Syntha Lab RU

Returns policy: effect on profit

Compares profit under the current and a new returns policy (a fee for a return, a period, rules) with your estimate of the change in demand and in the return share. Shows the cost of returns from trying several sizes (bracketing) and the order-change threshold beyond which the new policy does not pay.

Platforms and marketplaces For whom: Heads of online sales and finance directors deciding whether to change the returns policy.

Calculate on your data →

At a glance

What question does it answer?
What happens to profit if a returns fee is introduced or the period shortened, and how far orders can fall for it still to pay.
What data is needed?
Orders, price, cost, return share, the cost of one return and the write-off share.
How to read the result?
On the example 10,000 orders at 4,500 with a cost of 1,800, 25% returns, a return cost of 350 and 10% written off. Profit now is 18.9m, 1,892.5 per order. The new policy: a fee of 250, returns 3 pp lower and orders 6% lower; profit per order is 2,044.4, in total 19.2m, that is +292,360. The new policy pays until orders fall by more than 7.4%. Returns from trying several sizes cost 530,000. Example on the default values: Profit now: RUB 18.9 million; Profit under the new policy: RUB 19.2 million; Effect of the new policy: RUB 292,360; Profit per order: now: RUB 1,892.5. The figures are illustrative: enter your own to see your result.

Why and how to reason

Free returns raise orders but every return costs money. When you introduce a fee or tighten the rules, demand falls and returns shrink. Whether the change pays is a balance, and it can be computed on one order. Profit per order = (1 − return share) × (price − cost) − returns × (return cost + write-off share × cost) + fee × returns. In the example now (1 − 0.25) × 2,700 = 2,025 minus 0.25 × (350 + 180) = 132.5 gives 1,892.5. The new policy: returns 22%, fee 250: 0.78 × 2,700 = 2,106, minus 0.22 × 530 = 116.6, plus 250 × 0.22 = 55, total 2,044.4. Orders fall 6% (9,400) but profit is 19.2 million against 18.9 million. The threshold: orders may fall by 7.4%, beyond which the policy does not pay.

When to use it

It is useful when discussing a return fee, a shorter term or new fitting rules. Especially useful in apparel and footwear where returns run 20–40%. It does not replace a test on part of the traffic: changes in demand and in return share are your estimates. Return periods and procedure are set by the consumer protection law and your offer, so check with a lawyer before changing. Assumptions: price and cost excluding VAT, write-off share constant.

How to read the result

The key figures are the effect of the new policy and the order drop beyond which it does not pay. If your estimate of the demand fall is far from the threshold the decision is robust. If close, run a test. Look at the cost of returns from trying several sizes: 530 thousand is what you pay for customers ordering three sizes, and the fee targets them. But a fee can also push away honest buyers, so watch the share of new customers and repeat orders, not only profit per order.

Common mistakes

Understating the return cost: it includes transport, handling and loss of the item’s condition. Forgetting that returns to another channel (a store) run at a different cost. Expecting the fee to remove only “excess” returns while honest buyers do not leave.

What data is needed?

  • Orders, price, cost, return share, the cost of one return and the write-off share.
  • Your estimates: the returns fee, the change in the return share and in orders.

Inputs

FieldUnitValue in the exampleMeaning
Orders in the periodpcs10,000How many orders were placed over the period.
Item price excl. VAT₽4,500Amount excl. VAT: the general rate is 22% from 01.01.2026. The rate follows the shipment date; confirm your regime and rate with an accountant.
Item cost excl. VAT₽1,800Unit cost excl. VAT, delivered to the warehouse.
Return share%25The share of orders with a return from your reports. There is no single standard in Russia. For footwear and dresses online the return share is usually above the store average (trying several sizes); for children’s it depends on the child’s height, accessories have no sizes. We give no guide without your own data: take your own statistics by category and channel.
Cost of one return₽350Logistics, receiving, checking, repacking.
Share of returns that cannot be resold%10The share of returns that cannot be resold, in percent: the cost is lost on such returns; the value is yours, from return records.
Share of returns from trying several sizes%40Optional: used for the line on the cost of bracketing.
Fee for a return charged to the customer₽250Check the admissibility of a fee and of return periods under the consumer protection law with a lawyer.
Change in the return sharepp−3Minus: fewer returns.
Change in the number of orders%−6Your estimate: a paid return usually lowers conversion; check with a test on part of the traffic.

How it is calculated

StepFormula
Profit per order(1 − returns) × (price − cost) − returns × (return cost + write-off share × cost) + fee × returns
Profitorders × profit per order
Order thresholdprofit per order now ÷ profit per order after − 1

Worked numbers

Default values from the app; in the interactive version you enter your own.

Profit now
18.9 m ₽
Profit under the new policy
19.2 m ₽
Effect of the new policy
292,360 ₽
Profit per order: now
1,892.5 ₽
Profit per order: new policy
2,044.4 ₽
Order change beyond which the new policy does not pay
−7.4 %If orders fall by more than this, profit will be lower than now.
Cost of returns from trying several sizes
530,000 ₽Returns × share of trying sizes × (return cost + write-off).

Two policies

IndicatorNowNew
Orders10,0009,400
Return share25 %22 %
Profit per order1,892.5 ₽2,044.4 ₽
Profit18.9 m ₽19.2 m ₽

The change in demand and in the return share are your estimates: check them with a test on part of the traffic. Return periods and procedure are set by the consumer protection law and your offer; check with a lawyer.

Nuances and limits

  • The fall in orders and in the return share are your estimates: check them with a test on part of the traffic.
  • Check the returns fee and periods with a lawyer under the consumer protection law.
  • The effect on loyalty and repeat purchases is not included.

Terms used

Calculate on your data →