Provision for inventory impairment: FSBU 5/2019, IAS 2, net realizable value
Determines how far stock on the balance sheet exceeds what it can be sold for, and how much loss must be recognized in advance. It shows the real value of old-collection stock and the hidden loss in it; it is used to decide whether to create a provision, how large, and when to cut the price or clear the goods.
Why this document
Stock in the books stands at cost, but if it will be sold below cost after a markdown, the loss already exists and just has not been shown. So the chief accountant and finance director calculate the provision, and the owner, the bank and the auditor read it: for them it is an honest valuation of stock. Without a provision profit is overstated and last season’s collection ties up working capital. Net realizable value is therefore estimated on real discounts and timing, not on the list price.
At a glance
- What is this document and why is it needed?
- Determines how far stock on the balance sheet exceeds what it can be sold for, and how much loss must be recognized in advance. It shows the real value of old-collection stock and the hidden loss in it; it is used to decide whether to create a provision, how large, and when to cut the price or clear the goods.
- Who owns the document and how often is it rebuilt?
- Chief accountant and CFO with the head of buying; computed at each reporting date (month, quarter, year) by age and expected price, approved by a committee.
- What mistakes are the most common?
- NRV computed with VAT → provision understated → expected price excl. VAT. Selling costs not deducted → NRV overstated → commission, logistics, marking of stock. An average provision for the whole warehouse → profit on some groups offsets losses on others → compute by item or similar group.
For whom
- Brand
- The brand values finished goods, raw materials and fabrics: finished goods at net realizable value after markdown, raw materials by usefulness for future collections; fabric impairment is often tied to fashion change and MOQs.
- Retail
- The retailer values goods for resale by merchandise group and season; the basis is usually age buckets of stock and the clearance plan, with impairment growing each season unsold.
What it consists of
The rule
- FSBU 5/2019 “Inventories” (Ministry of Finance order of 15.11.2019 No. 180n): at the reporting date inventories are carried at the lower of actual cost and net realizable value (para. 28; text not checked); the excess of cost over NRV is a provision for impairment (para. 30; text not checked).
- Net realizable value = expected selling price excl. VAT − costs to complete and sell (platform commission, logistics, repacking, marking of stock).
- IAS 2: inventories at the lower of cost and NRV; item-by-item or grouped when similar; reversal when NRV rises, but not above original cost.
Taxes and accounting
- For corporate income tax a provision for impairment of inventories does not reduce the tax base (the Tax Code provides a doubtful-debt reserve, Art. 266, but not an inventory impairment reserve): a temporary difference and a deferred tax asset arise.
- The actual tax relief arises on write-off or sale below cost.
What each side does
- Brand: values finished goods, fabric and trims separately: for raw materials the useful life depends on whether they will enter future collections, and the reserve is built per group, not on the total balance.
- Retailer: computes net realizable value by season age buckets and clearance channels (outlet, off-price, commission); deducts the platform commission and logistics from the price excl. VAT.
- Brand: for consignment stock at partners the owner, that is the brand, makes the reserve until the goods are sold; takes the data for the estimate from the partner reports.
- Retailer: on commission does not make a reserve for goods that are not its stock; on a buyout makes and recomputes it at each reporting date.
Control questions on the reserve
- Is the price in the net realizable value calculation based on real clearances of past seasons and on current platform tariffs?
- Was the reserve recomputed at the last reporting date and reversed where the selling value rose?
- Is deferred tax accounted for and does the owner understand that the reserve reduces accounting profit but not the tax base?
Brand and retailer: what differs in practice
- Brand: values finished goods, fabrics and trims separately: raw materials are checked for use in future collections, not by the fabric market price.
- Brand: leftovers of past seasons at commission customers are valued by expected return and reallocation, not at the sale price.
- Brand: uses the plan of clearance channels (outlet, sale, rework, liquidator) when estimating the expected price.
- Brand: settles the question of factory margin and return of fabric to the supplier before creating a reserve for raw materials.
