people take the decisions and the levers differ.
Control checks
- The sum of footprint stage shares equals 100% in every category (checked by code); the sum of material shares equals 1 (checked by code).
- Leftovers and returns by fate reconcile: 60,750 = 16,213 + 25,990 + 11,265 + 7,282 (checked by code).
- Brand: every published claim has a dossier (document, calculation, date, boundary); without a dossier the claim is withdrawn.
- Retailer: supplier data are marked “received” or “estimate”; an estimate is not presented as fact in publications.
- The method and boundary are the same as in the previous period; if they changed, the previous period is recomputed by the new method.
Where the data comes from
| Data source | Fields |
|---|---|
| Specifications and material cards | composition, item mass, gross use, supplier, country, certificate (number, term, scope), recycled share |
| Factory contracts and audits | code of conduct, check date, findings and cure terms, chain tier, country |
| Purchases, sales, leftovers and returns | units by SKU, sales, end-of-season leftover, returns and their reasons, the decision on a return (to sale, outlet, recycling, disposal) |
| Logistics and packaging | mass and route of shipments, transport type, packaging mass by material |
| Advertising and labels | claim text, medium, date, a link to the evidence dossier |
How to build it step by step
- Step 1. Appoint a responsible person, define the accounting boundary (which items, which stages, which period) and fix it.
- Brand: Step 2. Collect composition, mass, gross use and factory by style; request missing data from suppliers and mark an estimate until you get it.
- Brand: Step 3. Compute the footprint and water per item, per collection and per RUB 1,000 of revenue; find the three styles with the largest contribution.
- Brand: Step 4. Build a chain map by tier and compute traceability; schedule factory checks by risk.
- Retailer: Step 5. Link leftovers and returns by SKU with the decision on their fate (to sale, outlet, recycling, disposal) and compute the share kept.
- Retailer: Step 6. Request from suppliers the documents for items you promote as sustainable and keep a register of documents.
- Brand: Step 7. Collect the mass of goods and packaging placed on the market by EPR list groups and consult the lawyer on duties and deadlines (unverified).
- Step 8. Draft the list of claims for publication; attach a dossier to each and pass the five-question test with the lawyer.
- Step 9. Consolidate the indicators in a table with the boundary, method and a note “estimate” or “verified”; reconcile category sums with the total.
- Step 10. Approve an improvement plan with targets and dates for next year and repeat the calculation by the same method so that the indicators are comparable.
Formulas
| Measure | Formulas | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Brand: Carbon footprint of an item (simplified) | CF = m × (1 + w) × Σ(s_j × f_j) + m × e_sew + m × e_log + p | m item mass, kg; w cutting loss; s_j share of material j; f_j emission factor, kg CO2e per kg; e_sew and e_log per kg; p packaging per item. Example: women 5.1 kg (illustrative coefficients). |
| Brand: Footprint per RUB 1,000 of revenue | I = CF / (P / 1000) | P is the price excl. VAT. Example: women 1.6, men 1.9, kids 2, footwear 2.7, accessories 2.3 kg. It shows which roubles of revenue carry more emissions. |
| Water footprint of an item | V = m × (1 + w) × Σ(s_j × v_j) | v_j liters of water per kg of material. Example: women 1,522 L, footwear 6,073 L (illustrative coefficients); for publication take supplier data. |
| Share of certified materials | C = Σ(m_i × u_i × c_i) / Σ(m_i × u_i) | c_i is the certified share of materials in item i, u_i units. Example: 23.3% by mass; target 30%. |
| Retailer: Share of leftovers kept | K = (L + R − D) / (L + R) | L season leftover, R returns, D disposed. Example: 88%. |
| Retailer: Season leftover and returns in units | L = U × (1 − s); R = U × s × r | U output, s sold share, r returns share of sold. |
| Traceability of a tier | T_k = purchases with a known factory of tier k / all purchases | In money or units, the method is fixed; it grows from tier 1 to tier 3 more slowly. |
| Environmental fee for a group (simplified) | Fee = M × (N − D) × S × k | M mass, t; N recycling target; D share actually recycled; S base rate per tonne; k group coefficient. Rates and targets are not checked against the text (unverified): check against the current edition. |
Formulas in notation
- Item footprint
CF = m(1+w)Σ s_j f_j + m e_s + m e_l + p
m is mass, w cutting loss, s_j material share, f_j factor, e_s and e_l sewing and logistics per kg, p packaging.- Certified share
C = Σ m_i u_i c_i / Σ m_i u_i
A share by mass, not by item count.
