Property and network: geomarketing, lease structure, formats, pop-ups
The document sets the order for choosing a site and lease: geomarketing (traffic, audience, competitors), the allowable rent from store economics, payment structure (fixed plus percentage of turnover, holidays, indexation and FX corridor), store formats and temporary pop-ups. Decision: whether to open a site, on what terms and in what format.
Why this document
The commercial and expansion directors read this when they choose a site, sign a lease or decide whether to close a store. It matters because rent is the most rigid cost: it is paid regardless of sales and the contract often runs for years. So the rate is tested against the store’s turnover and margin beforehand, not after opening. Fixed rent plus a percentage, rent-free periods and indexation change the payment more than the headline rate suggests. A pop-up lets you test a location cheaply before a long commitment.
At a glance
- What is this document and why is it needed?
- The document sets the order for choosing a site and lease: geomarketing (traffic, audience, competitors), the allowable rent from store economics, payment structure (fixed plus percentage of turnover, holidays, indexation and FX corridor), store formats and temporary pop-ups. Decision: whether to open a site, on what terms and in what format.
- Who owns the document and how often is it rebuilt?
- Maintained by the network development (expansion) director with the finance director and a lawyer; the opening decision is made by an investment committee from the site passport; the store portfolio and lease terms are reviewed yearly.
- What mistakes are the most common?
- Comparing rates at plan rather than across scenarios -> the store loses money when revenue falls -> compute return in three scenarios. Allowable rent taken as a target -> no margin for error -> working rate below the ceiling. Cannibalization not counted -> network turnover growth is below the passport -> estimate zone overlap.
For whom
- Brand
- For a brand a site is a showcase and channel: own stores, showrooms, pop-ups and department store corners. The allowable rent is computed from the store target role (image, profit, collection testing) and total effect on online in the region; a lower-return store for brand reasons is acceptable within a loss limit.
- Retail
- For a retailer rent is the main fixed cost item; the allowable rate follows from gross margin, store costs and target return; each site is decided on its passport (traffic, sales per m², payback) comparing format and city.
What it consists of
1. Geomarketing
- Catchment area (walking and transport access), traffic by hour and day, audience and its income, neighboring tenants and competitors, share of target audience in the zone; result: a turnover and conversion forecast for the site.
- Retailer: Cannibalization: how much the new site takes from existing stores and online in the overlapping zone.
2. Allowable rent
- Allowable rent = gross profit - store variable and operating costs - target return; expressed as a share of turnover and per square meter.
- This is a ceiling for negotiation, not a target: the working rate is lower by a margin for the turnover forecast error.
3. Rent structure
- Fixed part, percentage of turnover (with a threshold or as the greater of two), service and marketing charges, indexation, deposit, holidays (a period of reduced or zero rent after opening).
- FX corridor: pegging part of the rate to the exchange rate within bounds (floor and cap) that splits currency risk between the parties.
4. Store formats and pop-ups
- Flagship (image), standard store, small format, corner or shop-in-shop, outlet, showroom, pop-up; for each: area, sales per m², staff, investment, payback period.
- Retailer: Pop-up: from weeks to a few months, minimal investment, a test of location and demand; computed on the full period cost and turnover per day.
5. Site passport and portfolio
- Passport: turnover forecast, costs, return, payback of investment, sensitivity to turnover, risks (contract, neighbors, repairs).
- Retailer: Portfolio: stars, stable, loss-making; negative-return sites are tested for closure or renegotiation within the contract term.
6. Brand and retailer: what is computed when choosing a site
- Brand: The brand’s own retail: a store gives not only profit but also image and demand data; allowable rent is computed twice, as a point (P&L contribution) and as marketing (cost of presence), without mixing them.
- Retailer: A retailer store: what matters is the store contribution after rent, payroll and losses; the portfolio is judged by contribution per m² and return on investment, and loss-making points are revised under the contract.
- Brand: Brand showroom and flagship: sales per m² are lower but the role is in wholesale; showroom rent is compared with the effect on wholesale orders and content.
- Retailer: Brand corners and shop-in-shops inside a retailer: for the retailer this is a rental model, a percentage or commission on corner turnover; for the brand this is investment in fixtures and staff; terms are fixed by contract.
