Defects: losses, supplier recovery and a reserve
By category counts the defect rate, the loss at cost, the proceeds from selling defective items (second grade), the supplier’s recovery, the net loss and an estimate of a reserve for the next period. Shows where defects cost most.
At a glance
- What question does it answer?
- What defects cost, how much the supplier will return and what reserve to set aside.
- What data is needed?
- By category: sold, defective units, cost per unit, optionally proceeds per unit of second grade and the sales plan.
- How to read the result?
- On the example of 22,000 units sold and 440 defective units (2.0%) the loss at cost is 742,000; the second grade returns 172,000 and the supplier refunds 40% of the rest (228,000). The net loss is 342,000, that is 15.5 per unit sold. Most defects are in footwear (4.0%). The estimate of the reserve for the next period is 357,720; check the accounting treatment with an accountant. Example on the default values: Defect rate in units sold: 2%; Loss at cost: RUB 742,000; Proceeds from second grade: RUB 172,000; Supplier recovery: RUB 228,000. The figures are illustrative: enter your own to see your result.
Why and how to reason
Defects cost more than they seem: you pay for goods, cannot sell them at the normal price and spend time on returns. The calculation follows a chain so that nothing is lost. Loss at cost = defective units × unit cost: 80 × 3,200 + 180 × 900 + 120 × 2,500 + 60 × 400 = 742,000. Part is recovered by selling second grade (172,000). Residual loss 570,000. Then the supplier may reimburse part, here 40%: net loss = 570,000 × (1 − 0.4) = 342,000, or 15.55 per unit sold. Reserve for next period = sales plan × defect rate × (cost − second grade) × (1 − reimbursement) = 357,720. Total defect rate 440 of 22,000, 2%, but footwear is 4%: the category with the highest risk. The category figure matters more than the average.
When to use it
Use it at goods receipt, when talking to a supplier about reimbursement and when forming a reserve. It suits a brand and a retailer. It does not suit a case without defect records by category: the result is then nominal. Assumptions: supplier reimbursement is set as an average share; second grade sells at the stated price; the reserve is computed from the sales plan and the current period’s defect rate.
How to read the result
First the category with the highest defect rate: start the supplier conversation there. Then compare net loss with net sales: if above 1% defects cut margin materially. If supplier reimbursement is low, discuss raising it or a penalty for exceeding the tolerance (AQL). Build next period’s reserve into the price or the purchase margin. The decision: change the factory, tighten incoming inspection, agree reimbursement or drop the category. If supplier reimbursement is low, prepare for the next contract a table of actual losses by category: it is the best argument.
Common mistakes
Counting defects only from customer returns and missing what was rejected at receipt. Entering cost at selling price. Expecting the supplier to reimburse everything: in a contract reimbursement is usually limited by term and share. Another trap: sending all defects to second grade without checking that the buyer accepts such goods: returns will rise.
What data is needed?
- By category: sold, defective units, cost per unit, optionally proceeds per unit of second grade and the sales plan.
- The supplier recovery share; optionally the net sales of the period.
Inputs
| Field | Unit | Value in the example | Meaning |
|---|---|---|---|
| Supplier recovery | % | 40 | The share of the residual loss (cost minus second-grade proceeds) that the supplier refunds under the contract and claims. An example, not a standard. |
| Net sales of the period excl. VAT | ₽ | — | Optional: needed to show the loss as a share of sales. Amount excl. VAT: the general rate is 22% from 01.01.2026. The rate follows the shipment date; confirm your regime and rate with an accountant. |
How it is calculated
| Step | Formula |
|---|---|
| Loss at cost | defective units × cost per unit |
| Residual loss | loss at cost − second-grade proceeds |
| Net loss | residual loss × (1 − supplier recovery) |
| Reserve | planned sales × defect rate × (cost − second grade) × (1 − recovery) |
Worked numbers
Default values from the app; in the interactive version you enter your own.
- Defect rate in units sold
- 2 %Basis: units sold, not units inspected at receiving. Inspection defects (defective ÷ inspected) are in the “Sampling inspection and cost of defects” calculation; the figures differ, do not compare them.
- Loss at cost
- 742,000 ₽
- Proceeds from second grade
- 172,000 ₽
- Supplier recovery
- 228,000 ₽
- Net loss from defects
- 342,000 ₽
- Net loss per unit sold
- 15.55 ₽
- Net loss in net sales
- enter net sales
- Category with the highest defect rate
- 4 % · Footwear
- Reserve for defects next period (estimate)
- 357,720 ₽
By category
| Category | Defect rate | Loss at cost | Second grade | Recovery | Net loss | Reserve |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Outerwear | 2 % | 256,000 ₽ | 64,000 ₽ | 76,800 ₽ | 115,200 ₽ | 126,720 ₽ |
| Knitwear | 2 % | 162,000 ₽ | 36,000 ₽ | 50,400 ₽ | 75,600 ₽ | 79,800 ₽ |
| Footwear | 4 % | 300,000 ₽ | 72,000 ₽ | 91,200 ₽ | 136,800 ₽ | 136,800 ₽ |
| Accessories | 1 % | 24,000 ₽ | 0 ₽ | 9,600 ₽ | 14,400 ₽ | 14,400 ₽ |
The reserve is a management estimate: the past defect rate applied to the sales plan. Whether and how to create a reserve in the books is set by the accounting policy; check with an accountant.
There is no single standard for the defect rate in Russia: compare with your own past periods and across suppliers. Check the buyer’s rights on goods of inadequate quality with a lawyer.
Nuances and limits
- Taking the supplier recovery share for a guarantee: it depends on the contract and claims.
- Calculating a reserve without a sales plan: it depends on the volume of the next period.