Syntha Lab RU

Commercial terms: payment terms, retro bonuses, MDF and listing fees, SLA penalties, chargebacks

The contract annex where the list price becomes the real one: how much the brand receives from each rouble of shipment after payment delay, retro bonuses, marketing and listing payments, penalties and chargebacks. It is used to decide whether to enter a chain and what discount and terms can be offered.

Contracts, tax, accounting Brand and retail Verified: 2026-11-14

Open interactively →

Why this document

A chain rarely asks for a price cut directly; it asks for a volume bonus, a listing fee, a payment delay and delivery penalties, and every line reduces margin. So the head of sales, the finance lead and the brand’s lawyer read the annex: the first negotiates, the second calculates what remains after all lines, the third checks the grounds for deductions. Without conversion to net revenue a discount looks small while the real revenue per rouble shipped drops below cost. Terms are therefore calculated for the whole year together, before signing.

At a glance

What is this document and why is it needed?
The contract annex where the list price becomes the real one: how much the brand receives from each rouble of shipment after payment delay, retro bonuses, marketing and listing payments, penalties and chargebacks. It is used to decide whether to enter a chain and what discount and terms can be offered.
Who owns the document and how often is it rebuilt?
Commercial and finance directors; effective price per customer quarterly, terms renegotiated yearly before the season.
What mistakes are the most common?
Customers compared on list price → the one that looks best on list is cheapest on effective price → compute realization from the table. A bonus papered as a service with no act → audit risk and a VAT deduction dispute → write “discount” or document the service. An uncapped penalty → deduction larger than the lot → a percentage cap on the order.

For whom

Brand
The brand computes the net price per customer: list price less retro bonus, marketing payments, short-shipment and OTIF penalties, returns and receivables financing. Customers and channels are compared on the effective price, not the list price.
Retail
The retailer computes the entry cost: purchase price less bonuses and compensation, shown as supplier income; it checks that bonuses do not inflate margin and follow accounting rules (cost adjustment or service revenue).

What it consists of

What makes up the effective price

  • Base discount and price level (wholesale price, % of RRP excl. VAT): formulas and ranges live in the platform calculations.
  • Brand: Retro bonus (rebate): a % of turnover for the period if the plan is met; under the contract it is either a price discount (adjustment) or a fee for a service.
  • Retailer: Marketing payment (MDF) and listing fee: payment for catalog entry, shelf space, advertising; it is paid for a service and must be evidenced by a service report.
  • Brand: SLA penalties: OTIF, shipping time, marking and e-document errors; computed on order value, usually capped; chargeback: an amount deducted from payment (defects, mis-sorts, returns, lateness).
  • Brand: Cost of deferral: amount × rate × days / 365; rate = your cost of borrowing (an input, not a constant).

How to paper the terms: discount, service, penalty

  • Brand: writes the retro bonus as a price discount in the annex and in adjustment documents, not as a “service without an act”; builds the payout probability into the calculation from the customer’s plan history.
  • Retailer: books the supplier bonus either as a reduction of purchase cost or as service income depending on how it is named and evidenced; matches acts against real delivery of the service (shelf photos, advertising reports).
  • Brand: caps penalties at a percentage of the order and sets a claim period; disputes deductions without documents (discrepancy act, ASN).
  • Retailer: issues OTIF penalties and chargebacks only under the contract rules and within the claim period; does not withhold an amount that is not in the contract.

Control checks

  • The sum of all terms as a percentage of shipment is compared with the customer margin: if deductions and cost of money eat more than a third of gross margin, the customer is unprofitable and the terms are revisited.
  • Reconcile with receivables: actual days to pay above the contractual ones lengthen the deferral, and the cost of money is computed on actuals, not on the contract.

Typical questions for a customer contract

  • What is the effective realization as a percentage of shipment for the customer in the last season, and is it three or more points below target?
  • Which deductions were disputed and how much came back: if the recovered share is below a third, the dispute process needs strengthening.
  • Does the contract have a penalty cap, a claim period and a set-off procedure, and is the bonus written as a discount or as a service?

Brand and retailer: what differs in practice

  • Brand: sums bonuses, contributions, fines and deferral into one effective realization per customer and compares it with the target for the channel.
  • Brand: disputes deductions within the claim term: without an objection under the contract a deduction becomes a brand cost.
  • Brand: words bonuses as a price discount or a service because VAT and corporate income tax depend on it.
  • Retailer: counts commercial terms as the purchase price after all bonuses (net-net), not the list: category margin depends on it.
  • Retailer: introduces and controls on-time-in-full fines so that deliveries hit the receiving window.
  • Retailer: asks for deferral and a marketing contribution in exchange for volume and shelf space, and counts deferral as a loan from the brand.

