Price consistency between countries and channels: the price corridor, the gray market, the exchange rate and EAEU VAT
A review of how to check that the prices of one item in different countries and channels are consistent: bring them to one basis (excluding VAT, in roubles), set a corridor around the base price, check the gap at which resale between markets pays and decide in advance at what rate shift a price is revised. The document complements the calculation of a price for a country and the documents on price for the EAEU: they build a price, this one checks prices already set.
Why this document
Different prices in different countries and channels are inevitable: taxes, commissions, the rate and purchasing power differ. What is dangerous is not the differences but those nobody decided on: a forgotten price in tenge after a rate collapse, a marketplace cheaper than your own store, wholesale dearer than a partner’s retail. They feed the gray market and anger partners. The document gives a way to see all prices on one basis, to set a tolerance in advance and to revise a price at a threshold rather than in panic.
At a glance
- What is this document and why is it needed?
- A review of how to check that the prices of one item in different countries and channels are consistent: bring them to one basis (excluding VAT, in roubles), set a corridor around the base price, check the gap at which resale between markets pays and decide in advance at what rate shift a price is revised. The document complements the calculation of a price for a country and the documents on price for the EAEU: they build a price, this one checks prices already set.
- Who owns the document and how often is it rebuilt?
- Brand: the pricing or commercial director with the finance director and the head of export; retailer: the assortment and buying director; indices are viewed monthly and after every noticeable rate move; the result goes into decisions on revising prices and into partner contracts.
- What mistakes are the most common?
- Comparing shelf prices with VAT → a tax difference looks like a price one → count excluding VAT and in one currency. Demanding one price everywhere → pointless disputes with partners → set a corridor and the admissible reasons for deviation. Revising prices after a rate collapse → late and in panic → set the shift thresholds and the owner of the decision in advance.
For whom
- Brand
- The brand manages the price in several countries and channels and answers for their consistency. It needs to see the price index of each market against the base, keep the gap below the cost of moving goods and decide when to revise the price in local currency.
- Retail
- The retailer compares the price of one item across brands and channels and sets the shelf price itself. It needs to agree the tolerance on price and discounts with the brand and not to create channels from which goods go into gray circulation.
What it consists of
How to bring prices to one basis
- Remove the market VAT: price excluding VAT = shelf price ÷ (1 + VAT). Otherwise a tax difference looks like a price one: in the example Kazakhstan with VAT of 16% and Belarus with VAT of 20% are otherwise incomparable.
- Convert to roubles at the rate on the date of comparison (units of local currency per RUB 1). Kazakhstan: 44,000 tenge at a rate of 5.5 and VAT of 16% give RUB 6,897 excluding VAT, an index of 114.9 to the base of RUB 6,000.
- Compare one item and one size: promotions, sets and different sizes distort the index; for sets reduce the price to a unit.
- Distinguish the shelf price from the brand’s price: a marketplace and wholesale have different commissions and markups; the shelf index shows what the buyer sees, the index of the brand’s net receipt what stays with you. Count both.
- Fix the date and the source of the rate: a price recounted on different days gives different indices; for decisions take the weekly average so as not to react to noise.
The corridor: width and exceptions
- The corridor is a tolerance around the base: in the example ±10%, that is from 5,400 to RUB 6,600 excluding VAT. The width is set before looking at market prices, otherwise it is fitted to the result.
- For luxury the corridor is narrower, for mass goods wider: the more the image is tied to the price, the smaller the tolerance; for seasonal and promo items the tolerance is set separately.
- Exceptions are written down: a marketplace with its own promotion, a closed sale, a country with a special tax; without a record exceptions turn into a habit.
- The corridor does not demand one price everywhere: taxes, commissions and purchasing power legitimately differ; the aim is for differences to be a decision, not a forgotten price.
Gray flow: when it pays and what to do
- The condition: the gap of prices excluding VAT between the dearest and the cheapest market exceeds the cost of moving goods (delivery, duty, documents, the reseller’s profit). In the example the gap is RUB 1,610 between “Russia, marketplace” and “Kazakhstan” against a cost of moving of RUB 450: a margin of RUB 1,160.
