Syntha Lab RU

Close the store or keep it

A store that loses money on the report may still cover shared costs. The calculation compares the store’s contribution up to the end of the lease with closing it: exit costs and the margin on sales that stay in the network (the website and neighboring stores).

Store format, rent and the fate of a store For whom: Chain and finance directors.

Calculate on your data →

At a glance

What question does it answer?
Close a loss-making store or keep it until the lease ends.
What data is needed?
Revenue, variable margin, direct fixed costs and allocated shared costs for a year.
How to read the result?
A store with revenue of 30m shows −2.8m a year on the report, a contribution before shared costs of −1.6m. Keeping it for the 18 months until the lease ends means −2.4m. Closing, with exit costs of 4.5m and a 25% transfer, gives +0.56m: closing is better by 2.96m. The options are equal at a 10.4% transfer. Example on the default values: Store contribution a year (before shared costs) — −1.6 m RUB; Store result on the report a year — −2.8 m RUB; Keep: result until the lease ends — −2.4 m RUB; Close: result until the lease ends — RUB 562,500.

Why and how to reason

A store that loses money on the report should not necessarily be closed: part of its costs in the report are shared costs that will not disappear with the store. So the decision is made on contribution: revenue × variable margin − direct fixed costs. Here 30 million × 48% − 16 million = −RUB 1.6 million a year (the report shows −2.8 million including shared costs of 1.2 million). Contribution is negative, but the decision depends on the lease term and exit costs. Keep until the lease ends (18 months): −1.6 × 1.5 = −2.4 million. Close: some customers will move to the site and nearby stores (25% of revenue at a 45% margin), giving 30 × 0.25 × 0.45 × 1.5 = 5.06 million, minus exit costs 4.5 million: +0.56 million. Closing is better by RUB 2.96 million. The decisions are equal if 10.4% of revenue transfers.

When to use it

Use it when a store is steadily unprofitable and you must decide whether to close it before the lease ends. Assumption: transfer is estimated from data (loyalty cards, online orders from the area), shared costs do not change. It does not fit a store that acts as a brand window or feeds traffic to others for hidden reasons, nor a case where early exit is impossible. If the lease is short, exit costs decide everything.

How to read the result

Read annual contribution and the transfer at which decisions are equal (10.4%). If your estimate of transfer is higher, closing pays more; if lower, keep. A difference of RUB 2.96 million against exit costs of 4.5 million means the conclusion is sensitive to them: check penalties and dismantling. If contribution is positive (it covers part of shared costs), closing is almost never worthwhile: shared costs fall on the other stores. Decision: close at negative contribution and a loss-making rest of the lease, otherwise look for ways to improve the store. Before closing check alternatives: revising the area, changing the format, subletting part of the premises. They often beat both keep and close in the simple framing.

Common mistakes

The usual mistakes: relying on the report loss instead of contribution; ignoring shared costs that remain; overstating transfer (customers rarely move); forgetting staff payments and penalties. Transferred revenue over the whole term cannot be counted as guaranteed: its estimate is the weakest part of the calculation. Do not count transferred sales across all customers of the district: not all will move.

What data is needed?

  • Revenue, variable margin, direct fixed costs and allocated shared costs for a year.
  • The time to the end of the lease, exit costs, the share of transferred sales and its margin.

Inputs

FieldUnitValue in the exampleMeaning
Store revenue a year, excl. VAT₽30,000,000Price excl. VAT: the general rate is 22% from 01.01.2026 (17.12.2025). The rate follows the shipment date; confirm your regime and rate with an accountant.
Variable margin%48The share of revenue after the cost of goods and variable costs (commissions, sellers’ bonuses).
Direct fixed costs a year₽16,000,000Rent, staff and utilities of this store: costs that disappear on closing.
Allocated shared costs a year₽1,200,000The share of head office and warehouse allocated to the store. It does not disappear on closing. Empty: zero.
Time to the end of the leasemonths18How many months you are tied by the contract if you keep the store.
Exit costs: penalties, severance, removal₽4,500,000One-off costs of closing now. Empty: zero.
Transfer: the share of revenue that stays in the network%25Customers who will buy on the website or in a neighboring store. An estimate from loyalty cards and delivery addresses.
Variable margin on transferred sales%45Empty: the same as the store’s variable margin.

How it is calculated

StepFormula
Contributionrevenue × variable margin − direct fixed costs
Keepannual contribution × term in years
Closerevenue × transfer × transfer margin × term in years − exit costs
Equalitytransfer = (keep + exit costs) ÷ (revenue × transfer margin × term in years)

Worked numbers

Default values from the app; in the interactive version you enter your own.

Store contribution a year (before shared costs)
−1.6 m ₽Revenue × variable margin − direct fixed costs.
Store result on the report a year
−2.8 m ₽
Keep: result until the lease ends
−2.4 m ₽
Close: result until the lease ends
562,500 ₽Margin on transferred sales − exit costs.
Closing beats keeping by
2.96 m ₽ · close
Transfer share at which the options are equal
10.4 %If the actual transfer is higher, closing is better.

Closing at different transfer shares

TransferCloseKeepBetter
0 %−4.5 m ₽−2.4 m ₽keep
10 %−2.48 m ₽−2.4 m ₽keep
25 %562,500 ₽−2.4 m ₽close
40 %3.6 m ₽−2.4 m ₽close
60 %7.65 m ₽−2.4 m ₽close

Exit costs (rent, penalties, severance) are entered by you from the contracts; check them with a lawyer. The decision counts only money: assess the store’s role as a brand window separately.

Nuances and limits

  • Allocated shared costs do not disappear on closing: do not include them in the decision.
  • The transfer is an estimate: check it against loyalty cards and delivery.
  • Check exit costs against the contracts with a lawyer; assess the store’s role as a brand window separately.

Terms used

Calculate on your data →