FSBU 25, 6 and 26: lease, fixed assets and capital investments in the accounts of a retailer and a brand
Three federal accounting standards that change the balance sheet of a company with stores and production: a premises lease becomes an asset and a liability, the cost of fitting out a store goes through capital investments and equipment and furniture follow new rules. The document answers: what exactly goes into the balance sheet when a lease is signed and a store is opened, how that changes EBITDA, debt and profit and what to explain to the bank.
Why this document
Before, rent was a cost line and the finance manager saw it as a fixed cost. Under FSBU 25 a long-term lease is an asset and a debt: the balance sheet grows, EBITDA is higher and profit in the first years lower. The decision to open a store, covenants on a loan and the valuation of the business are computed on a different basis. The chief accountant, the finance director and the owner read this document before signing a lease and when preparing statements. It gives an order of reasoning: what to count as a payment, which rate to take and how to match the result with cash flow so as not to take EBITDA growth for growth in cash.
At a glance
- What is this document and why is it needed?
- Three federal accounting standards that change the balance sheet of a company with stores and production: a premises lease becomes an asset and a liability, the cost of fitting out a store goes through capital investments and equipment and furniture follow new rules. The document answers: what exactly goes into the balance sheet when a lease is signed and a store is opened, how that changes EBITDA, debt and profit and what to explain to the bank.
- Who owns the document and how often is it rebuilt?
- The chief accountant keeps the accounts under the standards and the accounting policy, the finance director recomputes metrics and covenants; revised for every new lease and when the term or rate changes; the bank and the auditor see the statements.
- What mistakes are the most common?
- VAT is included in the liability → the liability is overstated → take payments excl. VAT and account for VAT under tax rules. The rate is taken by feel → the liability and interest do not match the audit → confirm the rate with bank offers for a comparable term. Celebrating EBITDA growth → forgetting interest and depreciation → look at profit, cash flow and covenants together.
For whom
- Brand
- Brand: rent is for a showroom, a warehouse, an office and a workshop and the finishing and workshop equipment are fixed assets and capital investments. The key questions for a brand: the discount rate on loans, the variable part under percentage rent and accounting for sewing equipment.
- Retail
- Retailer: a chain has dozens of leases with indexation and a turnover percentage, so the standard changes the balance sheet noticeably: right-of-use assets and liabilities grow and the debt to EBITDA and interest cover covenants are recomputed. A separate topic: the store fit-out as a capital investment and its depreciation period.
What it consists of
FSBU 25/2018: lease
- What is on the balance sheet: the right-of-use asset (at the start equal to the liability plus advances and direct costs less lessor incentives) and the lease liability (the present value of payments).
- The discount rate: the rate implicit in the lease if it can be determined; otherwise the borrowing rate for a comparable term; the choice and calculation are fixed in the accounting policy (not checked).
- The composition of payments: fixed payments, indexation of a known size, an option price, a termination penalty if reflected in the term; VAT and the variable part (a turnover percentage) are not in the liability.
- The lease term: the non-cancellable period plus extension periods that are reasonably expected to be used; a revision of the term changes the liability and the asset.
- Exceptions: short-term leases (up to 12 months) and leases of low-value assets may be expensed; whether the organization may apply the simplification and to what extent is set by the standard and the accounting policy (not checked).
- Expenses by year: interest on the liability (higher in the first years) plus straight-line depreciation of the asset; over the whole term their sum equals cash payments and costs, only the distribution by year changes.
FSBU 6/2020 and FSBU 26/2020: fixed assets and capital investments
- Fixed assets: an asset with an expected useful life over 12 months; the cost threshold for recognition is set by the organization in its accounting policy; the initial cost includes price, delivery, installation and other direct costs (not checked).
- Depreciation: the term and method are set by the organization; a residual value is considered; the term and method are revised when conditions change (not checked).
- Capital investments: the costs of creating, improving and preparing an asset are accumulated separately until commissioning; the fit-out of a store and the equipment of a showroom go through this account and then into fixed assets.
- Improvements to leased premises: the lessee’s cost of inseparable improvements is depreciated over a term not exceeding the lease term; check the term against the contract and options.
- Brand: sewing and cutting equipment, molds and tooling are fixed assets; set the depreciation term by real wear and shifts and not by the tax reference.
- Brand: the costs of developing a collection and technological preparation are more often period expenses; intangibles are possible only if the recognition conditions are met, check with the intangible assets standard.
- Retailer: the fit-out, trading equipment and signage of a new store go into capital investments and not into the month’s expenses; count the store payback with depreciation and rent under the standard.
- Retailer: closing a store early requires revising the lease term and writing off unamortized improvements; build that into the closure scenario.
What changes in the metrics and what to explain to the bank
- EBITDA grows by the amount of fixed rent because it is no longer in operating costs while interest and depreciation are present; there is no more cash, so compare with cash flow.