- Retailer: values goods by merchandise groups and age buckets of stock, impairment grows with each season without a sale.
- Retailer: uses past sales as expected prices and platform tariffs as selling costs.
- Retailer: recomputes the reserve at each reporting date and reconciles it with the markdown schedule so as not to book the reserve twice.
How to read the result and what decisions follow
- If the reserve share grows period after period, purchases outrun sales: look at buying seasonality and size-run depth, not only price.
- A group where NRV is below cost shows which leftovers must be cleared faster before the sale price falls further.
- Decision: a leftover clearance plan with dates and channels, a buying limit by age bucket, price review for groups with a negative gap.
Where the data comes from
| Data source | Fields |
|---|---|
| Stock snapshot by age | SKU, quantity, unit cost (incl. landed cost), receipt date |
| Clearance plan and prices | expected price excl. VAT, sell-through date |
| Selling costs | commission, logistics, rework |
How to build it step by step
- Retailer: Step 1: Split stock by season and age, exclude goods in transit.
- Step 2: For each group set the expected selling price excl. VAT (after the planned markdown).
- Step 3: Deduct selling costs to get NRV.
- Step 4: Compare with cost and compute the provision by group.
- Retailer: Step 5: Test assumptions: sell-through window, past-season prices, channels (outlet, off-price, commission).
- Step 6: Book the provision; recompute at each reporting date and reverse when NRV rises.
- Brand: Step 7: Compute deferred tax and show the owner the profit effect.
- Retailer: Step 8: Prepare a report by age buckets: stock, net realizable value, reserve, change against the previous period.
- Brand: Step 9: Separately revisit the reserve for fabric and trims before closing a collection and decide what goes into the new collection and what to sell.
Formulas
| Measure | Formulas | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Net realizable value | NRV = Expected price excl. VAT × (1 − Selling cost %) | Price excl. VAT: VAT is not the company’s income. |
| Provision | Provision = Qty × max(0; Cost − NRV) | Computed by group but position-aware: a gain on one item does not offset a loss on another. |
| Deferred tax asset | DTA = Provision × Corporate income tax rate | The 25% rate is from the registry. |
| Net realizable value of a group | NRV = Expected price excl. VAT × (1 − Commission − Logistics, %) − Preparation and marking cost per unit | Take the price after the planned markdown, not the season price tag. |
| Group reserve and deferred tax | Reserve = Σ max(0; Cost − NRV) × Quantity; DTA = Reserve × 25% | Example: a RUB 1,000,000 reserve gives a deferred tax asset of RUB 250,000 at 25% (Art. 284); PBU 18/02 applies; check the way it is applied against its current edition (unverified). |
Formulas in notation
- Reserve for a group
R = max(0; C − NRV) × Q
C unit cost, Q stock. The reserve is never negative: an excess of NRV over C is not recognized as profit. Example for dresses: RUB 256,000.- Reserve share
r = ΣR / Σ(C × Q)
Example: 21.0% of the book value of stock. Split by age and category.- Reserve reversal
ΔR = R_open − R_close if NRV rose
If the realizable value rose the reserve is reduced by no more than the amount previously created.
Worked example
Past-collection stock: prices and selling costs are expectations, VAT excluded
| Group | Qty | Cost per unit | NRV per unit | Provision, RUB | Provision, % of cost |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Dresses SS25 | 400 | 2,400 | 1,760 | 256,000 | 26.7% |
| Footwear AW25 | 250 | 3,200 | 3,080 | 30,000 | 3.8% |
| Accessories | 600 | 500 | 616 | 0 | 0.0% |
| Kids SS25 | 300 | 1,100 | 720 | 114,000 | 34.5% |
| Outerwear | 150 | 5,200 | 3,432 | 265,200 | 34.0% |
| Total | 1,700 | 3,170,000 | 665,200 | 21.0% | |
| Deferred tax asset 25% | 166,300 |
Accessories and footwear (NRV above cost) need no provision: a loss on one group is not offset by profit on another. Illustrative figures.
