Circular models: resale, upcycling, repair, rental
Four models that extend the life of a garment: resale, upcycling, repair and rental, with their unit economics and accounting. It decides whether to launch a model at all, by which scheme to account for the goods and how to compute payback, so that the service does not turn out less profitable than core sales and does not eat the brand margin.
Why this document
A circular model sounds attractive, but the money in it is counted differently: the same item earns income several times, but logistics, cleaning, repair and wear risk appear. The owner and the finance director read this document before launching resale, rental or repair: it shows how many turns an item needs to pay back and how to account for such goods. Without it the project starts on image logic and quietly eats the margin. So unit economics is computed first, and the program is announced after it.
At a glance
- What is this document and why is it needed?
- Four models that extend the life of a garment: resale, upcycling, repair and rental, with their unit economics and accounting. It decides whether to launch a model at all, by which scheme to account for the goods and how to compute payback, so that the service does not turn out less profitable than core sales and does not eat the brand margin.
- Who owns the document and how often is it rebuilt?
- Kept by the line manager with a finance controller; quarterly on model actuals; presented to the owner as a separate business line.
- What mistakes are the most common?
- Pricing rental from purchase price without cleaning and losses → a false profit → count the cost per rental separately. Not setting the number of rentals per lifetime → a loss-making model → compute N* and compare with real wear. Mixing resale commission with sales revenue → inflated revenue → recognize only the fee.
For whom
- Brand
- A brand uses resale and repair to retain customers and brand value, upcycling for waste, rental for marketing and access to a new audience; separate accounting is needed so it is not mixed with core revenue.
- Retail
- A retailer uses resale as a new goods and traffic flow, rental as an add-on for the premium range; decides whether to take items on commission or buy them.
What it consists of
Models
- Resale: a sales commission (goods stay with the owner, the platform is an intermediary, off-balance) or buy-and-resell (goods on the balance, risk with the seller); key: intake, authentication, grading, exposure time.
- Brand: Upcycling: turning leftovers and waste into new items; small runs, manual labor, price tied to story and scarcity; accounted as production from owner-supplied or own materials.
- Repair and care: paid services or warranty programs; extends product life and loyalty; counted as a service with its own cost.
- Rental and subscription: a fleet of items let for a period; income from rent, costs of cleaning, logistics, wear and losses; the fleet is an asset, not inventory, accounting by policy: unverified.
Unit economics and accounting
- Brand: Rental: number of rentals N over the item life; profit = N × (rental price − cost per rental − wear) − purchase cost + residual value.
- Retailer: Resale commission: platform revenue = commission × price; costs: intake, photos, storage, logistics, returns, fraud.
- Repair: service price − labor − materials − overhead; affects customer LTV.
- Accounting: the rental fleet as fixed assets (useful life over 12 months) or inventory per company policy; commission goods off-balance; agree the choice with an accountant.
Brand and retailer: what is done differently
- Brand: an own take-back program: the brand accepts items, gives points or a discount and resells in its own channel; count intake and inspection cost, the share accepted, the resale price and cannibalization of new sales.
- Brand: warranty repair and paid repair are accounted differently: warranty repair goes into warranty costs, paid repair into a service with its own cost; state the term and coverage list in the product card.
- Brand: upcycling of leftovers: compare processing cost with write-off and the tax result, limit the series to the available fabric; the item story and transparency of material origin work in sales.
- Retailer: resale as an acquisition channel: commission or buyout brings a new audience and returns customers to the store; count exposure time, the share of rejected items and the inflow of new customers.
- Retailer: rental as a service: item fleet, cleaning, logistics, losses; count fleet utilization (share of days on rental) and idle cost; in accounts the fleet goes as fixed assets or inventory per the accounting policy, agree with the accountant.
- Retailer: swap and trade-in (an old item for a discount): limit the discount term and intake conditions; account for the obligation to the customer separately and agree the treatment with the accountant.
How to read the result and which decisions follow
- The bridge shows the park total of RUB 11,700: profit comes from women and accessories, the other 3 categories pull it down. Decision: launch rental on categories with a positive lifetime margin (for the bag 7.7 rentals), not across the whole range.
- Brand: rental and resale of own items give a second turn of one unit but cannibalize new sales; launch on evening and high-priced items and track the move of the client from purchase to rental as a separate metric.
