Business insurance: cargo, property, liability, receivables, how to read a policy and when insurance pays off
What a brand and a retailer of apparel, footwear and accessories should insure: cargo in transit and imports, the property of a warehouse and stores, liability to customers and visitors, the receivables of wholesale customers, fraud risk and cyber risk. The document answers: which policy is worth its premium, how to read the sum insured, the deductible and the exclusions and what to do on an insured event in order to get paid.
Why this document
Insurance is bought in two ways: everything “just in case” or none at all. Both mistakes are expensive: the first eats profit in premiums for coverage that will not trigger because of deductibles and exclusions, the second leaves the business without protection against a rare but large loss. The finance director, the operations director and the owner read this document before renewing policies and when opening a new warehouse or store. It explains how to compare expected loss with the premium, read a policy and act on an insured event so that the payout does not turn into a dispute.
At a glance
- What is this document and why is it needed?
- What a brand and a retailer of apparel, footwear and accessories should insure: cargo in transit and imports, the property of a warehouse and stores, liability to customers and visitors, the receivables of wholesale customers, fraud risk and cyber risk. The document answers: which policy is worth its premium, how to read the sum insured, the deductible and the exclusions and what to do on an insured event in order to get paid.
- Who owns the document and how often is it rebuilt?
- The finance director and the operations director keep the register of risks and policies, a lawyer checks contracts and exclusions, an insurance broker helps with placement; revised annually and with major changes in the business; the owner sees the result.
- What mistakes are the most common?
- Insuring everything → premiums eat profit → insure the rare and large and keep the small in a reserve. Looking only at the premium → a low price with a large deductible and exclusions will not trigger → compare the sum, deductible, exclusions and territory. Understating the sum insured → the payout is reduced proportionally → value assets and revise annually.
For whom
- Brand
- Brand: the main risks are cargo from the factory and imports, the property of the warehouse and stock, liability for the quality and safety of products (especially kids’), the receivables of wholesale customers and chains; cargo insurance is chosen together with the delivery terms (Incoterms).
- Retail
- Retailer: the main risks are the property of stores (stock, equipment, fit-out), liability to visitors, theft and shortages, a business interruption after a fire or flooding, cyber risk and payment data; a chain needs a single register and a program for all points.
What it consists of
Map of risks and kinds of insurance
- Cargo: loss, damage and delay of goods in transit and imports; the cover depends on the route, the delivery terms (Incoterms) and packaging; it is insured for the cargo value plus expected profit if the terms allow.
- Property: a warehouse, stores, equipment, stock and fit-out against fire, flooding, natural disasters, an explosion, unlawful acts of third parties; look at the list of risks and exclusions.
- Liability: civil liability to customers and visitors, liability for product quality; for a kids line this is especially important.
- Receivables: insurance against the risk of non-payment by a wholesale buyer on bankruptcy or a long delay; it requires limits on buyers and checks of their solvency.
- Business interruption: compensation of lost profit and fixed costs over the recovery period after an insured event; suits a retailer and production.
- Directors’ liability (D&O), cyber risk and employee fraud: they cover specific losses; the decision depends on size and the business’s dependence on digital systems.
How to read a policy and when insurance pays off
- The sum insured and limits: the maximum payout per event and per period; if the sum is below the value of the property the payout is reduced proportionally; check how the value is determined.
- The deductible: the part of the loss you bear yourself; a conditional deductible removes small losses and an unconditional one is subtracted from any payout; a high deductible lowers the premium.
- Exclusions and conditions: what is not covered (intent, wear, a breach of storage conditions, absence of security or an alarm); exclusions are where refusals most often happen.
- Territory and term: where and when the cover applies; for imports and a route through several countries check the territory and the claim procedure.
- Expected loss and premium: the probability is multiplied by the expected payout allowing for the deductible and the limit and the result is compared with the premium; the insurance loading shows how much you overpay for removing the risk.
- Brand: insurance for cargo and wholesale receivables is needed more often than for petty theft; small losses are cheaper to bear yourself with a reserve and rare, large ones are what to insure.
- Retailer: property and business interruption matter more than theft: shortages are better controlled by procedures and a shortage reserve and a fire or flooding in a mall ruins the point for months.
