Syntha Lab RU

Group structure, dividends and CFC: how to arrange the ownership of a brand and a retailer and what to check

A short guide for an owner: which legal entities a brand and a retailer need (an operator, production, a retail network, real estate, trademark rights), how to arrange ownership and management, when and how to pay dividends, what to do with a foreign company (a controlled foreign company, CFC) and how not to get a claim for an artificial split of the business. The document answers: in which structure to run the business to protect assets, simplify reporting and not break the law.

Contracts, tax, accounting Brand and retail Verified: 2026-11-14

Open interactively →

Why this document

The structure of a group often grows spontaneously: first one entity, then a second for a warehouse, a third for a new brand, a fourth abroad. After a few years the owner cannot answer who owes whom, where the trademark rights lie and how much tax the group pays. The owner, the finance director and a lawyer read this document when entering new markets, attracting an investor and preparing for a sale. It gives an order of reasoning: why each entity is needed, how to divide functions and money, how to compute dividends and how to check the risk of foreign structures and claims about artificial splitting.

At a glance

What is this document and why is it needed?
A short guide for an owner: which legal entities a brand and a retailer need (an operator, production, a retail network, real estate, trademark rights), how to arrange ownership and management, when and how to pay dividends, what to do with a foreign company (a controlled foreign company, CFC) and how not to get a claim for an artificial split of the business. The document answers: in which structure to run the business to protect assets, simplify reporting and not break the law.
Who owns the document and how often is it rebuilt?
The owner approves the structure and dividend policy, a lawyer and the finance director keep the ownership chart, the contracts between companies and the consolidation; the chart is revised with each new entity, investor and market entry; the board or the owners see the result.
What mistakes are the most common?
Brand rights are registered to an individual → in a conflict or departure the brand is lost → fix rights in a company and license them. Splitting the business for a special regime → the tax office assesses additional taxes → check the business purpose and real functions of each company. Internal prices below market ones without a reason → a claim on controlled transactions → arrange contracts on market terms.

For whom

Brand
Brand: usually an operating company (sales), production (a workshop or contracts with factories), an owner of trademark and design rights and sometimes a foreign company for markets and payments are needed; the main thing is to protect the brand rights and agree an intra-group license on market terms.
Retail
Retailer: usually an operator of stores, a company that owns real estate or leases large areas, a logistics company and companies in the regions are needed; the main thing is to separate the risk of real estate and lease from working trade and not to breach rules on related parties and splitting.

What it consists of

What a structure consists of and why

  • Forms: a limited liability company (the most common, simple rules, liability within the contribution), a joint-stock company (for large investors and going to the exchange), a sole trader (answers with all property); the choice of form determines liability and management.
  • Functions in separate companies: sales, production, brand rights, real estate, logistics; splitting protects assets but requires contracts between companies on market terms and separate accounting.
  • Rights to the trademark and design: hold them in a company with minimal operating risk and issue a license to operating companies by contract; check registration and terms so as not to lose the brand.
  • Management and the shareholders’ agreement: governing bodies, major transactions and related-party transactions, voting order, pre-emption right on a share, tag-along, an exit option; fix them before a conflict.
  • Dividends: the order and conditions of payment are set by law and the charter; payment is possible with net profit and sufficient assets; dividend tax depends on the recipient and the country (take the rate from the current law, not checked).
  • Consolidation and intra-group settlements: group statements eliminate internal turnover; arrange intra-group loans, licenses and services by contracts at market prices.

CFC and foreign structures

  • A controlled foreign company (CFC): a foreign organization that a Russian taxpayer controls through a share or otherwise; the owner must notify the tax authority and may pay tax on the undistributed profit of such a company (not checked).
  • Control criteria and share thresholds are defined by the Tax Code; they differ depending on the participation of related persons and whether the owner is a tax resident (not checked); check in the current edition with a lawyer.
  • Practical questions: why a foreign company is needed (payments, markets, assets), who its beneficiary is, how contracts with Russian companies are arranged, what the prices look like; an inspector looks at business purpose and real presence.
  • Brand: a foreign company in the EAEU or China market is needed for payments and contracts; arrange activity, contracts and prices as for an independent party and keep documents on real functions.
  • Retailer: when opening stores in Belarus, Kazakhstan, Armenia or Kyrgyzstan arrange a local entity or a representative office and check whether it becomes a CFC for the Russian owner.

