Revenue recognition: commission, agency, supply, returns
Defines how much revenue, and when, appears in the brand’s and the retailer’s accounts: under supply, commission, agency and after returns. Corporate income tax, turnover and gross margin depend on it; the document is used to decide in which period and in what amount sales are recorded.
Why this document
The same shipment can be shown as full revenue or only as a fee, and that changes tax, margin and market comparison. So the chief accountant, the finance director and the auditor read the document: they decide who is the principal and who the agent in the deal, and when the goods count as sold. If revenue recognition is not agreed, the brand and the retailer show different figures for one deal. The rule is therefore fixed before the scheme starts and applied consistently, not picked to suit the reporting period.
At a glance
- What is this document and why is it needed?
- Defines how much revenue, and when, appears in the brand’s and the retailer’s accounts: under supply, commission, agency and after returns. Corporate income tax, turnover and gross margin depend on it; the document is used to decide in which period and in what amount sales are recorded.
- Who owns the document and how often is it rebuilt?
- Chief accountant; the policy sits in the accounting policy and is reviewed before month-end and year-end; FSBU 9/2025 is mandatory for 2027 reporting.
- What mistakes are the most common?
- The agent shows the full price as revenue → revenue overstated, margin understated, corporate income tax and contributions on a wrong base → recognize the fee. The principal nets the fee against revenue → revenue and VAT understated → fee into selling expenses, VAT on the fee claimed as input. Revenue recognized on shipment to the agent → recognized before the sale → recognize on the date of sale to the buyer per the report.
For whom
- Brand
- A brand acting as principal recognizes the full sale price to the buyer (excl. VAT) on the date of the agent’s sale; the commission goes into selling expenses and does not reduce revenue.
- Retail
- A retailer acting as commission agent recognizes only the fee; receipts from buyers for the principal are not income (PBU 9/99 para. 3, Tax Code Art. 251). A retailer on a buyout recognizes the full price to the customer.
What it consists of
Who recognizes what
- The statement “the agent’s revenue is the full price” is wrong: under Russian rules the commission agent’s revenue equals its fee; the full sale price is the principal’s revenue. Exception: an intermediary that in substance acts as principal (below).
- Accounting: PBU 9/99 (para. 3: receipts under commission and agency contracts for the principal are not income); from 2027 FSBU 9/2025 (Ministry of Finance order of 16.05.2025 No. 56n) replaces PBU 9/99, with a principal-or-agent test on substance, not on the contract name.
- Corporate income tax: the agent’s income is the fee (Tax Code Art. 251(1)(9): property received under a commission contract is not income); the principal’s on the date of sale (Art. 249).
- Brand: VAT: the principal charges VAT on the full price on the date of shipment to the buyer; the agent charges VAT on the fee (Tax Code Art. 156).
- Simplified tax, “income”: the agent counts the fee; the principal pays on the full proceeds from buyers (Ministry of Finance position; the letter details are not confirmed).
When a retailer may be principal
- Retailer: Principal indicators: controls the goods before transfer, sets the price, bears inventory and return risk; then revenue is gross. Agent indicators: price set by the brand, no inventory risk, fee is a percentage.
- Retailer: The logic follows the IFRS 15 principal-versus-agent test (B34 onwards); the exact FSBU 9/2025 paragraphs were not opened.
Principal or agent: what each side checks
- Brand: checks who in substance controls the goods before the buyer: if the partner sets the price and bears stock and return risk, the brand recognizes a sale to the partner on shipment; if not, brand revenue arises on the sale to the buyer.
- Retailer: checks the reverse: whether it acts as agent (price set by the brand, no stock risk, a percentage fee) and then shows only the fee, or as principal and then the full price; the conclusion goes into the accounting policy for each contract type.
Control questions before use
- Does brand revenue per agent reports equal the sum of sale prices excl. VAT, and does the fee equal the rate times sales?
- Is the “principal or agent” conclusion recorded in the accounting policy for each contract type, and is it revisited when terms change?
- Is the transition to FSBU 9/2025 prepared for 2027 reporting: a list of contracts where the conclusion may change?
Brand and retailer: what differs in practice
- Brand: on sale through a commission agent recognizes revenue on the date of sale to the customer on the basis of the report, not on the shipment date.
- Brand: books the agent fee as selling expense and reconciles the rate with the amount in each report.
- Brand: keeps goods at the agent in separate records as shipped and unsold so that stock agrees with the report.
- Brand: for supply with a right of return estimates expected returns and reserves for them, reducing revenue.
