Counterfeits and the gray market: lost margin, customer complaints, the cost of protection, payback and the needed reduction of losses
From an estimate of counterfeits and the volume of authentic goods outside your channels it counts how much margin a brand loses in a year, what customer complaints about fakes cost, what a protection program costs (marketplace monitoring, takedowns, an authenticity layer on the item) and whether it pays back at a given reduction of losses. The main result: what share of the losses protection must remove to pay for itself. The volumes of counterfeits and the gray market are estimated by you: this is an estimate from monitoring, not a fact.
At a glance
- What question does it answer?
- How much margin a brand loses on counterfeits and the gray market in a year, what the protection program costs, whether it pays back and what share of the losses it must remove to pay back.
- What data is needed?
- Estimates of the number of counterfeits and of authentic goods outside your channels from monitoring, test purchases and complaints.
- How to read the result?
- Example on the default values (1,200 items, 600 counterfeits, 300 gray, monitoring RUB 360 thousand): losses without protection RUB 1.09 million, of which counterfeits and complaints RUB 552,000, gray market RUB 540,000; the program costs RUB 458,400, the effect is RUB 382,800, the result −RUB 75,600; to pay back it must remove 42% of losses against an actual 35%. Example on the default values: Brand losses without protection a year: RUB 1.09 million; Of which counterfeits and complaints: RUB 552,000; Of which gray market: RUB 540,000; Cost of the protection program: RUB 458,400. The figures are illustrative: enter your own to see your result.
Why and how to reason
A fake is not a lost sale: many buyers would not have bought the original at your price. So losses are counted not by the number of fakes but by the share of those who would buy the authentic item, plus the cost of customer complaints about fakes. The gray market loses margin only where it takes a sale from your channel. The price of the program is set against these losses: monitoring, takedowns, an authenticity layer. The main number: what share of losses protection must remove to pay back. So the calculation guards against two errors: buying protection “just in case” and refusing it when losses are large. Example: losses of RUB 1.09 million a year, a program of RUB 458,400, it must remove 42% and gives 35%: a result of −RUB 75,600.
When to use it
The calculation is needed before buying monitoring and an authenticity layer, when revising the brand protection budget, when noticeable counterfeits grow on marketplaces and when entering new markets where parallel import is widespread. It does not prove an infringement and does not assess the lawfulness of a specific channel: parallel import is allowed in Russia by lists. For footwear and leather accessories the share of fakes is higher, for children’s the safety of a fake matters, and for jewelry and watches the authenticity layer costs differently.
How to read the result
First compare two shares: the needed loss reduction (42%) and the actual one by your pilot estimate (35%). While the actual is below the needed, the program is in the red and the payback of 14 months is longer than a year. Then look at where the losses are: counterfeits and complaints RUB 552,000, gray market RUB 540,000. The gap of gray goods to your price in the example is RUB 1,200 per item: if it stays, the flow comes back after any campaign. Recheck the estimates of fakes and gray goods every quarter: both the losses and the payback threshold of protection depend on them.
Common mistakes
The first error: counting each fake as a lost sale. The second: buying costly monitoring without a pilot and without a payback threshold. The third: fighting the gray market only with claims without touching the price gap. The fourth: mixing authentic gray goods and fakes: they have different losses and different measures.
What data is needed?
- Estimates of the number of counterfeits and of authentic goods outside your channels from monitoring, test purchases and complaints.
- The price excluding VAT, the gross margin and sales in lawful channels.
- The cost of monitoring, takedowns and the authenticity layer and the expected loss reduction from a pilot.