- Debt to EBITDA: the lease liability may enter debt under the bank’s definition; clarify in the loan agreement whether lease liabilities count as debt (not checked).
- ROIC and return on assets: assets grow by the right of use so metrics on the old basis are not comparable; recompute prior periods on the same basis.
- Corporate income tax: tax accounting of lease follows the Tax Code and need not coincide with accounting; the difference creates deferred taxes (not checked).
- Brand: if a brand has several showroom stores, count the portfolio of leases and not each separately and reflect uniform approaches to the rate and term in the accounting policy.
- Retailer: for a chain keep a register of contracts with the start date, term, payments, indexation, options and rate; without a register the revision of terms and indexation is unmanageable.
Brand and retailer: what to count differently
- Brand: the discount rate is taken from a loan for production or working capital and not a mortgage; record which bank product it comes from and on what date it was determined.
- Brand: if premises for a warehouse and workshop are leased from a related party, check the terms against market ones and keep the justification for inspectors.
- Brand: part of the contracts are leases of equipment and vehicles; decide for each whether it is leasing or lease and do not mix them in one register without a mark.
- Brand: in the first year of production equipment depreciation and the premises right of use overlap with low revenue; show them on a separate line in the payback plan.
- Retailer: mall contracts usually have a fixed part and a turnover percentage; only the fixed part goes into the liability and the percentage is a variable cost.
- Retailer: a chain has a common indexation by a price index: it enters the liability only when the payment actually changes and the recalculation goes with every indexation.
- Retailer: when a store closes early the liability and the asset are written off and unamortized fit-out goes to expenses; put this amount in the store closure card.
- Retailer: when a chain or business is sold the buyer looks at EBITDA before and after the standard; prepare both versions with an explanation so as not to lose in valuation.
Where the data comes from
| Data source | Fields |
|---|---|
| Lease contracts and addenda | term, payments, indexation, options, deposit, variable part |
| Loan agreements and bank offers | borrowing rate for a comparable term |
| Primary documents on fit-out, equipment and commissioning | price, delivery, installation, commissioning date, useful life |
| The accounting policy | recognition threshold, depreciation term, simplifications for short-term and low-value leases |
How to build it step by step
- Step 1: Compile a register of lease contracts and mark which fall under the simplifications (up to 12 months, low-value) under your accounting policy.
- Step 2: Determine the term: the non-cancellable period and an extension that is likely to be used; record the justification.
- Step 3: Separate the payments that enter the liability (fixed, indexation of a known size) and exclude VAT and the turnover percentage.
- Step 4: Choose the rate: the lease rate or the borrowing rate for a comparable term; fix the source and date.
- Step 5: Compute the liability as the present value of payments and the right of use with advances, direct costs and incentives.
- Step 6: Build the schedule: monthly interest, depreciation, the liability balance; at the end of the term the balance must become zero.
- Step 7: Recompute EBITDA, debt to EBITDA, interest cover and ROIC on the new basis and compare with the loan agreement terms.
- Step 8: Account separately for fit-out capital investments: accumulate costs, set a useful life no longer than the lease term and the commissioning.
- Step 9: When the term, indexation or rate changes recompute the liability and the asset and reflect the difference; keep the calculation for the auditor.
Formulas
| Measure | Formulas | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly rate | r = (1 + R)^(1/12) − 1, R: annual rate | Choose one approach (effective or nominal monthly rate) and keep it in all contracts. |
| Liability | L₀ = Σ P_k ÷ (1 + r)^(k−1) with payment at the start of the month | With payment at the end of the month the exponent is k. |
| Right of use | ROU = L₀ + Advances + Direct costs − Incentives + Dismantling | Depreciation straight-line: ROU ÷ term in months. |
| Monthly interest | Interest = (Balance − Payment) × r with payment at the start of the month | The new balance: balance − payment + interest. |
| EBITDA growth per year | ΔEBITDA = Fixed rent for the year | Cash flow does not change; the composition of expenses does. |
Formulas in notation
- Lease liability
L0 = Σ_k P_k / (1 + r)^(k-1)
P_k: the month k payment excl. VAT; r: the monthly rate from the annual one; with payment at the end of the month the exponent is k.- Check over the term
Σ I + ROU = Σ P + A + D - S
I: interest, ROU: the right of use, P: payments, A: advances, D: direct costs, S: incentives; both parts equal cash costs.
