Brand resale: buy-back, processing and resale
Calculates the economics of one item in the secondary market: what you pay the customer, what inspection, cleaning and repair cost, what you sell it for and what is left after commission and returns. Shows the item margin, the impact on new sales and the payback of the launch.
At a glance
- What question does it answer?
- Does an item pay back in the secondary market and does it not eat into new sales.
- What data is needed?
- The buy-back to the customer, processing, resale price, commission, delivery.
- How to read the result?
- An item accepted for 2,500 and sold for 6,500 at a 12% commission gives 5,720 after commission. After processing, inspection (70% acceptable), 85% sold and returns the margin is 1,516 per accepted item. If 20% of buyers would have bought new (margin 3,200), 972 remains. At 300 items a month a launch of 1.5m pays back in 5.1 months; the break-even resale price is 4,474. Example on the default values: Revenue per sold item after commission — RUB 5,720; Cost per accepted item — RUB 3,064.29; Margin per accepted item — RUB 1,515.51; Margin after lost sales of new items — RUB 971.51.
Why and how to reason
Brand resale is the economics of one item that has a buy-back price, preparation costs and risks: not everything offered is suitable, not everything accepted sells, and some of what sells is returned. So we count per accepted item. Revenue per sold item 6,500 × (1 − 12%) = RUB 5,720; after delivery of 300 and expected return of 8% × 400 = 32 there remains RUB 5,388. Costs: buy-back 2,500 + processing 450 + inspection of offered items attributable to one suitable: 80 ÷ 70% = RUB 114, total RUB 3,064. 85% of accepted items sell: margin per accepted item 0.85 × 5,388 − 3,064 = RUB 1,516. But resale takes part of the demand for new: 20% of buyers would have bought a new item with a margin of 3,200, loss 0.2 × 0.85 × 3,200 = RUB 544. Margin after the loss RUB 972. Break-even resale price RUB 4,474. At 300 items a month profit is 291 thousand ₽ and the 1.5 million launch pays back in 5.1 months.
When to use it
It comes in handy when deciding to launch a program of buying back and reselling a brand’s items and choosing the buy-back price. Assumptions: shares of suitable, sold and returned items are estimated from a pilot. It does not fit a brand whose items lose value after first wear nor cases where authenticity cannot be guaranteed. Besides money, resale brings customers and brand sustainability, but they are not counted here: assess them separately.
How to read the result
Look at margin after lost sales of new: it shows the real benefit. If cannibalization eats most of the margin, resale is useful only as image. The break-even resale price (RUB 4,474) against a price of RUB 6,500 gives a cushion that protects if price falls. Payback of the launch in 5 months at 300 items a month depends on volume: check whether you can source that many. Decision: start with a small pilot. Launch the program with a limited set of categories and measure three things: suitable share, sold share and cannibalization; then rerun the calculation on real shares.
Common mistakes
The usual mistakes: ignoring inspection of rejected items; assuming all accepted items will sell; not entering returns; ignoring cannibalization; setting a buy-back price higher than resale can cover. The cost of cleaning and repair depends heavily on item condition. Do not promise customers a buy-back price before the item is inspected.
What data is needed?
- The buy-back to the customer, processing, resale price, commission, delivery.
- The share acceptable and sold, returns; launch investment, flow, the margin of a new item and the share who would have bought new.
Inputs
| Field | Unit | Value in the example | Meaning |
|---|---|---|---|
| Buy-back or credit to the customer | ₽ | 2,500 | What you pay for an accepted item. |
| Cleaning, repair and photos | ₽ | 450 | Per accepted item. Empty: zero. |
| Resale price excl. VAT | ₽ | 6,500 | Check taxes and the accounting of second-hand goods with an accountant and a lawyer. |
| Platform or payment commission | % | 12 | A share of the resale price. Empty: zero. |
| Delivery to the customer | ₽ | 300 | Per sold item. Empty: zero. |
| Share of acceptable items among those offered | % | 70 | The rest are rejected at inspection. |
| Inspection of one offered item | ₽ | 80 | Time and logistics for each item offered. Empty: zero. |
| Share of accepted items that will sell | % | 85 | Unsold items are worth zero in the calculation: conservative. |
| Share of sold items returned | % | 8 | The share of sold items that are returned, in percent: from sales records; empty means zero. |
| Cost of one return | ₽ | 400 | Logistics and handling. Empty: zero. |
| Launch investment | ₽ | 1,500,000 | Website, processes, training. Empty: payback not calculated. |
| Accepted items a month | pcs | 300 | Empty: payback not calculated. |
| Margin of a new item | ₽ | 3,200 | To estimate cannibalization. Empty: cannibalization not calculated. |
| Share of resale buyers who would have bought new | % | 20 | An estimate from a survey or a control. Empty: zero. |
How it is calculated
| Step | Formula |
|---|---|
| Cost per accepted item | buy-back + processing + inspection ÷ acceptable share |
| Margin | sold share × (price × (1 − commission) − delivery − returns × return cost) − cost per accepted item |
| Break-even price | (cost ÷ sold share + delivery + returns × return cost) ÷ (1 − commission) |
| Payback | investment ÷ (margin after the loss × items a month) |
Worked numbers
Default values from the app; in the interactive version you enter your own.
- Revenue per sold item after commission
- 5,720 ₽
- Cost per accepted item
- 3,064.29 ₽Buy-back + processing + inspection of offered items attributable to one acceptable item.
- Margin per accepted item
- 1,515.51 ₽
- Margin after lost sales of new items
- 971.51 ₽Minus the share of buyers who would have bought new, times the margin of a new item.
- Break-even resale price
- 4,473.91 ₽
- Profit a month
- 291,454 ₽
- Payback of the launch
- 5.1 months
The path of one item
| Item | Per accepted item |
|---|---|
| Buy-back to the customer | −2,500 ₽ |
| Processing | −450 ₽ |
| Inspection of offered items | −114.29 ₽ |
| Revenue after commission × sold share | 4,862 ₽ |
| Delivery and returns × sold share | −282.2 ₽ |
| Margin | 1,515.51 ₽ |
| Lost sales of new items | −544 ₽ |
| Margin after the loss | 971.51 ₽ |
Resale is useful to a brand as a retention channel and a way to work with leftovers, but check taxes, accounting and rights to trade second-hand goods with a lawyer and an accountant. Data on traceability and the condition of the item will also help with a digital product passport.
Nuances and limits
- Taxes, accounting and rights to trade second-hand goods are not confirmed by this calculation: check with a lawyer and an accountant.
- Unsold items are counted as zero: conservative.
- Take the cannibalization estimate from a survey or a control, not from a feeling.