Splitting, risks and the order of action

  • Artificial splitting of a business: dividing a single business into several companies for the sake of a special regime or a relief while the business is in fact one may be contested by the tax authority with additional tax assessed (not checked).
  • Signs: common management, shared employees and a warehouse, the same customers, companies’ dependence on each other; if each company has a business purpose and real functions the risk is lower.
  • Brand: if the brand and production entities are related check the prices of services, license and rent against market ones and keep documents; an unjustified price difference is a ground for a claim.
  • Brand: when attracting an investor at the brand level think through which rights to the brand and data the investor gets and how they are fixed in the shareholders’ agreement.
  • Retailer: when separating real estate into its own company arrange lease relations at market rates and fix rights to the fit-out; a breach makes the scheme vulnerable.
  • Retailer: when selling a chain the buyer needs an ownership chart, unified statements and clean contracts; prepare them in advance so as not to lower the valuation.
  • The order of action: draw the chart, check why each entity is needed, compile a register of contracts between them, compute consolidated profit and dividends, check foreign companies for CFC, fix the policy and revise it annually.

Brand and retailer: what to decide differently

  • Brand: decide where design, patterns, photos and content lie: if contractors created them arrange the transfer of exclusive rights by contract otherwise the rights stay with the author.
  • Brand: when attracting an investor decide what you sell: a share of the operating company, a share of the brand owner or only a share in a project; control over the brand depends on this.
  • Brand: production can be held in a separate company with its own pricing for the brand; confirm transfer prices with costs and the market.
  • Brand: an option for key staff (designers, production heads) is fixed through a share in the company or a shareholders’ agreement and not an oral promise.
  • Retailer: separate the operator company and the lessee company of large real estate so that the lease risk does not fall on the whole chain and arrange sublease at market rates.
  • Retailer: regional companies of a chain complicate reporting; decide which to keep separate and hold a single policy of prices, buying and accounting.
  • Retailer: franchisees are separate owners: fix the brand rights and standards by contract and arrange financial flows and royalties by a clear scheme.
  • Retailer: before selling a chain assemble the ownership chart, lease contracts and store statements into a single package for the buyer.

Where the data comes from

Data sourceFields
Constituent documents, extracts and the ownership chartshares, governing bodies, beneficiaries, foreign holdings
Contracts between group companiesprices, terms, licenses, loans, rent
Statements by company and consolidatedprofit, equity, dividends, internal turnover
Tax policy and a lawyer’s consultationsrates, regimes, CFC, business purpose

How to build it step by step

  1. Step 1: Draw the group chart: companies, shares, functions, internal contracts, foreign holdings.
  2. Step 2: For each company write the business purpose and real functions; close or merge companies without a purpose.
  3. Step 3: Check where the trademark rights lie, whether licenses are arranged and whether they are paid at a market price.
  4. Step 4: Compile a register of internal contracts with prices, terms and a price justification; compare prices with market ones.
  5. Step 5: Compute consolidated profit eliminating internal turnover and check that distributable profit and assets allow paying dividends.
  6. Step 6: Set a dividend policy: the payout share, dates, conditions (obligation cover, covenants, the investment plan) and the recipient’s tax.
  7. Step 7: Check foreign companies for CFC signs, notifications and tax on undistributed profit and prepare documents with a lawyer.
  8. Step 8: Conclude a shareholders’ agreement between owners and investors with rights of exit, sale and management; discuss conflict scenarios in advance.
  9. Step 9: Once a year revise the chart and the policy; repeat the check with every new company, investor and market.

Formulas

MeasureFormulasNote
An owner’s dividendDividend_i = Net profit × Payout share × Owner share_iPayment is admissible only with net profit and sufficient assets.
Tax and net amountNet_i = Dividend_i × (1 − Tax rate)Take the rate from the current law for the recipient.
Company equityEquity_t+1 = Equity_t + Net profit_t × (1 − Payout share)A simple model: profit equals return on equity.

Formulas in notation

Equity growth
E_{t+1} = E_t · (1 + g · (1 - d)), g = ROE
E: equity; g: return on equity; d: the dividend payout share; the larger d the slower the growth.
Net dividend
N_i = NP · d · s_i · (1 - τ)
NP: net profit; d: the payout share; s_i: the owner’s share; τ: the dividend tax rate.

Worked example

Dividends of three owners at a 60% payout (illustrative shares and tax rate, roubles)

OwnerShare, %DividendTax, illustrative 15%Received
Founder507,200,0001,080,0006,120,000
Product partner304,320,000648,0003,672,000
Investor202,880,000432,0002,448,000
Total10014,400,0002,160,00012,240,000

The inputs are illustrative: the group’s net profit is 24 m RUB, a payout of 60%, the dividend tax rate of 15% is taken for illustration: put in the current rate for your recipient from the law. The remaining 40% of profit stays in the group and grows equity.

