Syntha Lab RU

Sales formats: offline, online and secondary channels

A summary of formats: mono-brand, flagship, department store (buyout, consignment, corner), outlet, off-price, concept store, travel retail, pop-up, D2C, marketplaces, flash sales, live and social commerce, rental and resale. It decides which channels carry the product and who bears stock, commission and return risk.

Categories and audiences Brand and retail Verified: 2026-11-14

Open interactively →

Why this document

The same product earns different money in different channels: commission, returns, settlement time and who holds the stock differ several times over. The commercial and finance directors read this document when they decide where to sell a new collection and how much working capital it needs. Without it a channel is chosen by revenue rather than by margin after commissions and returns, so a growing marketplace can turn out less profitable than a modest wholesale account. That is why formats are compared by money per rouble of sales and by risk, not by turnover.

At a glance

What is this document and why is it needed?
A summary of formats: mono-brand, flagship, department store (buyout, consignment, corner), outlet, off-price, concept store, travel retail, pop-up, D2C, marketplaces, flash sales, live and social commerce, rental and resale. It decides which channels carry the product and who bears stock, commission and return risk.
Who owns the document and how often is it rebuilt?
Kept by the commercial director (brand) or network development director (retailer); computed by finance; reviewed quarterly on channel actuals and yearly with strategy; presented to the owner as a channel, contribution, risk map.
What mistakes are the most common?
Comparing channels by revenue rather than CM per unit → growth in a negative-contribution channel → compute CM after returns and unsold. Ignoring who holds stock → underestimating frozen cash in consignment and FBO → compute CCC and average stock per channel. Taking the commission from the platform price list without returns, storage and ads → an inflated margin → use actual deductions from the report.

For whom

Brand
A brand compares channels by contribution per sold unit (CM after commissions, logistics, returns and marketing), by who holds inventory (the brand under consignment and marketplace FBO, the retailer under buyout) and by effect on price and image. The core question: what remains per unit after all deductions and how much cash is frozen in goods at the channel.
Retail
A retailer picks a format by traffic, ticket, space payback and stock controllability: own stores bring rent and staff, a department store brings traffic for a revenue share, outlets and off-price handle leftovers, online brings logistics and returns. For a retailer a format is a unit P&L: sales per m², rent load, GMROI, shrinkage.

What it consists of

Offline formats: who bears risk and how it pays

  • Brand: Mono-brand (own store): the brand pays rent and staff, holds stock, keeps the whole retail margin; controls price and service; all risk on the brand. Metrics: sales per m², rent-to-sales, conversion, UPT, AOV.
  • Brand: Flagship: image and showcase; often loss-making at store level, repaid through the halo effect and online; judge by network contribution, not store P&L alone.
  • Department store: buyout (the retailer buys, risk and margin are its); consignment (goods at the store, owned by the brand, the store takes a sales commission, stock risk on the brand); corner/concession (the brand pays the store a revenue percentage and staffs it). Commission and corner rates are set by contract, there are no universal figures: unverified.
  • Brand: Outlet (including made-for-outlet): a channel for leftovers and a dedicated line; price below the shelf price, a growing turnover role; risk of cannibalizing the full-price channel and brand image; track channel share and price gap.
  • Off-price (a chain buying surplus and leftovers). Risk: with the retailer from the moment of purchase; the brand gets cash fast and stops bearing leftover risk. Cash by date: D0 batch order, D0-D14 payment and pickup (prepayment or 7-14 days, per contract), D14-D90 high-turnover clearance. Brand slice per unit: batch at 25% of full price (RUB 2,500), cost RUB 3000, handling RUB 150, CM RUB -650: the channel is cheaper than storage and a public markdown only if otherwise the leftover would be written off or cannibalize the full-price channel. Retailer slice per RUB 100 of revenue: purchases 46, store and staff 24, logistics 6, losses and markdowns 5, marketing 2, EBIT 17. KPIs: turnover (T of at least 6 as a working hypothesis), branded goods share, GMROI, dead stock share. Risks: the brand loses control over price and territory (restrict territory and online in the contract), the retailer depends on the leftover flow.
  • Retailer: Concept store / multibrand boutique: a curated set, high ticket, small space; risk is a narrow range and dependence on a few brands.
  • Travel retail (airports, stations, duty-free). Risk: with the brand; the operator takes a percentage of turnover, often with a minimum rent guarantee; check the zone tax and currency regime separately (unverified). Cash by date: D-90 contract and stand fit-out (capex), D0 opening and immediate customer payment, monthly percentage to the operator, D+30-60 settlement by operator report. Slice per unit: a 30% concession leaves the brand RUB 7,000 of the price 10000, staff 700, unsold 300 (sell-through 80%, residual recovery 60%), CM RUB 3,000 (30%), but with fixed stand costs and a minimum guarantee the store P&L is usually weaker. KPIs: sales per passenger, flow conversion, rent-to-sales, stand payback. Risks: flow seasonality, dependence on flights and zone rules, high fixed payments.
  • Brand: Pop-up: short rent, a market and product test, a drop; risk is limited by duration, set-up and staff costs are high per day.

