Accounting for defects, mis-sorts and stock losses: acts, liable parties, corporate income tax
Describes how to document discrepancies found by counting and receiving (defects, mis-sorts, shortages) and who pays: an employee, a carrier, a supplier or the company. It is used to decide what to write off, what to recover and how to reflect it in tax accounting, so the expense is accepted and the claim can be proved.
Why this document
A shortage cannot simply be written off: to recover from the liable party or have the expense accepted for corporate income tax, acts, deadlines and proof of cause are needed. So the accountant, security, the lawyer and the warehouse head read the document. They decide whether to claim from a supplier or carrier, whether to withhold from an employee and what to book as company loss. Without acts on time the claim fails and an audit will challenge the expense. Documentation therefore starts on the day of the discrepancy, not at the annual count.
At a glance
- What is this document and why is it needed?
- Describes how to document discrepancies found by counting and receiving (defects, mis-sorts, shortages) and who pays: an employee, a carrier, a supplier or the company. It is used to decide what to write off, what to recover and how to reflect it in tax accounting, so the expense is accepted and the claim can be proved.
- Who owns the document and how often is it rebuilt?
- Chief accountant, warehouse and security managers; scheduled stocktakes and on change of responsible person, acts within a week, summary in month-end close.
- What mistakes are the most common?
- Shortage written off without an act → the expense is disallowed on audit → committee and explanations. Mis-sorts netted across periods or prices → assessments → netting conditions. Deducted more from an employee than allowed → Labor Code breach → deduction limit.
For whom
- Brand
- The brand reconciles receipts from factories and shipments to partners, files claims against suppliers and carriers, accounts for production defects and natural loss within norms; post-acceptance defects at the customer fall under returns (returns-acc).
- Retail
- The retailer accounts for store and warehouse losses: theft, mis-sorts, damage, cashier errors; tools: stocktakes, video control, RFID, liability agreements and shrink analytics by store.
What it consists of
Documents
- Retailer: Stocktake order; inventory list (form INV-3) and reconciliation statement (form INV-19): unified forms are convenient but not mandatory.
- Brand: Defect act, receiving discrepancy act, explanations from liable persons, committee conclusion.
- Mis-sort: netting a surplus against a shortage is allowed under the Ministry of Finance position (not from the act text) when both were found in the same inventory period, for the same liable person and for the same product name; at different prices the netting is by quantity and the value difference is computed separately and treated as a shortage or surplus.
Who bears the loss
- Retailer: Culpable employee: compensation of direct actual damage (Labor Code Art. 238; full liability under a contract, Art. 243); deduction within the statutory limit (Art. 138).
- Brand: Supplier or carrier: claim under acts within the contract or Civil Code term; set-off against payment per contract.
- The company: write-off into expenses; corporate income tax allows losses within natural-loss norms (Tax Code Art. 254(7)) and other losses when supported (Art. 265).
What each side does about a shortage
- Retailer: runs scheduled stocktakes and cycle counts, issues a reconciliation statement, collects explanations from liable staff; separates a shortage within the natural-loss norm from the excess because the tax and management treatment differ.
- Brand: reconciles receipts from the factory and shipments to partners through discrepancy acts, files a claim with the supplier and carrier within the contract period; separates production defects from losses at the customer, which flow through returns.
- Retailer: for a mis-sort first nets similar items of the same liable person within one period and only then books the remaining difference as a shortage or surplus.
- Brand: on consignment and commission is responsible for safekeeping only until the goods are accepted by the retailer for custody; writes the safekeeping terms into the contract and the transfer act.
Control questions on shortages
- Is the base of the loss percentage the same in all reports (cost of goods sold) and is it named next to the figure?
- How many shortages were closed by mis-sort netting, how much was recovered from those at fault and how much was written off without evidence?
- Is there an act and an explanation from the liable person for every shortage above the threshold, and were claim periods to the supplier met?
Brand and retailer: what differs in practice
- Brand: receives goods from the factory and warehouse by quantity and quality with a discrepancy act on the day of receipt, otherwise the shortage cannot be claimed from the supplier.