- The direction of the flow is from the cheap market to the dear one: goods leave the market where the price is understated and interfere with sales where it is higher. Gray goods are lawful and subversive at the same time.
- Measures in order: pull the cheap channel up; limit lots to the cheap market; tie a lot to a partner by a number; only then claims and sanctions.
- If the price cannot be pulled up (the local market will not bear it), reduce the incentive: a different assortment, different sizes or packaging for the cheap market so that the goods are not interchangeable.
- Check each step with a lawyer: restrictions on prices and resale are regulated by competition law and admissibility depends on the country.
The rate: thresholds for revising a price
- If the local currency weakens by 15%, the price in roubles excluding VAT falls by the same: for the weakest foreign market (“Armenia”) the index falls from 95.5 to 81.2; 4 markets end up outside the corridor instead of 2.
- To restore the rouble revenue the local price is raised by 17.6% (1 ÷ (1 − shift) − 1): the raise is larger than the shift itself. This is arithmetic, not a position.
- Set thresholds in advance: for example, a shift of more than 5% in a week starts a check, more than 10% a revision. The decision “let us wait” is also a decision and is written down.
- It is sensible to revise prices in order: first the weakest markets and channels where the index fell below the corridor; strong markets can temporarily go above.
- Hedging and currency discounts (see “Price for the EAEU and CIS”) change the rate risk but do not replace the revision thresholds.
EAEU VAT: what to account for in the comparison
- VAT rates differ by country: in the example Russia 22%, Belarus 20%, Kazakhstan 16%, Armenia 20%, Kyrgyzstan 12%. Rates and regimes change, check the current ones for each country and item (unverified).
- Export to EAEU countries is taxed at 0% when confirmed by documents, while import is taxed with the recipient country’s VAT; the procedure and the terms of refund should be checked (unverified; see the calculations “Export to the EAEU” and “Import from the EAEU”).
- A tax difference is not a reason to change the price: the index is counted excluding VAT and the shelf price is obtained by a reverse calculation at the country’s rate.
- If the partner in a country is not a VAT payer, its shelf price equals the price excluding VAT; do not compare it directly with a payer’s price.
Brand: what to do
- Brand: choose the base market and the base price and write them down; all indices and the corridor are counted from it.
- Brand: collect a table of all channels and countries: shelf price, rate, VAT, commission; update monthly and after a noticeable rate move.
- Brand: set the width of the corridor and the rate thresholds before looking at prices and fix them with the owner of the decision.
- Brand: for each market outside the corridor write a decision: pull up, explain or leave with a review date.
- Brand: watch the gap of the dearest and the cheapest market against the cost of moving and pull the cheap channel up while the margin is positive.
- Brand: agree with partners the tolerance on price and discounts and the platform terms in the contract; check the wording with a lawyer.
- Brand: when a local currency falls revise the price at the threshold, starting with the weakest markets.
- Brand: keep the history of prices and decisions: a year later it explains why the price in a country is what it is.
Retail: what to do
- Retail: compare the price of an item across brands and channels excluding VAT; a shelf with VAT misleads when taxes differ.
- Retail: agree with the brand the tolerance on price and discounts so that a retailer’s promotion does not take the price outside the brand’s corridor.
- Retail: do not sell a brand’s goods into other countries and channels outside the contract: the price gap makes you a source of the gray flow.
- Retail: monitor competitors’ prices for the brand’s items and tell the brand about the prices of the gray channel.
- Retail: for private labels set the base and the corridor for the countries of presence and revise at the rate threshold.
- Retail: for imported goods count the shelf price from the full cost of import and the rate; build the rate reserve into the price in advance.
- Retail: keep online and offline prices in one corridor: a gap between the channels of one network irritates the buyer and breeds resale.
- Retail: write down exceptions (promotions, closed sales, special lots) with an end date.
