Capital: WACC, ROIC, dividends and reinvestment
Compares how much the business earns per invested rouble (ROIC) with what that rouble costs (WACC), and decides what to do with profit: return it to owners or reinvest it. It sets the discount rate for projects and the dividend policy.
Why this document
A business creates value only when the return on investment exceeds the cost of the money raised. If ROIC is below WACC, growth merely destroys capital, even with rising revenue. That is why the owner uses these figures to decide whether to expand the chain or pay dividends. WACC also serves the investment case as a hurdle rate for projects, and dividends are paid only after checking liquidity and covenants, otherwise cash leaves the company in the hardest season.
At a glance
- What is this document and why is it needed?
- Compares how much the business earns per invested rouble (ROIC) with what that rouble costs (WACC), and decides what to do with profit: return it to owners or reinvest it. It sets the discount rate for projects and the dividend policy.
- Who owns the document and how often is it rebuilt?
- The finance director prepares; the owner or board approves the rate and policy; rates yearly or when the market changes, ROIC quarterly, dividends after the period and after checking liquidity and covenants.
- What mistakes are the most common?
- WACC is taken as the loan rate → understated, projects look profitable → include the price of equity. ROIC is computed on capital including cash → understated → working capital and fixed assets excluding excess cash. Dividends are paid from profit, not from cash → a gap in season → a cash limit and after the peak.
For whom
- Brand
- A brand ROIC rests on margin and a small share of fixed assets: in Model B ROIC is 27.3% against WACC 22.5, a spread of 4.8 pp: the business creates value. The main invested capital is stock and receivables, so turnover matters more than the rate. Dividends of 6,000 in the model fit the year-end limits (cash 16,234, policy 10,526) but not the in-year cash minimum: before dividends it is -500 against a buffer of 4,117, so 0 is permitted without a line; the payout is set after the purchase peak or covered by a line (a peak need of RUB 8 million in the Treasury).
- Retail
- A retailer capital sits in stock and store fit-out; in Model R ROIC is 17.0% against WACC 19.8, a spread of -2.8 pp: the business does not yet earn its cost of capital. Dividends of 8,000 exceed the permitted 0: after capex and loan repayment there is no cash left before the seasonal peak. Leases under FSBU 25/2018 increase invested capital (the right-of-use asset) and reduce ROIC: keep the metric on two bases.
What it consists of
WACC: the cost of capital
- WACC = E ÷ (D + E) × Ke + D ÷ (D + E) × Kd × (1 − tax). It is the average price of the money the company uses: equity and debt.
- Ke (the cost of equity) is the return the owner requires for risk; it is set by CAPM: Ke = Rf + β × ERP + size and country premium, where Rf is the government bond (OFZ) yield for a term close to the horizon on the calculation date, β is the business sensitivity to the market, ERP is the equity market risk premium; or as the owner required return. In the example Rf, β and ERP are not taken from market data: Ke is an assumption and is revised.
- Kd (the cost of debt) is the rate of NEW funding with fees for the project term, not the rate of the existing loan. In the package Kd = 20%: between the stock-backed line (19% plus fees, 22% effective) and the overdraft (22%) from the Treasury document; the existing loan of the models (14% for the brand and 15% for the retailer) goes into the P&L interest and is not the price of new capital. The tax shield (1 − tax) accounts for the interest deduction (with limits).
- Weights come from the target capital structure, not the book one: in a stable company the average over the cycle.
ROIC and economic profit
- ROIC = NOPAT ÷ Invested capital. NOPAT = EBIT × (1 − tax); invested capital = working capital + fixed and intangible assets (on the period average).
- Spread = ROIC − WACC. If the spread is positive, growth creates value; if negative, growth destroys it. Economic profit = spread × capital.
- ROIC levers: margin (price, discounts, cost), capital turnover (stock, receivables, space), tax. A DuPont breakdown shows which is weaker.
Dividend policy
- The policy answers three questions: how much to pay (a share of profit or the residual after investment), when (after the seasonal peak, not before purchasing) and under what conditions (covenants, a cash buffer).
- A practical cap: the minimum of four: the year-end cash limit (cash before dividends less a buffer), the debt limit (net debt not above a threshold × EBITDA), the policy limit (a share of profit) and the in-year limit (the lowest quarter-end balance before dividends less a buffer: year-end cash can hide a seasonal trough).
