Syntha Lab RU

A payment to a foreign supplier: full cost, timing and exchange-rate risk

Compares ways to pay an invoice: the bank’s or agent’s rate against the official one, commission, a fixed fee, how many days money is in transit and how many days the rate stays unfixed. Shows the full cost of the payment, the price of time and the amount at risk if the rate moves.

A payment abroad, import and export to the EAEU For whom: Buyers, finance directors and accountants paying a foreign supplier.

Calculate on your data →

At a glance

What question does it answer?
Which payment way is cheaper allowing for commission, spread, days in transit and the rate risk.
What data is needed?
The invoice amount in currency, the rate on the day of the decision, payments per year.
How to read the result?
An invoice of 100,000 currency units at 90: at the official rate 9,000,000. A direct transfer (example: commission 0.5%, spread 0.3%, fee 3,000, 3 days in transit) costs 9,075,135, with the price of time 14,918 and 9,000 at rate risk 9,099,053. A payment agent (example: commission 2.5%, spread 1%, 5 days) 9,317,250 and 9,351,777 in all. A difference of 252,724 per payment, 3,032,684 a year at 12 payments. Example on the default values: The payment at the official rate: RUB 9 million; Cheaper with time and the rate shift: RUB 9.1 million · Direct bank transfer; Premium over the official rate of the cheaper way (commissions and spread): 0.8% · RUB 75,135; The price of time at the cheaper way (money in transit): RUB 14,918. The figures are illustrative: enter your own to see your result.

Why and how to reason

Paying a foreign supplier costs more than the figure on the invoice, and the difference has three parts. The first is rate and fee: the bank or agent takes a spread over the official rate and a percentage, sometimes a fixed charge as well. The second is time: while the money is in transit it is frozen, and that has a price. The third is risk: the rate is not fixed until the moment of payment (1 day in the default calculation), and in that time it may rise. For an invoice of 100,000 at RUB 90 the official amount is 9,000,000. Direct bank transfer: 9,000,000 × 1.003 × 1.005 + 3,000 = 9,075,135, three days in transit at a money cost of 20% costs 14,918, rate risk 9,000, total 9,099,053. Payment agent: 9,317,250 + 25,527 + 9,000 = 9,351,777.

When to use it

Use it when there is a choice of payment channel or regular payments: it shows that a low fee does not mean a cheap payment. It does not replace checking that a payment method is allowed: currency-control rules, sanctions and bank terms change, so check them separately. Assumption: rates and terms are constant, the stress move of the rate is linear. It also helps when reviewing a contract with a supplier: some terms (payment period, rate) can be changed.

How to read the result

Compare “Better when time and rate move are counted” with the payment at the official rate: the premium of the best method here is 0.83%, and the worst is several times more. “Better and worse: gap per year” (3.03 million at 12 payments) shows that the channel choice is money, not a trifle. “Amount at risk from the rate” (9,000) is not a loss but the size of a possible hit: if it frightens you, fix the rate or pay earlier. If the better method is only slightly cheaper, take the one that is more reliable on timing: a late payment usually costs more than the fee gap.

Common mistakes

Mistakes: comparing only the fee, omitting the fixed charge, using working days instead of calendar days, treating the cost of money as zero. It is wrong to count as a benefit a rate move “in our favor”: that is not a calculation but a bet on the rate. Remember that an agent may change the rate on the payment day: get the fixed figure in writing.

What data is needed?

  • The invoice amount in currency, the rate on the day of the decision, payments per year.
  • For each way: commission, spread, fixed fee, days until the rate is fixed and until the supplier receives.
  • The cost of money and the rate shift over 30 days.

Inputs

FieldUnitValue in the exampleMeaning
Invoice amount in foreign currencycurrency units100,000How much you owe the supplier in the contract currency. The example is illustrative.
Rate on the day of the decisionRUB per unit90The Bank of Russia official rate or your internal rate on the day you decided to pay. The example value is illustrative.
Such payments per yeara year12Needed to show the difference between ways over a year.
Your cost of money% a year20The rate of your own loan or overdraft from the bank contract; see the Bank of Russia key rate for the calculation date. The example value is illustrative.
Rate rise over 30 days (stress)% per 30 d3Your scenario: by how much the rate rises in a month. There is no single standard: take the worst month of your own past. Minus means a fall of the rate.

How it is calculated

StepFormula
Paymentamount × rate × (1 + spread) × (1 + commission) + fixed fee
Price of timepayment × cost of money × days in transit ÷ 365
At risk from the rateamount × rate × rise over 30 days × days until fixing ÷ 30

Worked numbers

Default values from the app; in the interactive version you enter your own.

The payment at the official rate
9 m ₽The invoice amount at the rate of the day of the decision: a guide without commissions and spread.
Cheaper with time and the rate shift
9.1 m ₽ · Direct bank transfer
Premium over the official rate of the cheaper way (commissions and spread)
0.8 % · 75,135 ₽
The price of time at the cheaper way (money in transit)
14,918 ₽
Amount at risk from the rate at the cheaper way
9,000 ₽Payment × rate rise over 30 days × days until fixing ÷ 30. If the rate is locked on the day of the decision there is no risk.
Dearest against cheapest: difference over a year
3.03 m ₽ · Payment agent
Total price of the payment by method
Bar chart: Direct bank transfer 9.1m, Payment agent 9.35m02m4m6m8m10mDirect bank transferDirect bank transferTotal: 9.1m9.1mPayment agentPayment agentTotal: 9.35m9.35m₽
Data as a table
MeasureTotal
Direct bank transfer9.1m
Payment agent9.35m

Payment ways: roubles for the invoice

WayRate with spreadCommissions and feesPaymentPrice of timeAt risk from the rateTotal
Direct bank transfer90.27 ₽48,135 ₽9.08 m ₽14,918 ₽9,000 ₽9.1 m ₽
Payment agent90.9 ₽227,250 ₽9.32 m ₽25,527 ₽9,000 ₽9.35 m ₽

The way cheapest by commission is not always cheaper overall: “Direct bank transfer” beats “Payment agent” by 252,724 ₽ per payment, with the price of time and the rate shift included.

Take the terms of the ways and the crediting times from the contract: the example is illustrative. The order and permissibility of payments abroad, including through payment agents, are governed by currency legislation (Federal Law of 10.12.2003 No. 173-FZ) and by measures that change; check them with the bank and a lawyer before paying, current measures are for the calculation date.

The rate can be locked in advance, but that is a separate bank service with a price: compare it with the amount at risk. The tax on exchange differences and their accounting: check with an accountant.

Norms (a guide as of 13.11.2026, check against the act text): Law of 10.12.2003 No. 173-FZ “On Currency Regulation and Currency Control”; Exchange rate and key rate on the calculation date. Check with an accountant and a lawyer.

Nuances and limits

  • The terms of the ways in the example are illustrative, not tariffs: take yours from the contract.
  • Check the permissibility of payments and currency-control measures with the bank and a lawyer (Federal Law of 10.12.2003 No. 173-FZ).
  • The amount at risk from the rate is a scenario, not a forecast.

Terms used

Calculate on your data →