Unit economics (CM1, CM2, CM3) with buyout
Unit economics shows how much money is left from one ordered item after each layer of cost: goods and commission (CM1), logistics and storage (CM2), marketing (CM3). It decides which channel and style to grow and which to stop; the buyout rate matters most, since a return brings no revenue but still costs logistics.
Why this document
Order revenue hides losses: in apparel and footwear a large share of orders comes back, and every return costs delivery, handling and sometimes a write-off. Unit economics counts contribution per purchased order, not per placed one, so it shows where rising sales make the company poorer. The e-commerce manager chooses price and promotions by it, the finance director decides how much to spend on acquisition, and when platform tariffs change it is at once clear which styles stopped paying back.
At a glance
- What is this document and why is it needed?
- Unit economics shows how much money is left from one ordered item after each layer of cost: goods and commission (CM1), logistics and storage (CM2), marketing (CM3). It decides which channel and style to grow and which to stop; the buyout rate matters most, since a return brings no revenue but still costs logistics.
- Who owns the document and how often is it rebuilt?
- Brand: finance and the e-commerce manager, per channel and SKU, monthly. Retailer: online director and analyst, by channel and category, whenever platform tariffs change.
- What mistakes are the most common?
- Counting per bought item rather than per ordered item → returns are invisible → the unit is the order. The site-wide average buyout is used → loss-making SKUs are hidden → buyout per SKU. Returned goods are assumed resold at full price → profit overstated → introduce a sellable share and write-off.
For whom
- Brand
- A brand computes unit economics per channel: its own site (D2C), marketplaces, wholesale; a marketplace withholds commission and logistics while the own site has higher acquisition costs but no platform commission. For wholesale, deferral and bonuses replace the buyout rate.
- Retail
- A retailer computes online and marketplace unit economics separately from stores: delivery, try-on and returns are added; the result is compared with store economics (the “Store economics” calculation). With omnichannel, click-and-collect and ship-from-store are added.
What it consists of
Contribution layers
- CM1 = revenue of bought items − cost − commission and acquiring.
- CM2 = CM1 − logistics (delivery and returns) − storage and packing.
- CM3 = CM2 − marketing (advertising cost share, DRR).
- Net profit per order = CM3 − tax.
The buyout effect
- Buyout k = bought ÷ ordered; a return (1 − k) brings logistics costs and sometimes goods loss.
- Returned goods go back into stock at full price only if sellable; the sellable share sets the threshold.
Sensitivity
- A table: buyout, price, commission, DRR, FX and their effect on CM3; the break-even price.
- Sensitivity to buyout: at 80% buyout on the platform the net profit per order under the general regime is RUB 661, at 65% buyout RUB 427 (down RUB 234 on every order): a return shrinks revenue and adds write-off of units not fit for sale. For footwear buyout is more sensitive (a size-return range of 25 to 40% is an editable hint, not checked).
- Platform logistics and storage depend on volume and warehouse localization, storage is paid by day: in the calculation take logistics at the platform tariff for the item size, storage as rate × days × volume; fixed amounts are acceptable only to estimate the order of magnitude. Platform tariffs change, take the current ones from the personal account on the calculation date (not checked).
Brand and retailer: what is computed differently
- Brand: a brand computes unit economics by channel: own site, marketplaces and wholesale; on a marketplace commission and logistics are withheld, on the site customer acquisition costs are higher, in wholesale returns and the cost of deferral stand instead of buyout.
- Retailer: a retailer computes the online channel and marketplaces separately from stores, adding delivery, fitting, return, pickup and shipping from the store, and compares the result with the store economics (the “Store P&L” document).
Brand: how the document differs and what to add
- Brand: brand unit economics is computed by channel: marketplace, site, wholesale; each has its own commission, logistics, returns and payment term.
- Brand: on the marketplace commission (20% in the model) and logistics (8%) are computed from price; the platform revises tariffs, and a 3 pp rise changes unit profit immediately.
- Brand: on the own site delivery per order (RUB 350), acquiring and acquisition costs are added; buyout is higher than on the platform but traffic is paid.
- Brand: wholesale gives a lower price but no marketing or delivery to the customer: unit contribution accounts for the cost of the 45-day payment deferral.