- Retailer: decides for each contract whether it is principal or agent: price, control of goods and stock risk set the conclusion and revenue scale.
- Retailer: on an agent conclusion shows only the fee in revenue and keeps the principal goods off balance.
- Retailer: accounts for loyalty programs and gift cards as a liability: part of the sale price goes to points and revenue is recognized on redemption.
- Retailer: counts customer returns and the return reserve by channel and season, not one percentage for the company.
How to read the result and what decisions follow
- If revenue under an agent conclusion is many times lower than under a principal conclusion, margins and turnover cannot be compared between companies with different conclusions.
- A gap between revenue in the agent report and the brand ledger is a signal: either returns are not reflected or a shipment is booked as a sale.
- Decision: record the principal-or-agent conclusion in the accounting policy for each contract type and review it when terms change.
Control checks
- Revenue equals the sum of sale prices excl. VAT in the reports and the fee equals the rate times this sum.
- The stock at the agent at period end equals opening stock plus shipments minus sales minus returns.
- The liability for points and cards at period end equals issued minus used minus the part recognized as unused.
Where the data comes from
| Data source | Fields |
|---|---|
| Commission or supply contract, agent reports | price, rate, date of sale, returns |
| POS and marketplace data | sales, returns, platform fee |
| Warehouse records | stock at the agent, cost |
How to build it step by step
- Step 1: For each contract decide who is principal in substance (control, price, risk).
- Step 2: Record in the accounting policy the recognition method and date (shipment, sale to buyer, agent report).
- Brand: Step 3: Principal: recognize revenue on the date of sale to the buyer per the report; the fee goes into selling expenses.
- Retailer: Step 4: Agent: recognize the fee; keep the cash received in settlements with the principal.
- Step 5: Compute VAT separately at each party and reconcile invoices.
- Step 6: Returns and adjustments: document returns-acc; a provision for expected returns where a return right exists.
- Brand: Step 7: Reconcile: brand revenue equals the sum of sale prices in reports; fee = rate × sales.
Formulas
| Measure | Formulas | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Brand: Principal revenue | Rev = Sold × Price_incl_VAT / (1 + VAT) | VAT 22% under Tax Code Art. 164; kids goods 10% (see vat). |
| Retailer: Agent revenue | Agent rev = Rate × Sale price / (1 + VAT) | The rate base (with or without VAT) follows the contract. |
| Retailer: Agent turnover distortion | Overstatement = Sale price excl. VAT / Fee excl. VAT | Shows how many times “revenue” grows and gross margin falls if booked wrongly. |
Formulas in notation
- Brand revenue on sale through an agent
R = Q_s × P / (1 + r)
Q_s units sold, P sale price incl. VAT, r VAT rate. Example: RUB 2,868,852.- Agent fee and revenue
A = k × R
k fee rate. Example: 30% × 2,868,852 = RUB 860,656.- Allocation of price to loyalty points
P_points = Price × SSP_points / (SSP_goods + SSP_points)
SSP is the relative stand-alone selling price. Illustrative example: 10,000 × 400 / 10,400 = RUB 384.62 (FSBU 9/2025 paragraphs not checked).
Worked example
Sold 700 pcs at RUB 5,000 incl. 22% VAT, fee 30%, cost RUB 1,500 (entries under the chart of accounts)
| Party and entry | Amount, RUB |
|---|---|
| Principal: Dr 76 Cr 90.1 revenue excl. VAT | 2,868,852 |
| Principal: Dr 90.3 Cr 68 VAT | 631,148 |
| Principal: Dr 90.2 Cr 41/45 cost | 1,050,000 |
| Principal: Dr 44 Cr 76 fee excl. VAT; Dr 19 Cr 76 VAT | 860,656 / 189,344 |
| Agent: Dr 76 Cr 90.1 fee excl. VAT | 860,656 |
| Agent: Dr 90.3 Cr 68 VAT on fee | 189,344 |
| Agent: remitted to the principal (Dr 76 Cr 51) | 2,450,000 |
| Agent “revenue” if booked wrongly / correct, times | 2,868,852 / 860,656 = 3.33 |
Entries follow the standard chart of accounts (Ministry of Finance order No. 94n), not checked against the text; figures are computed in code from price, rate and VAT.
Figures
When revenue is recognized: principal and agent. Shipment to an agent is not brand revenue; revenue arises on sale to the customer, the agent fee is a brand expense or the agent own revenue.
