Contribution levels CM1–CM3 by channel with buyout
For sales channels (site, platforms, partners) calculates contribution step by step: CM1 after cost of goods and commissions on what was bought, CM2 after logistics and handling of orders and returns, CM3 after marketing. Shows contribution per order and the allowable marketing per order.
At a glance
- What question does it answer?
- How much is left of revenue after buyout at each contribution step and which channel is better per order.
- What data is needed?
- By channel: orders, ticket, buyout.
- How to read the result?
- On the default data (three channels) revenue after buyout is 26,750,000, CM1 11,395,952, CM2 8,590,052, CM3 5,140,052 (19.2% of revenue). The best channel by CM3 per order is the fashion platform: 1,176.75 (own site 1,176.21). The worst is the universal platform: 204.50 per order; while marketing per order is below 554.50 its CM3 is positive. Example on the default values: Revenue after buyout: RUB 26.8 million; CM1: RUB 11.4 million; CM2: RUB 8.59 million; CM3: RUB 5.14 million. The figures are illustrative: enter your own to see your result.
Why and how to reason
Profit by channel cannot be judged by revenue: each channel has its own share of non-redemption, commission, logistics and marketing. Contribution is counted in steps to see where it melts. CM1 is revenue from redeemed orders minus cost and commissions: an order may be placed but not collected, and then there is no revenue. CM2 subtracts logistics and handling of returns and non-collected orders. CM3 subtracts marketing. At the defaults revenue with redemption is 26.75 million, CM1 is 11.4 million, CM2 8.6 million, CM3 5.1 million, that is 19% of revenue. The steps show that a channel with a high CM1 may lose at CM3. The allowable marketing per order at the worst channel is 554.5: that much can be spent until CM3 reaches zero. For the universal marketplace it is 350 plus 204.5 of margin.
When to use it
It fits when distributing budget between channels, reviewing marketplace tariffs and assessing a new channel. Do not use it if return and logistics data are estimates: an error of 5 points in redemption flips the conclusion. Assumptions: redemption and commission are constant, logistics and storage costs per order are known, marketing is attributed to orders evenly. It also helps answer whether to launch a new channel: the steps show at once what is missing to reach a plus.
How to read the result
Compare channels by CM3 per order: the best gives 1,177, the worst 204.5. That is a sixfold difference at similar revenue. The worst channel need not be closed: see at which step it loses most (commission, logistics, marketing) and whether that can be fixed. Allowable marketing per order shows the ceiling for advertising in the channel. If CM2 is already negative, marketing will not help: change the tariff, packaging or assortment. It is worth writing the conclusion for each channel in one line (“where we lose, what we do”): such a summary helps at a meeting with the marketing team.
Common mistakes
Typical trap: taking revenue from placed orders instead of redeemed ones, ignoring returns and non-collection, mixing commission with marketing, setting marketing below real, comparing channels with different average baskets by contribution per order without regard for turnover. Enter all channels on the same basis.
What data is needed?
- By channel: orders, ticket, buyout.
- Cost of goods and commission as a percentage of revenue after buyout.
- Logistics, return and marketing per order, write-off of non-purchased.
Inputs
| Field | Unit | Value in the example | Meaning |
|---|---|---|---|
| Compare channels per rouble of turnover and find the equalizing ticket | No | To compare neutral “platform 1–3” under the same assumptions: CM3 per rouble of ordered turnover and the ticket at which the channel gives as much CM3 per order as the best one. Enter each platform’s tariffs in the table from your account as of the date. |
How it is calculated
| Step | Formula |
|---|---|
| Revenue after buyout | orders × ticket × buyout |
| CM1 | revenue after buyout × (1 − cost % − commission %) − write-off |
| CM2 | CM1 − orders × logistics − non-purchased orders × return − orders × storage and packing |
| CM3 | CM2 − orders × marketing |
Worked numbers
Default values from the app; in the interactive version you enter your own.
- Revenue after buyout
- 26.8 m ₽
- CM1
- 11.4 m ₽After cost of goods, commissions and write-offs.
- CM2
- 8.59 m ₽CM1 minus logistics and handling of orders, returns, storage and packing (the “Storage and packing per order” column, if filled).
- CM3
- 5.14 m ₽CM2 minus marketing.
- CM3 in revenue after buyout
- 19.2 %
- Best channel by CM3 per order
- 1,176.75 ₽ · Fashion platform
- Worst channel by CM3 per order
- 204.5 ₽ · Universal platform
- Allowable marketing per order for the worst (CM3 = 0)
- 554.5 ₽
- positive
- negative
- total
Data as a table
| Step | Change | Level |
|---|---|---|
| Revenue after returns | — | 26.8m |
| Cost, commission, discounts | −15.4m | 11.4m |
| CM1 | — | 11.4m |
| Logistics and returns | −2.81m | 8.59m |
| CM2 | — | 8.59m |
| Marketing and other | −3.45m | 5.14m |
| CM3 | — | 5.14m |
Data as a table
| Measure | CM3 |
|---|---|
| Own site | 2.35m |
| Universal platform | 1.02m |
| Fashion platform | 1.77m |
Channels: contribution steps
| Channel | Revenue after buyout | CM1 | CM2 | CM3 | CM3 per order | CM3 in revenue |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Own site | 8.06 m ₽ | 4.61 m ₽ | 3.75 m ₽ | 2.35 m ₽ | 1,176.21 ₽ | 29.2 % |
| Universal platform | 11.6 m ₽ | 4.2 m ₽ | 2.77 m ₽ | 1.02 m ₽ | 204.5 ₽ | 8.9 % |
| Fashion platform | 7.14 m ₽ | 2.59 m ₽ | 2.07 m ₽ | 1.77 m ₽ | 1,176.75 ₽ | 24.7 % |
Across all channels CM3 is 5.14 m ₽ (19.2 % of revenue after buyout). The best channel is “Fashion platform”: 1,176.75 ₽ per order; the worst is “Universal platform”: 204.5 ₽.
The CM1–CM3 scheme is the single Lab scheme (CM1 after cost of goods, commissions and write-offs; CM2 after logistics, handling, returns, storage and packing; CM3 after marketing). The borders may differ in your company: fix your own in your accounting policy and write the formula next to the figure. Fixed costs (team, warehouse rent) are not included. Amounts excl. VAT.
Nuances and limits
- Take buyout from the channel’s actual figure for the period: an expected buyout overstates contribution.
- Your CM1–CM3 borders may differ: fix them and write the formula next to the figure.
- For footwear buyout is usually lower, for accessories cost and logistics differ: the defaults are set for apparel.
- Fixed costs are not included: compare channels by contribution, not profit.