Concession matrix: what to give first to get what you need and what it costs
From a list of concessions you can offer a partner (paying earlier, a volume commitment, a forecast, a lot size, prepayment, exclusivity) calculates the cost of each to you and the value to the partner with different cost of money, ranks them by “value to him ÷ cost to you”, builds the order of giving until the value covers what you ask and shows the net gain. Separately gives equivalents: how many days of deferral one percent of discount is worth and how many percent of discount a deferral is worth.
At a glance
- What question does it answer?
- What to give the partner first to get what you need, what it costs you and what it is worth to him and how a deferral is swapped for a discount.
- What data is needed?
- The annual volume and two rates of money: yours and the partner’s.
- How to read the result?
- Example on the default values (volume RUB 24 million, your rate 22%, the partner’s 18%, an ask of RUB 720 thousand): one day of acceleration costs you RUB 14,466 and brings the partner RUB 11,836; 1% of discount equals 16.6 days of deferral, 30 days of deferral equal a 1.81% discount. To cover the ask 4 concessions are needed costing RUB 315,000, a net gain of RUB 405,000. Example on the default values: Cost of one day of faster payment to you: RUB 14,466; Value of one day to the partner: RUB 11,836; One percent of discount equals days of deferral: 16.6 d; 30 days of deferral equal a discount of: 1.81%. The figures are illustrative: enter your own to see your result.
Why and how to reason
A concession is dear or cheap depending on whose it is. Paying 15 days earlier costs you volume × rate × days ÷ 365: at a volume of RUB 24,000,000 and a rate of 22% one day costs RUB 14,466. The same day brings the partner RUB 11,836 at a rate of 18%. So giving money does not pay: you spend more than he receives. An order forecast for 6 months costs you RUB 20,000 and gives him RUB 150,000: a return of 7.5 rubles of value per ruble of cost. The matrix ranks concessions by “value to the partner ÷ cost to you” and takes them until the value covers your ask (RUB 720,000 a year). Four were enough here: a value of RUB 870,000 at a cost of RUB 315,000, a net gain of RUB 405,000. The money exchange is counted as well: 1% of discount equals 16.6 days of deferral and 30 days of deferral equal a discount of 1.81%.
When to use it
Use it when you are going to ask for a discount, a better commission or terms and are ready to give something in return and when the partner asks for a discount instead of a deferral or vice versa: a common language of money is needed. Do not use it as a rigid script: you estimate the value to the partner and at the meeting it is checked against the reaction. Assumptions: concessions are independent and additive, the rates of money are constant for a year. For platforms and chains count direct value through their interests: predictability, visibility, volume.
How to read the result
The order of giving goes down the table: first what is cheap to you and dear to him (a public testimonial: 12 rubles of value per ruble; a forecast: 7.5; a volume commitment: 4.0), money last. The “In the set” column shows which concessions are needed to cover the ask. If concessions are not enough either reduce the ask, add concessions or strengthen the alternative. Look at the net gain: if it is small the exchange does not pay for the cost of negotiating. The equivalents help to answer quickly at the meeting: the partner asks for a 3% discount and you know that a 30-day deferral costs you 1.81%.
Common mistakes
Giving money first: afterwards there is nothing to trade. Counting the value of a concession to the partner at your own rate. Giving a concession for free without a counter-term. Not recording direct costs (excess stock at a larger minimum lot, lost flexibility): the concession looks cheaper than it is. For a prepayment count days as share × term, otherwise the cost is overstated.
What data is needed?
- The annual volume and two rates of money: yours and the partner’s.
- A list of concessions with days of faster payment, direct cost and value.
- How much money a year you ask for.