Reinvest or pay out
- If projects have a positive NPV at WACC, it is better to reinvest profit; if not, return it to the owner. The ROIC − WACC spread and the project queue show where the line lies.
- For a limited liability company dividends are restricted by net assets and statutory norms; for sole traders and USN the procedure differs; check with a lawyer before deciding.
Brand and retailer: what is computed differently
- Brand: brand ROIC rests on margin and a small share of fixed assets; the main invested capital is stock and wholesale receivables, so dividends are tied to the seasonal cash minimum after factory prepayments.
- Retailer: retailer capital sits in stock and store fit-out: ROIC is computed with and without the lease right of use and by segment (stores, online); dividends after the seasonal peak, not before purchasing.
Brand: how the document differs and what to add
- Brand: the brand’s cost of capital is higher (WACC 22.5%): a long cycle, customer dependence and FX; profitability targets are set higher.
- Brand: brand ROIC of 27.3% rests on small fixed capital: most invested capital is stock and receivables rather than assets.
- Brand: brand growth consumes working capital: each percent of revenue growth at DIO 240 days needs stock; by year end dividends are limited by policy (RUB 10.526 million, year-end liquidity allows 16,234), and in-year the cash minimum before dividends is -500: the payout is possible after the purchase peak.
- Brand: reinvestment in collections and channels is assessed by return on the working capital invested, not by margin: a project with high margin and long stock may not earn its capital.
- Brand: profit distribution between brand owners considers dividend tax and cash availability after the purchase season, not at the report date.
- Brand: for a new line the brand rate is used and the project ROIC is shown apart from the whole-brand ROIC.
- Brand: a brand raises external capital against stock growth (a stock-backed line, factoring), not against losses; the condition is written into the policy.
- Brand: with several owned entities owner income is compared at group level after transfer prices.
Retailer: how the document differs and what to add
- Retailer: the retailer’s cost of capital is lower (WACC 19.8%): a shorter cycle and a steadier cash flow, but a higher share of rent as debt.
- Retailer: retailer ROIC of 17.0% is below WACC: spread -2.8 pp, EVA −RUB 2.961 million; the network in the base does not earn its capital and opening more stores will not fix that.
- Retailer: retailer invested capital includes store fit-out and stock; under FSBU 25/2018 the right of use of leases is added and ROIC reads lower.
- Retailer: dividends are limited by liquidity: capacity RUB 0 thousand against a payout of 8,000 in the model: a payout above capacity is funded by debt.
- Retailer: the decision between opening a new store and refurbishing an existing one is made on project ROIC and NPV, not on general network growth.
- Retailer: closing a weak store raises network ROIC if the released capital and rent exceed the four-wall loss; the calculation includes exit payments.
- Retailer: the retailer borrows for opening projects and seasonal working capital; the cost of new debt is built into WACC, not the rate of old loans.
- Retailer: with a high share of rent in costs leverage is operating: a small revenue fall reduces ROIC sharply and the dividend policy must allow a cushion.
How to read the result and which decisions follow
- ROIC is below WACC two years in a row: the business destroys value; first raise the return on existing capital (turnover, closing weak points), only then increase growth; do not pay dividends above capacity.
- Dividend capacity is set by the smallest of four limits, and in both examples it is neither profit nor year-end cash but the in-year minimum: a payout before checking the in-season cash minimum puts the business at risk of a gap (the brand minimum before dividends is -500, the retailer -15,898); set the payout date after the purchase peak or open a line in advance.
- WACC rises by several points when the key rate rises: recompute NPV of postponed projects; those that were barely positive are taken off implementation.
Control checks
- ROIC is recomputed by the document formula: NOPAT ÷ average invested capital (brand 23,886 ÷ 87,343, retailer 17,850 ÷ 105,105).
- Capital shares in WACC add up to 100%, the cost of debt is the price of new debt, not the rate of old loans; the tax shield is applied once.
- Typical traps: ROIC on closing rather than average capital, owner income mixed with company dividends, WACC from the book structure instead of the target one.