- Brand: separates losses at the finished goods warehouse and in commission at the customer from losses of its own retail.
- Retailer: runs the stock count on schedule and when the accountable person changes, with an order, a sheet and explanations.
- Retailer: prevents shortages with inbound control, a recount on receipt and recording of transfers between stores.
How to read the result and what decisions follow
- The net loss percentage rises even with few units if mis-picks are not offset: check that surpluses are not booked separately from shortages.
- The structure of causes (records, supplier, staff, customers) shows where to invest: record errors are cured by process, theft by tags and security.
- Decision: an amount threshold above which an investigation is mandatory; a stock-count schedule by store risk; a plan of supplier claims with terms.
Control checks
- Book stock plus surpluses minus shortages equals the physical count for each item.
- The sum of write-offs, recoveries and offsets equals the total shortage in the sheet and no amount is counted twice.
Where the data comes from
| Data source | Fields |
|---|---|
| Warehouse system and WMS | book stock by SKU and size, movements |
| Count results | actual count, surplus, shortage |
| Contracts and job descriptions | liability, loss norms |
How to build it step by step
- Step 1: Freeze movement and count by SKU and size.
- Step 2: Compare with book stock, compute shortages and surpluses at cost.
- Step 3: Find mis-sorts (same price and period) and net them.
- Step 4: Obtain explanations from liable persons and draw up the committee act.
- Step 5: Identify culpable parties and recovery; decide what goes to expenses.
- Step 6: Book in accounting and taxes; check the VAT treatment of shortages with the accountant.
- Retailer: Step 7: Compute shrink % by store and compare with plan.
- Brand: Step 8: Take action: receiving control, RFID, cameras, rotation.
- Retailer: Step 9: Introduce a monthly store report: shortage, surplus, mis-sort netting, staff reimbursement, the remainder in expenses.
- Brand: Step 10: Keep a claims log against factories and carriers with deadlines and outcomes.
Formulas
| Measure | Formulas | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Retailer: Net shortage in units | Net = Shortage − Netted mis-sorts | Netting only for the same period, person and price. |
| Retailer: Shrink, % | Accounting basis: Shortage at cost / Turnover at cost. Lab KPI (single basis): Shortage at cost / Revenue excl. VAT | Lab gives no loss benchmark: no verified Russian data were found and foreign surveys do not work as a norm. Compute from your own stores; the base of the percentage is the cost of goods sold (as in the loss document), with any other base always name it. |
| Corporate income tax effect | Saving = Accepted expense × Rate | Only if the expense is accepted; without support it is disallowed. |
| Retailer: Mis-sort netting | Net shortage = Σ(Shortage_pcs × Price) − Σ(Surplus_pcs × Price); netting by quantity min(Shortage_pcs; Surplus_pcs) | Example: shortage 3 pcs at RUB 4,000 and surplus 3 pcs at RUB 3,500: 3 pcs are netted, the difference 3 × (4,000 − 3,500) = RUB 1,500 remains a shortage. |
| Retailer: Part of a shortage within the norm | Above norm = max(0; Shortage − Natural-loss norm × Turnover) | For clothing approved norms may not exist: then the whole shortage is treated as a loss under Arts. 252 and 265 of the Tax Code, provided it is evidenced. |
Formulas in notation
- Net shortage at equal price
N = (S − O) × C
S shortage, O surplus of the same item, C unit cost. Example: RUB 72,000.- Offset at different prices
N = S × C_s − O × C_o
Offset by quantity, the price difference is counted separately (the Ministry of Finance position, not the act text).- Loss percentage
p = N / COGS × 100%
COGS is the cost of goods sold in the period. Example: 1.20%. There are no norm benchmarks: compare with your own history.- Amount to recover
V = S_guilty × P_market
S_guilty is the part of the shortage caused by a person, P_market the price under labor law (procedure and grounds: unverified against the text).
