Syntha Lab RU

WACC: cost of capital, ROIC against WACC and economic profit

Calculates the weighted average cost of capital from the shares, the cost of equity and debt after tax, then compares it with ROIC and finds economic profit (EVA); the table shows how WACC and EVA change at another debt share.

Investment and store openings For whom: Chief financial officers, owners and analysts when valuing projects, store openings and the business and choosing the financing structure.

Calculate on your data →

At a glance

What question does it answer?
What the company’s capital costs, whether the business earns more than that cost and how much economic profit it creates.
What data is needed?
The equity and debt shares, Ke, Kd and the tax rate.
How to read the result?
On the default data (Model B: 75% equity at Ke 25%, debt at 20% with tax 25%) WACC is 22.5%: equity contributes 18.75 points, debt after tax of 15% contributes 3.75. ROIC is 27.35% (NOPAT 23,886,000 on capital 87,342,500), the spread 4.85 pp, economic profit 4,233,938. For “Model R” (60% equity, Ke 23%, Kd 20%) WACC is 19.8%, ROIC 16.98%, the spread is negative and EVA is about −2,960,790. Every 10 points of debt share at an unchanged Ke lowers WACC by 1 pp, but in fact Ke rises. Example on the default values: WACC: 22.5%; Equity contribution to WACC: 18.8%; Cost of debt after tax: 15%; Debt contribution to WACC: 3.8%. The figures are illustrative: enter your own to see your result.

Why and how to reason

Capital costs money: owners want a return for risk, lenders want interest. The weighted average cost of capital (WACC) is the single “price of a rouble” for a company. It takes the cost of each source, weights it by share and accounts for interest on debt reducing tax. For an equity share of 75% and a cost of 25% the contribution is 18.75 points. Debt at 20% before tax costs 15% after tax of 25%, contribution 25% × 15% = 3.75 points. WACC is 22.5%. Then the return of the business is compared with the price of capital: NOPAT (profit after tax without interest) of 23.9 million on average capital of 87.3 million gives ROIC of 27.3%. A spread of 4.8 points is positive, and economic profit NOPAT − WACC × capital equals 4.23 million. This is profit above the charge for capital.

When to use it

Reach for it to assess whether the business creates value, to choose a rate for DCF and when deciding on investment or capital structure. Do not use it as an exact number: the cost of equity is an estimate and the capital structure is taken as target, not actual. Assumptions: rates are constant, tax is linear, capital is taken as the average of the beginning and end of the period.

How to read the result

The key comparison is ROIC against WACC. A spread of 4.8 points means the business earns more than the price of capital, and growth with new capital is justified. If the spread is negative, growth destroys value: first raise the return. Economic profit gives the spread in roubles (4.2 million), and “Breakeven EBIT at WACC” (26.2 million) shows the minimum operating profit below which capital does not pay back. The table on the debt share shows that more debt lowers WACC only up to a point beyond which risk and cost of capital rise. It is worth recording the rate you use in DCF and project hurdles in one place: different rates for similar decisions create disputes.

Common mistakes

The usual mistakes: taking the cost of debt from the coupon instead of the real rate, ignoring tax, taking shares from the balance sheet instead of market or target ones, comparing end-of-period ROIC with WACC. Do not use one WACC for projects with different risk: a fast, risky project has a higher rate.

What data is needed?

  • The equity and debt shares, Ke, Kd and the tax rate.
  • EBIT for the period.
  • Invested capital at the start and the end.

Inputs

FieldUnitValue in the exampleMeaning
Equity share%75The target capital structure, not necessarily the balance sheet. The rest is debt. The default comes from the end-to-end “Model B” (a brand, illustrative data).
Cost of equity (Ke)%25The return owners demand for risk: your estimate (risk-free rate plus a premium for business risk and size). For seasonal footwear and children’s ranges stock risk is usually priced higher: take your own. The default comes from the end-to-end “Model B” (a brand, illustrative data).
Cost of debt before tax (Kd)%20The average rate on loans including fees. Take the key rate on the calculation date, the bank spread is yours. The default comes from the end-to-end “Model B” (a brand, illustrative data).
Corporate income tax rate%25Needed for the debt tax shield. Check the regime and benefits with an accountant. The example value is illustrative.
Operating profit (EBIT)₽31,848,000Profit before interest and tax for the period. The default comes from the end-to-end “Model B” (a brand, illustrative data).
Invested capital at the start₽83,880,000Working capital (receivables + net inventory + advances − payables − payroll − loyalty) plus fixed assets. The default comes from the end-to-end “Model B” (a brand, illustrative data).
Invested capital at the end₽90,805,000The same composition at period end. The default comes from the end-to-end “Model B” (a brand, illustrative data).

How it is calculated

StepFormula
Cost of debt after taxKd × (1 − tax)
WACCequity share × Ke + debt share × Kd after tax
NOPAT and capitalNOPAT = EBIT × (1 − tax); capital = (start + end) ÷ 2
ROIC and spreadROIC = NOPAT ÷ capital; spread = ROIC − WACC
Economic profitNOPAT − WACC × capital

Worked numbers

Default values from the app; in the interactive version you enter your own.

WACC
22.5 %Equity share × Ke + debt share × Kd × (1 − tax).
Equity contribution to WACC
18.8 %
Cost of debt after tax
15 %
Debt contribution to WACC
3.8 %
Debt tax shield in WACC
1.3 %By how many points WACC is lower because interest reduces tax.
Debt to equity (D/E)
0.33×
NOPAT
23.9 m ₽EBIT × (1 − tax); with a loss, no tax.
Invested capital (average)
87.3 m ₽
ROIC
27.3 %
Spread ROIC − WACC
4.8 %
Economic profit (EVA)
4.23 m ₽NOPAT − WACC × capital, the same as spread × capital.
Break-even EBIT at WACC
26.2 m ₽The operating profit at which EVA is zero.

Sensitivity to the debt share (Ke unchanged)

Equity shareDebt shareWACCSpread ROIC − WACCEVA
100 %0 %25 %2.35 %2.05 m ₽
90 %10 %24 %3.35 %2.92 m ₽
80 %20 %23 %4.35 %3.8 m ₽
70 %30 %22 %5.35 %4.67 m ₽
60 %40 %21 %6.35 %5.54 m ₽
50 %50 %20 %7.35 %6.42 m ₽
40 %60 %19 %8.35 %7.29 m ₽

ROIC 27.3 % is above WACC 22.5 % by 4.8 %: the business earns more than the cost of capital, economic profit 4.23 m ₽.

In the sensitivity table Ke stays the same: in fact as debt grows owners’ risk and Ke rise and the bank rate is higher, so the benefit of debt is overstated. This is an illustration, not capital-structure advice.

Ke and Kd are your estimates: there is no single norm in Russia. Take the key rate on the calculation date; check the tax shield and regime with an accountant. A project discount rate may differ from the company WACC. Amounts excl. VAT.

Nuances and limits

  • Ke and Kd are your estimates: do not plug in someone else’s “market” values without adjusting for your own risk.
  • The capital structure is a target and not the balance sheet: the balance sheet reflects past decisions.
  • Do not compare ROIC with WACC on a single year of a seasonal business: take average capital and several periods.

Terms used

Calculate on your data →