Where the data comes from
| Data source | Fields |
|---|---|
| P&L and balance sheet (average values) | EBIT, tax, working capital, fixed assets |
| Loan terms and market rates | rates, fees, term; take current benchmarks at the decision date |
| Owner expectations | required return, horizon, reinvestment share |
| Project queue | NPV, IRR, payback, cash need for each project |
How to build it step by step
- Step 1: Define the target capital structure and rates: Ke from the owner assumption, Kd from the price of new debt (a stock-backed line, an overdraft with fees), not from the rate of existing loans.
- Step 2: Compute WACC; record the source and date of every rate; revise when rates change.
- Step 3: Compute invested capital on the period average and NOPAT.
- Step 4: Get ROIC and the spread to WACC; break ROIC into margin and capital turnover.
- Step 5: Compare by segment (channels, categories, stores): where the spread is negative, revise the model or close it.
- Step 6: Use WACC (adjusted for project risk) as the discount rate in investment cases.
- Step 7: Compute the dividend cap: by year-end cash, by debt, by policy and by the in-year cash minimum; take the minimum.
- Step 8: Check covenants and the seasonal minimum cash after payment (including scenarios).
- Step 9: Compare payout and reinvestment against the project queue; decide the share.
- Step 10: Fix the policy in a document: size, timing, conditions, approval procedure.
Formulas
| Measure | Formulas | Note |
|---|---|---|
| WACC | WACC = E% × Ke + D% × Kd × (1 − T) | T is the corporate income tax rate; for USN the tax shield differs or is absent. |
| ROIC | ROIC = EBIT × (1 − T) ÷ (NWC + Fixed assets) | NWC is the definition from the Balance (net of payroll debt and deferred loyalty revenue), so ROIC can be reproduced from the text. Take capital as the period average and excluding cash; for a retailer compute with and without the right-of-use asset. |
| Economic profit | EVA = (ROIC − WACC) × Invested capital | Positive means profit is above the charge for capital. |
| Ke by CAPM | Ke = Rf + β × ERP + Size and country premium | Take Rf from the OFZ yield on the calculation date and record the date; β and ERP come from market reviews or an analyst estimate; for unlisted companies take β from peers and re-lever it to the capital structure. |
| Dividend cap | Cap = min(Cash before dividends − Buffer; k × EBITDA − Net debt; p × Net profit; min over quarters (balance before dividends) − Buffer) | k and p are set by the policy and bank terms; in the example k = 2.5, p = 50%. Cash before dividends is the year-end balance plus dividends paid. |
| Sustainable growth | g = ROIC × Reinvestment rate | Growth above g needs new capital or debt. |
Formulas in notation
- Weighted average cost of capital
WACC = w_e · k_e + w_d · k_d · (1 − t)
w_e, w_d are the shares of equity and debt, k_e is the cost of equity, k_d is the cost of new debt, t is the corporate income tax.- Cost of equity
k_e = r_f + β · ERP + Δ
r_f is the risk-free rate, β is market sensitivity, ERP is the risk premium, Δ is an add-on for size and specific risk; in the model the rate is entered as an assumption.- Dividend capacity
Cap = min(Cash − Buf, 2.5 · EBITDA − ND, 0.5 · NP, min_q(Bal_q) − Buf)
Four limits: year-end liquidity after the buffer (Cash is cash before dividends, i.e. the year-end balance plus dividends paid), leverage not above 2.5 EBITDA, a 50% profit share and the lowest quarter-end balance before dividends Bal_q after the buffer; the limits are the example policy, not a norm.