Online and secondary formats

  • D2C (own site and app). Risk: entirely with the brand: stock, returns, CAC, payment and logistics costs. Cash by date: the supplier is paid 60-120 days before D0, stock is frozen; D0 customer payment, acquiring credits the cash in 1-3 business days (per contract), D+1-3 shipping, then the distance-sale return window and refund to the customer. Slice per unit (price RUB 10,000 excl. VAT): cost 3000, delivery and packing 500, acquiring 250, CAC 2,200, return losses 217, CM RUB 3833, that is 38.3% of price; without CAC 60.3%. KPIs: CAC, LTV/CAC by cohort (set the threshold yourself, there is no universal norm), conversion, return rate, repeat share, CM after marketing. Risks: CAC growth without organic traffic, returns, dependence on ad platforms, unclear cohort payback.
  • Brand: Fashion marketplaces (specialized fashion platforms): a model closer to retail or commission with fashion curation; requirements for the card, photos, timing and returns; access to a high-intent audience.
  • Brand: Universal marketplaces: the buyout rate is below expectations, category commissions, logistics, storage, on-platform ads; the brand pays for visibility; tariffs change, check the seller cabinet at the calculation date.
  • Flash sales (closed sales, a 2-7 day window). Risk depends on the contract: under commission the leftover is with the brand until the window ends, under buyout with the platform. Cash by date: D-14 loading goods and photos, D0-D5 window, D+7-14 settlement by report, returns after the window. Slice per unit: price -50% (RUB 5,000), a 20% commission gives brand revenue of RUB 4000, handling 400, return losses 44, CM RUB 556 (5.6%): the channel is justified only for leftovers that otherwise do not sell. KPIs: window sell-through, share of new customers, share of customers waiting for the next sale, CM, leftover clearance time. Risks: it trains customers to wait for discounts, cannibalizes the full-price channel and needs size depth: otherwise the window closes with broken runs.
  • Live shopping and social commerce. Risk: the brand holds stock and returns, the platform takes a commission, the host gets a fee or a percentage. Cash by date: D-7 samples and host contract (fee and ads are paid before the broadcast), D0 broadcast and payment at order, D+1-3 shipping, D+7-14 returns, settlement with the platform on its schedule. Slice per unit: price -10% (RUB 9,000), a 12% commission gives RUB 7920, logistics 500, host and ads 900, return losses 215 at a 35% return rate, CM RUB 3,305 (33%). KPIs: view-to-order conversion, broadcast average ticket, returns, CM after the host, share of new customers, broadcast payback (CM / broadcast costs). Risks: a returns peak, dependence on one host, advertising requirements (marking and internet identifier), image rights.
  • Rental / subscription and resale: see doc circular; separate accounting models (fleet and lifetime, commission).

Format summary table (columns)

  • Brand: Brand revenue per sold unit = price excl. VAT × (1 − channel commission/discount); for buyout the wholesale price.
  • Variable costs per unit: logistics, payment, packaging, on-channel advertising.
  • Brand: Losses from returns: (return rate / buyout) × (reverse logistics + write-off).
  • Brand: Losses from unsold: (1 / sell-through − 1) × C × (1 − recovery), if the risk is on the brand.
  • Brand: CM after the channel = revenue − C − variable − returns − unsold.

The retailer in formats: buyout, shelf, off-price

  • Retailer: department store and buyout. Compute IMU, MMU, GMROI and shelf share per brand: consignment removes stock risk but costs commission; a corner gives the store a steady percentage of turnover at lower risk. Choosing a format means comparing buyout GMROI with consignment income on the same shelf.
  • Retailer: online fashion multibrand. The platform buys goods or takes them on commission; key brand requirements are delivery time, photo quality, returns and exchange. For the retailer, what matters is the brand share of turnover, returns per brand and stock turnover time.
  • Retailer: off-price and flash sales. The buying price is set from the brand comparable price; watch the branded range share, rights to use the brand in advertising and the territory and online terms the brand imposes; when the leftover flow breaks, revenue is lost.