- Brand: A brand pop-up: a test of site and audience before a long lease; cost is counted at full cost of presence (installation, staff, rent, dismantling), not by the rate.
- Retailer: Closure and relocation: the retailer has an exit under the contract and a closure cost (dismantling, reserve for stock liquidation); the closure decision rests on the point’s annual contribution and outlook, not one season.
How to read the result and which decisions follow
- The allowed rent of a women store is 18.0% of turnover, or RUB 54,000 per m² per year. Accessories have a rate of RUB 252,000 per m², “Kids” RUB 31,200. Decision: a rent rate is carried not by the format as a whole but by turnover per meter and category margin; kids and footwear will not carry high rates.
- Retailer: the rent decision is taken on the allowed rate, not on the landlord offer: if the offered rate is above the allowed one, change the format, area or terms (percentage rent, holidays, indexation).
- Brand: own retail in an expensive location is justified as a showcase and a base of brand sales; count its payback together with the effect on online and wholesale, not only on store revenue.
- Retailer: the chart shows that turnover rent is safer when revenue falls, and fixed rent is better when it grows; the choice depends on confidence in store revenue.
- Brand: a pop-up and a department store corner give an entry ticket to a location without a long contract; the rate per meter is higher there, but the risk is limited by the term.
Control checks
- Check: allowed rent of RUB 49.32 m over the sum of categories on revenue of RUB 291.5 m equals 16.9% of turnover (code).
- Retailer: include service and marketing charges in rent; a rate without them understates the real burden.
- Brand: take revenue per meter from comparable stores and from sales, not from the landlord forecast.
- Retailer: lease accounting under FSBU 25/2018: variable payments are not part of the liability; check with the accountant (unverified).
- Brand: the payroll and other cost shares (9-12% in the example) are assumptions; substitute your own values.
Brand and retailer: further differences
- Brand: in the lease watch the exclusive rights of the tenant and the competitor restriction radius; an own store near a multi-brand retailer stocking your brand creates channel conflict.
Where the data comes from
| Data source | Fields |
|---|---|
| Footfall counters and tills | Entries, conversion, turnover, ticket by hour and day, sales per m² |
| Catchment data | Population and income, site traffic, competitors and neighbors, transport access |
| Draft lease | Rate, percentage, thresholds, indexation, holidays, term, deposit, termination terms |
| Store budget | Gross margin, payroll, other costs, opening investment, fit-out, equipment |
How to build it step by step
- Step 1. Build a catchment passport: traffic, audience, competitors, transport access.
- Step 2. Forecast sales per m² from analogs and from traffic with conversion; record three scenarios (downside, plan, upside).
- Step 3. Estimate cannibalization of existing stores and online in the zone.
- Step 4. Compute the allowable rent from gross margin, costs and target return.
- Step 5. Compare lease offers on store return in all three scenarios, not on the plan rate.
- Step 6. Check the structure: percentage threshold, holidays, indexation, FX peg, deposit, termination right.
- Step 7. Estimate investment (fit-out, equipment, stock) and payback period.
- Step 8. For doubtful sites choose a pop-up or small format instead of a full store.
- Step 9. Sign only with a clear exit (term, early termination conditions, loss cap).
- Retailer: Step 10. Reconcile actual with the passport quarterly and review the portfolio yearly.
- Brand: Step 11. Brand: separate flagship and showroom image costs from a point judged on return; compare a pop-up by full cost of presence.
- Retailer: Step 12. Retailer: recompute the allowable rate by store category (women, men, kids, footwear, accessories) and check that total rent does not exceed the category ceilings.