- Brand: the general and simplified regimes change the conclusion: under the simplified regime the shelf price does not rise by VAT and purchases with VAT enter cost; the VAT threshold under the simplified regime (228-FZ) is checked against turnover.
- Brand: the first order and repeat purchases are counted separately: a customer pays back over several orders, and the brand accounts for LTV and acquisition payback.
- Brand: buyout and size returns depend on category: footwear and outerwear return more often, and unit economics is computed by product group.
Retailer: how the document differs and what to add
- Retailer: retailer unit economics is computed per SKU and per store: gross margin less shrink, online returns and direct store costs.
- Retailer: retailer online adds last mile, packaging and returns (22% in the model): without them an online order looks more profitable than a store sale.
- Retailer: third-party brand goods on own online bring margin by purchase terms, while a marketplace charges commission: the channel is chosen by net contribution.
- Retailer: loyalty bonuses and card discounts reduce net price: unit economics takes the price after points accrual, not the price tag.
- Retailer: pickup from a store is cheaper than delivery and brings traffic to the point: its contribution is a separate line.
- Retailer: retailer marketing is counted per acquired customer and per repeat order: average ticket and purchase frequency make marketing pay.
- Retailer: clearance online goes through the marketplace or own site: the channel is chosen by net contribution after commission, not by price.
How to read the result and which decisions follow
- CM2 (after commission and logistics) is negative: the channel loses money per unit; raise price, reduce returns or change channel, do not add marketing.
- CM3 is positive but net profit after tax is not: look at the tax regime and the VAT threshold; the decision depends on the regime, not marketing.
- Buyout is 5 pp below plan: recompute unit profit at actual buyout; with size returns work on the size chart and description, not on price.
Control checks
- The layers tie (marketplace, general regime, RUB per order): revenue 2,960 − cost 984 − commission 592 − logistics 237 − marketing 266 − tax 220 = net profit 661; outbound 197 + return 39 = logistics 237; DRR 9% of buyout = 7.2% of orders.
- Prices in lines are either all excluding VAT or including VAT with a note; the DRR base (orders or buyout) is always stated.
- The sum of layers equals net profit per unit; units for all channels are the same (an ordered unit).
- Typical traps: cost per sold rather than ordered unit, returns without write-off, commission on a price including VAT, corporate income tax on a negative contribution.
Where the data comes from
| Data source | Fields |
|---|---|
| Marketplace reports | Orders, buyouts, commission, logistics, storage, penalties, advertising by SKU. |
| Own site and payments | Orders, acquiring, delivery, returns, acquisition costs. |
| Accounting | Unit cost, tax regime, VAT rate. |
How to build it step by step
- Step 1. Choose the unit: an order or a SKU-size; count per ordered unit so that buyout enters the calculation.
- Step 2. Collect price, cost, channel commission and acquiring.
- Step 3. Determine the buyout rate per SKU over the last 2-3 months (not for the whole site).
- Step 4. Compute CM1 per order: revenue of bought items − cost − commissions.
- Step 5. Subtract logistics (outbound on all orders, return on returns) and storage: CM2.
- Step 6. Subtract marketing by DRR: CM3.
- Step 7. Subtract tax by regime and obtain net profit per order.
- Step 8. Compute sensitivity and the break-even price; decide per SKU: raise the price, delist from the channel, change the size grid.
Formulas
| Measure | Formulas | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Revenue per order | Revenue = Price × k | Buyout k as a fraction of one. |
| CM1 | CM1 = Price × k − Cost × k − Revenue × (Commission + Acquiring) | Assumes returned goods go back on sale without loss; otherwise subtract the write-off share. |
| CM2 | CM2 = CM1 − Outbound logistics − Return logistics × (1 − k) − Storage | The “Marketplace unit economics and break-even price” calculation. In the example the return logistics tariff equals the outbound one, and the 8% of revenue at base buyout is split into outbound and return parts: as buyout falls the return part grows. |
| CM3 | CM3 = CM2 − Revenue × DRR | One DRR base for the whole document: revenue of bought items (9% in Model B). Platforms compute DRR on orders: DRR on orders = DRR on buyout × buyout; do not mix bases, otherwise the numbers differ by 1.2 to 1.5 times. |
| Break-even price | Price: solve CM3 = 0 for Price at given k and rates | Found by iteration or the inverse formula. |
Formulas in notation
- Revenue per ordered unit
R = P · k
P is the price excluding VAT (general regime), k = 1 − returns is the buyout share.- Cost with returns
C_k = c · k + c · (1 − k) · w
c is unit cost, w is the share of returned units that cannot be resold.- Contribution layers
CM1 = R − C_k − Fee; CM2 = CM1 − Log; CM3 = CM2 − Mkt
Fee is commission and acquiring, Log is logistics and delivery, Mkt is marketing; each layer answers its own question.- DRR on orders
DRR_orders = m · k
m is the marketing share of revenue of bought-out units; in terms of orders it is lower by the buyout share.