How to read the result and which decisions follow

  • Read the figures in order: where there are more roubles per unit, where money comes sooner. In the example the best channel by CM is “D2C (site), CAC RUB 2,200” (RUB 3,833 per unit), the worst “Off-price: batch at 25% of price” (−RUB 650). CM per unit is not yet a decision: check the cash timing and who holds the stock.
  • Retailer: for you the format sets who holds the stock and when settlement arrives. Consignment, concession and flash sales move the risk of leftovers to the brand but do not remove your space and staff costs; compare formats by profit per square meter and days of cash, not by margin share.
  • Retailer: settlement at D+30-60 in travel retail and D+7-14 in flash sales is credit to the brand or to you, depending on the contract; include these terms in the cash-flow plan and working capital.

Control checks

  • Bridge check: revenue minus three deductions equals CM (RUB 3,833 for D2C and RUB 3,279 for the marketplace), the code reconciles it with the table.
  • Retailer: in consignment and concession revenue and stock are recognized under the contract; check with the accountant whose stock is on your balance sheet before computing format turnover.
  • Retailer: compute the rent burden on store revenue excl. VAT and the full rate including service charges; otherwise the format looks better than it is.

Where the data comes from

Data sourceFields
Contracts with department stores, platforms, operatorscommission/corner rate, payment terms, return rules, penalties, retro-bonuses
Platform reports and ledgersales and buyout, deductions, returns, logistics, storage, advertising
Store accountingrent, payroll, utilities, shrinkage, traffic, receipts

How to build it step by step

  1. Step 1. List the channels and for each record who owns the goods and who bears unsold risk.
  2. Brand: Step 2. Collect commission/discount, logistics, returns, advertising from contracts and reports; separate “per contract” and “actually deducted”.
  3. Step 3. Set planned sell-through and residual recovery per channel (from past seasons).
  4. Step 4. Compute CM per sold unit with the formulas above and total channel CM.
  5. Step 5. Add channel fixed costs (rent, staff, platform) to get the channel P&L; reconcile the sum of channels with the company P&L.
  6. Step 6. Compute cash frozen in the channel: average stock at the retailer and brand, receivables, payment terms (CCC by channel).
  7. Step 7. Check price effects: cannibalization of the full-price channel by outlet and marketplace, price parity.
  8. Step 8. Show the owner a table “channel, CM per unit, revenue share, frozen cash, risk”; leave detail to the team.

Formulas

MeasureFormulasNote
Brand: CM per sold unitCM = P×(1−c) − C − v − (r/(1−r))×(lr + w) − (1/s − 1)×C×(1−q)P price excl. VAT; c channel commission; v variable; r return rate; lr reverse logistics; w write-off; s channel sell-through; q residual recovery. The last term only if the brand bears unsold.
Retailer: Store paybackT = Investment / (monthly store profit before depreciation)Profit after rent and payroll, before head-office allocation; compare with the “Store payback” calculation.
Retailer: Rent-to-salesRent / store revenueCommonly quoted thresholds (e.g. 10-18%) are not confirmed by sources: unverified; use your actual history and peers.

Formulas in notation

Contribution per unit
CM = P × (1 − c) − C − v − r/(1 − r) × (l_r + w) − (1/s − 1) × C × (1 − q)
P price excl. VAT, c commission, C cost, v variable costs, r return rate, l_r return logistics, w handling, s sell-through, q share of unsold goods recovered.
CM as % of price
CM% = CM / P × 100
Compare channels in roubles per unit and in percent: a high-price channel can have a lower percent with more roubles.
Store payback
T = I / π_m
I is the store investment, π_m store profit before depreciation per month; T in months.
Rent-to-sales
ρ = Rent / Revenue_store
Store rent burden is computed on store revenue, not company revenue.

Worked example

Brand CM per sold unit by channel and format (exercise assumptions; price excl. VAT RUB 10,000, C = RUB 3,000)

ChannelBrand revenue, RUBVariable costs, RUBReturns, RUBUnsold, RUBCM, RUBCM % of priceWho holds stock
Wholesale buyout5,000300001,70017retailer
Department store consignment6,50025007712,47924.8brand
Corner (concession) 30%7,00060006002,80028brand
Marketplace FBO, 24% commission7,6001,15017103,27932.8brand
D2C (site), CAC RUB 2,20010,0002,95021703,83338.3brand
Own outlet (price -40%)6,000800002,20022brand
Off-price: batch at 25% of price2,50015000−650−6.5retailer
Flash sales: price -50%, 20% commission4,0004004405565.6per contract
Live and social: price -10%, 12% commission7,9201,40021503,30533brand
Travel retail: 30% concession7,00070003003,00030brand

