Luxury and premium: scarcity, drops and the client ladder
Whether a limited release pays for the smaller volume and how much can be lost on the entry item for the sake of later purchases.
About the topic
Luxury and premium brands sell not only an item but the feeling that it is hard to get. This topic answers questions such a brand faces constantly. What edition size should you produce: smaller and pricier, or larger and cheaper? Should you release a limited run (a drop, a one-off release)? How do you build the customer path from an inexpensive first purchase to core pieces? And where does scarcity turn from strength into lost sales?
The reasoning starts from the fact that demand is unknown. Suppose three demand scenarios are equally likely. A drop: 800 units at RUB 30,000 with a unit cost of RUB 10,000 and demand of 600, 900, 1,200. On average 733 units sell: 600, 800 and 800. Revenue is RUB 22.0 million, production cost 8.0 million, profit 14.0 million. A regular run: 1,200 units at RUB 24,000 with demand 900, 1,200, 1,500 sells 1,100 on average: revenue 26.4 million, cost 12.0 million, profit 14.4 million. Profit is close, but the drop ties up 8 million of money, not 12, so return per rouble invested is 175% versus 120%. And it leaves less stock to sell at a discount and so destroy the image: 67 units on average against 100 (200 units remain only when demand is 600).
The price premium has to pay for the smaller volume. If the premium is too small, scarcity just loses sales. If it is too large, people do not buy even the limited item. Scarcity works only as long as the brand is known and desired.
The customer ladder solves a different problem. An inexpensive entry product (an accessory, cosmetics, a small leather good) may lose RUB 500 on the first purchase. That is fine if 40% of buyers return for a core piece with a RUB 6,000 margin: 0.4 x 6,000 = RUB 2,400 expected against RUB 500 invested. But if nobody climbs the ladder, the entry is just a cheap product that dilutes the image.
Start with the customer base: who buys the entry product, who returns, how much time passes between steps. Enter your own parameters; luxury market figures are not needed here. Traps: making scarcity artificial (the customer sees the item later sold at a discount), confusing prestige with a high price, measuring a drop by revenue alone.
Key ideas
Scarcity is a decision under uncertainty
Demand is unknown beforehand, so expected profit is compared over scenarios. A drop of 800 with demand 600/900/1,200 sells 733 on average, a regular run of 1,200 sells 1,100. The drop ties up less money and leaves less stock: 67 units on average against 100.
The premium must pay for lost sales
The minimum premium can be calculated. A regular run of 1,200 units at RUB 24,000 with a unit cost of RUB 10,000 earns RUB 16.8 million. A run of 800 units at RUB 31,000 earns the same, a premium of about 29%, and only if all 800 sell. If customers will pay less, limiting the run does not pay off.
Leftover stock destroys the image
A discount on a luxury item teaches customers to wait. So the price of leftover stock is part of the run calculation: better to under-produce than to clear. Each run includes a plan for leftovers: destroying is not an option, discounting is costly, so output is usually below expected demand.
The customer ladder pays for the entry
The inverse question: what share of customers must move up for the entry not to lose money? With a loss of RUB 800 and a main piece margin of RUB 9,000, 8.9% is enough (800 / 9,000). If 5% move up, the expected value is RUB 450 against RUB 800, so the entry loses; at 20% it is RUB 1,800. Count the share who move up by customer, not sales of the entry product.
Prestige is protected by control and licensing
Licenses, sub-licenses and distribution extend reach but dilute the image. The decision depends on who sells under your name and how. A high price in someone else’s point with poor service hurts the brand more than a discount.
A fake is not a lost sale
Counting losses by the number of fakes overstates them: many buyers would not have bought the original at your price. In our case there are 600 fakes in circulation but only a quarter of buyers would have bought the original: 150 lost sales at a margin of RUB 3,600 (RUB 6,000 × 60%) give RUB 540,000, and customer complaints (5 per 100 fakes at RUB 400) add RUB 12,000. Authentic gray goods take sales only where the buyer would have chosen you: of 300 items 150, that is RUB 540,000. In total RUB 1,092,000 a year instead of RUB 3,240,000 when counting “by units”.
Formula: Losses = fakes × substitution × margin + complaints + gray × share × margin
What to do: Estimate fakes and gray goods from monitoring as a range and count them separately: they have different losses and different measures.
