Syntha Lab RU

Cost of payment terms, deductions and factoring

Compares three ways to get paid for a wholesale shipment: wait out the credit, give a discount for fast payment or sell the invoice to a factor. Shows what credit and buyer deductions cost and what price uplift they call for.

Wholesale terms and credit For whom: Brands with wholesale sales: finance and commercial directors.

Calculate on your data →

At a glance

What question does it answer?
What the buyer’s credit and deductions cost us and which way of getting paid is better.
What data is needed?
The shipment amount, buyer credit, cost of capital.
How to read the result?
Look at three figures at once: the cost of credit, deductions and their share in the shipment margin. If the fast-payment discount has an annual cost above your cost of capital it is not worth it. Tiered prices by payment term stop fast payers subsidizing slow ones. Example on the default values: A shipment of RUB 10m, a 60-day delay and a rate of 18%: the delay costs RUB 278,137 and the buyer’s deductions RUB 600,000. Together they eat 19.5% of the shipment margin; the best option by net result yields RUB 9,238,164. A 2% discount for payment within 10 days costs 14.9% a year. If a prompt-payment discount costs less than your capital rate, it pays to offer it; if not, decline. Next: “Wholesale terms: wholesale discount, prepayment, credit” and “Early-payment discount: annual rate”.

Why and how to reason

A wholesale shipment turns into money not on the day of sale. A buyer may pay in 60 days, withhold part of the amount (penalties, marketing bonuses), and you need cash sooner. There are three ways: wait, give a discount for fast payment, or sell the invoice to a factor. To compare, everything is brought to one measure: how much money you really receive.

Waiting has one price: the cost of capital for the days of credit = amount x rate x days / 365. A discount loses a percent of the amount but saves days. Factoring costs a fee, and on the part not covered by the advance also interest.

Example. Invoice RUB 10 m, deductions 6% (RUB 9.4 m after them), rate 18%, credit 60 days. Wait: 9.4 - 0.278 = RUB 9.122 m. Discount 2% for payment in 10 days: RUB 9.167 m. Factoring (fee 1.5%, advance 90%): RUB 9.238 m, the best. The discount is worth 14.9% a year: cheaper than the cost of capital of 18%, hence it beats waiting.

When to use it

It is useful when choosing payment terms for large buyers and when assessing a factoring offer. It helps compute what credit costs as a percentage of margin. Assumption: the cost of capital is constant and the buyer pays on time. Factoring with or without recourse carries different risks, which the calculation does not reflect. Enter terms from contracts. Take real deductions from reconciliation statements.

How to read the result

Compare the three options by net outcome and look at the share of margin that credit and deductions eat: in the example 19.5% of margin, that is almost a fifth of earnings goes on terms. The annualized cost of the discount (14.9%) is compared with the cost of capital: if lower, the discount is worthwhile. Decision: offer the discount to buyers ready to pay fast, and give long credit terms for a price. Make sure deductions do not grow without your agreement. Prepare a table of concession prices for negotiations: what each day of credit and each percent of deductions costs. This turns “no” into “yes, but at this price”.

Common mistakes

Typical trap: considering a 2% discount “small” without annualizing; forgetting buyer deductions; not accounting for the factoring fee on the whole amount; taking the cost of capital as a deposit rate instead of the real cost of money. Also: comparing options with different terms without bringing them to one basis.

What data is needed?

  • The shipment amount, buyer credit, cost of capital.
  • Buyer deductions: markdown allowances, fines, returns, fees.
  • Optionally: the fast-payment discount, factoring terms, margin on the shipment.
  • Where to take it: the shipment amount from the invoice; the delay and deductions (discounts, penalties, returns, marketing fees) from the contract and the history of settlements with the buyer in 1C; the capital rate from the bank’s terms (check the key rate for the calculation date); factoring terms from the factor’s offer. Delay and deductions first, then factoring and the discount.

Inputs

FieldUnitValue in the exampleMeaning
Shipment amount on the invoice₽10,000,000The shipment amount on the invoice excl. VAT.
Buyer creditdays60For how many days the buyer asks for payment credit from the shipment date.
Cost of capital% a year18Illustrative 18% a year: replace it with your loan rate or the return you give up.
Buyer deductions% of invoice6Markdown allowances, fines, returns, marketing fees the buyer deducts on payment.
Discount for fast payment%2The discount you give for paying early, as a percentage of the invoice.
If paid withindays10Within how many days payment must be made to get the early-payment discount.
Factoring: fee% of invoice1.5The factor fee as a percentage of the invoice under the contract.
Factoring: advance% of invoice90The share of the invoice the factor pays at once as an advance under the contract.
Brand margin on the shipment (optional)% of invoice45To see what share of margin the credit eats. Optional. Empty: the field is ignored (counted as zero in sums).

How it is calculated

StepFormula
WaitInvoice × (1 − deductions) − cost of capital for the credit days
DiscountInvoice × (1 − discount) × (1 − deductions) − cost of capital for the discount days
FactoringInvoice × (1 − deductions) − fee − cost of capital on the part not covered by the advance (the advance is a share of the invoice)
Price uplift for creditRate × days ÷ 365

Worked numbers

Default values from the app; in the interactive version you enter your own.

Cost of the credit
278,137 ₽ · 2.78 %Cost of capital × days ÷ 365 on the amount to be received (invoice net of deductions), as in the “Wait” scenario.
Buyer deductions
600,000 ₽
Best option by net result
9.24 m ₽ · Factoring
Share of margin eaten by credit and deductions
19.5 %
Annual cost of the fast-payment discount
14.9 %If above your cost of capital the discount is not worth it.

Three ways to get paid

OptionNet resultAfter, daysVersus waiting
Wait out the credit9.12 m ₽600 ₽
Discount for fast payment9.17 m ₽1044,708 ₽
Factoring9.24 m ₽0116,301 ₽

Price uplift for credit at your rate: 0 days — 0 %; 30 days — 1.48 %; 60 days — 2.96 %; 90 days — 4.44 %; 120 days — 5.92 %. Pricing by payment terms should be tiered: fast payers must not subsidise slow ones. A “2/10” discount makes sense only for those who really pay on time.

Nuances and limits

  • Deductions with large buyers can be noticeable: allow for them in the cash forecast in advance and take them from your own contracts.
  • Factoring makes sense for a structural gap, not for covering disputes and short shipments.
  • Factoring makes sense for a structural gap, not to cover a random delay; check the terms with a lawyer and the bank.
  • Enter buyer deductions from past seasons’ actuals, not from the contract.

Terms used

Calculate on your data →