Channels: wholesale, retail, platforms
What is left per unit in each channel after fees, logistics, returns and advertising and whether a channel withstands your discount policy.
About the topic
The same sweater can be sold four ways: wholesale to a shop, in your own retail, through a marketplace and on your own site. From each of these the brand gets different money, because each has its own commissions, logistics, returns, advertising and payment terms. This topic teaches an honest comparison of channels: how much really remains per unit after everything, and in which channel growth pays and in which it only inflates turnover.
The reasoning starts from a common point: what the brand receives for a piece and what the piece costs. Take a conditional example. The item stands on the shelf at RUB 5,000 with 22% VAT, RUB 4,098 without tax, cost RUB 900. In wholesale the brand usually gets about half of the retail price before VAT: say RUB 2,050. Margin per unit is RUB 1,150, and this is money without advertising, but with payment deferral and risk. On a marketplace you set the shelf price, but commission and logistics are taken from it. For a conditional calculation let commission be 20% (RUB 1,000), logistics RUB 200, advertising 10% (RUB 500), buyout rate 70%: for each sold unit there are about 0.43 returns, and reverse logistics and loss of presentable condition add about RUB 65. What remains is 4,098 − 1,000 − 200 − 500 − 65 = RUB 2,333 before cost and about RUB 1,433 after. That is more than in wholesale, but the money arrives differently and part of sales depends on advertising.
This is exactly why channels cannot be compared by unit margin. Volume, capital turnover and risk matter. Wholesale gives large volume in one deal and money by contract, but presses on price and requires deferrals. A marketplace gives reach but takes control of price and customer. Own retail and a site give the highest margin and customer data but require investment in traffic and premises.
The decisions of the topic: which channel to direct stock to; how to build a discount policy so a discount in one channel does not crush the price in the others; whether to enter a new channel or a franchise. Traps: ignoring returns, comparing margin before advertising and logistics, not noticing price conflict between channels. Where to start: compute the contribution levels (CM1-CM3) for each channel on the same model and compare them side by side.
Key ideas
Channel margin after everything
It is convenient to express deductions as percentages of the price without VAT: that makes channels comparable. Price RUB 3,000: commission 18% (RUB 540), direct logistics RUB 150 (5%), advertising 8% (RUB 240), returns 4% (RUB 120). Together 35%, or RUB 1,050. RUB 1,950 remains, and with a cost of RUB 800 the contribution is RUB 1,150, or 38% of the price.
Contribution levels CM1, CM2, CM3
CM1 is revenue minus cost and channel commissions, CM2 subtracts logistics, order handling and returns, CM3 subtracts advertising. This shows at which level a channel loses money: often it is fine on CM1 and weak on CM3. Buyout affects everything: at a 70% buyout the cost of reverse logistics lands on the units sold.
Volume and capital matter more than unit margin
Wholesale earns less per unit but takes volume in one order and turns stock quickly. If wholesale gives RUB 1,150 per unit and a marketplace RUB 1,433, but wholesale sells 2,000 pieces per season and the marketplace 600, wholesale brings RUB 2.3 million against RUB 0.86 million. Compare money per year, not unit margin.
Returns as a channel cost
Online returns are large and costly: reverse logistics, inspection, loss of presentable condition, sometimes write-off. A channel with a 50% buyout and one with 85% at the same commission give different economics. A return must be included in unit economics as a mandatory line.
Discounts and channel conflict
A discount in one channel is visible to the buyer in all. If goods are cheaper on a marketplace than in your retail, the buyer leaves and your retail loses sales. The price and discount policy must account for all channels, and a promotion must pay back: sales growth must cover the margin loss. A price gap between channels and countries feeds the gray flow: in the illustrative case the gap of prices excluding VAT between the extreme markets is RUB 1,610 against a cost of moving of RUB 450, so the cheap channel is pulled up first and claims are applied afterwards.
How to work through it
- Choose one model and fix the shelf price, the price before VAT and the cost.
- For each channel assemble terms: commission, logistics, advertising, returns, payment term.
- Compute CM1-CM3 for each channel taking the buyout rate into account.
- For a marketplace find the break-even price and check the cost of returns.
