Footwear returns: reasons, reverse logistics, the share back on sale and the loss
Splits footwear returns by reason (size, defect, did not like), calculates reverse logistics and handling, what share went back on sale as new and at a reduced price (worn returns), how much is lost on the price reduction and write-offs and what one return costs.
At a glance
- What question does it answer?
- What footwear returns cost, what part goes back on sale as new and worn, and what cutting size returns would give.
- What data is needed?
- Pairs, the return rate, the price and cost of a pair.
- How to read the result?
- On the default data (9,000 pairs at 4,500, a 15% return rate, 1,350 pairs: size 55%, defect 15%, did not like 30%) 79.25% of returns went back on sale (as new 66.5%, at a price reduced by 30% 12.75%), 20.75% were written off. Reverse logistics, handling and preparation are 720,090, price reduction 232,369, write-off 166,050; in total 1,118,509, that is 828.5 per return and 2.76% of revenue. The largest loss is on size (600,311). Cutting size returns by 20% gives 120,062. Example on the default values: Returns in the period: 1,350 pairs; Back on sale: 79.3%; Back on sale as new: 66.5%; Back on sale at a reduced price (worn): 12.8%. The figures are illustrative: enter your own to see your result.
Why and how to reason
A shoe return costs more than a clothing return for two reasons: a pair may be worn after trying on, and a mistake in size or last is particularly common in footwear. So it is important to split returns by cause and by the fate of the pair. Of 9,000 pairs sold 15% come back, that is 1,350. Causes: size or last 55%, defect 15%, did not like 30%. Of returns for size 80% go back on sale as new and 15% at a reduced price. A pair with a defect goes to the supplier with a refund of 70%. The overall picture: 66.5% back on sale as new, 12.75% at a reduced price, 20.75% written off or returned to the supplier. Losses add up from logistics and handling (720 thousand), the 30% price reduction (232 thousand) and write-off (166 thousand): 1.12 million in total, or 829 per return.
When to use it
Reach for it when planning online footwear sales, choosing size help and in negotiations with a supplier about defects. Do not use it as an assessment of service quality: the calculation is only about money. Assumptions: the shares of the pair’s fate by cause are known from your records, preparation for resale applies only to those returning to sale, the reduction of size returns is linear. It is also handy when choosing return terms: free or paid, period, condition of the pair.
How to read the result
Look at the cause with the largest loss (600 thousand, size) and at the effect of cutting size returns (120 thousand for the period with a 20% cut): that is money that a size chart, insole fitting or fit reviews can bring. The loss per return (829) is compared with the margin on a pair: if a return eats almost half, change the policy (paid return delivery, limits on promotions). If defects take a large share, the conversation is with the factory, not with the customer. Check what share of returned pairs really goes back on sale as new: almost all the loss depends on it, and it is what the receiving process should improve.
Common mistakes
Typical trap: treating all returns as equally returnable to sale, ignoring the preparation of the pair, taking supplier refund from plan rather than fact, computing the price loss before inspection. Measure the shares of the pair’s fate from the receiving of returns over 1 to 2 months, do not take “by feel”.
What data is needed?
- Pairs, the return rate, the price and cost of a pair.
- The cost of a return: reverse logistics, inspection and handling, preparation for resale, the price reduction for worn pairs.
- The return reasons and the fate of the pair for each, the supplier refund.