Worked example
WACC, ROIC and permitted dividends of the end-to-end models, RUB thousand
| Metric | Brand (Model B) | Retailer (Model R) |
|---|---|---|
| COST OF CAPITAL | ||
| Cost of equity Ke, % | 25 | 23 |
| Cost of debt Kd before tax, % | 20 | 20 |
| Equity share in the structure, % | 75 | 60 |
| WACC = E×Ke + D×Kd×(1 − tax), % | 22.5 | 19.8 |
| RETURN ON CAPITAL | ||
| NOPAT = EBIT × (1 − 25%) | 23,886 | 17,850 |
| Invested capital (average: working capital + fixed assets) | 87,343 | 105,105 |
| ROIC, % | 27.3 | 17 |
| Spread ROIC − WACC, pp | 4.8 | −2.8 |
| Economic profit (spread × capital), RUB thousand | 4,234 | −2,961 |
| DIVIDENDS | ||
| Free cash flow (operations + investing) | 14,351 | −234 |
| Dividends paid in the model | 6,000 | 8,000 |
| Cash limit: cash before dividends − 30-day buffer | 16,234 | 0 |
| Debt limit: up to net debt of 2.5× EBITDA | 83,971 | 46,766 |
| Policy limit: 50% of net profit | 10,526 | 5,831 |
| Intra-year limit: the lowest quarter-end balance before dividends − buffer (the balance before dividends in the tightest quarter: see the Treasury) | 0 | 0 |
| Lowest quarter-end balance before dividends, RUB thousand | −500 | −15,898 |
| Can be paid (the minimum of the four limits) | 0 | 0 |
| Paid above the permitted | 6,000 | 8,000 |
Ke of 25% and 23% and capital structures of 75/25 and 60/40 are assumptions of the example, not market data; Kd of 20% is the price of new debt from “Treasury”, not the rate of the existing loan in the models. The same WACC (22.5% and 19.8%) is used in the investment case and valuation, so the documents are consistent. The main takeaway: the retailer paid dividends of 8,000 above the cash limit: cash falls short at the seasonal peak, and the payment should rather be moved or funded from a pre-agreed credit.
Figures
- ROIC
- WACC
- Spread ROIC − WACC
Data as a table
| Measure | ROIC | WACC | Spread ROIC − WACC |
|---|---|---|---|
| Brand (Model B) | 27.3 | 22.5 | 4.8 |
| Retailer (Model R) | 17 | 19.8 | −2.8 |
ROIC, cost of capital and spread. The brand creates value (ROIC above WACC), the retailer in the base destroys it: the spread is below zero.
- Brand
- Retailer
Data as a table
| Measure | Brand | Retailer |
|---|---|---|
| By year-end liquidity | 16,234 | 0 |
| By leverage | 83,971 | 46,766 |
| By profit share | 10,526 | 5,831 |
| By in-year minimum | 0 | 0 |
| Result (minimum) | 0 | 0 |
Dividend capacity: four limits and the result. The payout is limited by the smallest of four limits: year-end liquidity after the buffer, leverage, share of profit and the in-year cash minimum; the result is the minimum.
Specifics by category
- Apparel
- Apparel: ROIC is set by stock turnover and markdown depth; ROIC targets are set separately for core and fashion.
- Footwear
- Footwear: higher capital intensity (size run stock, tooling), lower ROIC at the same margin; a smaller permitted payout.
- Accessories
- Accessories: higher margin and less capital, so a higher ROIC; the key for growth is the brand and rights, not working capital.
- Kids
- Kids: seasonal peaks require large working capital at a point in time; average capital understates the need; compute at the peak.
- Men
- Menswear: a stable ROIC and a predictable cash flow allow a steady payout policy.
- Women
- Womenswear: ROIC volatility is higher because of markdowns and dead stock; dividends are better tied to the year after actual profit, not the plan.
Common mistakes
- WACC is taken as the loan rate → understated, projects look profitable → include the price of equity.
- ROIC is computed on capital including cash → understated → working capital and fixed assets excluding excess cash.
- Dividends are paid from profit, not from cash → a gap in season → a cash limit and after the peak.
- Ke is set by eye with no document → different rates in projects → a single rate and project risk.
- Leases under FSBU 25/2018 are ignored → retailer ROIC is overstated → compute two bases.
- Growth with a negative spread → the business grows and loses value → margin and turnover first, then scale.
Russian specifics
- Corporate income tax of 25% (Art. 284 of the Tax Code as amended by Law 176-FZ) enters WACC and NOPAT; for USN and other regimes the tax shield differs. Rule: Tax Code Art. 284: Tax Code, Art. 284 (corporate income tax rates) (rule check not completed).
- Dividends are paid in the manner set by company law and the charter; taxation of dividends and net asset restrictions should be checked with a lawyer and an accountant; these rules are not in the norm register: not verified.
- Leasing and rent change the capital structure: a lease under FSBU 25/2018 includes a right-of-use asset and a liability, leasing is regulated by the leasing law; agree with the bank whether they enter debt. Rule: Order 208n of 16.10.2018: Ministry of Finance Order of 16.10.2018 No. 208n (FSBU 25/2018 Lease accounting) (rule check not completed).
- Take the key rate and other market benchmarks for Kd and Ke from current Bank of Russia data at the calculation date; in the example rates are set as assumptions.