Resale, collaborations and packaging: economics of buy-back and resale, capsule P&L and partner deal structure, the eco fee (EPR)
Three blocks of economics that are new to a brand: the secondary market (buy-back, inspection, repair, resale), collaborations and licensing (a capsule with a partner, fixed fee and royalty) and obligations for packaging and goods (extended producer responsibility). The document gives formulas and structure to decide what buy-back price can be paid, whether a capsule will pay back and how much to set aside for the eco fee.
Why this document
Resale, collaboration and the eco fee look like different topics but share one mistake: decisions are made from the picture, not from unit economics. Buy-back at a price “because it is a pity” loses money on items in average condition, a capsule with a loud partner without a minimum guarantee and run loses money on leftovers, and the eco fee grows silently with the mass of packaging. The document is read by the commercial and finance directors and the sustainability manager; it is needed to count before the deal, not after.
At a glance
- What is this document and why is it needed?
- Three blocks of economics that are new to a brand: the secondary market (buy-back, inspection, repair, resale), collaborations and licensing (a capsule with a partner, fixed fee and royalty) and obligations for packaging and goods (extended producer responsibility). The document gives formulas and structure to decide what buy-back price can be paid, whether a capsule will pay back and how much to set aside for the eco fee.
- Who owns the document and how often is it rebuilt?
- The commercial director (resale and collaborations), the finance director (deals and reserves), the sustainability manager and a lawyer (EPR and rights); revised once a year and before every deal.
- What mistakes are the most common?
- Buy-back is paid “fairly” and not at the maximum price → the contribution is negative for average condition → count the maximum by grade. Brand: signs a collaboration without a minimum guarantee and a run limit → leftovers are sold at a discount and the image is lost → a run by scenario and the right to sell off in the contract. Retail: places a secondary-market corner on the best meters → loses the margin of the main hall → compare margin per meter with the main hall.
For whom
- Brand
- The brand launches its own resale as an extension of the product’s life and a way to keep a customer, releases collaborations for awareness and a new audience and is responsible as producer or importer for the recycling of packaging and goods; it has more rights to the trademark and quality, so more image risk.
- Retail
- The retailer can accept items for trade-in, hold a secondary-market corner, sell partners’ collaboration capsules and is responsible for the packaging of private labels and imported goods; turnover, shelf space and absence of cannibalization of new items matter more to it.
What it consists of
Resale: buy-back and resale
- Models: own resale (the brand buys back and resells), a secondary-market platform (the brand gives authentication and a catalog), trade-in (the customer gets points or a discount on a new purchase).
- Condition assessment: grade A, B, C by a checklist (wear, defects, odor, hardware); the grade determines the buy-back price, repair and the probability of sale; grade C more often goes to recycling.
- Buy-back price: not above the maximum at which the expected contribution is non-negative: (probability of sale × resale price − costs) ÷ (1 − (1 − probability) × residual share).
- Authentication and repair: checking authenticity and condition, dry cleaning and minor repair as part of the price; for luxury authentication is the main advantage and the key to trust.
- Accounting and taxes: for the brand a buy-back from an individual and the subsequent sale are recorded as a purchase and sale of goods; tax consequences (VAT on the difference, personal income tax for the customer) depend on the scheme, check with a tax specialist.
Collaborations and licensing
- Goals: awareness, a new audience, a limited run with hype, access to design or technology; the goal determines the partner and the run.
- Deal structure: a fixed payment to the partner, royalty on sales, a minimum guarantee, a mixed model; the higher the royalty and guarantee, the lower the partner’s risk and the higher yours.
- Run and marketing: the run is limited so that surplus does not have to be sold at a discount; the marketing budget is planned immediately, not after release.
- Rights and termination: whose trademarks and copyrights are used, term, territory, the right to sell off leftovers after expiry, quality and sample approval.
- Capsule P&L: revenue, price reductions, cost of goods, royalty, fixed payment, marketing, tooling, other, profit; calculated before signing the contract.
Packaging and extended producer responsibility (EPR)
- What is covered: goods and packaging under the lists approved by the Government; the obligation lies with producers and importers of goods and packaging, including those who sell under their own brand.
- How it is fulfilled: recycling at a normative share of the mass of goods and packaging released or payment of the eco fee; normatives and rates are set by Government acts and change.
- Reporting: a declaration and a recycling report, supporting documents; check the deadline and procedure in current acts.
