Customer service: SLA, FCR, claims and consumer rights
The service procedure sets response times, rules for resolving requests, the claims routine and the line between a loyalty gesture and an expert check. It decides how many requests to close at first contact, when to accept a return without an expert check and where the line lies between consumer rights and company cost.
Why this document
A dispute with a customer is almost always decided in the first hours, and a mistake in the procedure costs more than the item: an extra refusal turns into a complaint or a lawsuit, an extra loyalty gesture into a direct loss. The service head, the lawyer and the commercial director read this document when they set deadlines and staff authority. It separates a voluntary gesture from an obligation under consumer protection law, so an operator knows what to decide alone and what to send for an expert check.
At a glance
- What is this document and why is it needed?
- The service procedure sets response times, rules for resolving requests, the claims routine and the line between a loyalty gesture and an expert check. It decides how many requests to close at first contact, when to accept a return without an expert check and where the line lies between consumer rights and company cost.
- Who owns the document and how often is it rebuilt?
- Brand: head of customer service or e-com, daily SLA control, weekly review of reasons, a monthly report to the director; claims are agreed with production. Retailer: head of chain service and store managers; some requests are solved in store, some at the call center or marketplace.
- What mistakes are the most common?
- The SLA target ignores staffing → SLA is red every day and the team stops looking at it → set achievable values and review them. FCR is counted from closed tickets without repeats → an inflated figure → cancel “solved” on a repeat within 7 days. A gesture instead of the customer right → a complaint to supervisors or court → record that both paths were offered and fix the choice.
For whom
- Brand
- The brand receives requests through its own channels (site, messengers, social) and from retailers. The key difference: a customer who orders on the site has a contract with the brand, a retailer customer has one with the retailer, and a product claim first goes to the seller. The brand agrees with partners on the returns procedure, deadlines, response times for defects and acceptance of items for examination.
- Retail
- A retailer accepts returns and claims in store and online, answers to the customer as the seller and then claims against the brand under the contract. A single policy for stores is needed, clear terms for passing defects to the supplier and reason accounting (otherwise neither the brand refund nor the buying fix is possible). For a chain, a separate indicator: the share solved in store without escalation.
What it consists of
Standards and indicators
- SLA: first reply (for example within 4 working hours), resolution time by request type; the target is set by the owner, not by a regulation.
- FCR (First Contact Resolution): the share of requests solved on first contact = solved on the first ÷ all.
- Brand: SLA runs on two loops: the end customer of own D2C and retail partners (claim reply time, batch replacement time).
- Retailer: SLA runs by channel (store, online, call center) and by brand; a deadline breach on a third-party brand product is recorded so it can be presented to the brand under the contract.
- Other indicators: escalation share, repeat requests, cost per request, customer rating (CSAT/NPS), claim resolution time.
Claim procedure
- Brand: claims from retail partners come by act (batch, SKU, sizes, photos); procedure, reply times and compensation are set by the supply contract, and defects are tracked by batch and factory.
- Retailer: the store accepts requests at the till and online under one procedure; a return of an online order in the store is processed the same way as in the web shop so the customer does not get different results by channel.
- Retailer: Intake: request form, photos, order number, receipt date; confirmation of receipt.
- Check: inspection, and in a dispute over the cause an examination at the seller expense; the response and decision terms are fixed in the policy.
- Retailer: Decision: refund, replacement, discount, repair; the selection and agreement with the customer; reason accounting and passing it to the supplier.
Loyalty gesture and rules
- Brand: costs of gestures and replacements in D2C are charged to the brand service cost; a production defect is passed back to the factory under the contract terms, so the cause is recorded before the gesture.
- Retailer: the retailer bears gesture costs itself if there is no defect; for a defect of a third-party brand compensation is claimed under the contract, so a gesture without examination on expensive items is agreed with the category manager.
- Decision table: when a gesture (discount, coupon) is allowed without examination and when an examination is needed; thresholds by item value and customer history.
- The customer right comes first: a gesture does not replace a lawful demand if the customer insists on it.
How to read the result and which decisions follow
- Cost per order ranges from RUB 4 (“Accessories”) to RUB 15.6 (“Footwear”); across all categories RUB 9.1 per order. Decision: the cheapest way to cut service cost is not hiring but removing causes in the product card: for footwear 52% of requests are about size.
- Brand: the most expensive topic is “Return and exchange” with RUB 79,800 in the period and FCR of 67%. Decision: put trained specialists and an expertise procedure on defects and claims; for basic questions use templates and order status in the account.
- Retailer: SLA and FCR for you depend on channels (chat, phone, store) and partner logistics; delivery requests are more often the carrier than yours. Decision: split requests by cause owner and pass reasoned claims to the carrier and brand.
- Brand: the consumer right to return and exchange is set by law and brand rules can only widen it; do not restrict rights below the law in the policy, otherwise a dispute is decided against you.
- Retailer: for a store chain requests arrive at the store, not the center; recording store requests in the same system is mandatory, otherwise SLA and FCR are computed for online only.