Think first: There are 600 fakes in circulation, a margin of RUB 3,600 per item. How much margin does the brand lose if a quarter of buyers would have bought the original?
Answer: 600 × 25% = 150 sales × 3,600 ₽ = 540,000 ₽ (without complaints), not 2,160,000 ₽ by units.
Protection pays when it removes the needed share of losses
A protection program (monitoring, takedowns, an authenticity layer) costs RUB 458,400 a year: RUB 360,000 + 240 × RUB 350 + RUB 12 × 1,200 items. Against losses of RUB 1,092,000 it gives an effect of RUB 382,800 (a reduction of 40% and 30%), that is 35% of losses, while 42% is needed. The result is −RUB 75,600: in our case protection does not pay back. The main number is the needed loss reduction, equal to the cost divided by the losses; it is compared with what a pilot showed.
Formula: Needed reduction = program cost ÷ losses; result = losses × reduction − cost
What to do: If a pilot does not promise the needed reduction, narrow the program to the costliest losses and touch the price gap that feeds the gray flow; extend protection only after a pilot.
Think first: The program costs RUB 458,400, losses RUB 1,092,000. What share of losses must it remove to pay back?
Answer: RUB 458,400 ÷ RUB 1,092,000 = 42%. If a pilot shows less, the program is in the red.
Clienteling is limited by the consultant’s time
The client book works while the consultant has time. In the case three client circles (60, 240 and 300) with different contact frequency need 720 hours a year, that is 1.3 consultants at 540 hours for clients each. Payback differs by circle: the inner circle gives RUB 483,120 of net result, the core base RUB 72,960, new clients −RUB 20,400 after an hour’s cost of RUB 1,500. The consultant’s time is needed more by the inner circle, and for new clients mailings and CRM are more effective. Sales after a contact are not necessarily a result of the contact: compare with a group without contacts.
Formula: Contacts = clients × frequency; hours = contacts × minutes ÷ 60; result = contacts × conversion × check × margin − hours × rate
How to work through it
- Describe three demand scenarios (low, medium, high) and their probabilities from your own data.
- Calculate expected profit and money invested for a drop and for a regular run.
- Decide what you do with leftovers and include their cost in the calculation.
- Check that the price premium covers the lost sales at expected demand.
- Write out the customer ladder: entry, core, premium line, and climb rates.
- Work out how much you can afford to lose on entry at the given climb rate.
- Track the real climb rate in the CRM and adjust the entry price.
Where to start
Planning a drop: first the drop and scarcity calculation (run, sale of leftovers), then the client ladder from CRM data: entry item and the customer’s climb. Calculations of the topic in order: “Drop and scarcity: run size, sell-out and leftover”, “Client ladder: entry item and climbing”, “Counterfeits and the gray market: lost margin, customer complaints, the cost of protection, payback and the needed reduction of losses”.
Calculations in this topic
Drop and scarcity: run size, sell-out and leftover
Compares a limited release (a drop) with a regular one on expected profit. For each it calculates the optimal run size under uncertain demand, the probability of selling out and the expected leftover. Shows whether the price premium pays for the smaller volume.
Does the price premium pay for the smaller volume of a drop and what should the run size be.
Client ladder: entry item and climbing
A premium brand customer starts with an affordable item and then climbs the steps. The calculation counts revenue and margin per customer over the horizon, the payback of acquisition and how much the brand can lose on the entry item for the sake of later purchases.
How much can be lost on the entry item for the sake of later purchases.
Counterfeits and the gray market: lost margin, customer complaints, the cost of protection, payback and the needed reduction of losses
From an estimate of counterfeits and the volume of authentic goods outside your channels it counts how much margin a brand loses in a year, what customer complaints about fakes cost, what a protection program costs (marketplace monitoring, takedowns, an authenticity layer on the item) and whether it pays back at a given reduction of losses. The main result: what share of the losses protection must remove to pay for itself. The volumes of counterfeits and the gray market are estimated by you: this is an estimate from monitoring, not a fact.
How much margin a brand loses on counterfeits and the gray market in a year, what the protection program costs, whether it pays back and what share of the losses it must remove to pay back.
Self-check questions
- What do we do with unsold stock and what does it cost?
- What demand do we consider minimum, medium and maximum?
- Does the price premium pay for the smaller volume?
- How much money is tied up in the run and when does it return?