The insured event, accounting and mistakes
- On an insured event: record the event, call the necessary services, keep evidence (photos, acts, delivery notes), file the claim on time and do not dispose of damaged property before inspection if the policy requires it.
- Accounting: the premium goes to expenses and the compensation is accounted for as income or a reduction of the loss under accounting rules; check tax consequences with an accountant (not checked).
- Insurance of pledged property: the bank requires insurance of the pledged property; make sure the sum insured and the beneficiary match the loan agreement.
- Brand: keep cargo documents (delivery notes, packing lists, loading photos): without them the insurer wins a dispute on the quantity and state of the cargo.
- Retailer: for theft and fraud in a store a police report, a stocktake act and video recordings are needed; run the procedure in the same way at all points.
Brand and retailer: what to insure differently
- Brand: cargo insurance is chosen together with logistics: consolidated cargo, a sea container and road haulage in the CIS are covered on different terms and deductibles.
- Brand: liability for quality and safety is especially important for a kids line; insure it together with certification and supplier control.
- Brand: wholesale receivables insurance works if buyers are checked and limits are agreed with the insurer; otherwise no payout for a large buyer can be obtained.
- Brand: for an own workshop add insurance of equipment against breakdown and production interruption that an ordinary property policy does not cover.
- Brand: keep evidence of the insured event by lot: lot numbers, photos, receiving acts at the carrier and at the consignee.
- Retailer: for stores a single program with equal terms and sums for each point is needed; a patchwork of policies makes accounting and claims unmanageable.
- Retailer: a business interruption after a fire or flooding is costlier than the property damage itself: count lost margin and fixed costs over the recovery period.
- Retailer: shop theft is built into the loss norm and controlled by procedures; insurance is needed for large thefts and employee fraud.
- Retailer: the online channel adds cyber risk and the risk of payment data; check the cover and the insurer’s requirements for system protection.
- Retailer: liability to visitors and the lessor is often mandatory under the lease; reconcile the sums in the contract and in the policy.
Where the data comes from
| Data source | Fields |
|---|---|
| Policies, insurance rules and addenda | sum insured, deductible, exclusions, territory, term |
| Loss and incident history for 3-5 years | number of events, amounts, causes, recovery time |
| Register of property, stock and cargo | value, location, security, routes |
| Terms of supply and lease contracts | Incoterms, responsibility for risk, insurance requirements |
How to build it step by step
- Step 1: Compile a register of risks with probability and severity on a five-point scale and mark those with high severity and low probability.
- Step 2: Divide risks into those better borne yourself (frequent and small), reduced by procedures and insured (rare and large).
- Step 3: Collect insurers’ offers on equal terms and compare the sum insured, deductible, exclusions and territory and not only the premium.
- Step 4: Compute the expected payout and the insurance loading (premium ÷ expected payout) for each policy.
- Step 5: Read the exclusions and conditions: security, alarm, storage, transport; meet them and fix them in procedures.
- Step 6: Align insurance with the contract terms (Incoterms, lease, credit) and with tax and accounting.
- Step 7: Describe the procedure on an insured event (who, what, by when) and train those responsible; keep a claim template.
- Step 8: Once a year revise the program: asset values, new warehouses and stores, loss history, market conditions.
Formulas
| Measure | Formulas | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Expected payout | Expected payout = Probability × min(Limit; max(0; Loss − Deductible)) | The probability is annual; compute from your history and with caution from the industry. |
| Insurance loading | Loading = Premium ÷ Expected payout | Above 1: you pay for removing the risk; the higher, the costlier the protection. |
| Risk priority | Priority = Probability × Severity (scores 1-5) | For sorting the register; does not replace a money calculation. |
| Residual loss | Residual = Loss − Payout | The deductible and the amount over the limit stay with you. |
Worked example
Five risks: premium and expected payout (probabilities, amounts and premiums are illustrative, roubles)
| Risk | Annual premium | Expected payout | Loading, × |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cargo in transit | 160,000 | 114,000 | 1.40 |
| Fire and flooding of a warehouse | 290,000 | 200,000 | 1.45 |
| Theft and fraud | 150,000 | 100,000 | 1.50 |
| Customer non-payment (receivables) | 210,000 | 162,000 | 1.30 |
| A product quality claim | 125,000 | 90,000 | 1.39 |
| Total for the five risks | 935,000 | 666,000 | 1.40 |
The inputs are illustrative: for example cargo with a probability of 4% a year, a loss of 3 m RUB, a deductible of 150 k RUB and a limit of 5 m RUB. A loading above one is normal: the premium includes the insurer’s costs and profit. A theft policy at a 20% probability insures almost small losses: it is cheaper to keep a reserve.