How to read the result and what decisions follow

  • Effective realization below target by three or more points means the customer is unprofitable on terms: revisit the bonus, deferral or price.
  • The largest item shows where to negotiate: if it is deferral, trade it for part prepayment or an early-payment discount.
  • Customer decision: extend terms, change the bonus scale, cap deferral or reduce volume; the decision is recorded with a review date.

Checklist before signing customer terms (unverified: a reference, not legal advice)

  • Bonuses are tied to a measurable base: it is defined whether the base is with VAT, after returns and for which goods.
  • Penalties have a cap as a percentage of delivery, a claim term and a dispute procedure; set-off without an act is not allowed.
  • The payment term counts from a clear date (acceptance or shipment) and carries interest for delay.
  • Unilateral changes are prohibited or limited by notice, and for platforms the platform-economy law norms are checked (unverified against the text).

Where the data comes from

Data sourceFields
Contract and customer annexesbonus and penalty rates, plans, caps, deadlines
Retailer reports (OTIF, returns, acts)% on time in full, deduction amounts
Receivables by dateactual days to pay, overdue

How to build it step by step

  1. Step 1: List all customer terms in a table: term, base, rate, cap, deadline.
  2. Step 2: Classify each term: discount (reduces price), service (separate document), penalty or deduction.
  3. Step 3: Estimate payout probability (is the plan achievable?) and multiply by the amount.
  4. Brand: Step 4: Compute the cost of deferral and receivables.
  5. Step 5: Assemble the effective price and compare it with target margin and channels.
  6. Retailer: Step 6: Check wording: bonus as a discount, services evidenced by acts, penalties capped.
  7. Brand: Step 7: Keep a log of deductions and dispute unfounded ones within the claim period.
  8. Brand: Step 8: Put customer terms into one “realization, %” table and revisit the most expensive ones before the season starts.
  9. Retailer: Step 9: Keep a separate supplier-income register per supplier and check that the bonus does not inflate the gross margin of the product group.

Formulas

MeasureFormulasNote
Effective priceEffective = Shipment − Retro − MDF − Listing − Penalties − Chargebacks − Shipment × Rate × Days / 365Divide by shipment to get the realization %.
OTIF penaltyPenalty = Shipment × Rate_per_point × (Plan − Actual) if Actual < PlanRate and cap come from the contract; the formula is contractual.
Cost of deferral as a percentage of shipmentDeferral, % = Rate × Days / 365In the example 18% × 60 / 365 ≈ 3% of shipment; if the customer pays late use actual days.
Annualized cost of an early-payment discountCost = d / (1 − d) × 365 / (N − n); d is the discount, n the days to earn it, N the credit termTerms “2/10 net 30”: 0.02 / 0.98 × 365 / 20 ≈ 37% p.a.; compare with your cost of money (the earlypay calculation).

Formulas in notation

Cost of deferral
D = S × i × t / 365
S shipment, i annual money rate, t deferral days. Example: RUB 295,890, 3.0% of the shipment.
On-time-in-full fine
F = (OTIF_plan − OTIF_fact) × q × S
Gap in points, rate q per point, base S. Example: 5 points × 0.5% = RUB 250,000.
Effective realization
E = 1 − (B + M + L + F + C + D) / S
Bonus, marketing, listing fee, fine, deductions and deferral relative to shipment. Example: 87.0%.
Annual cost of an early-payment discount
Y = d / (1 − d) × 365 / (T − t)
d discount, T normal term, t discount term. For 2/10 net 30: 0.02 / 0.98 × 365 / 20 ≈ 37.2% per year.

Worked example

Shipment of RUB 10 million excl. VAT, 60-day deferral, 18% p.a. (example)

ItemAmount, RUB% of shipment
Retro bonus 3%300,0003.0%
Marketing payment 1.5%150,0001.5%
Listing fee200,0002.0%
OTIF penalty: 5 points × 0.5%250,0002.5%
Chargeback on returns 1%100,0001.0%
Cost of deferral295,8903.0%
Total deductions and costs1,295,89013.0%
Effective realization8,704,11087.0%

Rates are illustrative; take real terms from the contract. The effective price is about 13% below list, so customer discounts are judged against it.

Figures

From list price to the real brand revenue under customer terms
Waterfall: Shipment at list 10m, Volume retro-bonus −300k, Marketing contribution −150k, Listing fee −200k, OTIF fine −250k, Deductions −100k, Cost of deferral −296k, Real revenue 8.7m02m4m6m8m10mShipment at listShipment at listShipment at list: 10m10mVolume retro-bonusVolume retro-bonusVolume retro-bonus: −300k−300kMarketing contributionMarketingcontributionMarketing contribution: −150k−150kListing feeListing feeListing fee: −200k−200kOTIF fineOTIF fineOTIF fine: −250k−250kDeductionsDeductionsDeductions: −100k−100kCost of deferralCost of deferralCost of deferral: −296k−296kReal revenueReal revenueReal revenue: 8.7m8.7mRUB
  • positive
  • negative
  • total
Data as a table
StepChangeLevel
Shipment at list—10m
Volume retro-bonus−300k9.7m
Marketing contribution−150k9.55m
Listing fee−200k9.35m
OTIF fine−250k9.1m
Deductions−100k9m
Cost of deferral−296k8.7m
Real revenue—8.7m

From list price to the real brand revenue under customer terms. Each contract term shifts real revenue: volume bonus, marketing contribution, listing fee, on-time-in-full fine, deductions and the cost of deferral. The terms take 13.0% of the shipment. Rates and volumes are illustrative.