Inputs
| Field | Unit | Value in the example | Meaning |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sales in your channels a year | units | 1,200 | How many items a year you sell through your own and authorized channels. The example value is illustrative. |
| Average price excluding VAT | ₽ | 6,000 | The price at which the item goes to the brand in lawful channels, excluding VAT. The example value is illustrative. |
| Gross margin | % | 60 | The share of the price excluding VAT left after cost: this is what is lost. The example value is illustrative. |
| Counterfeits in circulation a year | units | 600 | An estimate from marketplace monitoring, test purchases and complaints; the figure cannot be measured exactly, give a range. The example value is illustrative. |
| Share of fake buyers who would buy the authentic item | % | 25 | Many buyers of fakes would not buy the original at your price: count only those who would. The example value is illustrative. |
| Complaints per 100 fakes | cases | 5 | How many buyers of a fake approach the brand with a claim (warranty, return, complaint). The example value is illustrative. |
| Cost of one complaint | ₽ | 400 | Support time, checking the item and a reply: what it costs to handle one complaint. The example value is illustrative. |
| Authentic goods outside your channels | units | 300 | How many authentic items are sold without your knowledge: parallel imports, resale beyond distribution terms. An estimate. The example value is illustrative. |
| Discount of gray goods to your price | % | 20 | How much cheaper the gray item is than yours: how many customers it takes depends on this gap. The example value is illustrative. |
| Share of gray goods taking sales from you | % | 50 | What part of gray sales takes a sale from a lawful channel rather than going past you. The example value is illustrative. |
| Marketplace monitoring a year | ₽ | 360,000 | The cost of a service or people who search for counterfeits and gray sales over a year. The example value is illustrative. |
| Takedowns a year | cases | 240 | How many takedown requests to marketplaces you file. The example value is illustrative. |
| Cost of one takedown | ₽ | 350 | A lawyer’s or specialist’s work on one request, including repeated ones. The example value is illustrative. |
| Authenticity layer per item | ₽ | 12 | An extra tag or authenticity code beyond the mandatory marking: the price per item. The example value is illustrative. |
| Reduction of counterfeit losses by protection | % | 40 | What share of counterfeit losses and complaints the program will really remove; do not promise yourself more than a pilot showed. The example value is illustrative. |
| Reduction of gray-market losses by protection | % | 30 | What share of gray losses distribution control by contract and work with violators will remove. The example value is illustrative. |
How it is calculated
| Step | Formula |
|---|---|
| Counterfeit margin | counterfeits × substitution share × price × margin |
| Complaints | counterfeits × complaints per 100 ÷ 100 × cost of a complaint |
| Grey market | authentic outside channels × share taking sales × price × margin |
| Cost of protection | monitoring + takedowns × cost of a takedown + authenticity layer × sales |
| Result and threshold | effect − cost; needed reduction = cost ÷ losses |
Worked numbers
Default values from the app; in the interactive version you enter your own.
- Brand losses without protection a year
- 1.09 m ₽
- Of which counterfeits and complaints
- 552,000 ₽
- Of which grey market
- 540,000 ₽
- Cost of the protection program
- 458,400 ₽
- Effect of protection a year
- 382,800 ₽
- Result of protection a year
- −75,600 ₽
- Return on protection
- −16 %
- Payback time
- 14.4 months
- Loss reduction needed for payback
- 42 %
- Actual loss reduction by the program
- 35 %
- Share of fakes and grey goods in the brand’s circulation
- 43 %
- Grey goods price gap per item
- 1,200 ₽
- Without protection
- After protection
Data as a table
| Measure | Without protection | After protection |
|---|---|---|
| Counterfeits: margin | 540k | 324k |
| Customer complaints | 12k | 7,200 |
| Grey market: margin | 540k | 378k |
Data as a table
| Share of losses removed, % | Result |
|---|---|
| 0 | −458k |
| 10 | −349k |
| 20 | −240k |
| 30 | −131k |
| 40 | −21.6k |
| 50 | 87.6k |
| 60 | 197k |
| 70 | 306k |
| 80 | 415k |
Losses and effect by source
| Source | Losses, ₽ a year | Reduction, % | Effect, ₽ a year |
|---|---|---|---|
| Counterfeits: margin | 540,000 ₽ | 40 | 216,000 ₽ |
| Customer complaints | 12,000 ₽ | 40 | 4,800 ₽ |
| Grey market: margin | 540,000 ₽ | 30 | 162,000 ₽ |
| Total | 1.09 m ₽ | 35 | 382,800 ₽ |
At the set reductions the program does not pay back: it must remove at least 42% of the losses and it gives 35%. Narrow the program to the costliest losses or check the estimates.
Counterfeits and the grey market are estimated from marketplace monitoring, test purchases and complaints: there is no exact figure, give a range and recalculate when the estimate changes. Protection pays when it removes at least the needed share of losses, and its effect is not only in margin: the reputation and product safety risk falls. Remember the price too: the gap of grey goods to your price sustains the flow, so fighting violators alone will not stop it (see the calculation “Price corridor”). For footwear and leather accessories fakes are more frequent, and the authenticity layer and material check are their own; for children’s the safety of a fake matters.
Nuances and limits
- Counting each fake as a lost sale: many buyers of fakes would not have bought the original.
- Buying costly monitoring without a pilot and without a payback threshold.
- Fighting the gray market with claims only, without looking at the price gap that feeds it.