Worked example
Unit economics per ordered unit from the Model B inputs: marketplace and own site, general regime and simplified 6% without VAT, RUB per order
| Line | Marketplace, general regime | Marketplace, USN | Own site, general regime | Own site, USN |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Shelf price for the customer (general regime: including 22% VAT, USN: no VAT) | 4,514 | 3,700 | 5,490 | 4,500 |
| Price excluding VAT (revenue is computed on it) | 3,700 | 3,700 | 4,500 | 4,500 |
| Buyout, % | 80 | 80 | 85 | 85 |
| Revenue (bought) | 2,960 | 2,960 | 3,825 | 3,825 |
| Cost: bought items plus 10% write-off of returned units (USN: purchase including VAT) | 984 | 1,200 | 1,038 | 1,266 |
| Platform commission or acquiring | 592 | 592 | 77 | 77 |
| CM1 | 1,384 | 1,168 | 2,711 | 2,482 |
| Logistics: 8% of revenue at the platform at base buyout, RUB 350 per order at the site | 237 | 237 | 350 | 350 |
| of which outbound logistics (on every order) | 197 | 197 | 350 | 350 |
| of which return logistics (on returns: the tariff equals outbound × the return share) | 39 | 39 | 0 | 0 |
| CM2 | 1,147 | 931 | 2,361 | 2,132 |
| Marketing: 9% of revenue (DRR on buyout) | 266 | 266 | 344 | 344 |
| CM3 | 881 | 664 | 2,016 | 1,788 |
| Tax (general regime: 25% of CM3, conditional; USN: 6% of revenue) | 220 | 178 | 504 | 230 |
| Net profit per order | 661 | 487 | 1,512 | 1,558 |
| Net profit, % of price excluding VAT | 17.9 | 13.2 | 33.6 | 34.6 |
| The same shelf price: net profit per order when the customer pays the general-regime price including VAT and on USN (the whole price is revenue) | 661 | 858 | 1,512 | 2,257 |
| Sensitivity: buyout 65%, CM3 per order | 569 | 388 | 1,350 | 1,169 |
| Sensitivity: buyout 65%, net profit per order | 427 | 244 | 1,013 | 994 |
The shelf price is not compared between regimes without stating VAT: under the general regime the customer pays 4514 (of which RUB 814 VAT goes to the budget), under USN without VAT the same shelf price of 3700 is all revenue. The marketplace under the general regime yields RUB 661 per order, under USN 487 (6% tax on all revenue and purchase including VAT in cost); the site 1512 and 1558. This is an example for a small brand: a brand of the Model B scale (revenue RUB 206.665 million) exceeds the income threshold for VAT exemption on USN (under Law 228-FZ RUB 20 million in 2026, the text was read in the register) and works under the general regime, so use the general-regime columns. DRR: in the model it is 9% of revenue of bought items; platforms compute DRR on orders, and the same spend gives 7.2% of orders on the platform (buyout 80%). Model B wholesale per unit: price 2,400, revenue 2328, cost 1168, deferral cost 57, marketing 210, contribution RUB 893 (37.2% of price). At a marketplace buyout of 65% CM3 per order falls from 881 to RUB 569 (-35%) and net profit from 661 to 427: returns shrink revenue, add write-off, and return logistics (RUB 69 per order against 39) and marketing per order stay. Tax: the general regime takes 25% of CM3 here, a conditional tax on profit before fixed costs, while USN takes 6% of revenue regardless of costs; so the regime columns are comparable only at the same shelf price, shown in the separate row (the customer pays the same: under the general regime RUB 4,514 including VAT, under USN the same amount is revenue), where the marketplace on USN gives RUB 858 per order against 661 on the general regime.