- Calculation: the fee = packaging mass (t) × recycling normative × rate per tonne × group coefficient; take values from the acts (illustrative in the example for teaching), include a reserve in the unit cost.
- Reducing the fee: lowering the mass of packaging, switching to recyclable materials, own recycling, recording and confirming recycling; eco-friendly packaging must still protect, otherwise returns grow.
What the brand does
- Brand: decides whether it needs its own resale or a platform; sets a grade checklist, buy-back prices by grade and item acceptance rules.
- Brand: watches cannibalization: the secondary market price must not push out sales of new items, so it sets a lower price bound and a volume limit.
- Brand: before a collaboration deal calculates the capsule P&L under three scenarios of run and sell-through and fixes in the contract the minimum guarantee and the treatment of leftovers.
- Brand: keeps records of the mass of packaging and goods by group and builds the eco fee into the unit cost, and looks for ways to reduce packaging mass.
What the retailer does
- Retail: accepts trade-in as a way to bring a customer to a new purchase; counts what a buy-back costs in points and what contribution a repeat visit gives.
- Retail: for a secondary-market corner counts turnover and margin per meter and compares with the main hall; the corner must not occupy the best meters.
- Retail: when selling collaboration capsules agrees a quota, price and the right to return leftovers; such capsules sell out quickly, and leftovers are hard to sell off.
- Retail: finds out who is the producer or importer of packaging and goods of private labels, keeps records and EPR reporting and includes the fee in the cost.
Where the data comes from
| Data source | Fields |
|---|---|
| Buy-back requests and the grade checklist | item, condition, photos, new price, offered buy-back price |
| Sales of the secondary channel | price, time to sale, returns, repair and authentication costs |
| Collaboration terms | run, price, royalty, fixed fee, guarantee, marketing, rights, terms |
| Packaging and goods records | mass by group, normatives and rates from acts, recycling reports |
How to build it step by step
- Step 1: Brand: choose a secondary-market model (own resale, platform, trade-in) and set the grade checklist A, B, C.
- Step 2: Retail: calculate by grade the probability and price of resale, repair, inspection and handling costs and the maximum buy-back price (see the example).
- Step 3: Brand: set the lower price bound of the secondary channel and a volume limit so as not to push out sales of new items.
- Step 4: For a collaboration build the capsule P&L in three scenarios of run and sell-through (see the figure) and find the run at which profit is non-negative.
- Step 5: Retail: agree on a quota, the right to return leftovers and payment terms; check that the capsule does not push out the main shelf.
- Step 6: Check the rights to trademarks and copyrights, term and territory, fix the right to sell off leftovers.
- Step 7: Brand: collect the mass of packaging and goods by group, find normatives and rates in the acts and calculate the fee per unit.
- Step 8: Retail: include the fee and resale in the unit cost and the budget; once a year revise buy-back prices and fees by new acts.
Formulas
| Measure | Formulas | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Expected contribution of a bought-back item | Contribution = p × Resale price + (1 − p) × s × Buy-back price − Buy-back price − (Repair + Inspection + Handling) | p: probability of sale in time, s: the residual share of the buy-back price recovered from an unsold item (for example by selling for recycling). |
| Maximum buy-back price | Max buy-back price = (p × Resale price − Costs) ÷ (1 − (1 − p) × s) | Above this price the contribution is negative; if the value is negative the item is not worth buying back. |
| Capsule profit | Profit = Revenue − Price reductions − Cost of goods − Royalty − Fixed fee − Marketing − Tooling − Other | Royalty is counted on revenue after price reductions; fix the royalty base in the contract. |
Formulas in notation
- Eco fee (structure)
E = M · n · c · k
M: mass of packaging or goods in tonnes, n: recycling normative, c: rate per tonne, k: group coefficient; the values n, c and k are taken from the acts.
Worked example
A teaching buy-back by grade: new price 10,000 ₽, handling 350 ₽, inspection 150 ₽, residual share 40%
| Grade | Buy-back, ₽ | Resale, ₽ | Probability of sale, % | Repair, inspection, handling, ₽ | Expected contribution, ₽ | Max buy-back price, ₽ |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| A: like new | 4,500 | 6,500 | 85 | 600 | 695 | 5,239 |
| B: good | 2,800 | 5,000 | 70 | 900 | 136 | 2,955 |
| C: with defects | 1,200 | 3,000 | 45 | 2,000 | −1,586 | do not buy |
The numbers are illustrative. Grade A brings a contribution even at a buy-back price above the offered one, grade B is near zero at the offered price (repair and handling eat the contribution), grade C loses: repair, inspection and handling costs at a low probability of sale exceed the expected revenue, such an item goes to recycling.