- Retailer: rental as a service creates traffic and repeat visits but needs cleaning, storage and condition tracking; if N* is above the lifetime in rentals (men 12.3 against 12, footwear 27 against 6) the model does not pay off, so limit it to a fleet with a high purchase price.
- Brand: footwear and kids do not pay off in rental in the example: rental costs almost equal the price and the lifetime is short; repair and resale suit them better than rental.
- Retailer: resale through your platform brings a commission without stock risk, but quality check and authentication fall on you; include the check cost per unit in the commission.
Control checks
- The sum of profit over five categories equals the park total of RUB 11,700 (the code reconciles it with the example table).
- Brand: the residual value V must be taken at the real resale price, not the book value; an overstated V hides unprofitability.
- Retailer: rental costs c include cleaning, logistics, repair and losses; without losses and insurance the N* threshold is understated.
- Brand: check the lifetime n on a pilot batch, not on expectation; one dress returned with a stain that cannot be restored shortens n for the whole fleet.
- Retailer: accounting for the rental fleet (fixed assets or inventory) and the tax effects must be checked with the accountant before launch; this document does not fix them.
Where the data comes from
| Data source | Fields |
|---|---|
| Resale intake and sales log | intake date, condition, price, commission, time to sale |
| Rental log | rental count, cleaning, repair, losses, useful life |
| Ledger and contracts | commission/rental contract, tax base |
How to build it step by step
- Step 1. Choose the model and legal form (commission, buyout, rental, service).
- Step 2. Set parameters: price, rental count, commission, time to sale.
- Step 3. Compute the cost per operation: cleaning, logistics, intake.
- Step 4. Compute unit economics and the payback point in rentals or time.
- Step 5. Decide accounting: on/off-balance, depreciation, taxes.
- Step 6. Check the effect on the core business: cannibalization of new sales.
- Step 7. Track KPIs: fleet turnover, exposure time, share of repeat customers.
Formulas
| Measure | Formulas | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Rental profit per item | Π(N) = N × (p − c) − C0 + V | p rental price; c cost per rental (cleaning, logistics, losses, wear); C0 purchase; V residual value. |
| Payback in rentals | N* = (C0 − V) / (p − c) | If N* exceeds the real number of rentals in a lifetime, the model loses money. |
Formulas in notation
- Item profit over N rentals
Π(N) = N × (p − c) − C_0 + V
p is the rental price, c rental costs (cleaning, logistics, repair), C_0 purchase, V residual value.- Payback threshold
N* = (C_0 − V) / (p − c)
The number of rentals after which Π(N) turns positive.- Lifetime margin
m = n − N*
n is the real lifetime in rentals; m < 0 means the model loses money at the given p and c.
Worked example
Rental by category: item payback and lifetime profit (exercise assumptions)
| Category (sample item) | Purchase, RUB | Rental price, RUB | Cost per rental, RUB | Residual, RUB | Rentals needed N* | Rentals per lifetime | Profit per item, RUB | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Women (evening dress) | 12,000 | 1,500 | 650 | 1,000 | 12.9 | 14 | 900 | pays back |
| Men (suit) | 15,000 | 1,800 | 700 | 1,500 | 12.3 | 12 | −300 | loss-making |
| Kids (occasion outfit) | 4,000 | 600 | 350 | 300 | 14.8 | 8 | −1,700 | loss-making |
| Footwear (shoes) | 6,000 | 700 | 500 | 600 | 27 | 6 | −4,200 | loss-making |
| Accessories (bag) | 30,000 | 3,000 | 800 | 3,000 | 12.3 | 20 | 17,000 | pays back |
| Fleet of one item each | 67,000 | 6,400 | 11,700 | positive only thanks to the bag |
Rentals needed N* = (purchase - residual) / (rental price - cost per rental). The dress (12.9 against 14 rentals per lifetime) and the bag (12.3 against 20) pay back, the suit is borderline, the kids outfit and shoes lose money: the shoes need 27 rentals against a realistic 6. A fleet of five items nets RUB 11,700, carried by the bag and the dress while the other items lose money, so the decision is made by category and item, not by the average. All parameters are exercise assumptions.
Figures
- Needed N*
- Rentals per lifetime
Data as a table
| Measure | Needed N* | Rentals per lifetime |
|---|---|---|
| Women | 12.9 | 14 |
| Men | 12.3 | 12 |
| Kids | 14.8 | 8 |
| Footwear | 27 | 6 |
| Accessories | 12.3 | 20 |
Rentals needed vs rentals achieved. Whether an item pays for itself: if the lifetime bar is below the N* threshold, renting loses money.
