Syntha Lab RU

Margin by sales channel

Compares how much money is left per unit in wholesale, own retail, marketplace and website after fees, logistics, returns and advertising.

Channels: wholesale, retail, platforms For whom: Brands selling through several channels.

Calculate on your data →

At a glance

What question does it answer?
What is left per unit in wholesale, own retail, marketplace and the website.
What data is needed?
Unit cost.
How to read the result?
Compare profit per unit and profit for the period: a channel with high unit margin may have small volume. Exclude channels with the tick to see the effect. Example on the default values: Cost RUB 2,200, four channels. Own retail leaves the most per ordered unit, RUB 5,127.96; the average profit per ordered unit across channels is RUB 2,978.47 and total profit for the period RUB 11,616,016. If the best-margin channel has a small volume, look at the total for the period, not only profit per unit. Next: “Marketplace unit economics and break-even price”, “Returns: what they cost and how they hit margin”.

Why and how to reason

One and the same item has a different fate in different channels: wholesale has a low price but almost no costs; a marketplace has a high price but commission, logistics, advertising and returns. What should be compared is not the price but what remains per unit. For each channel we trace the money: price, minus loss to returns, minus commission, minus cost (of sold units only), minus logistics and advertising.

A key point about returns: a returned unit brought no money, but its cost is not lost either, the item returned to stock. So profit per ordered unit is counted with the factor (1 - returns).

Example. Wholesale: price 4,900 x 0.98 = 4,802, minus cost 2,200 x 0.98 = 2,156, minus logistics 80: RUB 2,566. Own retail: 8,300 x 0.94 = 7,802, commission 2% about 156, cost 2,068, logistics 150, advertising 300: RUB 5,128. Marketplace: RUB 2,475.

When to use it

Use it when deciding which channel to direct goods to and how much advertising budget to give it. Especially useful before a season when allocating stock across channels. It does not reflect volume limits: the best channel may have small capacity. Assumption: prices, commissions and returns are constant. As a channel grows, its returns and logistics may change. Empty fields are treated as zero.

How to read the result

Compare channels by profit per ordered unit and by total profit: an expensive channel with small volume gives less money than a cheap one with large volume. In the example wholesale brings RUB 2,566 a unit but 2,400 units, while own retail brings RUB 5,128 from 500 units. The average profit shows the overall effect of the mix. Decision: strengthen channels with high profit and capacity, cut those with negative profit but check their strategic role. Then test a scenario of rising returns. Do not forget side effects: a marketplace gives reach and wholesale loads production, so a channel cannot be dropped on margin alone.

Common mistakes

Comparing only percentage margin rather than roubles; not including advertising and return logistics; entering the platform commission as a share of the price ex VAT when it is charged with VAT; using the same return rate for different channels. Also: failing to account that part of retail sales is made by the brand itself.

What data is needed?

  • Unit cost.
  • By channel: price, fee, logistics, advertising, returns and volume (prices excl. VAT).
  • Where to take it: prices and volumes by channel from the sales reports (wholesale, retail, marketplace, site) in 1C or the ERP; commissions from contracts and platform statements; logistics and advertising per unit from closing documents divided by units; returns from return reports. All prices excl. VAT, volume taken as “ordered before returns”.

Inputs

FieldUnitValue in the exampleMeaning
Unit cost₽2,200The same for all channels.

How it is calculated

StepFormula
Revenue net of returnsPrice × (1 − returns)
Profit per ordered unitRevenue − fee − cost × (1 − returns) − logistics − marketing
Per sold unitProfit per ordered unit ÷ (1 − returns); the marketplace calculation works the same way

Worked numbers

Default values from the app; in the interactive version you enter your own.

Best channel per ordered unit
5,127.96 ₽ · Own retail
Total profit for the period
11.6 m ₽Before the brand’s fixed costs.
Average profit per ordered unit
2,978.47 ₽

By channel

ChannelPer ordered unitPer sold unitMargin on price (per sold)Ordered, unitsTotal profit
Wholesale (stores)2,566 ₽2,618.37 ₽53 %2,4006.16 m ₽
Own retail5,127.96 ₽5,455.28 ₽66 %5002.56 m ₽
Marketplace2,474.68 ₽3,017.9 ₽36 %7001.73 m ₽
Brand website3,871.2 ₽4,301.33 ₽52 %3001.16 m ₽

The most per unit remains in “Own retail”: 5,127.96 ₽. A channel with high unit margin may have small volume, so look at the period total as well.

Nuances and limits

  • Percentages and amounts in the example are illustrative: replace with your own.
  • Include return logistics in “Logistics per unit”.
  • A returned item is assumed intact and resold with no loss in price: estimate markdown and write-off losses in the Returns model.

Terms used

Calculate on your data →