The cost of payment deferral grows linearly with the term
Line chart: Cost of deferral, % of shipment: 0 → 5.920123456020406080100120example term: 60 daysCost of deferral, % of shipment, 0: 0Cost of deferral, % of shipment, 15: 0.74Cost of deferral, % of shipment, 30: 1.48Cost of deferral, % of shipment, 45: 2.22Cost of deferral, % of shipment, 60: 2.96Cost of deferral, % of shipment, 75: 3.7Cost of deferral, % of shipment, 90: 4.44Cost of deferral, % of shipment, 120: 5.92%
Data as a table
MeasureCost of deferral, % of shipment
00
150.74
301.48
452.22
602.96
753.7
904.44
1205.92

The cost of payment deferral grows linearly with the term. Share of shipment eaten by deferral at a money rate of 18% per year; the marker shows the term from the example.

What the customer terms consist of, % of shipment
Bar chart: Retro-bonus 3, Marketing 1.5, Listing fee 2, OTIF 2.5, Deductions 1, Deferral 30123Retro-bonusRetro-bonus% of shipment: 33MarketingMarketing% of shipment: 1.51.5Listing feeListing fee% of shipment: 22OTIFOTIF% of shipment: 2.52.5DeductionsDeductions% of shipment: 11DeferralDeferral% of shipment: 33%
Data as a table
Measure% of shipment
Retro-bonus3
Marketing1.5
Listing fee2
OTIF2.5
Deductions1
Deferral3

What the customer terms consist of, % of shipment. The largest item is often not a bonus but the deferral: it is invisible in the contract as a payment.

Specifics by category

Apparel
Apparel: bonuses are often tied to the season plan and sell-through; delivery penalties matter because of the season window.
Footwear
Footwear: more returns and chargebacks for size and defects; build it into the effective price.
Accessories
Accessories: low average ticket and a high listing fee per unit; compute listing fee per piece.
Kids
Kids: more document requirements (certificate, marking), so document penalties weigh more.
Men
Men: basics and repeat orders; an annual-turnover bonus works better than seasonal plans.
Women
Women: fast collections; delivery penalties and order cancellation rights matter more than the discount.

Common mistakes

  • Customers compared on list price → the one that looks best on list is cheapest on effective price → compute realization from the table.
  • A bonus papered as a service with no act → audit risk and a VAT deduction dispute → write “discount” or document the service.
  • An uncapped penalty → deduction larger than the lot → a percentage cap on the order.
  • Cost of deferral ignored → in the example it is RUB 296 thousand, that is 3% of the shipment (10 million × 18% × 60 / 365), and margin is overstated by exactly those three points → compute it with the formula and your own rate.
  • A bonus written both as a discount and as a service → double counting or a VAT dispute → choose one kind and evidence it.
  • Terms computed on shipment excl. VAT while deductions are on the amount incl. VAT → percentage mismatch → bring all bases to one.

Russian specifics

  • For platforms: changing terms and lowering a partner’s price at its expense is governed by 289-FZ from 01.10.2026. Rule: Law 289-FZ of 31.07.2025: Federal Law of 31.07.2025 No. 289-FZ on the platform economy.
  • Penalty: Civil Code Art. 330; a court may reduce a clearly disproportionate one (Art. 333, text not checked). Rule: Civil Code part 1: Civil Code, part one (including Arts. 330, 424) (rule check not completed).
  • The trade-regulation law caps bonuses to retail chains for food products; it does not apply to clothing (not checked against the law text).
  • Volume bonuses and discounts: the VAT base effect depends on the form (price discount or bonus): Tax Code Art. 154 para. 2.1; check with the accountant.
  • Bonuses and service fees: the recipient of the service may deduct VAT with an invoice and an act (Tax Code Arts. 171–172, not checked against the text); a bonus called a discount is papered by an adjustment, not an act. Rule: Tax Code Art. 171: Tax Code, Art. 171 (VAT deductions) (rule check not completed).
  • The penalty rate in a supply contract is agreed by the parties, but a court may cut a clearly disproportionate one; a cap as a percentage of the order is therefore safer than a fixed sum per point. Rule: Civil Code part 1: Civil Code, part one (including Arts. 330, 424) (rule check not completed).

Open interactively →