Commercial terms: payment terms, retro bonuses, MDF and listing fees, SLA penalties, chargebacks
The contract annex where the list price becomes the real one: how much the brand receives from each rouble of shipment after payment delay, retro bonuses, marketing and listing payments, penalties and chargebacks. It is used to decide whether to enter a chain and what discount and terms can be offered.
Why this document
A chain rarely asks for a price cut directly; it asks for a volume bonus, a listing fee, a payment delay and delivery penalties, and every line reduces margin. So the head of sales, the finance lead and the brand’s lawyer read the annex: the first negotiates, the second calculates what remains after all lines, the third checks the grounds for deductions. Without conversion to net revenue a discount looks small while the real revenue per rouble shipped drops below cost. Terms are therefore calculated for the whole year together, before signing.
At a glance
- What is this document and why is it needed?
- The contract annex where the list price becomes the real one: how much the brand receives from each rouble of shipment after payment delay, retro bonuses, marketing and listing payments, penalties and chargebacks. It is used to decide whether to enter a chain and what discount and terms can be offered.
- Who owns the document and how often is it rebuilt?
- Commercial and finance directors; effective price per customer quarterly, terms renegotiated yearly before the season.
- What mistakes are the most common?
- Customers compared on list price → the one that looks best on list is cheapest on effective price → compute realization from the table. A bonus papered as a service with no act → audit risk and a VAT deduction dispute → write “discount” or document the service. An uncapped penalty → deduction larger than the lot → a percentage cap on the order.
For whom
- Brand
- The brand computes the net price per customer: list price less retro bonus, marketing payments, short-shipment and OTIF penalties, returns and receivables financing. Customers and channels are compared on the effective price, not the list price.
- Retail
- The retailer computes the entry cost: purchase price less bonuses and compensation, shown as supplier income; it checks that bonuses do not inflate margin and follow accounting rules (cost adjustment or service revenue).
What it consists of
What makes up the effective price
- Base discount and price level (wholesale price, % of RRP excl. VAT): formulas and ranges live in the platform calculations.
- Brand: Retro bonus (rebate): a % of turnover for the period if the plan is met; under the contract it is either a price discount (adjustment) or a fee for a service.
- Retailer: Marketing payment (MDF) and listing fee: payment for catalog entry, shelf space, advertising; it is paid for a service and must be evidenced by a service report.
- Brand: SLA penalties: OTIF, shipping time, marking and e-document errors; computed on order value, usually capped; chargeback: an amount deducted from payment (defects, mis-sorts, returns, lateness).
- Brand: Cost of deferral: amount × rate × days / 365; rate = your cost of borrowing (an input, not a constant).
How to paper the terms: discount, service, penalty
- Brand: writes the retro bonus as a price discount in the annex and in adjustment documents, not as a “service without an act”; builds the payout probability into the calculation from the customer’s plan history.
- Retailer: books the supplier bonus either as a reduction of purchase cost or as service income depending on how it is named and evidenced; matches acts against real delivery of the service (shelf photos, advertising reports).
- Brand: caps penalties at a percentage of the order and sets a claim period; disputes deductions without documents (discrepancy act, ASN).
- Retailer: issues OTIF penalties and chargebacks only under the contract rules and within the claim period; does not withhold an amount that is not in the contract.
Control checks
- The sum of all terms as a percentage of shipment is compared with the customer margin: if deductions and cost of money eat more than a third of gross margin, the customer is unprofitable and the terms are revisited.
- Reconcile with receivables: actual days to pay above the contractual ones lengthen the deferral, and the cost of money is computed on actuals, not on the contract.
Typical questions for a customer contract
- What is the effective realization as a percentage of shipment for the customer in the last season, and is it three or more points below target?
- Which deductions were disputed and how much came back: if the recovered share is below a third, the dispute process needs strengthening.
- Does the contract have a penalty cap, a claim period and a set-off procedure, and is the bonus written as a discount or as a service?
Brand and retailer: what differs in practice
- Brand: sums bonuses, contributions, fines and deferral into one effective realization per customer and compares it with the target for the channel.
- Brand: disputes deductions within the claim term: without an objection under the contract a deduction becomes a brand cost.
- Brand: words bonuses as a price discount or a service because VAT and corporate income tax depend on it.
- Retailer: counts commercial terms as the purchase price after all bonuses (net-net), not the list: category margin depends on it.