Inputs
| Field | Unit | Value in the example | Meaning |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pairs sold in the period | pairs | 9,000 | Pairs paid by customers in the period (before returns) for the channel you analyze. The example value is taken from the own-site channel of “Model B”: illustrative. |
| Return rate | % | 15 | Returned pairs ÷ sold. Online the rate is higher than in a store; for children’s footwear and narrow lasts it may differ: take your own. The 15% example is an own-site figure; in the “Footwear” sets of the returns and marketplace calculations a conditional 30% is used (marketplace): the channels differ, count them by one definition of the rate. The default comes from the end-to-end “Model B” (a brand, illustrative data). |
| Average price of a pair excl. VAT | ₽ | 4,500 | The price at which a pair was sold, excl. VAT. The default comes from the end-to-end “Model B” (a brand, illustrative data). |
| Cost of a pair | ₽ | 1,200 | Production or landed cost excl. VAT. For footwear usually higher than for apparel: take your own. The default comes from the end-to-end “Model B” (a brand, illustrative data). |
| Reverse logistics of one return | ₽ | 350 | Courier or pickup point back to the warehouse, excl. VAT; in the example the same as delivery in “Model B”. The default comes from the end-to-end “Model B” (a brand, illustrative data). |
| Inspection and handling of one return | ₽ | 120 | Receiving, sole and last inspection, photos, a decision on the pair’s fate. The example value is illustrative. |
| Preparing a pair for resale | ₽ | 80 | Cleaning, a new box, tags: only for pairs that go back on sale. The example value is illustrative. |
| Price reduction for worn pairs | % | 30 | By how many percent you reduce the price of a pair returned with signs of fitting or wear. Your policy. The example value is illustrative. |
| Reduction of size returns | % | 20 | What if the size chart, photos and last advice cut returns for size by this many percent. Your scenario. The example value is illustrative. |
How it is calculated
| Step | Formula |
|---|---|
| Returns | pairs × return rate; by reason × the reason share |
| Fate of the pair | as new; at a reduced price; the rest is written off or goes to the supplier |
| Cost of a return | logistics and handling for every return; preparation only for those back on sale |
| Price and write-off losses | reduced × price × reduction %; written off × cost × (1 − refund) |
| Total | the sum of five items; per return and to revenue; scenario: the cut in size returns × the loss per size return |
Worked numbers
Default values from the app; in the interactive version you enter your own.
- Returns in the period
- 1,350 pairs
- Back on sale
- 79.3 %As new plus at a reduced price, share of returns.
- Back on sale as new
- 66.5 %
- Back on sale at a reduced price (worn)
- 12.8 %
- Written off or returned to the supplier
- 20.8 %
- Reverse logistics, handling and preparation
- 720,090 ₽
- Loss from the price reduction on worn pairs
- 232,369 ₽
- Loss from write-offs
- 166,050 ₽The cost of written-off pairs less the supplier refund.
- Total loss from returns
- 1.12 m ₽
- Loss per return
- 828.53 ₽
- Loss to sales revenue
- 2.8 %Total loss ÷ revenue of pairs sold, points of revenue.
- Reason with the largest loss
- 600,311 ₽ · Size or last
- Effect of cutting size returns
- 120,062 ₽ · −20 %The first table row is treated as the “size” reason. The reduction × the loss on such a return.
Returns by reason
| Reason | Returns | As new | At a reduced price | Written off | Loss | Loss per return |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Size or last | 742.5 | 594 | 111.4 | 37.1 | 600,311 ₽ | 808.5 ₽ |
| Defect | 202.5 | 0 | 0 | 202.5 | 168,075 ₽ | 830 ₽ |
| Did not like | 405 | 303.8 | 60.8 | 40.5 | 350,123 ₽ | 864.5 ₽ |
Of 1,350 returns 79.3 % went back on sale, 12.8 % at a price reduced by 30 %. The loss is 1.12 m ₽, that is 828.53 ₽ per return and 2.76 % of revenue; the largest loss comes from “Size or last”.
A returned pair is sold later and may not find a buyer in season: the loss of a missed sale and the cost of money are not included. Check the return deadlines, the inspection procedure and refunds for footwear of proper quality with a lawyer under the consumer protection law. The example values are illustrative: take the data of your own returns, for children’s footwear and accessories they differ. Amounts excl. VAT.
Nuances and limits
- Do not mix a size return and a defect: they have different cures (a size chart and last against a claim to the supplier).
- A worn pair sells worse: do not count it as new, enter the share at a reduced price separately.
- Check the return deadlines and the inspection with a lawyer; the defaults are illustrative, children’s footwear and accessories give other reasons and shares.