Transfer price and producer or importer markup: range and tax
Finds the transfer price range between a producer (importer) and an affiliated seller: from below by the minimum markup on full cost, from above by the buyer’s minimum margin and by comparable deals; shows profit and tax by link at your price and at the range edges.
At a glance
- What question does it answer?
- In what range the price between your own companies is reasonable, who gets the profit at your price and what that means for tax.
- What data is needed?
- Link 1: units, cost, operating cost, the minimum markup, the tax rate.
- How to read the result?
- On the default data (Model B sells to Model R) the bound from a 20% markup on full cost of 1,500 gives 1,800, the bound from the buyer’s 8% margin gives 3,040, comparable deals narrow the range to 2,200-2,500. The price of 2,300 is inside (33.3% of the range) and 4.2% below the outside price of 2,400. The brand markup is 53.3%, the retailer margin 24.4%; profit 6,000,000 and 8,250,000, the group’s 14,250,000, tax 1,500,000 and 2,062,500, in total 3,562,500. With equal rates group tax does not depend on the price, only the split of profit changes. Example on the default values: Lower bound of the range: RUB 2,200; Upper bound of the range: RUB 2,500; Price position in the range: 33.3%; Amount outside the range for the period: RUB 0. The figures are illustrative: enter your own to see your result.
Why and how to reason
When a brand (a manufacturer or importer) sells to an affiliated retailer, the price between them determines where profit stays and how much tax each link pays. It cannot be arbitrary: tax authorities may check whether it matches the market. The calculation builds a range. At the bottom: full cost × (1 + minimum markup) = (1,200 + 300) × 1.2 = 1,800. At the top: retail minus the buyer’s margin and costs = 4,500 × 0.92 − 1,100 = 3,040. Plus the boundary of comparable deals, 2,200 to 2,500. The intersection gives a range of 2,200 to 2,500. Your price of 2,300 sits in it at 33%. Link 1 profit (2,300 − 1,500) × 7,500 = 6 million, link 2 (4,500 − 2,300 − 1,100) × 7,500 = 8.25 million, group tax 3.56 million.
When to use it
Use it when setting prices inside a group and when preparing justification. It does not replace transfer pricing under rules and documentation: controlled transactions, criteria and methods are set by norms, check them against the current text and with a tax adviser. Assumptions: two links, one product, tax by link linear, comparable deals confirmed by documents. The calculation also helps when prices are revised after a retail change: it will show whether the range has moved.
How to read the result
Look at the position of the price in the range and the amount outside the range: if non-zero, the price falls outside the limits and tax risk grows. Compare the price with the price to external customers: a deviation of minus 4% is acceptable, but explain the discount. Group tax at your price and at the lower boundary shows what the price choice costs: a difference of zero means both links pay at one rate and the decision is set not by taxes but by market-likeness. If rates differ, shifting the price changes group tax, but do not use that as a reason for an unjustified price.
Common mistakes
Typical trap: computing cost without the link’s operating expenses, taking comparable deals from a different category or volume, not updating the retail price, focusing only on tax. A price that cannot be explained by the market is a risk, even if tax is lower. Keep the documents that justify it. Also check that the costs of the buyer are per unit and on the same terms as the price, otherwise the upper bound is overstated.
What data is needed?
- Link 1: units, cost, operating cost, the minimum markup, the tax rate.
- Link 2: retail price, costs, the minimum margin, the tax rate.
- The transfer price, the outside price and the comparable-deal bounds.
