Syntha Lab RU

Reader question: a container or consolidated cargo for a batch of 800 garments and what demurrage is

A short answer to the question “what is cheaper and safer: to take a whole container or to go by consolidated cargo, and what a container standing costs”. The reasoning goes from the volume of the batch to the equality point of the two methods, then money in transit and demurrage are added: the charge for using a container beyond the free time and for storage at the terminal. The result: the method of shipping and the size of a reserve for delays.

Production, logistics, channels Brand and retail Verified: 2026-11-14

Open interactively →

Why this document

A batch of a few hundred garments almost always lies between “too much for the post” and “too little for a container”, and the choice is made by the rate per unit, forgetting time and fines. The buyer, the logistician and the CFO read this document before placing an order and when choosing the delivery terms. It shows at what volume a container pays off, how to count the price of a garment in consolidated cargo and how much each day of standing costs after the free time. Without such a calculation one customs delay easily eats the whole saving and the carrier rate becomes the only argument.

At a glance

What is this document and why is it needed?
A short answer to the question “what is cheaper and safer: to take a whole container or to go by consolidated cargo, and what a container standing costs”. The reasoning goes from the volume of the batch to the equality point of the two methods, then money in transit and demurrage are added: the charge for using a container beyond the free time and for storage at the terminal. The result: the method of shipping and the size of a reserve for delays.
Who owns the document and how often is it rebuilt?
The logistician and the buyer count, the CFO approves the reserve for delays; the calculation is made before the order and repeated when the delivery terms or the carrier change.
What mistakes are the most common?
Brand: a container and consolidated cargo are compared by the rate only → time and money in transit are not counted → count the full price per garment and a reserve for delay. Retail: who bears standing is not read in the contract → the buyer pays for standing → ask for the offer with the rates and fix the responsible party. Brand: the volume is counted by the number of garments → under- or overloading → count by cartons and the actual packing.

For whom

Brand
A brand decides by the production batch: the volume of one delivery, the time to the season, the readiness to receive a container at the warehouse or in port storage. The main thing: not to keep goods at the terminal longer than the free time and to agree in advance who pays demurrage under the contract.
Retail
A retailer sees the same shipping as a part of a purchase from a supplier or an importer: the delivery terms define who pays for standing. The main thing: to check the Incoterms and the responsibility for demurrage in the contract and not to accept “all risks on the buyer” without counting a reserve.

What it consists of

Two kinds of shipping: what differs

  • A container (20 or 40 feet): a fixed rate per container on the route, filling is in your hands; the unit price falls as the load grows.
  • Consolidated cargo: a charge per cubic meter or tonne (whichever is larger) plus fixed fees per shipment; the cargo waits for consolidation with others, so the time is longer and less predictable.
  • The volume is counted for the packed batch: cartons, not garments; dense packing without air reduces the volume and the cost per unit.

Demurrage, detention, storage

  • Demurrage: a charge for a loaded container staying at the terminal beyond the free time; detention: a charge for using the line’s container beyond the term outside the terminal. Names and procedure differ in carriers’ contracts: check the offer and the rates.
  • The free time is short and the rate rises in steps with every day after it; a delay of customs, documents or marking turns into a sum unrelated to the price of the shipping itself.
  • After consolidation cargo is stored at the consolidator’s warehouse: storage is also paid and the free storage time is set by the terms.

What each side does

  • Brand: collects the batch data (number of cartons, volume, mass, readiness of documents) and asks the logistician for both rates before ordering production.
  • Brand: puts a reserve for delay into the collection calendar and keeps the documents and the marking codes ready before the cargo arrives.
  • Retail: checks in the contract who bears demurrage and asks the supplier to confirm the delivery terms for the batch.
  • Retail: plans the receipt at the warehouse for the arrival date: a container waiting for an unloading slot costs money.

Where the data comes from

Data sourceFields
Batch and packingnumber of garments, cartons, volume, mass, value of the batch
Offers of carriers and consolidatorsrate per container and per cubic meter, fixed fees, time, free days, standing rates
Delivery terms in the contractIncoterms, who pays standing and storage, responsibility for documents

How to build it step by step

  1. Step 1: Brand: count the volume and mass of the packed batch by cartons (see the formulas), not by the number of garments.
  2. Step 2: Request the rate per container and the rate per cubic meter with all fixed fees on the route.
  3. Step 3: Count the volume at which a container is cheaper than consolidated cargo (the equality point) and compare it with the batch volume.
  4. Step 4: Retail: add the cost of money in transit: the batch value × rate × days / 365; consolidated cargo takes longer.
  5. Step 5: Write out the free days and the standing rate steps and count the sum for a delay of 3, 7 and 14 days.
  6. Step 6: Brand: make the reserve for delay equal to the sum for the most probable time and include it in the landed cost.
  7. Step 7: Retail: fix in the supplier contract who bears standing and the procedure for confirming the cause of the delay.
  8. Step 8: Prepare the documents and the codes before the cargo arrives so as not to pay for waiting for your own paper.

Formulas

MeasureFormulasNote
Cost of consolidated cargoLCL = max(V; M/1000) × c_m3 + FV: volume in m³, M: mass in kg (one tonne is equated to a cubic meter in the chargeable rule), c_m3: rate per m³, F: fixed fees. Check the chargeable rule in the offer.
Equality point by volumeV* = (C_cont − F) / c_m3At a volume above V* a container is cheaper; but it holds no more than its own volume: compare with the capacity.
Stepped demurrageD = min(d; n₁) × r₁ + max(0; d − n₁) × r₂d: days beyond the free time, n₁: length of the first step, r₁ and r₂: the step rates. Values come from the offer.
Delivery price per garmentΔ = (Shipping + Money in transit + Reserve) / GarmentsIt is this that is added to the landed cost, not the container rate.