- Retailer: introduces and controls on-time-in-full fines so that deliveries hit the receiving window.
- Retailer: asks for deferral and a marketing contribution in exchange for volume and shelf space, and counts deferral as a loan from the brand.
How to read the result and what decisions follow
- Effective realization below target by three or more points means the customer is unprofitable on terms: revisit the bonus, deferral or price.
- The largest item shows where to negotiate: if it is deferral, trade it for part prepayment or an early-payment discount.
- Customer decision: extend terms, change the bonus scale, cap deferral or reduce volume; the decision is recorded with a review date.
Checklist before signing customer terms (unverified: a reference, not legal advice)
- Bonuses are tied to a measurable base: it is defined whether the base is with VAT, after returns and for which goods.
- Penalties have a cap as a percentage of delivery, a claim term and a dispute procedure; set-off without an act is not allowed.
- The payment term counts from a clear date (acceptance or shipment) and carries interest for delay.
- Unilateral changes are prohibited or limited by notice, and for platforms the platform-economy law norms are checked (unverified against the text).
Where the data comes from
| Data source | Fields |
|---|---|
| Contract and customer annexes | bonus and penalty rates, plans, caps, deadlines |
| Retailer reports (OTIF, returns, acts) | % on time in full, deduction amounts |
| Receivables by date | actual days to pay, overdue |
How to build it step by step
- Step 1: List all customer terms in a table: term, base, rate, cap, deadline.
- Step 2: Classify each term: discount (reduces price), service (separate document), penalty or deduction.
- Step 3: Estimate payout probability (is the plan achievable?) and multiply by the amount.
- Brand: Step 4: Compute the cost of deferral and receivables.
- Step 5: Assemble the effective price and compare it with target margin and channels.
- Retailer: Step 6: Check wording: bonus as a discount, services evidenced by acts, penalties capped.
- Brand: Step 7: Keep a log of deductions and dispute unfounded ones within the claim period.
- Brand: Step 8: Put customer terms into one “realization, %” table and revisit the most expensive ones before the season starts.
- Retailer: Step 9: Keep a separate supplier-income register per supplier and check that the bonus does not inflate the gross margin of the product group.
Formulas
| Measure | Formulas | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Effective price | Effective = Shipment − Retro − MDF − Listing − Penalties − Chargebacks − Shipment × Rate × Days / 365 | Divide by shipment to get the realization %. |
| OTIF penalty | Penalty = Shipment × Rate_per_point × (Plan − Actual) if Actual < Plan | Rate and cap come from the contract; the formula is contractual. |
| Cost of deferral as a percentage of shipment | Deferral, % = Rate × Days / 365 | In the example 18% × 60 / 365 ≈ 3% of shipment; if the customer pays late use actual days. |
| Annualized cost of an early-payment discount | Cost = d / (1 − d) × 365 / (N − n); d is the discount, n the days to earn it, N the credit term | Terms “2/10 net 30”: 0.02 / 0.98 × 365 / 20 ≈ 37% p.a.; compare with your cost of money (the earlypay calculation). |
Formulas in notation
- Cost of deferral
D = S × i × t / 365
S shipment, i annual money rate, t deferral days. Example: RUB 295,890, 3.0% of the shipment.- On-time-in-full fine
F = (OTIF_plan − OTIF_fact) × q × S
Gap in points, rate q per point, base S. Example: 5 points × 0.5% = RUB 250,000.- Effective realization
E = 1 − (B + M + L + F + C + D) / S
Bonus, marketing, listing fee, fine, deductions and deferral relative to shipment. Example: 87.0%.- Annual cost of an early-payment discount
Y = d / (1 − d) × 365 / (T − t)
d discount, T normal term, t discount term. For 2/10 net 30: 0.02 / 0.98 × 365 / 20 ≈ 37.2% per year.
Worked example
Shipment of RUB 10 million excl. VAT, 60-day deferral, 18% p.a. (example)
| Item | Amount, RUB | % of shipment |
|---|---|---|
| Retro bonus 3% | 300,000 | 3.0% |
| Marketing payment 1.5% | 150,000 | 1.5% |
| Listing fee | 200,000 | 2.0% |
| OTIF penalty: 5 points × 0.5% | 250,000 | 2.5% |
| Chargeback on returns 1% | 100,000 | 1.0% |
| Cost of deferral | 295,890 | 3.0% |
| Total deductions and costs | 1,295,890 | 13.0% |
| Effective realization | 8,704,110 | 87.0% |
Rates are illustrative; take real terms from the contract. The effective price is about 13% below list, so customer discounts are judged against it.