- What share of entry-product buyers returns for a core piece?
- How long does a ladder step take?
- Does our discount practice teach customers to wait?
- Who sells our brand outside our own stores, and how?
Knowledge check
Multiple-choice questions. The correct answer and the explanation follow each question.
A drop: price RUB 12,000, cost RUB 5,000, the leftover after the season goes at RUB 3,000. What share of demand should the run cover (critical ratio) and what does it mean?
- A. 0.58: this is margin to price, the run must cover 58% of average demand
- B. 0.42: this is cost to price, the probability of selling out equals it
- C. 0.78: the run is chosen so that with a probability of 78% demand does not exceed it
- D. 0.25: this is the leftover price to price, the run exceeds demand by that much
Correct answer: C. 0.78: the run is chosen so that with a probability of 78% demand does not exceed it. Critical ratio = (price − cost) / (price − leftover price) = 7,000 / 9,000 = 0.78: a shortfall of the run costs the margin of RUB 7,000, an overage RUB 2,000 (5,000 − 3,000). The run is set at the level where the probability that demand is not above the run equals 0.78. 0.58 is margin to price (7 / 12), 0.42 cost to price, 0.25 leftover price to price: they do not compare the cost of a shortfall and of an overage.
600 fakes, a quarter of buyers would have bought the original, a margin of RUB 3,600 per item. How much lost margin (without complaints)?
- A. 2,160,000 ₽
- B. 552,000 ₽
- C. 900,000 ₽
- D. 540,000 ₽
Correct answer: D. 540,000 ₽. 600 × 25% × RUB 3,600 = RUB 540,000. RUB 2,160,000 counts every fake as a lost sale; RUB 552,000 includes customer complaints that are not in the question; RUB 900,000 counts revenue, not margin. Covered in: A fake is not a lost sale.
Protection costs RUB 458,400 a year, losses without protection RUB 1,092,000. What loss reduction is needed to pay back?
- A. 42%
- B. 35%
- C. 120%
- D. 100%
Correct answer: A. 42%. Cost ÷ losses = 42%. 35% is the actual reduction by a pilot, not the needed one; 120% divides the cost by the effect; 100% is not needed: one can pay back by removing a part of the losses. Covered in: Protection pays when it removes the needed share of losses.
Clienteling: 60 inner-circle clients, 12 contacts a year of 25 minutes. How many hours a year does this circle take?
- A. 540 h
- B. 300 h
- C. 720 h
- D. 18,000 h
Correct answer: B. 300 h. Contacts 60 × 12 = 720; hours 720 × 25 ÷ 60 = 300. 720 is the number of contacts and 540 hours is a consultant’s yearly time budget for clients. Covered in: Clienteling is limited by the consultant’s time.
By circles, new clients give a net result of −RUB 20,400 after the cost of hours. What is sensible to do?
- A. Refuse new clients
- B. Raise the price only for them
- C. Give them more of the consultant’s time
- D. Move them to mailings and CRM and give the consultant’s time to the inner circle
Correct answer: D. Move them to mailings and CRM and give the consultant’s time to the inner circle. A consultant’s contact with a new client costs more than it brings; mailings are cheaper and the time is needed more by the inner circle where the result is positive. There is no need to refuse new clients: they are the base of future circles. Covered in: Clienteling is limited by the consultant’s time.
Common mistakes
- Judging a drop by revenue only. Consequence: tied-up money and leftovers are missed. Avoid: compare profit and return per rouble invested.
- Scarcity without demand. Consequence: you make little and nobody wants it. Avoid: check recognition and a waiting list before release.
- Discounting luxury leftovers. Consequence: customers learn to wait, price erodes. Avoid: plan the run below demand and keep closed channels for leftovers.
- Making the entry too cheap. Consequence: the customer only buys the entry. Avoid: link entry to an invitation to the core line and measure the climb.
- Counting the ladder by entry units sold. Consequence: sales grow but customer value does not. Avoid: track the share who returned and their margin.
Mistake: Counting each fake as a lost sale
What it costs: The losses are overstated and protection looks profitable Having bought protection on overstated losses, the brand gets a result of −RUB 75,600 a year instead of the promised gain.
How to avoid: Count the share of buyers who would buy the original. Count losses by the share of buyers who would buy the original and compare the cost of protection with the payback threshold before buying a service; run a pilot on a narrow set of items.