- Add volume and turnover: how much each channel can sell and how fast money returns.
- Check the discount policy: whether a promotion pays back and whether it breaks the price in other channels.
- Decide the allocation of stock and volume across channels and, if needed, assess a franchise or a new channel.
Where to start
First “Margin by channel”, then “Marketplace unit economics and break-even price”, “Returns” and “Promo discount”. Calculations of the topic in order: “Margin by sales channel”, “Cost to serve an online order”, “Franchise: brand income and partner payback”, “Price corridor: prices by country and channel on one basis, gray flow and an exchange-rate shift”. See also (their primary topic is another one): “Marketplace unit economics and break-even price”, “Promo discount: the sales lift that makes it pay”, “Stacking: total discount and order of application”, “Contribution levels CM1–CM3 by channel with buyout”.
Calculations in this topic
Margin by sales channel
Compares how much money is left per unit in wholesale, own retail, marketplace and website after fees, logistics, returns and advertising.
What is left per unit in wholesale, own retail, marketplace and the website.
Cost to serve an online order
Gathers the costs of warehouse, delivery, returns, payment, support and marketing and shows what it costs to serve one order, what share of revenue that is and what margin remains after serving.
What it costs to serve one order and how much gross margin is left after warehouse, delivery, returns, payment, support and marketing.
Franchise: brand income and partner payback
Calculates the partner store’s profit and payback and the brand’s income from the store: upfront fee, royalty and the supply markup less support. Shows whether payback fits the contract term.
How much the brand earns on a franchise store, when the partner pays back and whether payback fits the contract term.
Price corridor: prices by country and channel on one basis, gray flow and an exchange-rate shift
Brings the existing shelf prices in different countries and channels to one basis (excluding VAT, in roubles), counts the index to the base price, shows which markets are outside the set corridor, whether there is a gap at which resale between markets pays and what happens to the index when the local currency weakens. The difference from the “price for a country” calculation: that one builds a price from margin and commission, this one checks the consistency of prices already set.
Which markets and channels went outside the corridor around the base price, whether there is a gap at which resale between markets pays and what a weaker local currency will do to the price.
Marketplace unit economics and break-even price
Calculates what is left per sold unit after commission, logistics, storage, advertising, returns and tax, and at what price and ad spend a sale breaks even.
What is left per sold unit after all deductions and at what price a sale breaks even.
Promo discount: the sales lift that makes it pay
Shows how much more you must sell for a promo discount not to reduce profit, and compares promo discount depths. Cutting the price of leftovers at season end needs a different calculation: it looks at the stock, not at the sales lift.
By how many percent you must sell more for a discount not to reduce profit.
Stacking: total discount and order of application
Combines a shelf discount, a promo code and points or cashback into one total discount, shows the unit price and margin, the “ceiling” of the total discount at your minimum margin and the difference between orders of application.
What a purchase really costs a customer with a discount, a code and points together and whether we broke the margin.
Contribution levels CM1–CM3 by channel with buyout
For sales channels (site, platforms, partners) calculates contribution step by step: CM1 after cost of goods and commissions on what was bought, CM2 after logistics and handling of orders and returns, CM3 after marketing. Shows contribution per order and the allowable marketing per order.
How much is left of revenue after buyout at each contribution step and which channel is better per order.
Self-check questions
- What remains with the brand per unit in each channel after all costs?
- Are returns and reverse logistics included in the calculation?
- What buyout rate is assumed and where does it come from?
- How many pieces and roubles per season can each channel give?
- How many days until money arrives from each channel?
- Does the channel withstand our discount policy?
- Is the marketplace price not lower than in our retail and wholesale?
- What happens if the channel commission rises or advertising gets more expensive?
Knowledge check
Multiple-choice questions. The correct answer and the explanation follow each question.
Wholesale: price RUB 4,000, cost RUB 1,800, returns 5%, logistics RUB 60 per unit. How much is left per ordered unit?