In wholesale the wholesale price is 50% of retail, residual risk sits with the retailer, so “Unsold” is 0. Consignment and corner: sell-through of 70% and 75%, residual recovery 40%. Marketplace: return rate 30%, ads 8%. D2C: return rate 25%, CAC RUB 2,200, acquiring 2.5%. Off-price: batch at 25% of full price, CM -6.5% (below cost, but with no storage and no public discount). Flash sales: price -50%, commission 20%, return rate 10%, CM 5.6%. Live and social: price -10%, commission 12%, host and ads 9% of price, return rate 35%, CM 33%. Travel retail: concession 30%, sell-through 80%, residual recovery 60%. All parameters are exercise assumptions, replace them with yours.

Figures

Brand CM per unit by channel
Bar chart: Wholesale buyout 1,700, Department store consignment 2,479, Corner (concession) 30% 2,800, Marketplace FBO, 24% commission 3,279, D2C (site), CAC RUB 2,200 3,833, Own outlet (price -40%) 2,200−1,00001,0002,0003,0004,000Wholesale buyoutWholesale buyoutCM per unit: 1,7001,700Department store consignmentDepartment storeconsignmentCM per unit: 2,4792,479Corner (concession) 30%Corner (concession)30%CM per unit: 2,8002,800Marketplace FBO, 24% commissionMarketplace FBO, 24%commissionCM per unit: 3,2793,279D2C (site), CAC RUB 2,200D2C (site), CAC RUB2,200CM per unit: 3,8333,833Own outlet (price -40%)Own outlet (price-40%)CM per unit: 2,2002,200Off-price: batch at 25% of priceOff-price: batch at25% of priceCM per unit: −650−650Flash sales: price -50%, 20% commissionFlash sales: price-50%, 20% commissionCM per unit: 556556Live and social: price -10%, 12% commissionLive and social:price -10%, 12%…CM per unit: 3,3053,305Travel retail: 30% concessionTravel retail: 30%concessionCM per unit: 3,0003,000RUB
Data as a table
MeasureCM per unit
Wholesale buyout1,700
Department store consignment2,479
Corner (concession) 30%2,800
Marketplace FBO, 24% commission3,279
D2C (site), CAC RUB 2,2003,833
Own outlet (price -40%)2,200
Off-price: batch at 25% of price−650
Flash sales: price -50%, 20% commission556
Live and social: price -10%, 12% commission3,305
Travel retail: 30% concession3,000

Brand CM per unit by channel. Contribution per unit sold at a price excl. VAT of RUB 10,000 and cost of RUB 3,000; a negative bar is a loss per unit. Exercise assumptions.

D2C unit bridge: from revenue to CM
Waterfall: Revenue 10k, Cost of goods −3,000, Variable costs and CAC −2,950, Returns −217, CM 3,83302,0004,0006,0008,00010kRevenueRevenueRevenue: 10k10kCost of goodsCost of goodsCost of goods: −3,000−3,000Variable costs and CACVariable costs andCACVariable costs and CAC: −2,950−2,950ReturnsReturnsReturns: −217−217CMCMCM: 3,8333,833RUB
  • positive
  • negative
  • total
Data as a table
StepChangeLevel
Revenue—10k
Cost of goods−3,0007,000
Variable costs and CAC−2,9504,050
Returns−2173,833
CM—3,833

D2C unit bridge: from revenue to CM. Revenue per unit minus cost, variable costs (incl. CAC) and returns gives CM.

Marketplace FBO unit bridge
Waterfall: Price excl. VAT 10k, Commission 24% −2,400, Cost of goods −3,000, Variable costs −1,150, Returns −171, CM 3,27902,0004,0006,0008,00010kPrice excl. VATPrice excl. VATPrice excl. VAT: 10k10kCommission 24%Commission 24%Commission 24%: −2,400−2,400Cost of goodsCost of goodsCost of goods: −3,000−3,000Variable costsVariable costsVariable costs: −1,150−1,150ReturnsReturnsReturns: −171−171CMCMCM: 3,2793,279RUB
  • positive
  • negative
  • total
Data as a table
StepChangeLevel
Price excl. VAT—10k
Commission 24%−2,4007,600
Cost of goods−3,0004,600
Variable costs−1,1503,450
Returns−1713,279
CM—3,279

Marketplace FBO unit bridge. The commission cuts revenue before settlement, returns and logistics add costs.