Formulas in notation

Equality point
V* = (C − F) / c
C: the container rate; F: fixed fees of consolidated cargo; c: the rate per m³. At V > V* a container is cheaper per unit.

Worked example

A batch at 0.02 m³ per garment (0.45 kg); a container RUB 300,000 (capacity 28 m³); consolidated cargo RUB 14,000 per m³ and RUB 12,000 fees; all rates conditional

Garments in the batchVolume, m³Container, RUB per garmentConsolidated, RUB per garmentCheaper
4008.0750.0310.0Consolidated
60012.0500.0300.0Consolidated
80016.0375.0295.0Consolidated
1,00020.0300.0292.0Consolidated
1,20024.0250.0290.0Container
1,40028.0214.3288.6Container

For a batch of 800 garments (16 m³) consolidated cargo is cheaper by the rate, but it takes longer and without a reserve for delay it is not comparable with a container; the equality point is about 20.6 m³. The rates are conditional.

Figures

Delivery cost of a garment: container and consolidated cargo by batch volume
Line chart: Container: 1,000 → 214; Consolidated cargo: 320 → 28902004006008001,00010152025Equality near 20.6 m³Container, 6: 1,000Container, 8: 750Container, 10: 600Container, 12: 500Container, 14: 429Container, 16: 375Container, 18: 333Container, 20: 300Container, 22: 273Container, 24: 250Container, 26: 231Container, 28: 214Consolidated cargo, 6: 320Consolidated cargo, 8: 310Consolidated cargo, 10: 304Consolidated cargo, 12: 300Consolidated cargo, 14: 297Consolidated cargo, 16: 295Consolidated cargo, 18: 293Consolidated cargo, 20: 292Consolidated cargo, 22: 291Consolidated cargo, 24: 290Consolidated cargo, 26: 289Consolidated cargo, 28: 289RUB per garmentBatch volume, m³
  • Container
  • Consolidated cargo
Data as a table
Batch volume, m³ContainerConsolidated cargo
61,000320
8750310
10600304
12500300
14429297
16375295
18333293
20300292
22273291
24250290
26231289
28214289

Delivery cost of a garment: container and consolidated cargo by batch volume. The container curve falls with the load; consolidated cargo hardly depends on volume and crosses it at the equality point.

Demurrage by days beyond the free time
Line chart: Demurrage for the batch: 0 → 99k020k40k60k80k100k05101520End of the first stepDemurrage for the batch, 0: 0Demurrage for the batch, 2: 6,000Demurrage for the batch, 4: 12kDemurrage for the batch, 6: 18kDemurrage for the batch, 8: 27kDemurrage for the batch, 10: 39kDemurrage for the batch, 12: 51kDemurrage for the batch, 14: 63kDemurrage for the batch, 16: 75kDemurrage for the batch, 18: 87kDemurrage for the batch, 20: 99kRUB per batchDays beyond the free time
Data as a table
Days beyond the free timeDemurrage for the batch
00
26,000
412k
618k
827k
1039k
1251k
1463k
1675k
1887k
2099k

Demurrage by days beyond the free time. The cost rises in steps: after the first step every day is more expensive; the sum is unrelated to the price of the shipping.

Specifics by category

Apparel
Apparel: the volume depends on packing (on hangers or in bags): outerwear takes several times more space than T-shirts, so the packing density decides the choice of method.
Footwear
Footwear: boxes are rigid and bulky and the mass is higher than for apparel; “kilogram against cubic meter” can decide in favor of mass, not volume: count both quantities.
Accessories
Accessories: bags are bulky and light (air), costume jewelry and belts are compact; for bags the packing density and nesting matter more than the rate.
Kids
Kids: many small items and size cartons; batches are often small and seasonal and the deadline of 1 September is strict, so reliability of time matters more than saving per unit.
Men
Men: suits and outerwear are heavier and bulkier, batches are larger, so a full container is reached earlier; for basic items a top-up by consolidated cargo is possible.
Women
Women: a wide matrix of models and sizes, many small batches; mixed loading of a container with several models lowers the price per unit but requires careful carton marking.

Common mistakes

  • Brand: a container and consolidated cargo are compared by the rate only → time and money in transit are not counted → count the full price per garment and a reserve for delay.
  • Retail: who bears standing is not read in the contract → the buyer pays for standing → ask for the offer with the rates and fix the responsible party.
  • Brand: the volume is counted by the number of garments → under- or overloading → count by cartons and the actual packing.
  • Retail: the warehouse unloading slot is forgotten → the container waits at the terminal and piles up demurrage → agree the receipt date before arrival.
  • Rates from an old calculation are used → the result is out of date → take the rates from the current offer and fix the date.

Russian specifics

  • Brand: Incoterms 2020 set who pays for the shipping and bears the risks on each section; demurrage and detention are not allocated by them: fix them in the contract.
  • Retail: carriers’ rates, the free storage time and the standing steps are not given in Lab: the numbers are conditional, take them from the offer.
  • Brand: import into Russia requires customs clearance, the price of waiting for release is part of the landed cost; the import duty and VAT are described in the document “Duties, anti-dumping, preferences and origin”.
  • Retail: if the cargo is insured, the insurance terms for delay and standing must be read separately: standing is usually not part of the standard cover, check the policy.

Open interactively →