Syntha Lab RU

Lease or buy: present value after tax and the break-even rate

Compares buying equipment (warehouse, workshop, shop) and leasing with a buyout by the present value of costs after corporate income tax, calculates the effective lease rate, the discount rate at which the schemes are equal and cumulative costs by month.

Cash and working capital For whom: Chief financial officers and owners before buying equipment, vehicles, warehouse machinery.

Calculate on your data →

At a glance

What question does it answer?
What is cheaper in present money after tax: buying or leasing with a buyout, and what the real lease rate is.
What data is needed?
The asset price excl. VAT, the term, the market value at the end.
How to read the result?
Example on the default values (equipment of RUB 6 million, 36 months): the present value of buying is RUB 3.71 million, of leasing RUB 3.24 million, a difference of −RUB 474,696; total lease payments RUB 7.56 million, the effective lease rate 20.9% a year, the schemes are equal at a rate of 12.9%. Example on the default values: Present value of costs: buying: RUB 3.71 million; Present value of costs: leasing: RUB 3.24 million; Difference: leasing minus buying: −RUB 474,696; Advantage of the cheaper scheme: RUB 474,696 · leasing. The figures are illustrative: enter your own to see your result.

Why and how to reason

Comparing leasing and buying by the sum of payments is not possible: money is paid at different times, the tax effect differs, and at the end of the term you get different assets. So both options are brought to a single moment and counted by cost after corporate income tax. Buying: you pay the price of 6 million, receive a tax saving on depreciation (tax × monthly depreciation), and at the end sell the asset for 3 million and pay tax on the difference between sale and residual value. Leasing: an advance of 20%, a payment every month, a buyout at the end, payments reduce tax. At a discount rate of 20% the present value of buying is 3.71 million and of leasing 3.24 million: leasing is cheaper by 475 thousand. The sum of payments of 7.56 million (an overpayment of 1.56 million) does not matter: leasing wins through tax and time.

When to use it

Use it when choosing how to obtain equipment, vehicles or premises for a warehouse or workshop. Do not use it if you have no free money or credit for buying: availability decides the choice, not mathematics. Check leasing terms and tax rules against the contract and current norms. Assumptions: the discount rate is yours, the asset is sold at market price, tax is paid on time.

How to read the result

Compare the two present values and look at the “Discount rate at which the schemes are equal” (12.9%): if your rate is higher, leasing wins, if lower, buying. Here your 20% is above the equality point, so leasing. The effective rate of leasing (20.9%) shows its price as a loan: compare it with the loan rate. The market value at the end of the term moves the result strongly: test it with a conservative figure. Tax matters: if you pay tax under a simplified regime, the tax shield does not work and the conclusion may change. It is worth testing sensitivity to the market price at the end of the term: if the conclusion changes when it drops by a quarter, the scheme is fragile, and you should choose by risk.

Common mistakes

The usual mistakes: comparing sums of payments, not entering the advance and buyout, taking the price with VAT, forgetting insurance and maintenance, overstating residual value. If tax in your regime is not reduced by payments, set the tax rate to zero and recalculate. Do not compare schemes with different buyout and insurance terms: bring them to the same scope of service.

What data is needed?

  • The asset price excl. VAT, the term, the market value at the end.
  • The advance, monthly payment and buyout price from the contract.
  • The discount rate, corporate income tax and depreciation life.

Inputs

FieldUnitValue in the exampleMeaning
Asset price excl. VAT₽6,000,000The purchase price excl. VAT; value added tax is not part of the calculation. The example value is illustrative.
Termmonths36The lease term and the comparison horizon.
Market value at the end of the term₽3,000,000What the asset can sell for after the term. Your estimate; for shop equipment usually far below the price. The example value is illustrative.
Depreciation lifeyears7Over how many years the cost is written off in equal parts when buying. Check the group and life with an accountant.
Advance% of price20The share of the price paid at the start. The example value is illustrative.
Monthly payment₽175,000The payment excl. VAT per the contract schedule. The example value is illustrative.
Buyout price₽60,000The amount at the end of the contract for the transfer of ownership.
Discount rate% per year20What money costs you: a loan rate or the required return. Your estimate. The example value is illustrative.
Corporate income tax%25The rate at which payments and depreciation reduce tax. Under a simplified regime on revenue set zero. Check the regime with an accountant.

How it is calculated

StepFormula
Monthly rate(1 + r)^(1/12) − 1
Buying−price; + tax × monthly depreciation; at the end + sale − tax × (sale − book value)
Leasing−advance × (1 − tax); −payment × (1 − tax); at the end −buyout + sale − tax × (sale − buyout)
Present value−Σ flow ÷ (1 + monthly rate)^month

Worked numbers

Default values from the app; in the interactive version you enter your own.

Present value of costs: buying
3.71 m ₽
Present value of costs: leasing
3.24 m ₽
Difference: leasing minus buying
−474,696 ₽Minus means leasing is cheaper in present money.
Advantage of the cheaper scheme
474,696 ₽ · leasing
Total lease payments
7.56 m ₽Advance, payments and buyout before tax.
Lease overpayment over the price
1.56 m ₽
Effective lease rate per year
20.9 %The internal rate of return of the pre-tax flows: the price less the advance received, payments and buyout paid.
Discount rate at which the schemes are equal
12.9 %
Book value at the end when buying
3.43 m ₽
Cumulative costs after tax
Line chart: Buying: 6m → 2.25m; Leasing: 900k → 3.42m02m4m6m0102030Buying, 0: 6mBuying, 36: 2.25mLeasing, 0: 900kLeasing, 36: 3.42m₽Month
  • Buying
  • Leasing
Data as a table
MonthBuyingLeasing
06m900k
25.96m1.16m
45.93m1.43m
65.89m1.69m
85.86m1.95m
105.82m2.21m
125.79m2.48m
145.75m2.74m
165.71m3m
185.68m3.26m
205.64m3.53m
225.61m3.79m
245.57m4.05m
265.54m4.31m
285.5m4.58m
305.46m4.84m
325.43m5.1m
345.39m5.36m
362.25m3.42m

In present money leasing is cheaper: payments are spread and the tax shield from payments is faster than the one from depreciation.

Value added tax, insurance, maintenance, penalties and the contract’s payment structure are not modelled here. Check lease accounting (at the lessee or the lessor) and the rates with an accountant or a tax adviser. For footwear and children’s equipment (lasts, moulds) has its own depreciation and residual value.

Nuances and limits

  • Comparing payment totals without discounting: money at different times is worth differently.
  • Forgetting the market value at the end: it can decide the comparison.
  • Counting the tax shield without checking the accounting treatment with an accountant.

Terms used

Calculate on your data →