Figures
- Unit cost
- Net realizable value
Data as a table
| Measure | Unit cost | Net realizable value |
|---|---|---|
| Dresses SS25 | 2,400 | 1,760 |
| Footwear AW25 | 3,200 | 3,080 |
| Accessories | 500 | 616 |
| Kids SS25 | 1,100 | 720 |
| Outerwear | 5,200 | 3,432 |
Unit cost and net realizable value by group. A reserve is needed where the cost bar is above the net realizable value bar. Net realizable value is the expected price less selling costs (illustrative values).
- positive
- negative
- total
Data as a table
| Step | Change | Level |
|---|---|---|
| Stock at cost | — | 3.17m |
| Dresses SS25 | −256k | 2.91m |
| Footwear AW25 | −30k | 2.88m |
| Kids SS25 | −114k | 2.77m |
| Outerwear | −265k | 2.5m |
| Stock net of the reserve | — | 2.5m |
From stock on the balance sheet to stock net of the reserve. The group reserves are subtracted from the book value; groups with cost below net realizable value need no reserve. The reserve of RUB 665,200 is 21.0% of book value.
Specifics by category
- Apparel
- Apparel: the provision grows with stock age; the next season lowers price by 30–60%, but the term and % come from your plan, not from the market.
- Footwear
- Footwear: size tail stock sells worse; value full size runs and tails separately. Footwear ages more slowly than clothing but the size run breaks quickly: the reserve is based on run completeness, not age alone.
- Accessories
- Accessories: lose price more slowly, so the provision is smaller; only obsolete lines are hit. Accessories are largely non-seasonal but fashion in shape and color makes part of the stock dead: put them in a separate bucket.
- Kids
- Kids: quickly outgrown, so an age-based provision is more conservative; certificate and marking affect saleability. Kids wear loses value by age group: stock in a toddler size does not sell after the next season.
- Men
- Men: basics hold their price and the provision is lower; fashion items behave as women’s.
- Women
- Women: strong seasonality and fashion content, higher provision; compute trend groups separately.
Common mistakes
- NRV computed with VAT → provision understated → expected price excl. VAT.
- Selling costs not deducted → NRV overstated → commission, logistics, marking of stock.
- An average provision for the whole warehouse → profit on some groups offsets losses on others → compute by item or similar group.
- A “same as last year” estimate without price checks → the provision ignores the market → review against actual sales.
- The price comes from the season tag, not after clearance → the reserve is understated → compute from the real clearance price.
- The reserve is made on the total balance, not by groups → good stock hides bad stock → compute by season and category.
- The reserve is not recomputed after the clearance forecast changes → profit is overstated until year end → recompute at every reporting date and after major price-cut decisions.
- The tax effect of the reserve is not shown to the owner → surprise at inspection → show accounting profit and the tax base separately.
Russian specifics
- FSBU 5/2019, order of 15.11.2019 No. 180n: lower of cost and NRV (para. 28), definition of NRV (para. 29), provision (para. 30), not checked against the text; the order text was not checked. Rule: Order 180n of 15.11.2019: Ministry of Finance Order of 15.11.2019 No. 180n (FSBU 5/2019 Inventories) (rule check not completed).
- The inventory impairment provision is not deductible for corporate income tax (doubtful-debt reserve: Tax Code Art. 266); the temporary difference goes to deferred tax under PBU 18/02 (in the current Ministry of Finance edition; check the exact paragraphs and the recalculation on a rate change against the text, unverified). Rule: Tax Code Art. 266: Tax Code, Art. 266 (doubtful debt reserves) (rule check not completed).
- IAS 2: lower of cost and NRV, reversal; not checked against the standard text.
- Impairment testing under FSBU 5/2019 is done at each reporting date by inventory groups; the grouping decision and price assumptions go into the accounting policy (paras 28-30 were not checked against the order text). Rule: Order 180n of 15.11.2019: Ministry of Finance Order of 15.11.2019 No. 180n (FSBU 5/2019 Inventories) (rule check not completed).