What it looks like (illustrative figures): Our case: 600 fakes × RUB 3,600 of margin = RUB 2,160,000. The protection program costs RUB 458,400 and it seems it will pay back. With a substitution share of 25% the losses from fakes are RUB 540,000, and the whole effect of protection is RUB 382,800.
Russia and the EAEU
For a premium brand in Russia the key defense of the image is the trademark. Register it with Rospatent by goods classes (clothing, footwear, accessories) and services; renewal is needed every ten years. A mark protects against counterfeits and against parallel imports under your name, but parallel import of original goods is allowed under a special list of the Ministry of Industry and Trade, so follow it.
On tax: VAT of 22% applies to retail, and 10% to children’s goods when conditions are confirmed; premium goods bear the general rate. Exclusive and closed sales (by invitation, pre-order) need careful contracts: restricting resale is acceptable, but imposing a retail price is not, as it violates the competition protection law (135-FZ). Have the wording checked by a lawyer.
Light-industry marking (Chestny ZNAK) is mandatory for most apparel and footwear, and rare runs go through it too. Every unit of a drop needs a code. For leather, fur and accessories deadlines and lists differ, which is a separate topic. License agreements are registered with Rospatent, and the licensor’s remuneration is taxed under general rules, so agree the scheme with your accountant. Enter the parameters in the calculations from your own sales.
The logic of scarcity and the customer ladder is the same. Legal protection of a mark and taxes differ. Guide, please verify: the union has common customs regulation, but trademarks are registered nationally (each country has its own office), and there are Eurasian mechanisms for some goods. VAT rates by country are on the page “EAEU and CIS countries”. Purchasing power and payment habits differ: rouble, tenge, dram, som and Belarusian rouble. Luxury prices are usually pegged to one currency, and the exchange rate is built into the premium. Check mark registration in each country before entry.
Categories and audiences
- Apparel
- For apparel: drops work for capsules and collaborations where value is in rarity. Basics are better not limited. Watch sizes: shortage of popular sizes annoys the customer, while extreme sizes remain in stock.
- Footwear
- If it is footwear: limited models and collaborations hold price, but a size run makes leftovers heavy. Plan size distribution in advance: better a wider run in a smaller edition. Size returns undermine scarcity, so fitting is needed.
- Accessories
- On accessories: the ideal entry on the customer ladder, because the check is lower and the image the same. A bag or belt introduces the brand. But a too-mass accessory dilutes prestige, while a limit on color or run works for rarity.
- Kids
- Premium kids' goods grow fast, but scarcity works weakly: the child outgrows the item, it is worn briefly, and parents compare price with wear time. The ladder runs from gift to family line. Value lies in material safety, gift packaging and resale option.
- Men
- Men are loyal to a brand and to a proven cut: entry is often an accessory or a basic, the climb is toward the suit and outerwear. Scarcity works on collaborations and footwear. Check grows through sets, not frequency.
- Women
- Women more often buy across categories: bags, shoes, clothing. The ladder is built between them. Scarcity works on seasonal collections and bags. Track returns and the status role of gift purchases.
Questions this topic answers
- Does the price premium pay for the smaller volume of a drop?
- What run size is optimal for a drop and how often will we sell out?
- How much can be lost on the entry item for the sake of later purchases?
- How much can be lost on an entry item for the sake of later purchases?
Key measures and terms
Study first
What next
Related: “Markdown and exit price”, “Customers and loyalty”, “Collection and range”.
Documents on this topic
- Intellectual property: trademark, industrial design, prints, patterns, dupes, counterfeits
- Brand licensing and collaborations: royalty, minimum guarantee, economics and contract
- Market pyramid: segments, markups and business model
- Circular models: resale, upcycling, repair, rental
- Diffusion lines, private label, multibrand balance, collaborations, capsules and drops
- Brand platform and positioning
- Price and purchase psychology: what to test and how to measure the effect
- Resale, collaborations and packaging: economics of buy-back and resale, capsule P&L and partner deal structure, the eco fee (EPR)
- Luxury and premium in Russian realities: brand identity, scarcity and drops, selective distribution, clienteling, the fight against counterfeits and the gray market
- Formats by economics: haute couture, luxury, bridge, mass market, off-price, flash sales, travel retail and live shopping