Worked example
One lease: what changes in the first year (illustrative inputs, amounts in roubles without kopecks)
| Metric | Retailer: store at 800 k RUB a month, 60 mo. | Brand: showroom at 350 k RUB a month, 36 mo. |
|---|---|---|
| Liability at the start | 32,873,892 | 9,999,807 |
| Right of use at the start | 33,173,892 | 10,119,807 |
| Rent under the contract in year one | 9,600,000 | 4,200,000 |
| Interest in year one | 5,004,958 | 1,400,815 |
| Right-of-use depreciation in year one | 6,634,778 | 3,373,269 |
| Expenses under the standard in year one | 11,639,737 | 4,774,084 |
| EBITDA increase in year one | 9,600,000 | 4,200,000 |
| Profit effect in year one | −2,039,737 | −574,084 |
| Liability at the end of year one | 28,278,851 | 7,200,622 |
The inputs are illustrative: payment excl. VAT at the start of the month, a rate of 18% a year (illustrative), direct costs 300 and 120 k RUB, no indexation or incentives. A minus sign means expenses under the standard in year one exceed rent: towards the end of the term they are lower and over the whole term they equal cash payments and costs.
Figures
- Liability
- Right of use (net)
Data as a table
| Lease year | Liability | Right of use (net) |
|---|---|---|
| Start | 32.9m | 33.2m |
| 1 | 28.3m | 26.5m |
| 2 | 22.9m | 19.9m |
| 3 | 16.5m | 13.3m |
| 4 | 8.91m | 6.63m |
| 5 | 0 | 0 |
The liability and the net right of use by year: a store. The liability falls faster than the right of use in the early years because payments first cover interest and then principal; by the end of the term both lines reach zero.
- Interest and depreciation
- Rent payments
Data as a table
| Measure | Interest and depreciation | Rent payments |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | 11,640 | 9,600 |
| 2 | 10,813 | 9,600 |
| 3 | 9,837 | 9,600 |
| 4 | 8,685 | 9,600 |
| 5 | 7,326 | 9,600 |
Expenses under the standard and rent payments by year: a store. Expenses under the standard are above rent at the start of the term and below at the end; over the whole term expenses under the standard exceed rent exactly by the direct costs of signing.
- positive
- negative
- total
Data as a table
| Step | Change | Level |
|---|---|---|
| Rent in costs | +9,600 | 9,600 |
| Interest | −5,005 | 4,595 |
| Depreciation of the right | −6,635 | −2,040 |
| Profit effect | — | −2,040 |
From rent in costs to interest and depreciation: year one of a store. EBITDA grows by the whole rent while profit before tax changes by the difference between rent and expenses under the standard.
Specifics by category
- Apparel
- Apparel: large areas and long contracts in malls; the liability is large so the choice of rate and the term with extension matter; revenue seasonality does not change the liability schedule.
- Footwear
- Footwear: smaller area, lower stock turnover and a higher share of rent in revenue; the effect on EBITDA is relatively noticeable, check covenants.
- Accessories
- Accessories: kiosks and small formats with short contracts; more often fall under the short-term lease simplification if the term is up to 12 months and the approach is fixed in the accounting policy.
- Kids
- Kids: rent for a play area and a large floor, often with a variable part; do not include the variable part in the liability and expense it as incurred.
- Men
- Men: formats with smaller areas and steady traffic; indexation is more often fixed and convenient to include in the liability when its size is known.
- Women
- Women: the largest floors and fit-outs; a large share of costs goes through capital investments, so the useful life of the fit-out and the lease term must be aligned so as not to depreciate longer than the contract.
Common mistakes
- VAT is included in the liability → the liability is overstated → take payments excl. VAT and account for VAT under tax rules.
- The rate is taken by feel → the liability and interest do not match the audit → confirm the rate with bank offers for a comparable term.
- Celebrating EBITDA growth → forgetting interest and depreciation → look at profit, cash flow and covenants together.
- Depreciating the fit-out longer than the lease term → an unexpected write-off at closing → align the useful life and the contract term.
- Not keeping a register of contracts → not recomputing on extension and indexation → introduce a register and a review date for each contract.
Russian specifics
- FSBU 25/2018 “Lease accounting”: Ministry of Finance Order of 16.10.2018 No. 208n, mandatory from 2022 reporting; check the simplifications for short-term and low-value leases and the composition of payments with the text. Rule: Order 208n of 16.10.2018: Ministry of Finance Order of 16.10.2018 No. 208n (FSBU 25/2018 Lease accounting).
- FSBU 6/2020 “Fixed assets” and FSBU 26/2020 “Capital investments”: Ministry of Finance Order of 17.09.2020 No. 204n, mandatory from 2022 reporting; thresholds and terms are set by the accounting policy.
- The accounting law of 06.12.2011 No. 402-FZ: the accounting policy is approved by the head, the methods of recognition and measurement are fixed in it. Rule: Law 402-FZ of 06.12.2011: Federal Law of 06.12.2011 No. 402-FZ on accounting.
- Brand: a small business’s accounts may follow simplified methods; check with an accountant whether the standards in simplified form are admissible for your organization.
- Retailer: in Belarus and Kazakhstan IFRS or national standards apply, Armenia and Kyrgyzstan have their own practice; carrying over the Russian approach without checking local norms is not admissible.