Where the data comes from
| Data source | Fields |
|---|---|
| Price lists, platform listings and retail prices by country | the shelf price in local currency with VAT, date, channel, promotion or not, size, set |
| Rates and VAT rates | the rate on the date of comparison (units per RUB 1), the source of the rate, the country’s VAT rate and the partner’s regime |
| Logistics and customs | the cost of delivery between markets, duty, documents, the reseller’s profit per item |
| Partner contracts and the history of price decisions | tolerance on price and discounts, platform rules, exceptions, revision thresholds |
How to build it step by step
- Step 1. Choose the base market and the base price, write down the date and the source of the rate.
- Step 2. Collect a table of markets and channels: shelf price, rate, VAT.
- Step 3. Bring prices to roubles excluding VAT and count the index to the base.
- Step 4. Set the width of the corridor before looking at prices and mark the markets outside it.
- Step 5. Find the dearest and the cheapest market and compare the gap with the cost of moving goods.
- Step 6. For each market outside the corridor write a decision: pull up, explain or revise by a date.
- Step 7. Play out a rate shift and see which markets will leave the corridor; set the revision thresholds in advance.
- Step 8. Check the table monthly and after a noticeable rate move and keep the history of decisions.
Formulas
| Measure | Formulas | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Price excluding VAT in roubles and the index | P = p ÷ (1 + VAT) ÷ k; I = P ÷ P₀ × 100 | p is the shelf price in local currency with VAT, k is the rate (units of local currency per RUB 1), P₀ is the base excluding VAT. |
| The gray flow condition | P_max − P_min − C > 0 | C is the cost of moving one item: delivery, duty, documents, the reseller’s profit. |
| Rate shift | I′ = I × (1 − s); price rise = 1 ÷ (1 − s) − 1 | s is the weakening of the local currency against the rouble; the local price rise is larger than the shift itself. |
Formulas in notation
- Price index
I = p / (1 + v) / k / P0 × 100
p is the shelf price, v is VAT, k is the rate (units per RUB 1), P0 is the base excluding VAT.- Price rise at a rate shift
u = 1 / (1 − s) − 1
s is the weakening of the local currency; the raise is larger than the shift itself.
Worked example
Prices of a hypothetical label by market and channel: base RUB 7,320 with VAT of 22%, a corridor of ±10%, a rate shift of 15%
| Market | Shelf price, units | In ₽ excl. VAT | Index | Corridor | Index after the shift |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Russia, own online store | 7,320 | 6,000 | 100.0 | inside | 100.0 |
| Russia, marketplace | 6,450 | 5,287 | 88.1 | below | 88.1 |
| Russia, wholesale: the partner’s shelf price | 7,990 | 6,549 | 109.2 | inside | 109.2 |
| Belarus | 255 | 6,071 | 101.2 | inside | 86.0 |
| Kazakhstan | 44,000 | 6,897 | 114.9 | above | 97.7 |
| Armenia | 33,000 | 5,729 | 95.5 | inside | 81.2 |
| Kyrgyzstan | 7,100 | 6,037 | 100.6 | inside | 85.5 |
The gap is RUB 1,610 against a cost of moving of RUB 450 (a margin of RUB 1,160); after the shift 4 markets are outside the corridor. All numbers are illustrative.
Figures
- Now
- After the rate shift
Data as a table
| Measure | Now | After the rate shift |
|---|---|---|
| Russia, own online store | 100 | 100 |
| Russia, marketplace | 88.1 | 88.1 |
| Russia, wholesale: the partner’s shelf price | 109 | 109 |
| Belarus | 101 | 86 |
| Kazakhstan | 115 | 97.7 |
| Armenia | 95.5 | 81.2 |
| Kyrgyzstan | 101 | 85.5 |
Index of the price excluding VAT to the base, % (base = 100). Now and after the local currencies weaken: markets outside a corridor of ±10% are visible at once; the Russian channels are not affected by the rate (illustrative data).
