Brand and retailer contracts: supply, commission, consignment, agency, dropshipping
The contract type decides who owns the goods, who carries the risk of unsold stock, when revenue is recognized and how VAT is calculated. It is used to choose the working model with a department store, marketplace or multi-brand store: supply, commission, consignment, agency or dropshipping, and to fix terms that are hard to change later.
Why this document
The same shelf price under different contracts gives the brand different money: under supply the unsold risk is the buyer’s, under commission and consignment it stays with the brand, and VAT and revenue recognition change. So the lawyer, the finance lead and the head of sales read the contract, and the commercial director decides the scheme before them. An error in contract type surfaces at the first reporting or audit. The scheme is therefore chosen before price negotiations, and payment, return and title terms are written separately.
At a glance
- What is this document and why is it needed?
- The contract type decides who owns the goods, who carries the risk of unsold stock, when revenue is recognized and how VAT is calculated. It is used to choose the working model with a department store, marketplace or multi-brand store: supply, commission, consignment, agency or dropshipping, and to fix terms that are hard to change later.
- Who owns the document and how often is it rebuilt?
- In-house lawyer and the commercial director of the brand or retailer; the template is reviewed yearly and before each season; signed by the CEO, the CFO approves payment and tax terms.
- What mistakes are the most common?
- Called the contract “consignment” without a Civil Code type → courts and tax inspectors look at substance: if ownership passes it is supply; taxes were wrong → state “commission” or “supply with return right”. No return term or procedure → end-of-season dispute over stock and penalties → return conditions and goods condition in an annex. Unilateral change of price or bonus without a contractual right → challenge (Civil Code Art. 424), and for platforms 289-FZ → include the right and notice period.
For whom
- Brand
- The brand chooses between selling (supply: ownership and risk pass) and intermediation (commission, agency, consignment: goods and the unsold risk stay with the brand). It matters when cash arrives, who pays for returns and markdowns, and whether the retail price can be controlled (limits: competition law, 135-FZ).
- Retail
- On a buyout the retailer owns the stock, pays for it and marks it down itself; on commission it invests no cash in stock, earns a fee and shows only the fee as revenue. The choice drives turnover, working capital and space metrics.
What it consists of
Contract types and risk allocation
- Supply (Civil Code chapter 30, part 2): goods are sold to the retailer, ownership and risk pass on shipment or acceptance; brand revenue on the shipment date; the retailer carries the unsold stock unless a return clause exists.
- Brand: Supply with return right (buy-back, stock balancing): legally a sale, but the brand agrees to take back a share of unsold goods; revenue and a returns provision follow the expected return.
- Commission (Civil Code ch. 51): the commission agent sells in its own name for the principal; the goods stay with the principal, whose revenue falls on the date of sale to the buyer, while the agent’s revenue equals its fee. Consignment in Russia is usually papered as commission or supply with return (there is no separate contract type).
- Brand: Agency (Civil Code ch. 52): the agent acts in the principal’s name (the buyer contracts with the brand) or in its own name; in retail the difference is that the sale is under the brand’s own contract with the customer.
- Retailer: Dropshipping: the retailer sells without stock, the brand or a warehouse ships to the customer directly; legally either supply after sale or agency; the key points are who is the seller towards the consumer and who handles returns and marking.
Contract section template
- Subject and assortment (season schedules, SKUs, size run); price and how it may change (Civil Code Art. 424: unilateral price change only under the contract or law).
- Delivery terms: ship window and cancel date, quantity tolerance (±%), place and terms of transfer, risk of accidental loss.
- Payment: prepayment, deferral (payment terms), set-off, penalties (Civil Code Art. 330); for commission: deadlines for the agent’s report and for remitting proceeds.
- Quality, acceptance, claims (deadlines, act), returns and defects, liability, marking, certificates, IP (trademark), confidentiality, termination, jurisdiction.
What each side decides when choosing the contract
- Brand: chooses between a sale and an intermediary model: with supply the money arrives earlier and the unsold risk moves to the retailer, with commission and consignment the brand keeps stock and risk until the buyer purchases; it fixes in advance whether it accepts returns and how a price cut is shared.
- Retailer: on a buyout pays for stock and cuts prices itself; on commission does not tie up cash in stock and shows only the fee as revenue; checks that the contract does not shift risks onto it that it cannot control (marking, certificates, batch quality).
Brand and retailer: what differs in practice
- Brand: on buyout receives money after the deferral and closes the unsold risk, so the wholesale price is lower and the cost of deferral is built into it.
- Brand: under commission stays owner of the goods: recognizes revenue on the basis of the agent report, and leftover and damage before sale are on the brand.
- Brand: asks the contract for return and exchange terms, condition of goods and the credit-note procedure, otherwise the dispute goes into claims work.
