Syntha Lab RU

Repeat purchases: what extra points of return are worth

Shows how much extra gross profit a year comes from raising the share of returning customers by a set number of percentage points, what one point is worth and how much can be spent on retention.

Customers and loyalty For whom: Marketers, CRM managers and owners.

Calculate on your data →

At a glance

What question does it answer?
How much profit extra points of customer returns give and how much can be spent on it.
What data is needed?
New customers a month and the returning share.
How to read the result?
The worth of one point shows the ceiling of spend on it. The table gives the effect at another lift. Measure returns by cohort, not by total orders. Example on the default values: Extra returning customers per year — 900; Returning share after the lift — 27% · was 22%; Extra orders — 1,620; Extra revenue — 10 m RUB.

Why and how to reason

A repeat purchase is cheaper than a new one, so an extra point of returns is valuable. Compute: 1,500 × 12 = 18,000 new customers come a year; raising the returning share by 5 points gives 18,000 × 5% = 900 extra returning customers. Each makes 1.8 repeat orders a year, so 1,620 orders are added, at a ticket of RUB 6,200 that is RUB 10.0 million revenue and at a 52% margin RUB 5.22 million gross profit. Subtract retention cost 1.8 million and net effect is RUB 3.42 million. One point of returns is worth 18,000 × 1% × 1.8 × 6,200 × 52% ≈ RUB 1.04 million a year, and retention costs RUB 2,000 per returning customer, against RUB 2,400 needed to acquire a new one.

When to use it

It comes in handy to assess how much can be spent on retention (mailings, programs, service) and whether it is worth the effort. Assumptions: those who return make as many orders as those already returning, with the same ticket. It does not fit if the returning share is measured inconsistently (by phone and by email), for goods with rare repeat purchase (wedding), or for exact causality: the increase may come from the season, not from you.

How to read the result

Compare the price of one point (1.04 million) with what getting it costs you: if you pay more, do not do it. Cost per returning customer (RUB 2,000) is below acquisition cost (RUB 2,400): retention beats acquisition on this data. But if a 5-point lift is unreachable, see at what lift the effect is zero: 1.8 ÷ 1.04 ≈ 1.7 points. Decision: test on part of your customers before scaling. If the effect is positive, start with the cheapest way to retain a customer (a post-purchase email, a size reminder) and only then move to costly programs.

Common mistakes

Typical trap: entering a share without remembering the period (a year or three months); counting new customers only from paid ads; overestimating lift from others' cases; ignoring that retention and acquisition influence each other. The effect should be measured by a test. Do not mix customers and orders: the returning share is computed on customers.

What data is needed?

  • New customers a month and the returning share.
  • Repeat orders per returning customer, ticket and margin.
  • Retention spend and acquisition cost for comparison.

Inputs

FieldUnitValue in the exampleMeaning
New customers per monthpeople1,500How many new customers come per month.
Share returning now%22Optional: the share of new customers buying again within 12 months.
Lift in returnspp5By how many percentage points the share of returning customers will grow. Your hypothesis or a pilot result.
Repeat orders per returning customer per yearpcs1.8How many repeat orders a year a returning customer makes.
Average ticket excl. VAT₽6,200The average ticket of a repeat order excl. VAT.
Gross margin%52Gross margin of an order, as a percent of revenue excl. VAT.
Retention spend per year₽1,800,000Mailings, program, staff.
Cost of acquiring a new customer₽2,400To compare with the cost of a returning customer.

How it is calculated

StepFormula
Extra returning customersNew customers per year × lift in pp ÷ 100
ProfitReturning × repeat orders × ticket × margin
EffectProfit − retention spend

Worked numbers

Default values from the app; in the interactive version you enter your own.

Extra returning customers per year
900
Returning share after the lift
27 % · was 22 %
Extra orders
1,620
Extra revenue
10 m ₽
Extra gross profit
5.22 m ₽
Net effect after costs
3.42 m ₽
Worth of one point of returns
1.04 m ₽The gross profit a year each percentage point gives.
Spend per extra returning customer
2,000 ₽ · CAC 2,400 ₽Compare with the cost of a new customer, but remember a new one also brings a first order.

If the lift is different

LiftExtra customersExtra gross profitNet effect
+1 pp1801.04 m ₽−755,424 ₽
+2 pp3602.09 m ₽289,152 ₽
+5 pp9005.22 m ₽3.42 m ₽
+10 pp1,80010.4 m ₽8.65 m ₽

Measure returns by cohort (customers of one month’s first order), not by total orders, and do not mix young and mature cohorts. Without your own data use estimates and check them in practice.

Nuances and limits

  • Measuring returns by total orders rather than cohorts.
  • Counting young cohorts as mature.
  • Ignoring the seasonality of the first order.

Terms used

Calculate on your data →