Worked example
A conditional collection: footprint, water, leftovers and returns by category (illustrative coefficients)
| Category | Output, pcs | Mass, kg | Footprint, kg CO2e per item | Total, t CO2e | Per RUB 1,000, kg | Water, L per item | Certified, % | Season leftover, pcs | Returns, pcs |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Women | 60,000 | 0.45 | 5.08 | 304.9 | 1.59 | 1,522 | 28 | 13,200 | 12,168 |
| Men | 30,000 | 0.6 | 6.99 | 209.8 | 1.94 | 2,567 | 24 | 5,400 | 4,182 |
| Kids | 40,000 | 0.3 | 3.05 | 122.1 | 2.03 | 1,656 | 35 | 6,000 | 4,760 |
| Footwear | 20,000 | 0.9 | 12.94 | 258.8 | 2.7 | 6,073 | 12 | 4,000 | 3,520 |
| Accessories | 25,000 | 0.35 | 5.54 | 138.6 | 2.31 | 2,462 | 15 | 6,000 | 1,520 |
| Total | 175,000 | 1,034.1 | 23.3 | 34,600 | 26,150 |
All coefficients and numbers are conditional: they show the order of calculation, not an actual footprint. The total is 1034.1 t CO2e for an output of 175,000 pcs; the category sum matches the total (checked by code).
Figures
- Materials
- Sewing
- Logistics
- Packaging
Data as a table
| Measure | Materials | Sewing | Logistics | Packaging |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Women | 4.08 | 0.54 | 0.36 | 0.1 |
| Men | 5.69 | 0.72 | 0.48 | 0.1 |
| Kids | 2.35 | 0.36 | 0.24 | 0.1 |
| Footwear | 11 | 1.08 | 0.72 | 0.1 |
| Accessories | 4.74 | 0.42 | 0.28 | 0.1 |
Item carbon footprint by stage and category. Kilograms of CO2e per item: materials dominate in every category; footwear and men are heavier because of mass and leather (illustrative coefficients).
- 0.8 … 85.6 %
Data as a table
| Materials | Sewing | Logistics | Packaging | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Women | 80.3 | 10.6 | 7.1 | 2 |
| Men | 81.4 | 10.3 | 6.9 | 1.4 |
| Kids | 77.1 | 11.8 | 7.9 | 3.3 |
| Footwear | 85.3 | 8.3 | 5.6 | 0.8 |
| Accessories | 85.6 | 7.6 | 5.1 | 1.8 |
Footprint structure by stage, %. The share of a stage in the item footprint: for leather categories materials weigh even more, logistics and packaging are almost invisible (illustrative coefficients).
- positive
- negative
- total
Data as a table
| Step | Change | Level |
|---|---|---|
| Leftovers and returns | — | 60.8k |
| Returned to sale | −16.2k | 44.5k |
| Outlet and sale | −26k | 18.5k |
| Recycling and donors | −11.3k | 7,282 |
| Disposed | — | 7,282 |
The fate of season leftovers and returns. From the total of leftovers and returns the items returned to sale, sold in the outlet and passed to recycling are subtracted; the remainder is disposed of (illustrative shares).
Data as a table
| Sold share, % | kg CO2e per RUB 1,000 of revenue | |
|---|---|---|
| 78 | 1.59 | Women |
| 82 | 1.94 | Men |
| 85 | 2.03 | Kids |
| 80 | 2.7 | Footwear |
| 76 | 2.31 | Accessories |
Sold share and footprint per RUB 1,000 of revenue. Categories at the bottom right work better: they sell almost completely and carry fewer emissions per rouble of revenue; at the top left the load is higher and leftovers are larger (illustrative data).
- Actual
- Target
Data as a table
| Measure | Actual | Target |
|---|---|---|
| Women | 28 | 30 |
| Men | 24 | 30 |
| Kids | 35 | 30 |
| Footwear | 12 | 30 |
| Accessories | 15 | 30 |
Share of certified materials and the target. Share by mass, %: the 30% target is reached only in kids; the other categories are below it (illustrative data, the target is editable).
Calendar for preparing a sustainability report. Weeks from the start: data collection, calculation, claim checks, agreement with the lawyer and publication with an improvement plan; claim checks begin before the totals are computed.
| Stage | Start, wk | Length, wk |
|---|---|---|
| Supplier data collection | 0 | 4 |
| Footprint, water, leftovers | 3 | 3 |
| Claims and dossier check | 4 | 4 |
| Agreement with the lawyer | 7 | 2 |
| Publication and improvement plan | 9 | 2 |
Specifics by category
- Apparel
- Apparel: the main load is in materials (cotton, polyester, wool), so the levers are composition, cutting loss and recycled share. Example: women 5.1 kg CO2e per item, 1.6 kg per RUB 1,000 of revenue, water 1,522 L, certified materials 28%, season leftover 22%, returns 26%; men 7 kg CO2e per item, 1.9 kg per RUB 1,000 of revenue, water 2,567 L, certified materials 24%, season leftover 18%, returns 17%. Claims are checked by item composition; a certificate confirms the material, not the finished style.
