Margin by sales channel
Compares how much money is left per unit in wholesale, own retail, marketplace and website after fees, logistics, returns and advertising.
At a glance
- What question does it answer?
- What is left per unit in wholesale, own retail, marketplace and the website.
- What data is needed?
- Unit cost.
- How to read the result?
- Compare profit per unit and profit for the period: a channel with high unit margin may have small volume. Exclude channels with the tick to see the effect. Example on the default values: Cost RUB 2,200, four channels. Own retail leaves the most per ordered unit, RUB 5,127.96; the average profit per ordered unit across channels is RUB 2,978.47 and total profit for the period RUB 11,616,016. If the best-margin channel has a small volume, look at the total for the period, not only profit per unit. Next: “Marketplace unit economics and break-even price”, “Returns: what they cost and how they hit margin”.
Why and how to reason
One and the same item has a different fate in different channels: wholesale has a low price but almost no costs; a marketplace has a high price but commission, logistics, advertising and returns. What should be compared is not the price but what remains per unit. For each channel we trace the money: price, minus loss to returns, minus commission, minus cost (of sold units only), minus logistics and advertising.
A key point about returns: a returned unit brought no money, but its cost is not lost either, the item returned to stock. So profit per ordered unit is counted with the factor (1 - returns).
Example. Wholesale: price 4,900 x 0.98 = 4,802, minus cost 2,200 x 0.98 = 2,156, minus logistics 80: RUB 2,566. Own retail: 8,300 x 0.94 = 7,802, commission 2% about 156, cost 2,068, logistics 150, advertising 300: RUB 5,128. Marketplace: RUB 2,475.
When to use it
Use it when deciding which channel to direct goods to and how much advertising budget to give it. Especially useful before a season when allocating stock across channels. It does not reflect volume limits: the best channel may have small capacity. Assumption: prices, commissions and returns are constant. As a channel grows, its returns and logistics may change. Empty fields are treated as zero.
How to read the result
Compare channels by profit per ordered unit and by total profit: an expensive channel with small volume gives less money than a cheap one with large volume. In the example wholesale brings RUB 2,566 a unit but 2,400 units, while own retail brings RUB 5,128 from 500 units. The average profit shows the overall effect of the mix. Decision: strengthen channels with high profit and capacity, cut those with negative profit but check their strategic role. Then test a scenario of rising returns. Do not forget side effects: a marketplace gives reach and wholesale loads production, so a channel cannot be dropped on margin alone.
Common mistakes
Comparing only percentage margin rather than roubles; not including advertising and return logistics; entering the platform commission as a share of the price ex VAT when it is charged with VAT; using the same return rate for different channels. Also: failing to account that part of retail sales is made by the brand itself.
What data is needed?
- Unit cost.
- By channel: price, fee, logistics, advertising, returns and volume (prices excl. VAT).
- Where to take it: prices and volumes by channel from the sales reports (wholesale, retail, marketplace, site) in 1C or the ERP; commissions from contracts and platform statements; logistics and advertising per unit from closing documents divided by units; returns from return reports. All prices excl. VAT, volume taken as “ordered before returns”.
Inputs
| Field | Unit | Value in the example | Meaning |
|---|---|---|---|
| Unit cost | ₽ | 2,200 | The same for all channels. |
How it is calculated
| Step | Formula |
|---|---|
| Revenue net of returns | Price × (1 − returns) |
| Profit per ordered unit | Revenue − fee − cost × (1 − returns) − logistics − marketing |
| Per sold unit | Profit per ordered unit ÷ (1 − returns); the marketplace calculation works the same way |
Worked numbers
Default values from the app; in the interactive version you enter your own.
- Best channel per ordered unit
- 5,127.96 ₽ · Own retail
- Total profit for the period
- 11.6 m ₽Before the brand’s fixed costs.
- Average profit per ordered unit
- 2,978.47 ₽
By channel
| Channel | Per ordered unit | Per sold unit | Margin on price (per sold) | Ordered, units | Total profit |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Wholesale (stores) | 2,566 ₽ | 2,618.37 ₽ | 53 % | 2,400 | 6.16 m ₽ |
| Own retail | 5,127.96 ₽ | 5,455.28 ₽ | 66 % | 500 | 2.56 m ₽ |
| Marketplace | 2,474.68 ₽ | 3,017.9 ₽ | 36 % | 700 | 1.73 m ₽ |
| Brand website | 3,871.2 ₽ | 4,301.33 ₽ | 52 % | 300 | 1.16 m ₽ |
The most per unit remains in “Own retail”: 5,127.96 ₽. A channel with high unit margin may have small volume, so look at the period total as well.
Nuances and limits
- Percentages and amounts in the example are illustrative: replace with your own.
- Include return logistics in “Logistics per unit”.
- A returned item is assumed intact and resold with no loss in price: estimate markdown and write-off losses in the Returns model.