- A. RUB 2,030
- B. RUB 1,940
- C. RUB 2,140
- D. RUB 2,090
Correct answer: A. RUB 2,030. A returned unit brings no price, but its cost stays in the warehouse: 4,000 × 0.95 − 1,800 × 0.95 − 60 = 3,800 − 1,710 − 60 = RUB 2,030. 1,940 comes from subtracting the cost of the whole ordered unit (3,800 − 1,800 − 60); 2,140 from ignoring returns; 2,090 from forgetting logistics.
Marketplace: tax 6%, commission 20%, acquiring 1.5%, advertising 7% of the price; returns 20%. Fixed costs per unit: logistics RUB 110, return handling RUB 140 per return, storage RUB 30, cost RUB 1,500 (a returned unit stays in the warehouse). What is the break-even price?
- A. RUB 2,089
- B. RUB 2,359
- C. RUB 3,183
- D. RUB 2,611
Correct answer: D. RUB 2,611. The share of the price after percentage deductions a = 1 − 0.06 − 0.20 − 0.015 − 0.07 = 0.655. Fixed: 110 + 140 × 0.2 + 30 + 1,500 × 0.8 = RUB 1,368. Price = 1,368 / (0.8 × 0.655) ≈ RUB 2,611. 2,089 comes without the factor (1 − returns); 2,359 from forgetting advertising (a = 0.725); 3,183 from putting the whole RUB 1,500 cost on every ordered unit.
The gap of prices excluding VAT between the dearest and cheapest market is RUB 1,610, the cost of moving RUB 450. What is the margin over the cost of moving?
- A. 450 ₽
- B. 1,160 ₽
- C. 1,610 ₽
- D. 2,060 ₽
Correct answer: B. 1,160 ₽. 1,610 − 450 = RUB 1,160: a positive margin means resale pays. RUB 1,610 is the gap itself, RUB 2,060 is its sum with the cost of moving.
The cost of moving is RUB 450, the gap of prices excluding VAT is RUB 1,610. At what cost of moving will the flow stop?
- A. Above 5,400 ₽
- B. The flow never stops
- C. Above 1,610 ₽
- D. Above 450 ₽
Correct answer: C. Above 1,610 ₽. The flow pays while the gap exceeds the cost of moving: it stops when the cost exceeds RUB 1,610. This rather suggests closing the gap than raising the cost.
Resale pays and the flow goes on. What is done first?
- A. Claims are sent to everyone at once
- B. The price in the dear country is lowered
- C. Nothing: the flow will stop by itself
- D. The cheap channel is pulled up and the batch is tied to the partner by a number
Correct answer: D. The cheap channel is pulled up and the batch is tied to the partner by a number. Claims without closing the price gap will not stop the flow: first the cause is removed, then claims and sanctions are applied.
Common mistakes
Mistake: Ignoring returns and reverse logistics
What it costs: Online channel margin is overstated
How to avoid: Include buyout and return cost in the calculation.
Mistake: Comparing channels by unit margin without volume
What it costs: Choosing a small but “expensive” channel
How to avoid: Compare money per year and capital turnover.
Mistake: Comparing channel margins before advertising and logistics
What it costs: The channel seems profitable
How to avoid: Count by levels CM1-CM3.
Mistake: Not noticing the pressure of one channel’s discount on the rest
What it costs: Price falls in retail and wholesale
How to avoid: Keep a single price and discount policy.
Mistake: Taking the marketplace commission by habit
What it costs: The calculation diverges from reality
How to avoid: Check against the platform’s current offer on the date of calculation.
Russia and the EAEU
In Russia channels differ in taxes and documents. Wholesale goes by a supply contract with UPD through electronic document exchange; the price with 22% VAT or without depends on your regime and the buyer’s. Own retail works with an online cash register under law 54-FZ, and marked goods must be withdrawn from circulation at sale and a receipt issued at return. A sale on a marketplace follows the platform’s offer: commissions, logistics, penalties and payout terms are set by it and change, so set them as parameters, not constants.
Chestny ZNAK marking (decree 1956) is mandatory in all channels: the code is passed down the chain and withdrawn at retail sale, and on marketplaces goods with a code pass through the corresponding mechanisms. Returns go through a return correction document and code handling.
