Syntha Lab RU

Defects: losses, supplier recovery and a reserve

By category counts the defect rate, the loss at cost, the proceeds from selling defective items (second grade), the supplier’s recovery, the net loss and an estimate of a reserve for the next period. Shows where defects cost most.

Working with stock: transfers, top-up, defects, prices, order entry For whom: Quality and buying directors, finance and category managers.

Calculate on your data →

At a glance

What question does it answer?
What defects cost, how much the supplier will return and what reserve to set aside.
What data is needed?
By category: sold, defective units, cost per unit, optionally proceeds per unit of second grade and the sales plan.
How to read the result?
On the example of 22,000 units sold and 440 defective units (2.0%) the loss at cost is 742,000; the second grade returns 172,000 and the supplier refunds 40% of the rest (228,000). The net loss is 342,000, that is 15.5 per unit sold. Most defects are in footwear (4.0%). The estimate of the reserve for the next period is 357,720; check the accounting treatment with an accountant. Example on the default values: Defect rate in units sold: 2%; Loss at cost: RUB 742,000; Proceeds from second grade: RUB 172,000; Supplier recovery: RUB 228,000. The figures are illustrative: enter your own to see your result.

Why and how to reason

Defects cost more than they seem: you pay for goods, cannot sell them at the normal price and spend time on returns. The calculation follows a chain so that nothing is lost. Loss at cost = defective units × unit cost: 80 × 3,200 + 180 × 900 + 120 × 2,500 + 60 × 400 = 742,000. Part is recovered by selling second grade (172,000). Residual loss 570,000. Then the supplier may reimburse part, here 40%: net loss = 570,000 × (1 − 0.4) = 342,000, or 15.55 per unit sold. Reserve for next period = sales plan × defect rate × (cost − second grade) × (1 − reimbursement) = 357,720. Total defect rate 440 of 22,000, 2%, but footwear is 4%: the category with the highest risk. The category figure matters more than the average.

When to use it

Use it at goods receipt, when talking to a supplier about reimbursement and when forming a reserve. It suits a brand and a retailer. It does not suit a case without defect records by category: the result is then nominal. Assumptions: supplier reimbursement is set as an average share; second grade sells at the stated price; the reserve is computed from the sales plan and the current period’s defect rate.

How to read the result

First the category with the highest defect rate: start the supplier conversation there. Then compare net loss with net sales: if above 1% defects cut margin materially. If supplier reimbursement is low, discuss raising it or a penalty for exceeding the tolerance (AQL). Build next period’s reserve into the price or the purchase margin. The decision: change the factory, tighten incoming inspection, agree reimbursement or drop the category. If supplier reimbursement is low, prepare for the next contract a table of actual losses by category: it is the best argument.

Common mistakes

Counting defects only from customer returns and missing what was rejected at receipt. Entering cost at selling price. Expecting the supplier to reimburse everything: in a contract reimbursement is usually limited by term and share. Another trap: sending all defects to second grade without checking that the buyer accepts such goods: returns will rise.

What data is needed?

  • By category: sold, defective units, cost per unit, optionally proceeds per unit of second grade and the sales plan.
  • The supplier recovery share; optionally the net sales of the period.

Inputs

FieldUnitValue in the exampleMeaning
Supplier recovery%40The share of the residual loss (cost minus second-grade proceeds) that the supplier refunds under the contract and claims. An example, not a standard.
Net sales of the period excl. VAT₽—Optional: needed to show the loss as a share of sales. Amount excl. VAT: the general rate is 22% from 01.01.2026. The rate follows the shipment date; confirm your regime and rate with an accountant.

How it is calculated

StepFormula
Loss at costdefective units × cost per unit
Residual lossloss at cost − second-grade proceeds
Net lossresidual loss × (1 − supplier recovery)
Reserveplanned sales × defect rate × (cost − second grade) × (1 − recovery)

Worked numbers

Default values from the app; in the interactive version you enter your own.

Defect rate in units sold
2 %Basis: units sold, not units inspected at receiving. Inspection defects (defective ÷ inspected) are in the “Sampling inspection and cost of defects” calculation; the figures differ, do not compare them.
Loss at cost
742,000 ₽
Proceeds from second grade
172,000 ₽
Supplier recovery
228,000 ₽
Net loss from defects
342,000 ₽
Net loss per unit sold
15.55 ₽
Net loss in net sales
enter net sales
Category with the highest defect rate
4 % · Footwear
Reserve for defects next period (estimate)
357,720 ₽

By category

CategoryDefect rateLoss at costSecond gradeRecoveryNet lossReserve
Outerwear2 %256,000 ₽64,000 ₽76,800 ₽115,200 ₽126,720 ₽
Knitwear2 %162,000 ₽36,000 ₽50,400 ₽75,600 ₽79,800 ₽
Footwear4 %300,000 ₽72,000 ₽91,200 ₽136,800 ₽136,800 ₽
Accessories1 %24,000 ₽0 ₽9,600 ₽14,400 ₽14,400 ₽

The reserve is a management estimate: the past defect rate applied to the sales plan. Whether and how to create a reserve in the books is set by the accounting policy; check with an accountant.

There is no single standard for the defect rate in Russia: compare with your own past periods and across suppliers. Check the buyer’s rights on goods of inadequate quality with a lawyer.

Nuances and limits

  • Taking the supplier recovery share for a guarantee: it depends on the contract and claims.
  • Calculating a reserve without a sales plan: it depends on the volume of the next period.

Terms used

Calculate on your data →