Figures
- positive
- negative
- total
Data as a table
| Step | Change | Level |
|---|---|---|
| Shipment at list | — | 10m |
| Volume retro-bonus | −300k | 9.7m |
| Marketing contribution | −150k | 9.55m |
| Listing fee | −200k | 9.35m |
| OTIF fine | −250k | 9.1m |
| Deductions | −100k | 9m |
| Cost of deferral | −296k | 8.7m |
| Real revenue | — | 8.7m |
From list price to the real brand revenue under customer terms. Each contract term shifts real revenue: volume bonus, marketing contribution, listing fee, on-time-in-full fine, deductions and the cost of deferral. The terms take 13.0% of the shipment. Rates and volumes are illustrative.
Data as a table
| Measure | Cost of deferral, % of shipment |
|---|---|
| 0 | 0 |
| 15 | 0.74 |
| 30 | 1.48 |
| 45 | 2.22 |
| 60 | 2.96 |
| 75 | 3.7 |
| 90 | 4.44 |
| 120 | 5.92 |
The cost of payment deferral grows linearly with the term. Share of shipment eaten by deferral at a money rate of 18% per year; the marker shows the term from the example.
Data as a table
| Measure | % of shipment |
|---|---|
| Retro-bonus | 3 |
| Marketing | 1.5 |
| Listing fee | 2 |
| OTIF | 2.5 |
| Deductions | 1 |
| Deferral | 3 |
What the customer terms consist of, % of shipment. The largest item is often not a bonus but the deferral: it is invisible in the contract as a payment.
Specifics by category
- Apparel
- Apparel: bonuses are often tied to the season plan and sell-through; delivery penalties matter because of the season window.
- Footwear
- Footwear: more returns and chargebacks for size and defects; build it into the effective price.
- Accessories
- Accessories: low average ticket and a high listing fee per unit; compute listing fee per piece.
- Kids
- Kids: more document requirements (certificate, marking), so document penalties weigh more.
- Men
- Men: basics and repeat orders; an annual-turnover bonus works better than seasonal plans.
- Women
- Women: fast collections; delivery penalties and order cancellation rights matter more than the discount.
Common mistakes
- Customers compared on list price → the one that looks best on list is cheapest on effective price → compute realization from the table.
- A bonus papered as a service with no act → audit risk and a VAT deduction dispute → write “discount” or document the service.
- An uncapped penalty → deduction larger than the lot → a percentage cap on the order.
- Cost of deferral ignored → in the example it is RUB 296 thousand, that is 3% of the shipment (10 million × 18% × 60 / 365), and margin is overstated by exactly those three points → compute it with the formula and your own rate.
- A bonus written both as a discount and as a service → double counting or a VAT dispute → choose one kind and evidence it.
- Terms computed on shipment excl. VAT while deductions are on the amount incl. VAT → percentage mismatch → bring all bases to one.
Russian specifics
- For platforms: changing terms and lowering a partner’s price at its expense is governed by 289-FZ from 01.10.2026. Rule: Law 289-FZ of 31.07.2025: Federal Law of 31.07.2025 No. 289-FZ on the platform economy.
- Penalty: Civil Code Art. 330; a court may reduce a clearly disproportionate one (Art. 333, text not checked). Rule: Civil Code part 1: Civil Code, part one (including Arts. 330, 424) (rule check not completed).
- The trade-regulation law caps bonuses to retail chains for food products; it does not apply to clothing (not checked against the law text).
- Volume bonuses and discounts: the VAT base effect depends on the form (price discount or bonus): Tax Code Art. 154 para. 2.1; check with the accountant.
- Bonuses and service fees: the recipient of the service may deduct VAT with an invoice and an act (Tax Code Arts. 171–172, not checked against the text); a bonus called a discount is papered by an adjustment, not an act. Rule: Tax Code Art. 171: Tax Code, Art. 171 (VAT deductions) (rule check not completed).
- The penalty rate in a supply contract is agreed by the parties, but a court may cut a clearly disproportionate one; a cap as a percentage of the order is therefore safer than a fixed sum per point. Rule: Civil Code part 1: Civil Code, part one (including Arts. 330, 424) (rule check not completed).