Online advertising in Russia is labeled (ERIR), and its cost is part of acquisition cost. From 1 October 2026 the law on the platform economy (289-FZ) applies, which changes relations with platforms: check which requirements apply to you. Taxes under the simplified and the general regime give different net revenue by channel: ask your accountant.
Channels in other EAEU countries are arranged differently. Indicative notes, verify before deciding: in Kazakhstan the large platform Kaspi has shown commissions before VAT since 5 January 2026, and VAT in the country is 16%; in Belarus 20%, in Armenia 20%, in Kyrgyzstan 12% plus a sales tax at a product-specific rate. Online shares, Wildberries and Ozon commissions outside Russia and platform terms in these countries differ by country, so do not assume Russian tariffs (indicative as of 14.11.2026, check the text of the act). Light-industry marking in Kazakhstan starts on 1 December 2026 (indicative), for other countries the dates: indicative as of 14.11.2026, check the text of the act. Currency and payment habits (cards, instalments) differ in each country.
Categories and audiences
- Apparel
- For apparel: returns are higher because of fitting, especially online, and this is the main item in channel economics. A size grid and accurate descriptions reduce them. Wholesale and retail give steady volume, but an end-of-season discount in one channel quickly spreads to the others.
- Footwear
- If it is footwear: returns are even higher due to size and fit, and reverse logistics is heavy and box-based. A marketplace gives reach, but break-even price is sensitive to the share of returns, so it is counted separately. Large retailers buy by size grids, and wholesale requires depth across the core of sizes.
- Accessories
- On accessories: fewer returns and light packaging, so online channels are often more profitable than for apparel. Purchases are often impulsive and gifts: holidays affect revenue. Wholesale to multibrand shops is useful for recognition, and own retail for image, so channels are counted as a system.
- Kids
- In children’s wear: the buyer is a parent, and the decision is tied to the growth season and school, with frequent size returns. Marketplaces give reach, but certificates and marking are needed in every channel. Wholesale to children’s chains runs on long deferrals, so check channel contribution including the cost of money.
- Men
- In a men’s basket of basics the buyer knows their size, so online buyout is higher and the returns line in the channel contribution is smaller. Check this on your own data and calculate channel contribution for the segment separately rather than for the brand on average. Evaluate promotions on basics for payback separately: the price of a basic item is easy to compare, and a discount quickly spreads to other channels.
- Women
- Women’s returns are higher because of fit: a shopper sometimes orders one model in two sizes and returns the extra. For the channel this is a separate returns line in the contribution calculation, which is taken by category (dresses, tops, knitwear) rather than as a brand average. Shoppers compare prices across channels actively, so check that a marketplace discount does not pull the price down in your own retail.
Questions this topic answers
- What is left per unit in each channel?
- Does the marketplace pay off after returns?
- Does a channel withstand our discount policy?
- What is better for a brand: giving volume to wholesale or selling less at a higher margin through its own channels?
Key measures and terms
- Contribution per unit
- Ad cost ratio (DRR)
- Margin
- Required sales lift for a promo discount
- Sell-in and sell-out
- Break-even price on a marketplace
- Purchase rate (share of ordered units kept) and non-purchases
- Returns and resale at full price
- Total platform deductions (take rate)
- Travel retail: airports and transport
- Dropshipping
Study first
What next
Next step: “Store sales and receipts: traffic, conversion, ticket”. Related: “Wholesale terms and credit”, “Platforms and marketplaces”, “Advertising and customer acquisition”.
Documents on this topic
- Income statement (P&L): management and statutory
- Sales formats: offline, online and secondary channels
- Marketplaces of Russia and the CIS: platform map, FBO, FBS and DBS models and how to choose
- Unit economics by platform: how to build the calculation from deductions, compare schemes and find the break-even price
- Formats by economics: haute couture, luxury, bridge, mass market, off-price, flash sales, travel retail and live shopping
- Jewelry: metal, fineness, stones and the cost by metal
- Price consistency between countries and channels: the price corridor, the gray market, the exchange rate and EAEU VAT
- Price for the EAEU and the CIS: channel parity, currency discounts, ladders in the local currency
- Luxury and premium in Russian realities: brand identity, scarcity and drops, selective distribution, clienteling, the fight against counterfeits and the gray market