- positive
- negative
- total
Data as a table
| Step | Change | Level |
|---|---|---|
| Women | +900 | 900 |
| Men | −300 | 600 |
| Kids | −1,700 | −1,100 |
| Footwear | −4,200 | −5,300 |
| Accessories | +17k | 11.7k |
| Park | — | 11.7k |
Park profit, one item per category. Lifetime profit per item by category: positive only for the bag and the evening dress, the rest reduce the total.
Specifics by category
- Apparel
- Apparel: the bulk of resale, repair and rental. Rental pays back for high-ticket items with a rare occasion (evening dress, suit): in the teaching example an item bought at RUB 12,000 with a rental price of RUB 1,500 and cost of RUB 650 pays back on the 13th rental. Everyday-wear resale depends on commission and speed: track exposure time and the share of rejected items. Upcycling of leftovers goes in small series and sells on story and rarity, not on material price.
- Footwear
- Footwear: resale is possible (sneakers, collector models, leather), but condition is judged by insole, sole and smell, and authentication and cleaning cost more than in apparel. Footwear rental usually does not pay back because of wear and hygiene (in the example 6 rentals against 27 needed). Repair (heel tips, sole, cleaning) is a separate service with a clear cost and extends wear life. Set a repair price threshold against a new pair (for example 40%) and test it with a customer survey.
- Accessories
- Accessories: bags and leather goods are the most mature resale by price: high residual value, critical authentication (fakes), commission justified by the ticket. Bag rental pays back faster than apparel at the same rental count thanks to a high rental price and low care cost: in the example a bag bought at RUB 30,000 with a rental of RUB 3,000 turns positive at 13 rentals. Check the accounting and marking regime for resale of jewelry separately (unverified); costume jewelry has little resale value.
- Kids
- Kids: the fastest resale and swap turnover: a garment serves one or two seasons, residual value exceeds the wear share, so consignment stores and height-based swaps work well. Safety requirements for kids items do not lapse on resale (TR CU 007/2011 for products placed on the market; applicability to used goods is not verified). Kids clothing rental rarely pays back (in the example 8 rentals against 15 needed), exceptions are occasion wear and photo shoots. Repair: zips, darning, hardware replacement.
- Men
- Men: resale is valued for classics (suits, coats, leather): higher residual value, little seasonal wear, atelier fitting (shortening, taking in) works as repair with a good margin. Suit rental for events pays back with frequent rentals and an atelier nearby: in the example 12 rentals against 13 needed, that is borderline. Fashion matters less and brand and fabric quality more, so condition assessment is simpler and faster than in women.
- Women
- Women: the largest resale and rental turnover by item count. Evening dresses and bags are the best rental candidates, everyday fashion quickly loses residual value and meets a flood of supply. Repair and alteration (fitting to the figure) extend item life. For rental, size and fit are critical: several sizes are needed in the fleet, and cleaning and losses go into the cost per rental. Size returns in rental are expensive: count them as a separate line.
Common mistakes
- Pricing rental from purchase price without cleaning and losses → a false profit → count the cost per rental separately.
- Not setting the number of rentals per lifetime → a loss-making model → compute N* and compare with real wear.
- Mixing resale commission with sales revenue → inflated revenue → recognize only the fee.
- Ignoring cannibalization → falling new sales → measure with the “Net effect of a new item” calculation.
Russian specifics
- Commission scheme: a commission contract under the Civil Code (ch. 51), the agent records the fee; VAT and corporate income tax/USN depend on the scheme; agree with an accountant. Rule: Civil Code part 2: Civil Code, part two (including Arts. 513, 713, 990, 1027) (rule check not completed).
- Rental fleet and fixed assets: accounting under federal standard FSBU 6/2020; applicability to a clothing fleet is not verified.
- Marking and certification of used goods differ from new; exact light-industry rules are not verified. Rule: Decree 1956 of 31.12.2019: Government Decree of 31.12.2019 No. 1956 (marking rules for light-industry goods) (rule check not completed).
- For the lessor, items let on rental are accounted under FSBU 25/2018 on lease accounting: lease classification, fleet depreciation and income recognition; applicability to a clothing fleet is unverified, agree the policy with the accountant. Rule: Order 208n of 16.10.2018: Ministry of Finance Order of 16.10.2018 No. 208n (FSBU 25/2018 Lease accounting) (rule check not completed).