- Footwear
- Footwear: a complex composition (leather, synthetics, sole, glue), so the footprint per item is higher and depends more on leather; separating footwear into materials for recycling is hard, returns are higher (22%). Example: 12.9 kg CO2e per item, 2.7 kg per RUB 1,000 of revenue, water 6,073 L, certified materials 12%, season leftover 20%, returns 22%. Claims need a specification by component, the overall composition is not enough.
- Accessories
- Accessories: small mass but leather and metal; the footprint per item is moderate, per RUB 1,000 it can be noticeable at a low price. Example: 5.5 kg CO2e per item, 2.3 kg per RUB 1,000 of revenue, water 2,462 L, certified materials 15%, season leftover 24%, returns 8%. For precious-metal jewelry the questions of accounting and metal origin are separate and not covered in this document.
- Kids
- Kids: items are outgrown quickly and the wear life is short, so durability and passing on (resale, exchange) are valuable; safety requirements for the materials of kids items are stricter (TR CU 007/2011, not checked against the text, unverified), so the claim “safe composition” requires documents. Example: 3.1 kg CO2e per item, 2 kg per RUB 1,000 of revenue, water 1,656 L, certified materials 35%, season leftover 15%, returns 14%.
- Men
- Men: heavier items (outerwear, jeans, suits), a higher basics share and fewer returns, so the footprint per item is higher and leftovers are lower. Example: 7 kg CO2e per item, 1.9 kg per RUB 1,000 of revenue, water 2,567 L, certified materials 24%, season leftover 18%, returns 17%. Durability and repair are a stronger lever here than a change of composition.
- Women
- Women: more SKUs, fashion and returns, so the main levers are buying accuracy, leftovers and the fate of returns; the footprint per item is lower but the volume is larger. Example: 5.1 kg CO2e per item, 1.6 kg per RUB 1,000 of revenue, water 1,522 L, certified materials 28%, season leftover 22%, returns 26%. Fast collection change strengthens the leftover risk and the risk of generic claims (“eco line”).
Common mistakes
- Taking emission factors “from the internet” without a source and publishing them as fact → the claim cannot be supported → use supplier data or a method marked “estimate”.
- Claiming an “eco-friendly collection” on one material in one style → misleading → claim only what is supported by object, base and period.
- Counting sustainability only for materials → leftovers and returns go to disposal → keep leftovers, returns and their fate as separate indicators.
- Checking only tier 1 factories → the risk in tiers 2 and 3 remains → start with tier 1 and add tiers by risk.
- Changing the calculation method between years without a note → indicators are not comparable → fix the boundary and method and recompute past periods.
- A retailer repeats a brand claim without a dossier → the retailer is responsible for the advertising → request documents before placement.
Russian specifics
- Extended producer and importer responsibility for goods and packaging: the waste law, the goods lists and recycling targets (Government Decree No. 2414), fee rates (Decree No. 1041); dates, targets and rates are not checked against the act texts (unverified). Rule: Law 89-FZ of 24.06.1998: Federal Law of 24.06.1998 No. 89-FZ “On production and consumption waste” (extended producer responsibility, Art. 24.2 ff.) (rule check not completed).
- The goods list and recycling targets: goods group No. 1 “Clothing and textile products”; there is no separate footwear group among goods (not checked against the text, unverified). Rule: Decree 2414 of 29.12.2023: Government Decree of 29.12.2023 No. 2414 (lists of goods and packaging subject to recycling, recycling targets) (rule check not completed).
- Environmental fee rates and group coefficients: Decree No. 1041 as currently amended; the calculation in the document is simplified and illustrative (unverified). Rule: Decree 1041 of 01.08.2024: Government Decree of 01.08.2024 No. 1041 (environmental fee rates and group coefficients) (rule check not completed).
- Advertising, including environmental claims: the general requirements of the advertising law (inaccurate advertising is prohibited); a specific norm against greenwashing in Russia was not identified in Lab. Rule: Law 38-FZ of 13.03.2006: Federal Law of 13.03.2006 No. 38-FZ on advertising.
- EU for exporters: Directive (EU) 2024/825 on environmental claims, Regulation (EU) 2024/1781 on ecodesign and the digital product passport, Directive (EU) 2025/1892 on extended responsibility for textiles; dates and content are not checked against the texts (unverified). Rule: EU Directive 2024/825 of 28.02.2024: Directive (EU) 2024/825 (empowering consumers for the green transition: ban on misleading environmental claims) (rule check not completed).
- The ban on goods made with forced labor on the EU market: Regulation (EU) 2024/3015, application from 14.12.2027 per unchecked data; it does not cover environmental claims. Rule: EU Regulation 2024/3015 of 2024: Regulation (EU) 2024/3015 (ban on forced-labor products) (rule check not completed).
- Safety of kids products and light industry products: technical regulations TR CU 007/2011 and 017/2011; a claim on composition or safety must match the conformity documents. Rule: CU Commission decision 797 of 23.09.2011: TR CU 007/2011 on safety of products for children and adolescents (Customs Union Commission Decision of 23.09.2011 No. 797).