Control checks
- Check: 4250 requests on 47000 orders gives 9 per 100 orders; the weighted FCR of 69.4% is computed on requests, not as an average of percentages.
- Brand: set the response and resolution term for defect claims by policy and check it against the consumer rights law; the terms are not fixed in this document (unverified).
- Retailer: compute the cost per request on full service load, including systems and overheads; otherwise the cost is understated.
- Brand: split the defect topic into confirmed and not; without it neither a claim against the factory nor a loss estimate is possible.
- Retailer: process client personal data in requests under the personal data law; set access and retention periods by policy.
Brand and retailer: further differences
- Brand: own service knows the product and can resolve questions on composition and care, but does not see the retailer warehouse operations; for exchanges and returns at a store rely on the partner rules.
- Brand: a defect returned by a retailer starts a claim against you under the supply contract; agree the expertise procedure and the response term in advance.
Where the data comes from
| Data source | Fields |
|---|---|
| Request system (helpdesk, chats) | First reply time, resolution time, type, solved on first contact, customer rating. |
| Returns and claims records | Order, reason, decision, amount, passed to the supplier, examination status. |
| Partner and marketplace contracts | Returns procedure, deadlines, responsibility for defects and transport damage. |
How to build it step by step
- Step 1. Draw up a request classifier (order status, size, return, defect, payment) and fix it in the system.
- Step 2. Define SLA by type: first reply and resolution time; align with staffing capacity.
- Step 3. Prepare reply templates and a decision tree for frequent cases; update monthly.
- Retailer: Step 4. Describe the claim procedure step by step: intake, check, examination, decision, payment, passing to the supplier.
- Step 5. Set a “gesture or examination” table with thresholds and compute the cost of each path.
- Retailer: Step 6. Fix customer rights in the returns policy text: terms, conditions, the list of goods not subject to exchange; check with a lawyer.
- Step 7. Set up the report: SLA, FCR, cost per request, repeat requests, reasons; thresholds and owners.
- Brand: Step 8. Pass reasons to the voice of customer (VoC) document weekly and close actions on them.
- Step 9. Run answer quality control (a 5% sample of requests) and update training and templates.
Formulas
| Measure | Formulas | Note |
|---|---|---|
| SLA, % | SLA = Requests answered on time ÷ All requests × 100 | Count by working time and by channel; night hours enter the statistics only for 24/7 service. |
| FCR, % | FCR = Solved on first contact ÷ All requests × 100 | A repeat request on the same issue within 7 days cancels “solved”. |
| Cost per request | Cost = (Service payroll + Systems + Overhead) ÷ Number of requests | Count by type: a defect costs many times more than an order status. |
| Gesture versus examination | Gesture = Price × Discount %; Examination = Examination cost + Confirmation share × Price × (1 − Sellable share) | The comparison shows costs but does not cancel the customer right to an examination. |
Formulas in notation
- SLA
SLA = requests answered in time / all requests × 100
The time limit is set by internal rules (4 hours in the example).- FCR
FCR = solved at first contact / all requests × 100
Count by closed requests, not replies.- Cost per order
c_order = Requests × c / Orders
Requests per 100 orders multiplied by the cost per request.
Worked example
Exercise: monthly service load across five categories (conditional assumptions)
| Category | Orders | Requests per 100 orders | Requests | Of which size, % | Of which defects, % | FCR, % | Cost per request, RUB | Service cost, RUB | Cost per order, RUB |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Women | 20,000 | 9 | 1,800 | 38 | 6 | 71 | 95 | 171,000 | 8.6 |
| Men | 9,000 | 7 | 630 | 30 | 5 | 76 | 90 | 56,700 | 6.3 |
| Kids | 6,000 | 11 | 660 | 42 | 8 | 66 | 105 | 69,300 | 11.6 |
| Footwear | 7,000 | 13 | 910 | 52 | 10 | 62 | 120 | 109,200 | 15.6 |
| Accessories | 5,000 | 5 | 250 | 4 | 7 | 78 | 80 | 20,000 | 4 |
| Total | 47,000 | 9 | 4,250 | 38.4 | 7.1 | 69.4 | 100 | 426,200 | 9.1 |
In total 4250 requests on 47000 orders, cost RUB 426200, RUB 9.1 per order. Footwear gives 13 requests per 100 orders and the lowest FCR (62%) because of size and last: RUB 15.6 per order against RUB 4 for accessories, which have no sizes. Kids costs more than men on defect share and needs fast escalation. Cost per order must be compared with category margin, not with the company average. All figures are exercise assumptions.
Figures
Data as a table
| Measure | Cost per order |
|---|---|
| Women | 8.6 |
| Men | 6.3 |
| Kids | 11.6 |
| Footwear | 15.6 |
| Accessories | 4 |
Service cost per order by category. How much support costs per order: footwear and kids are more expensive because of size and defects, accessories cheaper.