Money and goods by dates: flash sales and travel retail. Two chains from the formats table: when goods leave, when money comes in and where the risk sits.

  1. D-14: goods and photos uploaded → D0-D5: sales window
  2. D0-D5: sales window → D+7-14: settlement by platform report
  3. D+7-14: settlement by platform report → Returns after the window
  4. Returns after the window
  5. Sale in the operator zone → Monthly percentage to the operator
  6. Monthly percentage to the operator → D+30-60: settlement by operator report
  7. D+30-60: settlement by operator report

Specifics by category

Apparel
Apparel: online returns rise because of fitting, so in the CM formula take the category return rate, not the chain average (25-30% in the example is an assumption). Season leftovers leave as a ladder: own outlet, off-price, flash sales; the order matters because each next channel takes goods cheaper and cannibalizes the previous one. Plan the exit in advance: by which week of the season and what share of leftovers goes to which channel, and set a markdown-share threshold after which the full-price channel counts as damaged.
Footwear
Footwear: last and size make an online return costlier than in apparel: the pair comes back with sole and box wear, some pairs cannot be resold as new, so the write-off term w in the CM formula is noticeably larger for footwear. Offline needs fitting and size depth: a broken run in a store lowers conversion, while off-price takes broken runs readily. On a marketplace account for box weight and volume: logistics per pair is higher. Compute returns and warranty with the document footwear-returns.
Accessories
Accessories: no size, small volume, cheap logistics per unit, returns below apparel because the reason is more often “did not like it” than “did not fit”. Department stores and travel retail matter most for bags and jewelry, gift peaks are stronger online. Corner and consignment are common, but take the rate from the contract. Costume jewelry and jewelry follow different regimes: precious-metal items pass assay marking and GIIS DMDK, so consignment and corners need reconciliation by weight and item numbers.
Kids
Kids: the parent buys, so channels are multibrand, department stores, marketplaces and the app; size returns are high and the return window matches the fast size change. Pop-ups and school fairs work before 1 September. In consignment and FBO count the “outgrown size” risk: a leftover after a season loses not only price but also its height step. In the CM formula take channel sell-through by seasonal windows (school, winter), not for the year, otherwise unsold is understated.
Men
Men: the visit purpose is more often specific, so mono-brand stores and department stores give steady conversion, while online gains from a clear size table and repeat basics (shirts, underwear, socks). The outlet matters less as a fashion channel and more as a basics leftover channel; a men flagship holds suits and tailoring. With a clear grid returns are usually lower than women, but this is a hypothesis: take the return rate from your own channel report. The commercial logic is the CM formula, only the return and sell-through parameters change.
Women
Women: the widest channel set and the highest fashion share in leftovers, so outlet and off-price are busier. Live and social commerce give high conversion at broadcast time but also higher returns (fitting at home); include host and ad costs in CM. Many sizes and fits per style: count returns for “did not fit” separately from “did not like it”. Flash sales need depth by size, otherwise the window closes early and the remaining sizes become broken runs.

Common mistakes

  • Comparing channels by revenue rather than CM per unit → growth in a negative-contribution channel → compute CM after returns and unsold.
  • Ignoring who holds stock → underestimating frozen cash in consignment and FBO → compute CCC and average stock per channel.
  • Taking the commission from the platform price list without returns, storage and ads → an inflated margin → use actual deductions from the report.
  • Opening an outlet without product selection rules → falling full price → measure cannibalization and cap the share.
  • Treating a flagship as an ordinary store → a false loss conclusion → judge by network and online contribution.

Russian specifics

  • Consignment and commission contract: the goods stay owned by the brand, the seller receives a fee; in the brand accounts this is a shipment to the agent warehouse (off-balance at the agent), revenue is recognized on the agent report; check tax effects with an accountant. Rule: Civil Code part 2: Civil Code, part two (including Arts. 513, 713, 990, 1027) (rule check not completed).
  • Return and exchange for distance sales: art. 26.1 of the consumer protection law and the Sales Rules (from 01.09.2026 decree no. 657); the list of non-returnable goods depends on the edition in force. Rule: Law 2300-1 of 07.02.1992: Law of 07.02.1992 No. 2300-1 on consumer rights protection.
  • Marketplaces and the platform economy: governed by the platform economy law; tariffs and commissions change often, take them from the seller cabinet at the calculation date, the table figures are for teaching. Rule: Law 289-FZ of 31.07.2025: Federal Law of 31.07.2025 No. 289-FZ on the platform economy (rule check not completed).

Open interactively →