- Shipment to the agent → Sale to the customer; Brand: no revenue yet
- Sale to the customer → Agent report; Brand: revenue, fee as expense
- Agent report → Transfer of proceeds; Agent: revenue equals the fee
- Transfer of proceeds
- Brand: no revenue yet
- Brand: revenue, fee as expense
- Agent: revenue equals the fee
Data as a table
| Measure | Retailer revenue |
|---|---|
| As agent | 861k |
| As principal | 2.87m |
Retailer revenue under two conclusions: agent and principal. If the retailer acts as an agent its revenue is the fee; if as principal, the whole sale price. The conclusion sets the revenue scale and all ratios based on it. Sold 700 pcs at RUB 4,098 excl. VAT, fee 30%. Illustrative figures.
- positive
- negative
- total
Data as a table
| Step | Change | Level |
|---|---|---|
| Revenue | — | 2.87m |
| Agent fee | −861k | 2.01m |
| Cost of sold units | −1.05m | 958k |
| Result | — | 958k |
Brand result on sales through an agent. Revenue at the sale price, the agent fee and the cost of units sold.
Specifics by category
- Apparel
- Apparel: seasonality and returns: with a return right, a provision at the expected return.
- Footwear
- Footwear: high size-driven returns; for online sales the returns provision is better estimated from history. For footwear on a buyout size returns change the revenue estimate: the return reserve is computed by channel.
- Accessories
- Accessories: few returns, no difference in recognition; only the platforms' high commission share stands out.
- Kids
- Kids: 10% VAT for the principal (with a certificate on record, 218-FZ), 22% on the agent’s service fee; this creates a rate mismatch. In kids wear seasonal peaks coincide with the reporting date: check the revenue cut-off for shipments at period end.
- Men
- The rules of revenue recognition are the same; the difference is in the data. The men line returns less often and is replenished with basics more often, so the estimate of returns and revenue reversal is calmer; check your own history of returns by audience instead of taking one rate for the whole brand.
- Women
- The rules are the same, but the women line gives more returns for size and color and more markdowns: compute the return reserve and the revenue reversal separately for the women line and by season, otherwise period revenue will be overstated (an assumption, check against your data).
Common mistakes
- The agent shows the full price as revenue → revenue overstated, margin understated, corporate income tax and contributions on a wrong base → recognize the fee.
- The principal nets the fee against revenue → revenue and VAT understated → fee into selling expenses, VAT on the fee claimed as input.
- Revenue recognized on shipment to the agent → recognized before the sale → recognize on the date of sale to the buyer per the report.
- The contract name drives accounting → courts and inspectors look at substance → analyze control, price and risk.
- The “principal or agent” conclusion is made once for all customers → distorted revenue → assess per contract: price, control and stock risk.
Russian specifics
- FSBU 9/2025 “Income” was approved by Ministry of Finance order of 16.05.2025 No. 56n (the number 168n in the request is wrong); mandatory from 2027 reporting, early adoption allowed, replaces PBU 9/99. Rule: Order 56n of 16.05.2025: FSBU 9/2025 Income (Ministry of Finance order of 16.05.2025 No. 56n).
- Specific agent and commission rules in FSBU 9/2025: paragraph numbers not opened, the logic matches IFRS 15 (principal or agent). Rule: Order 56n of 16.05.2025: FSBU 9/2025 Income (Ministry of Finance order of 16.05.2025 No. 56n) (rule check not completed).
- Corporate income tax: the agent’s income is the fee (Tax Code Art. 251(1)(9)). Rule: Tax Code Art. 251: Tax Code, Art. 251 (income not taken into account for corporate income tax) (rule check not completed).
- Intermediary VAT on the fee: Tax Code Art. 156. Rule: Tax Code Art. 156: Tax Code, Art. 156 (VAT under intermediary contracts) (rule check not completed).
- VAT 22% from 01.01.2026 (425-FZ); for kids goods 10% applies from 01.10.2026 only when data on a certificate or declaration are in the register (218-FZ, checked against the act text); without such data the rate is 22%. Rule: Law 425-FZ of 28.11.2025: Federal Law of 28.11.2025 No. 425-FZ (amendments to parts one and two of the Tax Code; VAT 22%).
- Special rules for an agent and a commission agent in FSBU 9/2025: per unchecked data the assessment follows the substance of the contract (control of the goods before transfer to the buyer), not its name; the paragraph numbers of the standard were not checked. Rule: Order 56n of 16.05.2025: FSBU 9/2025 Income (Ministry of Finance order of 16.05.2025 No. 56n) (rule check not completed).