Inputs
| Field | Unit | Value in the example | Meaning |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sold to the buyer in the period | pcs | 7,500 | Units link 1 sold to link 2 in the period. The default comes from the end-to-end “Model B” (a brand, illustrative data). |
| Unit cost | ₽ | 1,200 | Production cost or, for an importer, landed cost (with freight and duty) excl. VAT. For footwear, accessories and children’s the values differ: take your own. The default comes from the end-to-end “Model B” (a brand, illustrative data). |
| Operating cost per unit at link 1 | ₽ | 300 | The share of management, sales and logistics costs per unit. The example value is illustrative. |
| Minimum markup on full cost | % | 20 | The markup below which link 1 should not sell. Your estimate from comparable companies. Values differ by category. The example value is illustrative. |
| Corporate income tax rate of link 1 | % | 25 | Regime, benefits, a foreign entity: check with a tax adviser. The example value is illustrative. |
| Retail price excl. VAT | ₽ | 4,500 | The price at which link 2 sells a unit to the end customer, excl. VAT. The default comes from the end-to-end “Model B” (a brand, illustrative data). |
| Buyer’s cost per unit | ₽ | 1,100 | Rent, staff, logistics, marketing per unit. The example value is illustrative. |
| Buyer’s minimum operating margin | % | 8 | The share of retail revenue that must remain with the buyer. Your estimate. The example value is illustrative. |
| Corporate income tax rate of link 2 | % | 25 | If the rates differ the price changes the group’s tax: check with a tax adviser. The example value is illustrative. |
| Transfer price per unit | ₽ | 2,300 | The price excl. VAT at which link 1 sells to link 2. The default comes from the end-to-end “Model B” (a brand, illustrative data). |
| Price to outside customers per unit | ₽ | 2,400 | The price of the same goods to unrelated wholesale customers: the basis for comparison. Empty: not compared. The default comes from the end-to-end “Model B” (a brand, illustrative data). |
| Comparable deals: lower price bound | ₽ | 2,200 | The lower bound of market prices for comparable goods from your data. Empty: no limit. The example value is illustrative. |
| Comparable deals: upper price bound | ₽ | 2,500 | The upper bound of market prices for comparable goods from your data. Empty: no limit. The example value is illustrative. |
How it is calculated
| Step | Formula |
|---|---|
| Full cost | unit cost + link 1 operating cost per unit |
| Bounds | bottom: full cost × (1 + markup); top: retail × (1 − buyer margin) − buyer cost; plus the comparable-deal bounds |
| Link profits | link 1: (price − full cost) × units; link 2: (retail − price − cost) × units |
| Tax | max(0; profit) × the link rate; group: the sum |
| Shift | units × (nearest bound − price) if the price is outside the range |
Worked numbers
Default values from the app; in the interactive version you enter your own.
- Lower bound of the range
- 2,200 ₽The higher of: the markup on full cost, the lower comparable bound.
- Upper bound of the range
- 2,500 ₽The lower of: the price from the buyer’s margin, the upper comparable bound.
- Price position in the range
- 33.3 %0% is the lower bound, 100% the upper; outside 0-100 the price is outside the range.
- Amount outside the range for the period
- 0 ₽The profit that would shift between the links if the price were brought to the nearest bound.
- Deviation from the outside price
- −4.2 %
- Link 1 markup on full cost
- 53.3 %
- Link 2 operating margin
- 24.4 %
- Link 1 profit
- 6 m ₽
- Link 2 profit
- 8.25 m ₽
- Group profit
- 14.3 m ₽Does not depend on the transfer price.
- Link 1 tax
- 1.5 m ₽
- Link 2 tax
- 2.06 m ₽
- Group tax
- 3.56 m ₽
- Group tax: price at the lower bound against yours
- 0 ₽Plus: group tax would rise. With equal rates and profitable links there is no difference.
Profit and tax by link at different prices
| Price | Per unit | Link 1 profit | Link 2 profit | Link 1 tax | Link 2 tax | Group tax | Link 1 markup |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lower bound | 2,200 ₽ | 5.25 m ₽ | 9 m ₽ | 1.31 m ₽ | 2.25 m ₽ | 3.56 m ₽ | 46.7 % |
| Your price | 2,300 ₽ | 6 m ₽ | 8.25 m ₽ | 1.5 m ₽ | 2.06 m ₽ | 3.56 m ₽ | 53.3 % |
| Upper bound | 2,500 ₽ | 7.5 m ₽ | 6.75 m ₽ | 1.88 m ₽ | 1.69 m ₽ | 3.56 m ₽ | 66.7 % |
| Outside price | 2,400 ₽ | 6.75 m ₽ | 7.5 m ₽ | 1.69 m ₽ | 1.88 m ₽ | 3.56 m ₽ | 60 % |
The price 2,300 ₽ is inside the range 2,200 ₽-2,500 ₽; link 1 markup is 53.3 % on full cost.
The rates are equal: with both links profitable group tax does not depend on the price but the price splits profit between the links: this affects dividends, bonuses, covenants and minority shares.
The calculation is educational and does not assess the tax consequences of controlled transactions: check the procedure, thresholds and documentation with a tax adviser. Take the comparable-deal bounds from your own data. Amounts excl. VAT.
Nuances and limits
- Do not take bounds from other people’s surveys: enter the data of your own comparable deals and keep them.
- Group tax does not change at equal rates but the price moves dividends, bonuses and covenants: look at the whole effect.
- The importer’s cost includes freight and duty; its share differs for footwear, accessories and children’s.