Figures

A typical group chart of a brand and a retailer. Brand rights lie in a separate company and are licensed out; real estate and logistics are separated from working trade; a foreign company is checked for CFC signs.

  1. Owners → Brand rights; Sales operator; Real estate and logistics
  2. Brand rights → Sales operator
  3. Sales operator → Production
  4. Real estate and logistics → Foreign company (CFC?)
  5. Production
  6. Foreign company (CFC?)
Owners’ dividends: before tax and received
Bar chart: Founder 7,200, Product partner 4,320, Investor 2,88002,0004,0006,0008,000FounderFounderDividend before tax: 7,2007,200Received: 6,1206,120Product partnerProduct partnerDividend before tax: 4,3204,320Received: 3,6723,672InvestorInvestorDividend before tax: 2,8802,880Received: 2,4482,448Amount, RUB thousand
  • Dividend before tax
  • Received
Data as a table
MeasureDividend before taxReceived
Founder7,2006,120
Product partner4,3203,672
Investor2,8802,448

Owners’ dividends: before tax and received. The difference between columns is tax; at another rate and recipient it changes.

Group equity over five years: a 60% and a 20% payout
Line chart: 60% payout: 50,000 → 73,466; 20% payout: 50,000 → 105,01750,00060,00070,00080,00090,000100,000110,00001234560% payout, 0: 50,00060% payout, 1: 54,00060% payout, 2: 58,32060% payout, 3: 62,98660% payout, 4: 68,02460% payout, 5: 73,46620% payout, 0: 50,00020% payout, 1: 58,00020% payout, 2: 67,28020% payout, 3: 78,04520% payout, 4: 90,53220% payout, 5: 105,017Equity, RUB thousandYear
  • 60% payout
  • 20% payout
Data as a table
Year60% payout20% payout
050,00050,000
154,00058,000
258,32067,280
362,98678,045
468,02490,532
573,466105,017

Group equity over five years: a 60% and a 20% payout. The larger the payout the slower equity grows; at a return of 20% the difference accumulates fast and owners get more now while the company has less for growth.

Specifics by category

Apparel
Apparel: if a brand grows through new lines separate companies per line are often created; check whether they are needed and keep brand rights together otherwise they dilute.
Footwear
Footwear: production and tooling are expensive and are useful to hold in a separate company with equipment leasing; compute the internal transfer price on market terms.
Accessories
Accessories: small volumes and many suppliers; extra companies only complicate accounting so keep the structure simple and protect brand rights separately.
Kids
Kids: liability for safety and certification; a separate company for the line lowers the risk of the rest but requires separate certificates and accounts.
Men
Men: a stable line and a long life cycle; the structure changes rarely and the main question is the dividend policy and attracting an investor.
Women
Women: a fast turnover of collections and strong marketing; arrange brand rights, content and accounts for the company and not a person so as not to lose the audience when a partner leaves.

Common mistakes

  • Brand rights are registered to an individual → in a conflict or departure the brand is lost → fix rights in a company and license them.
  • Splitting the business for a special regime → the tax office assesses additional taxes → check the business purpose and real functions of each company.
  • Internal prices below market ones without a reason → a claim on controlled transactions → arrange contracts on market terms.
  • Not checking foreign companies for CFC → a missed notification and fines → keep a register and check annually.
  • Paying dividends without computing equity and obligations → a breach of credit terms → check covenants and the sufficiency of assets before payment.

Russian specifics

  • Limited liability companies are regulated by the law of 08.02.1998 No. 14-FZ and joint-stock companies by the law of 26.12.1995 No. 208-FZ; check the order of dividend payment, major transactions and related-party transactions in the current edition (not checked).
  • Dividend tax and the order of taxing a CFC are set by the Tax Code; check rates, thresholds and notification dates in the current edition and with a lawyer (not checked).
  • Trademark rights are regulated by part four of the Civil Code; check registration, terms and license agreements. Rule: Civil Code part 4: Civil Code, part four (Arts. 1232, 1235, 1237, 1486, 1491, 1515).
  • Brand: currency settlements with a foreign company fall under currency control under 173-FZ; check terms and documents against the current law. Rule: Law 173-FZ of 10.12.2003: Federal Law of 10.12.2003 No. 173-FZ on currency regulation and control.
  • Retailer: a local entity in other EAEU countries works under national law; the tax and corporate scheme there differs and carrying over the Russian one without a check is dangerous.

Open interactively →