Worked example
Stocktake: shortage 52 pcs, mis-sort surplus 12 pcs, cost RUB 1800, turnover RUB 6 million at cost
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Net shortage, pcs | 40 |
| Loss at cost, RUB | 72,000 |
| Losses, % of turnover at cost (accounting basis) | 1.2% |
| If a culpable person is found: recovery at retail excl. VAT, RUB | 163,934 |
| If none found: expense accepted when supported, RUB | 72,000 |
| Corporate income tax saving at 25% if accepted, RUB | 18,000 |
Recovery price under Labor Code Arts. 238 and 246 depends on market or book value, not below book; the example is simplified. The 25% rate is from the norm registry.
Figures
- positive
- negative
- total
Data as a table
| Step | Change | Level |
|---|---|---|
| Shortage | +93.6k | 93.6k |
| Offset of surplus | −21.6k | 72k |
| Net loss | — | 72k |
From the shortage to the net loss after offsetting mis-picks. The shortage at cost is reduced by surpluses of the same item, period and accountable person. Shortage 52 pcs, surplus 12 pcs, cost RUB 1,800 per unit. Illustrative figures.
The path of a shortage from the count to the decision. Order, count, reconciliation sheet, explanation of the accountable person, decision: offset, recovery or write-off.
- Stock-count order → Count and reconciliation sheet
- Count and reconciliation sheet → Explanation of the accountable person
- Explanation of the accountable person → Offset of mis-picks; Recovery from the guilty; Write-off to expenses
- Offset of mis-picks
- Recovery from the guilty
- Write-off to expenses
Data as a table
| Measure | % of cost of sales |
|---|---|
| Shortage before offset | 1.56 |
| Net loss after offset | 1.2 |
Loss as a share of the cost of sales. The base of the percentage is always the same: the cost of goods sold; a percentage of revenue gives different numbers.
Specifics by category
- Apparel
- Apparel: size and color discrepancies, mis-sorts when picking; RFID and size-level scanning reduce losses.
- Footwear
- Footwear: lost pairs, mismatched boxes, size mis-sorts; count in pairs.
- Accessories
- Accessories: small size and high value per gram raise theft; more cabinets and tags.
- Kids
- Kids: packaging damage, mis-sorts by age sizes, marking.
- Men
- The accounting mechanics are the same, the loss structure differs: in the men line damage and loss of large items (outerwear) are more frequent, color mix-ups are rarer; check shortages against the unit price, which is higher.
- Women
- The mechanics are the same, but in the women line the share of mix-ups by color and size is higher because of the number of SKUs and color variants; before netting surpluses and shortages make sure the goods are comparable by name and period (netting conditions are not checked against the text, unverified).
Common mistakes
- Shortage written off without an act → the expense is disallowed on audit → committee and explanations.
- Mis-sorts netted across periods or prices → assessments → netting conditions.
- Deducted more from an employee than allowed → Labor Code breach → deduction limit.
- Shrink held to a foreign “norm” without own data → blind spot → compute by store.
- Mis-sort is netted across different names and periods → extra tax and a dispute → one period, one liable person, one product name.
- Taking shrink from a foreign “industry norm” → targets that do not fit your chain → set the target from your own trend and stores of one format.
Russian specifics
- Liability: Labor Code Arts. 238, 243 (not checked against the text; not in the registry).
- Losses within natural-loss norms: Tax Code Art. 254(7); approved norms for clothing may be absent (not verified). Rule: Tax Code Art. 254: Tax Code, Art. 254 (material costs, natural-loss norms) (rule check not completed).
- Other losses and shortages: Tax Code Art. 265, justification under Art. 252. Rule: Tax Code Art. 252: Tax Code, Art. 252 (expenses: justification and classification) (rule check not completed).
- The main corporate income tax rate is 25% (Tax Code Art. 284, 176-FZ). Rule: Tax Code Art. 284: Tax Code, Art. 284 (corporate income tax rates).
- Recovery from an employee: full liability only under a contract and in cases set by law, direct actual loss without lost profit (Labor Code Arts. 238 and 243, not checked against the text); deduction from pay is limited by Art. 138.
- VAT on shortages: per unchecked data the previously deducted VAT on lost goods is restored unless the shortage is natural loss; Tax Code paragraphs were not opened, check with the accountant. Rule: Tax Code Art. 171: Tax Code, Art. 171 (VAT deductions) (rule check not completed).