Figures
- positive
- negative
- total
Data as a table
| Step | Change | Level |
|---|---|---|
| Revenue with buyout | — | 2,960 |
| Cost and write-off | −984 | 1,976 |
| Commission | −592 | 1,384 |
| Logistics | −237 | 1,147 |
| Marketing | −266 | 881 |
| Corporate income tax | −220 | 661 |
| Net profit per unit | — | 661 |
Unit economics at the marketplace (general regime). From the price excluding VAT with buyout to net profit per ordered unit: commission, logistics and marketing take the main part.
- Contribution after marketing (CM3)
- Net profit
Data as a table
| Measure | Contribution after marketing (CM3) | Net profit |
|---|---|---|
| Marketplace, general | 881 | 661 |
| Marketplace, simplified | 664 | 487 |
| Site, general | 2,016 | 1,512 |
| Site, simplified | 1,788 | 1,558 |
Contribution and net profit per unit by channel and regime. Marketplace versus own site and the general regime versus the simplified one: regime and channel change the outcome more than the price suggests.
Specifics by category
- Apparel
- Buyout is lower because of try-on and size; 70-85% on a marketplace as a starting hint (editable, not verified); the key lever is size tables and photos that raise buyout.
- Footwear
- Buyout is the lowest and most sensitive: shoes are ordered in two sizes for trying, returns are costly and part of them is unsellable (wear marks); count the write-off share and box storage.
- Accessories
- Buyout is higher (no sizes) and returns are rare; the key costs are packaging and gift wrap, size and weight. High margin allows more marketing; counterfeit and quality complaint risk.
- Kids
- Returns are higher because of height-based sizes and rapid growth; seasonality (school, winter) makes logistics uneven; every item needs conformity documents, with certification costs spread over the batch.
- Men
- Buyout is higher than for women: the buyer knows the size and repeats purchases; marketing is cheaper on repeat orders; for basics CM3 is steadier.
- Women
- Buyout is lower and varies more by style: dresses and tops return more often; photos and fabric description affect returns more; DRR is higher because of competition and frequent range changes.
Common mistakes
- Counting per bought item rather than per ordered item → returns are invisible → the unit is the order.
- The site-wide average buyout is used → loss-making SKUs are hidden → buyout per SKU.
- Returned goods are assumed resold at full price → profit overstated → introduce a sellable share and write-off.
- The DRR base is changed within one report (orders at the platform, revenue in the model) → figures differ by 1.2 to 1.5 times → fix one base (revenue of bought items) and convert: DRR on orders = DRR on buyout × buyout.
- No recomputation when platform tariffs change → margin falls unnoticed → recompute at every tariff change.
- Prices are compared between regimes without stating VAT → USN “wins” for no reason → always state whether the shelf price includes VAT and compute revenue from the price excluding VAT on the general regime.
- Wholesale in unit economics is replaced by a general phrase about deferral → the main channel of a brand stays uncalculated → compute wholesale as a line: price, returns, deferral cost, marketing, contribution.
Russian specifics
- Distance sales are covered by return rules: the consumer may return a good-quality item bought remotely; the Constitutional Court stated a position on Art. 26.1 paras 3-4 (per summaries). Rule: Decree 7-P of 17.02.2026: Constitutional Court Ruling of 17.02.2026 No. 7-P (paras 3 and 4 of Art. 26.1 of the Consumer Rights Law) (rule check not completed).
- Consumer rights and returns: the consumer protection law (Arts. 25, 26.1). Rule: Law 2300-1 of 07.02.1992: Law of 07.02.1992 No. 2300-1 on consumer rights protection (rule check not completed).
- Terms for price reduction and deductions on a platform are fixed by contract and the platform economy law; check tariffs with the platform. Rule: Law 289-FZ of 31.07.2025: Federal Law of 31.07.2025 No. 289-FZ on the platform economy.
- The VAT exemption on USN holds while income does not exceed the threshold: under Art. 145 as amended by Law 228-FZ the threshold is RUB 20 million for 2025 to 2028 (the text was read in the register); a brand with revenue above the threshold loses the exemption and pays VAT, so its unit economics is computed on the general regime, while the USN column without VAT suits only a small brand. Rule: Law 228-FZ of 04.07.2026: Federal Law of 04.07.2026 No. 228-FZ (income threshold under Art. 145 of the Tax Code).