Figures
- 1 … 9 points
Data as a table
| Probability, score | Severity, score | Priority | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cargo in transit | 3 | 3 | 9 |
| Fire and flooding of a warehouse | 1 | 5 | 5 |
| Theft and fraud | 4 | 2 | 8 |
| Customer non-payment (receivables) | 2 | 4 | 8 |
| A product quality claim | 3 | 3 | 9 |
Risk map: probability, severity and priority. Priority is the product of scores; high severity at low probability (a warehouse fire, non-payment by a large customer) is usually what is insured.
- Premium
- Expected payout
Data as a table
| Measure | Premium | Expected payout |
|---|---|---|
| Cargo in transit | 160 | 114 |
| Fire and flooding of a warehouse | 290 | 200 |
| Theft and fraud | 150 | 100 |
| Customer non-payment (receivables) | 210 | 162 |
| A product quality claim | 125 | 90 |
Premium and expected payout by risk. Where the premium is far above the expected payout the insurance is expensive for removing the risk; for small and frequent losses a reserve is cheaper.
An insured event: the path to payout. The payout is most often lost at the second and third steps: the event was not recorded and the claim was not filed on time.
- Event → Recording and evidence
- Recording and evidence → Claim on time
- Claim on time → Inspection and expertise
- Inspection and expertise → Insurer’s decision
- Insurer’s decision → Payout and accounting
- Payout and accounting
Specifics by category
- Apparel
- Apparel: cargo is bulky and prone to wetting and spoilage in storage; insure cargo and the warehouse and keep storage conditions otherwise exclusions deprive you of payment.
- Footwear
- Footwear: boxes, higher stock value and the risk of wetting and deformation; for imports from Asia check the cover of sea cargo and transshipment conditions.
- Accessories
- Accessories: high value at small volume and a theft risk; a theft policy and security conditions matter more than a cargo policy by weight.
- Kids
- Kids: liability for product safety and compliance with regulations matters more than the rest; liability insurance and certificate control go together.
- Men
- Men: even turnover and fewer seasonal stock peaks; the load on property insurance is lower and the main risk is wholesale receivables and theft.
- Women
- Women: the widest range and peaks of stock, high returns; besides property and cargo an assessment of the risk of shortages and quality liability across many models is needed.
Common mistakes
- Insuring everything → premiums eat profit → insure the rare and large and keep the small in a reserve.
- Looking only at the premium → a low price with a large deductible and exclusions will not trigger → compare the sum, deductible, exclusions and territory.
- Understating the sum insured → the payout is reduced proportionally → value assets and revise annually.
- Not meeting policy conditions (security, alarm, storage) → a refusal under an exclusion → fix the conditions in procedures and check them.
- Not recording the event and filing the claim late → losing the payout → set an order and a claim template and train people.
Russian specifics
- Insurance is regulated by the Civil Code (chapter 48) and the law on the organization of insurance business of 27.11.1992 No. 4015-1; check mandatory kinds, tariffs and limits against the current acts (not checked).
- Brand: in imports the choice of Incoterms determines who insures the cargo and over which segment; fix in the supply contract who is the beneficiary and who files the claim.
- Retailer: mall lessors often require insurance of the lessee’s liability and property; check the minimum sums in the lease.
- Insurance of loans and receivables is related to contracts and bank requirements; for loans in other EAEU countries check local insurance rules.
- Consumer protection (law of 07.02.1992 No. 2300-1) sets the seller’s liability for the quality of goods; liability insurance does not cancel it but covers part of the financial consequences. Rule: Law 2300-1 of 07.02.1992: Law of 07.02.1992 No. 2300-1 on consumer rights protection.