- Size
- Defect
- Other
Data as a table
| Measure | Size | Defect | Other |
|---|---|---|---|
| Women | 684 | 108 | 1,008 |
| Men | 189 | 32 | 410 |
| Kids | 277 | 53 | 330 |
| Footwear | 473 | 91 | 346 |
| Accessories | 10 | 18 | 223 |
Request structure by category. Of the requests in a category the share of size and defects: for footwear size is more than half.
- FCR
- SLA
Data as a table
| Measure | FCR | SLA |
|---|---|---|
| Order status and delivery | 86.7 | 95 |
| Size and product choice | 75.2 | 90 |
| Return and exchange | 66.9 | 86 |
| Defect and claim | 40 | 69.5 |
| Payment and bonuses | 80 | 94.8 |
FCR and SLA by request topic. Resolved at first contact and in time: worst for defects and claims.
Specifics by category
- Apparel
- Main request reasons: size and fit, color, composition, shrinkage after washing. Part is solved on first contact from the garment measurement table and the care symbols on the label; a “shrank after washing” complaint is checked against the care conditions stated on the label. Claims about seams, stains and pattern matching need photos and inspection, and when the cause is disputed the examination is at the seller expense. Count requests per 100 orders separately for core and fashion: fashion has more size questions.
- Footwear
- The most loaded category: size and last (tight, loose, rubs), then defects in the sole, adhesive and hardware. Claims more often need inspection and examination, so FCR is lower and cost per request higher. The warranty wear period is set by the manufacturer; take the figures into the protocol from its documents, not from general guides. To cut size requests, give the insole length in mm and a conversion by the EU, UK, US, Mondopoint table. Do not confuse natural wear with a defect: an inspection criterion by components is needed.
- Accessories
- There are no sizes, so requests per order are the lowest; main reasons: hardware failure (zip, lock, buckle), color and scale “not as in the photo”, and size for belts and headwear. Jewelry in precious metals is a special group: fineness and hallmark are checked on intake, and the list of goods not subject to exchange and return is checked against the current sales rules (unverified, check the current edition). Gift returns after holidays produce a seasonal spike.
- Kids
- Requests are more emotional and concern safety (rash, odor, small parts, composition), so such cases are escalated quickly and the first-reply SLA is tighter. TR CU 007/2011 conformity documents are required; for children under one year the size range is limited to height up to 74 cm. Size is set by height (6 cm step), and “the child grew” is not a defect. Underwear and hosiery may be on the list of goods not subject to exchange; check the current list. Resolution time is longer in the school peak: reserve staff.
- Men
- Requests per order are fewer than for women (7 versus 9 in the example), and reasons concentrate on fit: sleeve length, shoulder, waist. Core repeat purchases are many, so a fast exchange for the same item in another size matters more than a loyalty gesture; discount gestures work weaker. The size curve is narrower, so a stock of the needed sizes for exchange must be kept, otherwise an exchange becomes a refund and a lost customer.
- Women
- More requests per order because of vanity sizing, color and the many silhouettes: the customer orders two or three sizes and returns the extras, so the exchange and return share is higher. The garment measurement table and photos on models of different sizes decide. A loyalty gesture (a coupon for the next purchase) is accepted more often than for men but does not replace a statutory demand. For fashion the load is planned by drop weeks, otherwise the SLA breaks on launch days.
Common mistakes
- The SLA target ignores staffing → SLA is red every day and the team stops looking at it → set achievable values and review them.
- FCR is counted from closed tickets without repeats → an inflated figure → cancel “solved” on a repeat within 7 days.
- A gesture instead of the customer right → a complaint to supervisors or court → record that both paths were offered and fix the choice.
- Reasons are not passed to buying and design → problems repeat each season → a weekly export to VoC and an owner for each action.
- The returns policy contradicts the law → a prohibition that cannot be applied → legal review and norm references in the text.
Russian specifics
- The consumer protection law (No. 2300-1): the right to return and exchange non-food goods of proper quality within the terms of Art. 25 and the right to refuse goods in distance selling under Art. 26.1; check exact terms and conditions against the current edition. Rule: Law 2300-1 of 07.02.1992: Law of 07.02.1992 No. 2300-1 on consumer rights protection.
- Demands on finding a defect (repair, replacement, refund), the terms of satisfaction and examination at the seller expense are governed by the articles of the consumer protection law on goods defects; exact terms are not fixed in the text: not checked against the full text. Rule: Law 2300-1 of 07.02.1992: Law of 07.02.1992 No. 2300-1 on consumer rights protection (rule check not completed).
- Retailer: The list of non-food goods of proper quality not subject to exchange and return (for example part of underwear and hosiery) is set by the rules of selling goods; Resolution No. 2463, per the register, is being replaced by a new resolution from 1 September 2026: check the current list. Rule: Decree 2463 of 31.12.2020: Government Decree of 31.12.2020 No. 2463 (former rules of sale of goods) (rule check not completed).
- Retailer: Receipt and electronic receipt on return: a refund is processed with a return receipt under the cash-register law. Rule: Law 54-FZ of 22.05.2003: Federal Law of 22.05.2003 No. 54-FZ on the use of cash registers.