- Retailer: on buyout pays for stock and cuts prices itself, so it asks for return of leftovers or markdown support, and the brand builds this into its price.
- Retailer: under commission does not tie up cash in stock but works for a fee: watches the fee share and the term of transferring proceeds.
- Retailer: under commission is responsible for safekeeping and records of the brand goods in the warehouse and store: storage, stock-count and insurance terms separately.
- Retailer: platform and chain standard contracts are reviewed by a lawyer: one-sided conditions and penalty rights are visible to the brand in advance.
How to read the result and what decisions follow
- Compare not only result but cash and risk: on buyout the brand has cash earlier, under commission result per unit is higher but leftover and payment term are on the brand.
- If the break-even fee is above the offered one, commission beats supply; if below, accept commission only with a leftover limit and a return term.
- Decision: the chosen model for the season, the rate, the retailer leftover limit, the settlement term and the return procedure go into the contract annex.
Control checks
- The commission agent fee equals the rate times the sale price excl. VAT, and brand revenue equals the sale price minus this fee.
- The brand stock with the agent in the report equals shipped minus sold minus returned; differences are reconciled by document numbers.
- The VAT amount in documents equals the rate applied to the base and matches between the brand sales ledger and the retailer purchase ledger.
Checklist before signing a contract (unverified: a reference, not legal advice)
- Is the contract type named under the Civil Code and does the content match: transfer of title, risk, report, return?
- Are the price and how it can change, bonuses and penalties with a cap, payment term and claim term written down?
- Is it defined who is responsible for certificates, marking of leftovers and defective returns, and which documents confirm transfer?
- Is there a dispute procedure, jurisdiction and a right to terminate on delay and change of control?
Where the data comes from
| Data source | Fields |
|---|---|
| Contract and schedules in the document system | type, parties, dates, price, deferral, fee rate, return limits, penalties |
| Data template “Supplier terms” | deferral, minimum order, bonuses, returns, ship window |
| Accounting system: shipments, stock, agent reports | shipment fact, date of sale to the buyer, stock at the partner |
How to build it step by step
- Step 1: Decide who is the seller to the end customer and who owns the goods until sale; this fixes the contract type.
- Step 2: Compute the economics of each model on one lot (see the example): revenue, margin, tied-up cash, unsold risk.
- Step 3: Fix the revenue and VAT recognition moment per model and agree it with the accountant (document revrec).
- Brand: Step 4: Write down returns: term, share, condition, who pays logistics, how documents are corrected (document returns-acc).
- Step 5: Agree commercial terms in a separate annex (document commterms): deferral, bonuses, penalties.
- Retailer: Step 6: Add duties on marking, certificates and electronic document exchange.
- Brand: Step 7: Check admissibility (Civil Code Arts. 424, 330, 333; resale price limits under 135-FZ) and balance between the parties, keep a protocol of disagreements.
- Step 8: Load terms into the accounting system and a calendar (cancel dates, payments, reports); reconcile actuals to the contract each season.
- Brand: Step 9: Prepare a standard form for each model (supply, supply with returns, commission) and a table of what may be changed for a customer without the lawyer.
- Retailer: Step 10: Before signing check payment terms, return rights and penalties against turnover and working-capital limits; put disputed clauses into a protocol of disagreements.
Formulas
| Measure | Formulas | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Brand: Brand revenue on supply | Revenue = Shipped × Wholesale_net − Returned × Wholesale_net | Recognized on shipment; with a return right, estimate the expected return. |
| Brand: Revenue and result on commission | Principal revenue = Sold × Retail_net; Fee = Rate × Sale price; Cash to brand = Sale price incl. VAT − Fee incl. VAT | The agent’s revenue is the fee, not the full price (document revrec). |
| Break-even fee rate | Break-even fee = 1 − Wholesale_net / Retail_net | Above this rate the brand is better off supplying; below it, commission, if return risk and cost of money are acceptable. |
Formulas in notation
- Brand result on buyout
R_b = Q × (W − C)
Q units shipped, W wholesale price excl. VAT, C unit cost. Example: 1,000 × (2,050 − 1,500) = RUB 550,000.- Brand result on commission
R_b = Q_s × (P / (1 + r)) × (1 − k) − Q_s × C
Q_s units sold, P retail price incl. VAT, r VAT rate, k fee rate, C cost. Example: RUB 958,197.- Retailer tied-up stock on buyout
Z = (Q − Q_s) × W
Q purchased, Q_s sold. This is retailer cash in unsold goods; under commission it stays with the brand. Example: RUB 615,000.