Formulas
| Measure | Formulas | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Retailer: Allowable rent share | Rent share = gross margin - payroll share - other costs share - target return | Shares are taken from store turnover; tested on three turnover scenarios. |
| Retailer: Rent per m² | Rate per m² = allowable rent / area | Compared with the market rates of the specific site, not with general ranges. |
| Retailer: Composite rent | Rent = fixed + percentage x max(turnover - threshold; 0) | The percentage shares turnover risk; compare with a fixed rent across scenarios. |
| Retailer: FX peg | Rent in roubles = rate x (1 + peg share x FX change within the corridor) | The corridor limits rises and falls; without a corridor the risk sits entirely with the tenant. |
| Retailer: Site payback | Payback = investment / annual store return before tax | Include stock and working capital. |
Formulas in notation
- Allowed rent share
ρ_max = GM − s_pay − s_oth − ROI
GM is gross margin, s_pay and s_oth the payroll and other cost shares, ROI the target return; all as fractions of turnover.- Allowed rate
r = ρ_max × Rev / Area
Rev is store revenue per year, Area the area; the result is in RUB per m² per year.- Turnover rent
Rent = B + p × max(Rev − BP, 0)
B is the base rent, p the percentage, BP the breakpoint on revenue.- Store margin
m = (Rev × (GM − s_pay − s_oth) − Rent) / Rev
Before tax and depreciation; compute by revenue scenarios.
Worked example
Exercise: allowable store rent by category at a 15% target return, RUB m a year
| Category | Area, m² | Sales per m², RUB k | Revenue | Gross margin | Allowable rent, % of turnover | Allowable rent | Rate, RUB per m² a year |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Women | 250 | 300 | 75.0 | 55% | 18.0% | 13.50 | 54,000 |
| Men | 200 | 280 | 56.0 | 53% | 18.0% | 10.08 | 50,400 |
| Kids | 300 | 240 | 72.0 | 52% | 13.0% | 9.36 | 31,200 |
| Footwear | 150 | 350 | 52.5 | 50% | 12.0% | 6.30 | 42,000 |
| Accessories | 40 | 900 | 36.0 | 62% | 28.0% | 10.08 | 252,000 |
| Total | 940 | 310 | 291.5 | 16.9% | 49.32 | 52,468 |
Notional: allowable rent = revenue × (gross margin − payroll − other − 15% target return). The women store equals the base example: 250 m², revenue RUB 75m, allowable rate RUB 54,000 per m². The allowable rate per m² differs several times: from RUB 31,200 in Kids to RUB 252,000 in Accessories: the small accessories area carries high sales per m². This is a ceiling for negotiation, not a target; the percentage part of rent shares risk, variable payments are not included in the lease liability under the Russian lease standard FSBU 25/2018 and are recognized as a period expense (unverified, check the wording). Inputs are exercise assumptions.
Figures
Data as a table
| Measure | Allowed rent |
|---|---|
| Women | 18 |
| Men | 18 |
| Kids | 13 |
| Footwear | 12 |
| Accessories | 28 |
Allowed rent as a percentage of turnover by category. The higher the gross margin and the lower the costs, the more rent a store carries: accessories carry three times footwear.
Data as a table
| Measure | Rate per m² per year |
|---|---|
| Women | 54k |
| Men | 50.4k |
| Kids | 31.2k |
| Footwear | 42k |
| Accessories | 252k |
Allowed rate per m² per year. The rate in roubles per square meter per year at a target return of 15%: accessories have small area and a high rate.
- positive
- negative
- total
Data as a table
| Step | Change | Level |
|---|---|---|
| Gross margin | +55 | 55 |
| Payroll | −11 | 44 |
| Other costs | −11 | 33 |
| Target return | −15 | 18 |
| Allowed rent | — | 18 |
What makes up the allowed rent of a women store. Payroll, other costs and the target return are taken from the 55% gross margin: the remainder is the allowed rent share.
- Fixed rent
- Base plus percentage
Data as a table
| Measure | Fixed rent | Base plus percentage |
|---|---|---|
| -30% | 13 | 18.1 |
| -20% | 15.5 | 18.5 |
| -10% | 17.4 | 18.8 |
| 0% | 19 | 19 |
| +10% | 20.3 | 19.2 |
| +20% | 21.3 | 19.3 |
| +30% | 22.2 | 19.5 |
Store margin under fixed and turnover-based rent. Turnover-based rent smooths a revenue fall; fixed rent gives more on growth. Horizontal axis: revenue change against plan.