Inputs
| Field | Unit | Value in the example | Meaning |
|---|---|---|---|
| Annual deal volume | ₽ | 24,000,000 | The sum of purchases or sales under the deal per year: the money released or frozen by a change in the payment term is counted from it. The example value is illustrative. |
| Your cost of money | % a year | 22 | The rate at which you raise money or forgo income: a loan rate or the required return. The example value is illustrative. |
| Partner’s cost of money | % a year | 18 | An estimate of the partner’s rate: for a large chain it is usually lower, for a small factory higher. It is an estimate, check it in conversation. The example value is illustrative. |
| What you ask for per year | ₽ | 720,000 | The money you want to get from the partner: a price discount, a lower commission, extra terms, in rubles per year. The example value is illustrative. |
How it is calculated
| Step | Formula |
|---|---|
| Cost to you | volume × your rate × days ÷ 365 + direct cost |
| Value to the partner | volume × partner’s rate × days ÷ 365 + direct value |
| Order | in descending value-to-cost ratio |
| The set | take concessions until the value is at least the ask |
| Gain | the ask − the cost of the chosen concessions to you |
Worked numbers
Default values from the app; in the interactive version you enter your own.
- Cost of one day of faster payment to you
- 14,466 ₽Volume × your rate ÷ 365.
- Value of one day to the partner
- 11,836 ₽Volume × the partner’s rate ÷ 365.
- One percent of discount equals days of deferral
- 16.6 d1% of volume ÷ the cost of one day: how many deferral days cost as much as one percent of discount.
- 30 days of deferral equal a discount of
- 1.81 %Your rate × 30 ÷ 365: if the partner asks for a 3% discount and you can give 30 days of deferral, see which is cheaper.
- Concessions in the list
- 7
- Concessions needed to cover the ask
- 4In the order of descending value-to-cost ratio.
- Value of the chosen concessions to the partner
- 870,000 ₽
- Cost of the chosen concessions to you
- 315,000 ₽
- Net gain per year
- 405,000 ₽The ask minus the cost of the chosen concessions to you.
- What the partner needs to agree
- 720,000 ₽The value of concessions to the partner must be at least what you ask.
- First concession in the order of giving
- A public testimonial about the partner
- Cost to you
- Value to the partner
Data as a table
| Measure | Cost to you | Value to the partner |
|---|---|---|
| A public testimonial about the partner | 5,000 | 60k |
| Order forecast six months ahead | 20k | 150k |
| A yearly volume as a commitment | 90k | 360k |
| Category exclusivity | 200k | 300k |
| Raise the minimum lot by 20% | 140k | 120k |
| Pay 15 days earlier | 217k | 178k |
| A 30% prepayment 20 days before shipment (equal to 6 days of the whole volume) | 86.8k | 71k |
Order of giving
| Concession | Cost to you | Value to the partner | Value per ruble of cost | In the set |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| A public testimonial about the partner | 5,000 ₽ | 60,000 ₽ | 12 | yes |
| Order forecast six months ahead | 20,000 ₽ | 150,000 ₽ | 7.5 | yes |
| A yearly volume as a commitment | 90,000 ₽ | 360,000 ₽ | 4 | yes |
| Category exclusivity | 200,000 ₽ | 300,000 ₽ | 1.5 | yes |
| Raise the minimum lot by 20% | 140,000 ₽ | 120,000 ₽ | 0.86 | no |
| Pay 15 days earlier | 216,986 ₽ | 177,534 ₽ | 0.82 | no |
| A 30% prepayment 20 days before shipment (equal to 6 days of the whole volume) | 86,795 ₽ | 71,014 ₽ | 0.82 | no |
The partner values concessions in its own way: its cost of money and direct value are different, so the same concession has to be counted with two numbers. Give first what is cheap to you and dear to him (a forecast, a public testimonial, a volume commitment) and do not start with money: money is given at the end. Do not give a concession for free: each must be tied to what you get in return. For footwear, accessories and children’s the set of concessions is its own: seasonal prepayment, the minimum lot for a size run, the school schedule.
Nuances and limits
- Giving money (discount, deferral) first: nothing is left to trade.
- Counting the value of a concession to the partner at your own rate.
- Giving a concession without tying it to a counter-term.