Worked example
One lot of 1000 pcs, retail RUB 5,000 incl. 22% VAT, wholesale RUB 2,050 excl. VAT, 70% sold, commission 30% of the sale price
| Model | Brand revenue (excl. VAT) | Retailer revenue | Retailer gross profit | Unsold stock: whose |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Supply, no return | 2,050,000 | 2,868,852 | 1,433,852 | retailer: 300 pcs |
| Supply with full return of unsold | 1,435,000 | 2,868,852 | 1,433,852 | brand: 300 pcs |
| Commission / agency | 2,008,197 (sale price 2,868,852 less fee 860,656) | 860,656 | 860,656 | brand: 300 pcs |
| Dropshipping (ship after sale) | 1,435,000 | 2,868,852 | 1,433,852 | brand: all stock before sale |
Break-even commission versus supply with return: 50.0%. At a 30% fee the brand gets RUB 2,008,197 against RUB 1,435,000 under supply with return, but ships with no cash movement and bears the dead stock. Illustrative figures.
Figures
Flows of goods, money and documents under four contracts. Rows: buyout, commission, consignment, agent. Each arrow is labeled with what moves along it: goods, money or a document.
- Brand: sells and ships → Retailer: owns the goods
- Retailer: owns the goods → Customer
- Customer
- Brand: owns until sale → Commission agent
- Commission agent → Customer; Brand: owns until sale
- Customer
- Brand: owns until sale → Consignee
- Consignee → Customer; Brand: owns until sale
- Customer
- Principal → Agent
- Agent → Customer; Principal
- Customer
- Brand
- Retailer
Data as a table
| Measure | Brand | Retailer |
|---|---|---|
| Buyout, all purchased | 550k | 819k |
| Commission 30% | 958k | 861k |
| Consignment | 385k | 1.43m |
Result of the parties when 70% of the lot sells: buyout, commission, consignment. Result on sold units excl. VAT: for the brand the gap to the cost of what sold, for the retailer sale price less purchase price or the fee. Leftover stock is not valued: it sits with the retailer on buyout and with the brand under commission and consignment. Buyout: the brand receives RUB 550,000 at once, but the retailer still holds 300 pcs at RUB 2,050 (RUB 615,000 of tied-up stock). Illustrative figures.
- positive
- negative
- total
Data as a table
| Step | Change | Level |
|---|---|---|
| Sale price excl. VAT | — | 2.87m |
| Commission agent fee | −861k | 2.01m |
| Cost of sold units | −1.05m | 958k |
| Brand result | — | 958k |
How the brand result builds under commission. From the sale price excl. VAT we subtract the commission agent fee and the cost of the units sold.
Specifics by category
- Apparel
- Apparel: seasonality and size runs make unsold risk the main factor; commission and returns are more common for seasonal collections, supply for basics.
- Footwear
- Footwear: deeper size grid and more size-driven returns; the contract fixes how odd pairs and worn shoes are returned.
- Accessories
- Accessories: small size and longer collection life make buyouts simpler; expensive leather goods and jewelry more often go on commission.
- Kids
- Kids: fast assortment change by age and season and strict certification (TR CU 007/2011); the certificate belongs in the contract as an acceptance condition.
- Men
- Men: stable demand and basics, a higher share of buyouts and lower returns.
- Women
- Women: fashion content and size spread raise risk; pre-orders, commission and end-of-season returns are more common.
Common mistakes
- Called the contract “consignment” without a Civil Code type → courts and tax inspectors look at substance: if ownership passes it is supply; taxes were wrong → state “commission” or “supply with return right”.
- No return term or procedure → end-of-season dispute over stock and penalties → return conditions and goods condition in an annex.
- Unilateral change of price or bonus without a contractual right → challenge (Civil Code Art. 424), and for platforms 289-FZ → include the right and notice period.
- Nobody agreed who marks the stock → fines and sale blocks → assign liability and deadlines to each party.
Russian specifics
- Contract types (supply, commission, agency, franchising) are in Civil Code part 2; price and penalty rules in part 1. Rule: Civil Code part 2: Civil Code, part two (including Arts. 513, 713, 990, 1027).
- Price and its change, penalties: Civil Code Arts. 424, 330. Rule: Civil Code part 1: Civil Code, part one (including Arts. 330, 424).
- Platforms: lowering a partner’s price at its expense only under the contract and with consent, notice at least five working days (Art. 9 of 289-FZ), in force from 01.10.2026. Rule: Law 289-FZ of 31.07.2025: Federal Law of 31.07.2025 No. 289-FZ on the platform economy.
- Setting a minimum retail resale price is restricted by competition law; a recommended price is allowed. Rule: Law 135-FZ of 26.07.2006: Federal Law of 26.07.2006 No. 135-FZ on protection of competition (rule check not completed).
- There is no separate “consignment” contract type in the Civil Code (general practice; not checked against the code text).