Figures
- Offered buy-back price
- Maximum buy-back price
Data as a table
| Measure | Offered buy-back price | Maximum buy-back price |
|---|---|---|
| A: like new | 4,500 | 5,239 |
| B: good | 2,800 | 2,955 |
| C: with defects | 1,200 | 0 |
Buy-back price and the maximum price by grade. The offered buy-back price and the maximum at which the contribution is zero: for grade C the maximum is below zero, so the bar is zero and the item is not bought.
- positive
- negative
- total
Data as a table
| Step | Change | Level |
|---|---|---|
| Revenue | — | 13,000 |
| Price reductions | −585 | 12,415 |
| Cost of goods | −5,200 | 7,215 |
| Royalty | −993 | 6,222 |
| Fixed fee | −500 | 5,722 |
| Marketing | −900 | 4,822 |
| Tooling | −400 | 4,422 |
| Other | −372 | 4,050 |
| Profit | — | 4,050 |
Collaboration capsule P&L. From revenue to profit: royalty and the fixed fee to the partner, marketing, tooling and price reductions on leftovers; a run of 2,000 units.
The secondary market loop. An item comes back, is checked, repaired and sold again; the unneeded goes to recycling.
- Customer returns an item → Assessment: grade A, B, C
- Assessment: grade A, B, C → Inspection and repair; Recycling; New purchase (points)
- Inspection and repair → Resale
- Resale
- Recycling
- New purchase (points)
Specifics by category
- Apparel
- Apparel: resale works well for outerwear, dresses and basics with a recognizable brand; condition (wear, odor, stains) and size determine the probability of sale.
- Footwear
- Footwear: sole and insole wear, the shape of the last and odor reduce price sharply; repair (heels, soles) often pays back; size limits buyers.
- Accessories
- Accessories: bags, belts, jewelry hold their price best on the secondary market; authentication and the condition of hardware are decisive, and repair and cleaning are cheap.
- Kids
- Kids: a short life of an item and fast growth; good demand on the secondary market, but safety, hygiene and certificates limit the format; prices are lower, volumes bigger.
- Men
- Men’s: stable styles and sizes, demand for classics and outerwear; resale is more predictable, and repair and cleaning pay back more often.
- Women
- Women’s: trends age quickly, so the secondary market price falls more sharply; dresses, outerwear and recognizable models sell well, fast turnover is needed.
Common mistakes
- Buy-back is paid “fairly” and not at the maximum price → the contribution is negative for average condition → count the maximum by grade.
- Brand: signs a collaboration without a minimum guarantee and a run limit → leftovers are sold at a discount and the image is lost → a run by scenario and the right to sell off in the contract.
- Retail: places a secondary-market corner on the best meters → loses the margin of the main hall → compare margin per meter with the main hall.
- The eco fee is not included in the unit cost → margin is overstated → keep the packaging mass and set the fee aside.
- Resale is considered “eco-friendly” without counting cannibalization → the secondary channel pushes out new sales → a volume limit and a lower price bound.
Russian specifics
- Extended responsibility of producers and importers is set by the law on production and consumption waste; lists of goods and packaging, recycling normatives and fee rates are set by Government acts (including decrees No. 2414, No. 1041 and the 2026 amendments); check values in the current version. Rule: Law 89-FZ of 24.06.1998: Federal Law of 24.06.1998 No. 89-FZ “On production and consumption waste” (extended producer responsibility, Art. 24.2 ff.).
- Rights to trademarks, design and copyright materials are transferred under a license agreement (part four of the Civil Code); check the form, term, territory and the need for registration with a lawyer. Rule: Civil Code part 4: Civil Code, part four (Arts. 1232, 1235, 1237, 1486, 1491, 1515).
- Packaging recycling normatives and the reporting procedure have changed; fee rates and coefficients for 2026 were kept at the 2025 level (decree No. 258); check new acts before calculating. Rule: Decree 258 of 11.03.2026: Government Decree of 11.03.2026 No. 258 (amendments to Decree No. 1041: 2026 coefficients kept at the 2025 level).
- Taxation of buy-back from individuals, trade-in and resale (VAT, corporate income tax, tax for the customer) depends on the scheme and the status of participants; unverified, consult a tax specialist.