Specifics by category
- Apparel
- Medium area and medium sales per m² (in the example 250 m² and RUB 300k per m², an assumption); traffic and neighbors decide. Percentage rent with a threshold fits when the turnover forecast is imprecise: if revenue falls 15%, the return under a fixed rate drops more. Seasonality shifts holiday months: rent holidays are placed on the ramp-up period, not the sales peak. Test the allowable rate on three scenarios, not on the plan.
- Footwear
- Space is needed for box stock and a fitting zone: size stock takes room, so sales per m² are lower than in apparel while the ticket is higher (in the example 150 m² and RUB 350k per m², an assumption). A run of 11 sizes per style-color needs storage depth: part of the area works as a warehouse, and the allowable rate should be computed separately on the useful selling area. A small format with online pick-up saves space, but fit returns will come to the store.
- Accessories
- Small area and high sales per m² (in the example 40 m² and RUB 900k, an assumption): the allowable rate per m² is several times that of apparel while absolute rent is small. Corners, kiosks, shop-in-shops and pop-ups fit; footfall and the window decide. Expensive jewelry needs security and insurance, which raises other costs, and gift seasonality compresses sales into a few months, so percentage rent with a threshold beats a fixed rate.
- Kids
- A family zone is needed: prams, bigger fitting rooms, a play corner, so area is larger (in the example 300 m² and RUB 240k per m², an assumption) and sales per m² are lower. The site depends on districts with a child audience and the school season: a peak before 1 September and another in November-December. The contract must reflect the peaks: indexation and turnover payments are counted by month so that seasonal weeks do not eat the return. A 6 cm height run affects stock: storage reserve is needed.
- Men
- The audience spends less time in the store and buys on impulse less, so accessibility is needed: transit, office centers, parking (in the example 200 m² and RUB 280k per m², an assumption). Demand is steadier, so a fixed rent is risky at weak traffic but less season-sensitive. A tailoring service and a suits zone take space and count as a separate income line. Test a traffic fall in business districts as a separate scenario.
- Women
- Visit frequency is higher and so is dependence on malls with weekend traffic; rent must absorb seasonal swings and markdown periods. Corners and pop-ups are useful for testing trend capsules: a term from weeks to a few months at minimal investment. Discount sensitivity is higher, so percentage-of-turnover payments work against you during sales: compute rent on turnover after price cuts. The allowable rate in the example uses gross margin without discounts.
Common mistakes
- Comparing rates at plan rather than across scenarios -> the store loses money when revenue falls -> compute return in three scenarios.
- Allowable rent taken as a target -> no margin for error -> working rate below the ceiling.
- Cannibalization not counted -> network turnover growth is below the passport -> estimate zone overlap.
- A lease without an exit -> a loss-making site cannot be closed -> early termination terms and a loss cap.
- FX peg without a corridor -> a rising rate lifts rent without limit -> a corridor or a cap on the peg share.
Russian specifics
- Lease accounting for the lessee is governed by FSBU 25/2018: the right-of-use asset and lease liability are recognized on the balance sheet (except permitted exceptions); this affects debt metrics and return calculations. Rule: Order 208n of 16.10.2018: Ministry of Finance Order of 16.10.2018 No. 208n (FSBU 25/2018 Lease accounting).
- The lease is governed by the Civil Code (part two); indexation, termination and deposit terms are set by agreement within the law. Rule: Civil Code part 2: Civil Code, part two (including Arts. 513, 713, 990, 1027) (rule check not completed).
- Check FX pegging of rent and permissibility of settlement in foreign currency against currency law and site practice; the peg in the example is notional. Rule: Law 173-FZ of 10.12.2003: Federal Law of 10.12.2003 No. 173-FZ on currency regulation and control (rule check not completed).
- Brand: when renting a showroom or a corner at a retailer the terms are documented as lease or agency; check the tax qualification of payments (rent, commission, remuneration) with a specialist (unverified).
- Retailer: variable lease payments (a percentage of turnover) are not included in the lease liability under FSBU 25/2018 and are recognized as a period expense; the fixed part and index-linked indexation enter the liability (check wording and details against the standard text, unverified). Rule: Order 208n of 16.10.2018: Ministry of Finance Order of 16.10.2018 No. 208n (FSBU 25/2018 Lease accounting) (rule check not completed).