Rent: fixed rate or a percentage of turnover
Compares two ways of paying for a store: a fixed rent and a percentage of turnover with a guaranteed minimum. Finds the turnover at which the payments are equal and the store’s break-even turnover under each option.
At a glance
- What question does it answer?
- What is cheaper at our turnover: a fixed rate or a percentage of turnover with a minimum.
- What data is needed?
- Store turnover, margin and other costs a month.
- How to read the result?
- At a turnover of 6m a fixed rent of 900 thousand (15% of turnover) and a percentage of 12% with a minimum of 450 thousand gives 720 thousand: cheaper by 180 thousand. The payments are equal at a turnover of 7.5m. Store profit is 1.02m and 1.2m, break-even turnover 4.04m and 3.17m. Example on the default values: Rent A (fixed) a month — RUB 900,000 · 15% of turnover; Rent B (percentage) a month — RUB 720,000 · 12% of turnover; Cheaper at your turnover — RUB 180,000 · percentage (B); Turnover at which payments are equal — 7.5 m RUB · you are below: percentage is cheaper.
Why and how to reason
Fixed rent does not depend on turnover, and percentage rent grows with it but usually has a guaranteed minimum. So the benefit depends on where your turnover sits relative to the equality point. Equality is where the percentage equals the fixed rent: 900,000 ÷ 12% = RUB 7.5 million a month (if the minimum is not above the fixed). At a turnover of 6 million the percentage gives max(450,000; 12% × 6 million = 720,000) = RUB 720,000, which is 180 thousand cheaper than fixed. Store profit = turnover × margin − rent − other: with fixed 6 × 0.52 − 0.9 − 1.2 = 1.02 million, with percentage 1.2 million. Break-even turnover: fixed (0.9 + 1.2) ÷ 0.52 = 4.04 million, percentage 3.17 million, lower because rent falls with turnover. A percentage scheme protects in weak months but takes part of success in strong ones.
When to use it
It comes in handy in negotiating mall rent and choosing the rate type. You need a turnover forecast with a range, not one figure. Assumption: your turnover does not depend on the scheme (but the landlord may affect traffic). It does not fit rent with indexation or stepped rates without recalculation nor street premises where percentage is rarely used. Note that percentage is charged on turnover with or without VAT: clarify in the contract.
How to read the result
If your turnover is below the equality point, percentage is cheaper and more so the more uncertain the revenue. If above, fixed is cheaper and more so the faster the store grows. Look at break-even turnover: with percentage it is lower, so closure risk is smaller. Compare the rouble difference with your view of risk: take percentage on a new store and fixed on a proven one. Negotiate a minimum not above the fixed rent, otherwise the protection is illusory. Compute both options at three turnover levels (pessimistic, base, optimistic) and bring this table to the negotiation: it shows the landlord you know the price of risk.
Common mistakes
Typical trap: comparing fixed and percentage under different VAT bases; ignoring utility and service charges that are sometimes separate; taking a minimum above the fixed rent; using margin before returns. If equality is undefined, the minimum is above the fixed rent and percentage cannot be cheaper. Do not compare percentages of turnover with and without VAT.
What data is needed?
- Store turnover, margin and other costs a month.
- Fixed rent; the percentage of turnover and the guaranteed minimum.
Inputs
| Field | Unit | Value in the example | Meaning |
|---|---|---|---|
| Store turnover a month, excl. VAT | ₽ | 6,000,000 | Price excl. VAT: the general rate is 22% from 01.01.2026 (17.12.2025). The rate follows the shipment date; confirm your regime and rate with an accountant. |
| Margin in turnover (after cost of goods) | % | 52 | The share of turnover left after the cost of goods and variable costs. |
| Staff and other costs a month | ₽ | 1,200,000 | Excluding rent. Count utilities here, separately from the rate. |
| Fixed rent a month | ₽ | 900,000 | Option A: you pay this at any turnover. |
| Percentage of turnover | % | 12 | Option B: the payment is the larger of the minimum and the percentage. |
| Guaranteed minimum under the percentage | ₽ | 450,000 | The minimum payment under option B. Empty: zero. |
How it is calculated
| Step | Formula |
|---|---|
| Payment A | the fixed rate |
| Payment B | max(minimum; percentage × turnover) |
| Equal-payment point | fixed ÷ percentage |
| Break-even turnover | A: (rent + other) ÷ margin; B: other ÷ (margin − percentage), if the percentage is above the minimum |
Worked numbers
Default values from the app; in the interactive version you enter your own.
- Rent A (fixed) a month
- 900,000 ₽ · 15 % of turnover
- Rent B (percentage) a month
- 720,000 ₽ · 12 % of turnover
- Cheaper at your turnover
- 180,000 ₽ · percentage (B)The difference in monthly payment.
- Turnover at which payments are equal
- 7.5 m ₽ · you are below: percentage is cheaperFixed ÷ percentage (if the minimum is not above the fixed rent).
- Store profit under A
- 1.02 m ₽
- Store profit under B
- 1.2 m ₽
- Break-even turnover under A
- 4.04 m ₽
- Break-even turnover under B
- 3.17 m ₽
Payment and profit at different turnover
| Turnover | Rent A | Rent B | Profit under A | Profit under B | Rent share A / B |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 3 m ₽ | 900,000 ₽ | 450,000 ₽ | −540,000 ₽ | −90,000 ₽ | 30 % / 15 % |
| 4.5 m ₽ | 900,000 ₽ | 540,000 ₽ | 240,000 ₽ | 600,000 ₽ | 20 % / 12 % |
| 6 m ₽ | 900,000 ₽ | 720,000 ₽ | 1.02 m ₽ | 1.2 m ₽ | 15 % / 12 % |
| 7.5 m ₽ | 900,000 ₽ | 900,000 ₽ | 1.8 m ₽ | 1.8 m ₽ | 12 % / 12 % |
| 9 m ₽ | 900,000 ₽ | 1.08 m ₽ | 2.58 m ₽ | 2.4 m ₽ | 10 % / 12 % |
| 12 m ₽ | 900,000 ₽ | 1.44 m ₽ | 4.14 m ₽ | 3.6 m ₽ | 7.5 % / 12 % |
A percentage protects when turnover falls, a fixed rent is cheaper when it grows. VAT and utilities are not included in the rent, take the terms from your own contract; no shopping-centre rates are substituted here.
Nuances and limits
- A percentage protects when turnover falls, a fixed rent is cheaper when it grows.
- Enter the center’s utilities and advertising charges separately.
- Have a lawyer check the contract; shopping-center rates are not substituted here.