- 71.6 … 115 %
Data as a table
| 0% | 5% | 10% | 15% | 20% | 25% | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Russia, own online store | 100 | 100 | 100 | 100 | 100 | 100 |
| Russia, marketplace | 88.1 | 88.1 | 88.1 | 88.1 | 88.1 | 88.1 |
| Russia, wholesale: the partner’s shelf price | 109 | 109 | 109 | 109 | 109 | 109 |
| Belarus | 101 | 96.1 | 91.1 | 86 | 81 | 75.9 |
| Kazakhstan | 115 | 109 | 103 | 97.7 | 92 | 86.2 |
| Armenia | 95.5 | 90.7 | 85.9 | 81.2 | 76.4 | 71.6 |
| Kyrgyzstan | 101 | 95.6 | 90.6 | 85.5 | 80.5 | 75.5 |
Price index by market at different weakening of the local currency, %. The stronger the weakening, the more foreign markets go below the corridor; the Russian channels stay at their values (illustrative data).
- Armenia
- Lower edge of the corridor
Data as a table
| Weakening of the local currency, % | Armenia | Lower edge of the corridor |
|---|---|---|
| 0 | 95.5 | 90 |
| 5 | 90.7 | 90 |
| 10 | 85.9 | 90 |
| 15 | 81.2 | 90 |
| 20 | 76.4 | 90 |
| 25 | 71.6 | 90 |
| 30 | 66.8 | 90 |
Index of the weakest foreign market as the currency weakens, %. The index falls linearly with the weakening; the crossing of the lower edge of the corridor shows the threshold for revising the price (illustrative data).
Specifics by category
- Apparel
- Apparel: seasonal collections and promotions shift the price in time, compare on one date and item; basic items hold a narrower corridor, seasonal ones a wider one.
- Footwear
- Footwear: the size grid and different lasts by country complicate the comparison of “one item”; the duty and marking regime for footwear is its own, so the cost of moving goods is higher.
- Accessories
- Accessories: light and expensive items are easier to resell, the cost of moving is small, so a gray flow appears at a small gap; the corridor is narrower.
- Kids
- Children’s: the tax regime and safety requirements may differ by country; count the price excluding VAT and check whether separate confirming documentation is needed for the market.
- Men
- Men’s: suits and outerwear are dearer and heavier, the cost of moving per unit is higher, so the admissible gap is wider and the corridor can be held wider.
- Women
- Women’s: more promotions, fittings and returns, the price in a channel jumps more; watch the index by weeks and keep the promotion rule in the contract.
Common mistakes
- Comparing shelf prices with VAT → a tax difference looks like a price one → count excluding VAT and in one currency.
- Demanding one price everywhere → pointless disputes with partners → set a corridor and the admissible reasons for deviation.
- Revising prices after a rate collapse → late and in panic → set the shift thresholds and the owner of the decision in advance.
- Punishing resellers and not touching the price gap → the flow returns → pull the cheap channel up while the margin over the cost of moving is positive.
- Forgetting a price in local currency set long ago → it falls below the corridor after a rate move → check the table monthly.
Russian specifics
- The VAT rate in Russia is 22% for taxable items; check the regime and exemptions for your item and tax regime (unverified).
- The taxation of exports and imports within the EAEU (a zero rate when confirmed, the recipient country’s VAT) is laid down in the EAEU Treaty, Annex 18; the details and terms have not been checked against the text (unverified). Rule: Treaty Annex 18 of 29.05.2014: Treaty on the Eurasian Economic Union, Annex No. 18 (indirect taxes) (rule check not completed).
- Agreements restricting resale prices and trade terms are checked under the competition law; admissibility depends on the type of agreement and the market share (unverified). Rule: Law 135-FZ of 26.07.2006: Federal Law of 26.07.2006 No. 135-FZ on protection of competition (rule check not completed).
- A comparison with the “former price” and an indication of a discount in advertising must be truthful under the advertising law (unverified). Rule: Law 38-FZ of 13.03.2006: Federal Law of 13.03.2006 No. 38-FZ on advertising (rule check not completed).